3.5 Stars
Most of the reviews I’ve seen for this book dub it genre-defying, and I’m not sure there's a more apt description. It seems like a mix between character-driven literary fiction and… Horror? Supernatural?? It’s also what I would technically call a Historical Fiction (taking place in 1983) that tends to give an alternate depiction of events.
Taking place in a small, coastal town at the height of the Cold War, this book focuses on four characters and how their lives intersect. After a body is unearthed, more and more questions about their town and their lives come to light.
Unfortunately, I’ve lost my reading-notes for this, so I’m going by memory here.
I received an ARC of this through Netgalley in exchange for an honest review
Pros:
While it’s the mystery element of this book so prominently mentioned in the blurb and tags, I would really argue it’s a side-plot. The true focus of this novel (to me) was definitely the four main characters, who were each fleshed-out and interesting in their own way:
Trina—Born deaf, this 9-year-old appears to sublimate her anxious and helpless feelings regarding her mother’s recent death into worry about a possible nuclear apocalypse. She was my absolute favorite and such a creative, sweet character.
Sam—Trina’s 18-year old brother, who longs to leave his town but struggles to find his footing after their mother’s death. His character really seemed very determined, but like he didn’t know what about; just a wayward sort of soul and I really enjoyed it.
Nick—A Vietnam Vet turned police officer, he was my least favorite character up until the end. Very self-destructive tendencies and he seemed to be struggling with PTSD, and watching his character toe the line between “keeping it together” and "losing it" was very interesting.
Dave-- The aging chief of police, recently widowed. His longing for his wife and passion for his job were depicted slowly and steadily, and cultivated in a very interesting overall arc.
There were some really great and fascinating descriptions here. Because I lost my reading notes, I don’t have any examples to list, sadly. But this truly was an atmospheric novel.
The characters themselves were all very dynamic, with multiple good and bad facets of their personalities being expressed. As more was revealed about how intertwined these four people were in each other’s lives, the similarities and contradictions between them were very strong and oddly beautiful.
At several points their lives would twist and turn while intersecting, and each of these twists took me by surprise.
Again, I’m really ranking this so high because I truly did love the characters and the way they were portrayed. Their dialogue was organic and the interactions overall felt subtle and every day, but still important. I had specific mentions of this in my reading notes, but since these have disappeared I’m just gonna say that Rosson really highlighted the overall similarities in human relationships. We’ve all laughed about something with someone we love so hard that we chuckle thinking about it months later, and moments like this were used to illustrate these relations and grief.
Cons:
Overall, I really did enjoy the writing style. But my biggest complaint with this book is that it was so description heavy. There were some fantastic descriptions, especially of the characters and settings. I really felt immersed in this town, and could picture the characters. But a lot of these really great descriptions seemed smothered by the sheer volume of descriptions. Most of the sentences were loaded with clauses and just exceedingly long (I’m not sure I’ve ever seen a story with as many semi-colons) and they built on each other to form huge paragraphs. I know I was reading this on an e-reader, so the pages were smaller, but I still don’t see a need for a paragraph to be three pages long.
I want to rate this higher, because I did very much enjoy the character aspect of this, but I wasn’t overtly happy with the way this ended. I think I was expecting the supernatural/thriller/mystery aspect to have more of an impact on the end result, but it surprisingly didn’t? To me the actual end seemed… what’s the opposite of dues ex machina? Instead of divine intervention that saved the day? The exact opposite.
Again, I did enjoy the writing style, but I was confused about a lot of repeating phrases? Particularly there was a lot of talk about skulls? Like when describing different characters it would mention someone’s skull, a dead body was found and the skull was described multiple times, and dead animals were always depicted based on their skulls. I don’t know if this was intentional and I’m just missing something… or maybe just a quirk of the author?
While I loved her character, I couldn’t help but think Trina acted older than the nine-years she was supposed to be. I understand she’s had a very difficult life and had to mature quickly, but she would often ponder the meaning of the universe, what nuclear war would mean for her, and if other girls asked these same questions. If she’d been a few years older, I’d have bought it.
This may be a personal preference, but there were several sections of this that just seemed needlessly crass? It’s not something I particularly dislike, but it just felt odd here. A character would be talking about how he married his wife, their life together, the dogs they raised and how much he missed her—and then he would go masturbate. It was disorienting, and I’m not sure I understand the reasoning.
In Conclusion:
The literary fiction and Supernatural lovechild, with perhaps the literary fiction aspect being carried better.