The Will to Whatevs: A Guide to Modern Life is Mirman's parody of a self-help book. There really isn't more summary to give, because after opening the cover, the book is just a series of jokes. At first, I found the book funny. I was reading it on the treadmill at the gym and drew a number of stares while laughing aloud as I worked my way through the Preface, Preface II, Introduction, Extra Introduction, and then More Extra Introduction. Funny, right? But somewhere into the third chapter, the book started to wear on me. At first, I had some trouble figuring out why. I mean, I like his humor, and the humor wasn't changing, so why did I stop finding it so funny?
And here's what I discovered: what makes the long series of Introductions funny is also what ends up making the book tedious and repetitive. He wears it out. I mean, wouldn't just a Preface, followed by a Preface II, and (maybe) then followed by an Introduction have been sufficiently funny? Why drag what works in 2-3 steps out into 5 steps? Less is more, right? The same with his habit of quoting himself. Like any self-help book, important points and quotations are pulled out into text boxes, outlined and emphasized in bold text. Example (from the Preface):
"Life is like a bus: you get on, you get off."
-Eugene Mirman, from his forthcoming philoso-novel,
Okay Life Similes
Funny. He's quoting himself, from a fictitious unpublished work, at the introduction to his own preface. But by chapter three, he has quoted himself in nearly every text box. Funny once; not funny 20 times. In fact, he's made the classic comic device of repetition work against himself. Since it's the unusual and the unexpected that makes us laugh (like when someone trips and falls instead of walking normally), the joke stops being funny when we know what's coming. When we see that text box down the page, we realize what he's going to do, and instead of delighting in his originality, we start to think "Here we go. He's quoting another fictitious source of his own authorship again. Been there, done that."
For those of you in the market for a good self-help parody, I recommend the much more successful Everything is Wrong with You: A Modern Woman's Guide to Finding Self-Confidence through Self-Loathing by Wendy Molyneux. But that's not to say that The Will to Whatevs is a failure. On the contrary, it was very successful in representing Mirman's tone of voice and comic style. But it was also unfocused and rambling, which is why I quit reading it. I got the point. I didn't need to read more. Proof that even a self-help parody can use a good editor.