Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

School for Extraterrestrial Girls #1

School for Extraterrestrial Girls #1: Girl on Fire

Rate this book
Tara Smith’s parents are super strict with all their rules and routines, and Tara is a dutiful daughter. Rule #1: No friends her own age. Rule #2: keep her bracelet on, or else. But when she breaks her routine—and then loses her bracelet—she’s in trouble.
Now outed as an extraterrestrial after wielding fire and losing her humanoid form, Tara is captured by the government. She’s given two options: get shipped far away where she won’t be a danger to anyone or stay on Earth and join a school for other extraterrestrial girls like her. Things at the school aren’t easy—especially for the girl whose only friends were textbooks. But Tara’s goal to learn how to control her powers is soon sidelined by the discovery that the people she’s called Mom and Dad all these years aren’t her parents. With her not-parents still out there, Tara must rely on others for the first time to figure out who she really is before she’s kidnapped a second time.

128 pages, Paperback

Published August 4, 2020

6 people are currently reading
1855 people want to read

About the author

Jeremy Whitley

406 books337 followers
Jeremy Whitley is the son of two teachers and the husband of a third.

Born in La Mesa, CA, Jeremy went to high school in Lenoir, NC and college at The University of North Carolina. He graduated with a Bachelors in English, and a minor in Creative Writing.

Jeremy lives in Durham, North Carolina with his wife Alicia and his two daughters Zuri and Amara.

Jeremy is the writer/creator of the comic series Princeless, Raven the Pirate Princess, School for Extraterrestrial Girls, and The Dog Knight. He is also the writer of the acclaimed Marvel series "The Unstoppable Wasp". His other works include extensive work for Marvel, the "Sea of Thieves" comics, and over sixty issues of My Little Pony comics.

Awards and Nominations:
3 time Glyph Winner
5 time Glyph Nominee
2 time Eisner Nominee
2 time Cyblis Nominee
2 time Bloomer Nominee
1 time Most Likely to Succeed Winner

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
75 (22%)
4 stars
157 (46%)
3 stars
85 (25%)
2 stars
19 (5%)
1 star
4 (1%)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 100 reviews
Profile Image for Geoff.
995 reviews130 followers
August 28, 2020
This was a lot of fun. It's a fairly standard "protagonist is secretly extraordinary and goes to a school for extraordinary beings" but it's combined with a very interesting SF universe where aliens are secretly omnipresent on Earth. It also has a strong focus on interpersonal relationships, kindness, and social support, which are great skills to model. Fun pandemic read.

**Thanks to the author, publisher, and NetGalley for a free copy in exchange for an honest review.
Profile Image for Madara.
360 reviews56 followers
May 24, 2020
More like 3.5-ish
School for Extraterrestrial Girls #1: Girl on Fire follows a 15 year old Tara Smith. Tara has always known she's destined to be extraordinary but even she couldn't have guessed how extraordinary she actually is. After being captured by the government, Tara must learn how to adapt to the new school, find friends and learn to accept her alien form.
Who would have thought aliens also have teenage problems? There's drama, there's friendship, there's some action. And there's Kat - the cat like being that loves american soap operas and doesn't understand the term "personal space". I love Kat. Can we get more of Kat, please?

Review copy provided by the publisher and NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.
Profile Image for Rod Brown.
7,424 reviews285 followers
November 28, 2020
While this doesn't have the same spark as his Unstoppable Wasp work, Jeremy Whitley serves up a fine variant on the superhero school trope. It starts off slow, but Ekaterina Kurilian adds some welcome fun in the closing stretch to offset and poke fun at all the teen drama. I'm looking forward to the next volume.
Profile Image for Jill.
1,323 reviews25 followers
October 13, 2020
Thank you to NetGalley for a free review copy of this book!

This was such a fun read! I really enjoyed getting to know Tara and all her friends as they came to terms with their newfound alien powers. I think if you like a high school setting but with an alien twist then you will love this! Can't wait to read volume 2!
Profile Image for Chrystopher’s Archive.
530 reviews38 followers
May 18, 2020
Three and a bit rounded up to four.

This a fast, fun read with a lot of tropes that I like - boarding school, sci-fi, and found family. While the section in the middle, as Tara figures things out, was a bit difficult to read, it got exponentially better once Kat came into the picture. I was also really intrigued by the character of Agent Stone, and I look forward to learning more about all the characters in the future.

If I have a nit-pick other than that it would be that I wished Kat and her sister were drawn a little cuter - I mean, come on, they're LITERAL CAT PEOPLE. But otherwise the artwork was great, and I appreciated that the characters were really diverse, from the inclusion of a hijab to a South East Asian teacher.

A really fun story.
Profile Image for Paige Dillard.
138 reviews42 followers
December 22, 2020
So, I'm a huge Doctor Who fan, and I really liked this graphic novel! It has humor, drama, action, diversity, feels, and a cliffhanger, which means there's going to be a next one!
Profile Image for Bobbie  Bomber.
644 reviews86 followers
December 17, 2020
I received a e-arc of School for Extraterrestrial Girls #1 from NetGalley and the publisher in exchange for an honest review.

This was another comic that initially drew me to it because of the cover and I really did enjoy the artwork throughout the whole comic.

School for Extraterrestrial Girls was a fun first comic of the series and I think a lot of kids or younger teens would definitely enjoy it. While this is another "kid finds out their special" comic it does a great job on also dealing with social issues and I really appreciate that.

I did enjoy it but I'm not entirely sure if I will continue the series or not.
Profile Image for Laura.
1,041 reviews33 followers
December 22, 2020
3.5 stars.

This story is v intriguing. The art is a bit simplistic (not necessarily my cup of tea), but it conveys the story well, and the panels/full page spreads of [spoilers] the main character on fire are honestly haunting.

Her vibe is very self-conscious/angsty , which is both relatable and hard to read. She comes across as being kind of rude to both of her roommates when she meets them, for example, even though it’s clear she’s just having a hard time (and at least she immediately realizes it). That said, I did laugh at some of her awkwardness in a “same” kind of way. Once she starts making friends, though, it’s v heartwarming.

Random quibble: It’s a bit weird that they both say that alien genders don’t work the same way as ours, but then break up the alien schools by gender?

Thanks to Netgalley for the ARC!
Profile Image for Cindy.
327 reviews31 followers
July 17, 2020
I received an ARC via NetGalley. I want to thank the publisher and author for providing an ARC in exchange for an honest review.

I really enjoyed this one! The cover art is what initially caught my eye, as well as the intriguing title. Besides the awesome artwork, this story had some good messages about friendship, and accepting yourself and others. The story itself is well paced and leaves you wanting the next volume. Overall, cool concept/story. I would definitely recommend this YA sci-fi graphic novel!
Profile Image for Margaret.
398 reviews14 followers
Read
September 17, 2020
This is a fun story about Tara, who always thought she's special. She finds out she is even moreso than she thought after she is taken by the govt and sent to a new school ( for extraterrestrials).
The comic follows her journey. excitement, friends, teenage angst, it's all there.
received from Netgalley in exchange for an honest review
Profile Image for Dubzor.
835 reviews10 followers
October 18, 2020
This was passable, but was definitely not my cup of tea. In terms of writing craft it's perfectly fine. The characters are well defined, nothing seems contrived or forced. At no point was I bored. I'm just not the audience for this particular book. Which is fine. Someone else will find this very enjoyable I'm sure. The only caveat is that the artwork on the human characters can be quite ugly at times.
Profile Image for Becky Loader.
2,212 reviews29 followers
February 10, 2021
Tara Smith thinks she is "the weird girl" in school. She studies, keeps to a routine, and doesn't have any friends. Imagine her surprise when she bursts into flames.

Yes, that would do it for anyone.

Tara ends up in a special school for others like her: aliens on planet earth.

Believe it or not, it works. These teenage girls are pretty much like other teenage girls I have known who have never visited Alpha Centauri.

Next, please!
Profile Image for Melanie.
286 reviews9 followers
August 7, 2020
I really enjoyed this! Found family, tons of different alien races, learning to accept not only others but your newfound identity? Yes, yes, and yes! Can't wait for the next one!
Profile Image for Lost Lare.
52 reviews
July 27, 2023
I went into this book thinking I wasn't going to get into it then I read the first 20-ish pages and loved it, and then we met the roommates and I really had trouble getting through the rest.

At its best School for Extraterrestrial Girls is MIB combined with a girl's high school drama. The different Alien types are unique and interesting. The characters are not perfect, but still understandably flawed. I was really excited when I learned that Tera was not going to dwell on losing her parents and her home. I also found the species/race commentary fresh. It was interesting to have one alien as a beautiful fairy, but have not idea about their dark history. And the elements of Tara coming to terms with what she is while not coming to terms with the real alien form of the nicest student ever was a bit fascinating. That is about where my positivity ends. The school's headmistress has a very tough love approach to sending new students into a deep end without giving guidance on how to swim. This gets to the point where I really am surprised the school functions as well as it does. I also found a lot of the drama and reactions a bit over the top. In the end I really hated all the characters except Summer. I will get more into my issues in the spoilers. I will say that the more I think about the problems the more sense they make for the story. Like they make logical sense for the characters and story, but it doesn't make it any easier for me to read. This is a long winded way of saying take my thoughts with heaps of salt. If an MIB high school drama sounds really cool for you give it a shot, but maybe get it from a library before purchasing it.

Profile Image for Nargis  Kalani.
407 reviews87 followers
December 9, 2020
Thanks to netgalley and Papercutz for this e-ARC. I can't resist when it comes to a fine graphic novel whether it's an e-copy or a physical one. When I saw the cover and description of this one, I instantly requested it. It's obviously a diverse read and lately, I am trying to read more of these types of books.

So this girl Tara has super strict parents with a bunch of rules that she needs to follow including not taking out that bracelet she wears. After an accident where her powers are revealed in front of ordinary people, she's captured by some government people and is given two options. Getting out of planet Earth or join this extraterrestial girls school. From here the real story unfolds.

I loved the graphics, obviously. The flow of the story was mind-blowing with such diverse characters. Yup, there are different kinds of aliens with different abilities. The story has a deep moral about accepting diversity, self-love and friendship. Another thing, I enjoy stories with aliens in it. Author's idea of a School for extraterrestial is just amazing and the execution was done quite well. I really want to read the next one in the series. There's action, drama and mystery as well. Honestly, I cannot get over the graphical representation of various alien races in this story.

Overall, it was such a fun read. Highly recommend it to those who love graphic novels/comics.
Profile Image for S.
1,106 reviews
October 18, 2020
This may be more a statement of the world we live in than the author's writing and intent but the government coming in and taking a child away from her parents, insisting they are bad for her, and giving her a "choice" between a special school or being shipped off to a place she has no knowledge of rubs me the wrong way. (Feelings further compounded by the illustrations in which she is depicted as a black child, though I get that technically that's a disguise). Anyway...if you can disconnect from the horrors of our reality, this might be fine. Otherwise it just seems to handle hard issues in poor taste or with out a great deal of care.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Profile Image for Pam.
9,919 reviews55 followers
July 10, 2020
Graphic Novel.
I received an ARC from Papercutz.
Engaging story about a school for extraterrestrial girls who all live on earth. Tara Smith thinks she is an ordinary 15-year old until the day her bracelet breaks and she doesn't take her meds. Suddenly, she catches fire at school and doesn't burn. From there, she's offered the choice to attend this high school and learn about herself.
The more important lessons apply to every species. She needs to learn about empathy and friendship as well as figuring out who she is.
Looking forward to more from this series.
Profile Image for The Sapphic Nerd.
1,147 reviews48 followers
June 12, 2020
While this is a fun read with lovable characters, there's a more important message here. With its themes of diversity, acceptance, identity, and chosen family, School for Extraterrestrial Girls presents an important message in a time where prejudice and discrimination are putting lives at risk.

For the full review, head over to my blog!
Profile Image for Pop Bop.
2,502 reviews125 followers
May 24, 2020
Getting Comfortable in Your Own Skin

This is a definite two-fer. Well imagined, and often surprising, alien characters. And, complicated teen girl high school drama with an extra-terrestrial twist. For me, both angles worked well. This book manages to touch on pretty much every teen issue you could think of, and earns bonus points by cleverly, if unapologetically and obviously, also hitting every adolescent metaphor on this or any other planet.

As we open Tara learns that she's a kidnapped alien who has been mind wiped and led to believe she's human. She's not. She's an alien in disguise. So, she is not who she thought she was, she does not really look like she thinks she does, she doesn't know what she really is, and she is in for a surprise when her restraint bracelet is switched off and she finds out what she physically looks like. In one fell swoop we get every identity crisis, body image, uncertain future, parent issue, find-yourself theme dropped on poor Tara. It is a testament to the way she's written and presented that most of the time she is an appealing, relateable and sympathetic character; even when she's a jerk, which happens fairly frequently, one can relate and empathize.

On top of this Tara has been whisked off to a school for teen girls from other alien worlds who are in pretty much the same boat as is she. Now she needs to deal with teachers, roommates, friends, frenemies, and how all of their issues affect her and are affected by her. She makes and loses friends, repairs relationships, and stumbles through every possible high school drama. An amusing late addition alien friend, who has been educated about American Earth only through study of teen TV shows and soap operas, enthusiastically points out all of the opportunities for high drama, and this cheerful and deadpan pal acts as a sort of Greek chorus to caption the various stages of Tara's increasingly antic and erratic high school life.

Sometimes the going is a bit slow and heavy, but the book has a lot of energy. There's even a fair amount of action. Tara really is engaging, and everything moves along briskly. There seemed to be an upbeat and optimistic vibe underlying the whole project that kept the story from becoming dreary or grim. You get the sense that Tara will be O.K., and everyone will survive high school, and maybe that's the best message of all.

(Please note that I received a free advance will-self-destruct-in-x-days Adobe Digital copy of this book without a review requirement, or any influence regarding review content should I choose to post a review. Apart from that I have no connection at all to either the author or the publisher of this book.)
Profile Image for Sharon Tyler.
2,815 reviews40 followers
September 16, 2020
Girl on Fire is the first volume of the School for Extraterrestrial Girls graphic novel series by Jeremy Whitley. Tara Smith’s parents are super strict with all their rules and routines, and Tara is a dutiful daughter. Rule #1: No friends her own age. Rule #2: keep her bracelet on, or else. But when she breaks her routine and then loses her bracelet she is in trouble. Outed as an extraterrestrial after wielding fire and losing her humanoid form, Tara is captured by the government. She’s given two options: get shipped far away where she won’t be a danger to anyone or stay on Earth and join a school for other extraterrestrial girls like her. Things at the school aren’t easy, especially for the girl whose only friends were textbooks. But Tara’s goal to learn how to control her powers is soon sidelined by the discovery that the people she’s called Mom and Dad all these years aren’t her parents. With her not-parents still out there, Tara must rely on others for the first time to figure out who she really is before she’s kidnapped a second time.

Girl on Fire is a teen, high school drama with flair. Tara discovers that her childhood has been a lie and everything she thought she knew about herself, her parents, and the world is not true. She has to adjust to that, on top of being a lizard like alien that creates fire. That is a lot to deal with, not add in boarding school with other aliens and trying to make friends while being anxious, awkward, and still not comfortable with herself. I found myself worried for her, relating to her, and cringing as she reacted in ways I cannot promise I would not mirror in her circumstances. The artwork does a good job of capturing the emotion and wonder of Tara facing all these changes. The different aliens, the facial expressions, and the action were very well portrayed and added a great deal to the whole. Despite the strangeness of the setting, the feelings, friendships, and fears of the individuals in the school were relatable and I think the book will speak to a wide range of readers on different levels. I enjoyed the read, and look forward to seeing what happens next.

Girl on Fire is a wonderful graphic novel for middle school through adult readers. I think there is a little something for everyone here and I am eager to see where the next volume of the story takes us.
Profile Image for Bruce.
1,589 reviews22 followers
May 14, 2021
Tara Smith is a disciplined, serious student with parents that pressure her to be extraordinary. She has few friends at school. It’s OK; Tara likes to study; she just doesn’t like school. Her classmates think she’s weird and she gets taunted and teased constantly. She’s got a strict schedule and a strict diet. She must take a lot of pills for her allergies and eat only the right foods. Her only break is taking out the trash at night. Then she can look up at the stars and dream of becoming an astronaut. Her routine is stressful, but she can handle it, until the day the alarm clock doesn’t go off. She gets up late, spills her breakfast and her morning pills, and almost misses the school bus. She’s late, frustrated and angry. So, when the bullies on the bus start to pick on her, instead of just ignoring them as she usually does, she screams SHUT UP and her eyes glow like burning red coals. It’s no better when she gets to school. She’s good at math but standing up in front of the class, to solve a problem on the board, when feeling embarrassed and upset, she suddenly combusts into flame.

On fire she runs to the locker room showers to douse herself, and collapses. When she awakens, she’s confronted by a woman in black who reveals to Tara her true identity. Tara is not the studious African American teen she has assumed she was for the past fifteen years. In fact, she a green skinned alien reptile in disguise, and she’s about to be sent to a secret government boarding school for girls like her. Alas, Tara finds it just as hard to fit in at this new school as she did at her old school. Everybody there is just so different.

Whitley’s PrinceLess series challenged racial and patriarchal stereotypes. Now he tackles the challenges of diversity, multiculturalism, and xenophobia in this new series. Noguchi’s sharp lines and dramatic panel composition along with her and Lilly’s vivid colors add verve to the story.
Profile Image for Arminzerella.
3,746 reviews93 followers
October 3, 2020
Tara Smith has a very carefully regimented life and plans to keep her head down and get through high school so she can achieve her dreams of heading into space. But after missing her alarm one morning, her day snowballs out of control, culminating in her self-immolating, passing out, and waking up in the custody of agents who claim she is an extraterrestrial. After removing the devices that hide her true nature, Tara is faced with her true self - she's a flaming lizard. Her choices are limited - she can choose to be sent "home" to a planet and people she's never known, or she can stay on Earth as part of its alien expatriat community and attend a special school for extraterrestrial girls. It's a no-brainer for Tara who has yet to come to grips with her true identity. Her roommates are welcoming, but Tara has some issues getting to know them - she's never had real friends before, so she's awkward and unintentionally rude. Just as she's finding her way, the headmistress outs her and this puts even more stress on some of her relationships. When one of her roommates disappears, Tara becomes concerned. Is this all her fault?

There are so many aliens among us! It's interesting to learn about all of the different species/races attending the extraterrestrial school for girls. There's some legitimate drama too, as they make discoveries about themselves and develop - in Tara's case especially - some very essential social skills. At the end, they're set to join up with the extraterrestrial school for boys (where I'm sure all kinds of hijinks will ensue). Entertaining and fun with some serious content about friendship and acceptance.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Profile Image for Eule Luftschloss.
2,115 reviews54 followers
May 19, 2020
trigger warning


Tara is leading a very boring life with a strict routine in order to have an extraordinary future and become an astronaut.
At least, that's what her life was, until she discovers she's not human.

This was fun!
Tara gets the choice: Either she is shipped back to her home planet or she joins the school for extraterrestial girls. If she does the latter, after three years she is deemed safe for public, which would be a good thing since she turns to burn when emotional.

There are the usual problems of changing schools in the middle of the year and having to find new friends while being awkward, but also conflicts due to being from a race that might be at war with someone else's people.

I really like the aspect of having a school full of pupils in which everyone has different abilities, and see how these play out. Apart from the daily slice of life, we have an overarching plot, but I won't say anything about that. Look for yourself.

This was short and sweet. I would not go out of my way to read on, but if I should stumble upon further issues I'd carry on.

I recieved a copy of this book in exchange for a honest review.
Profile Image for Annamarie Carlson (she, her).
1,259 reviews23 followers
Read
October 15, 2020
Tara Smith longs to be extraordinary--but, when she said that, she dreamed of becoming an astronaut, not spontaneously combusting in math class. She wanted to travel to space--not find out she is really an alien. She wanted her parents to be a little less routine-oriented--not really be kidnappers that tore her away from her home and hid Tara's true identity from her for years.

But, things don't always work out the way you expect. Such as when you discover all of these extraordinary things about yourself, while also finding out that you still have to go to high school (but now a high school for alien teenage girls). New friendships, drama, and confusion seem to follow Tara wherever she goes as she tries to figure out where she fits in among the big, wide universe.

A new series by the author of Princeless! This wasn't quite as amazing as Princeless, but I am definitely looking forward to the sequel. Tara's emotional ups and downs felt very real, and I'm excited to see more of the world created in this series, including the multitude of alien species (more cat people please!). I'm also ready for the strength of a united Tara, Summer, and Misako--their new school isn't going to know what hit them.
Profile Image for Lucia.
12 reviews
August 28, 2020
La historia es muy buena,si lo que quieres es una historia tranquila ,relajada,sin mucha prisa para leerla,esta historieta es la adecuada,tanto para niños y adolescentes,la protagonista va creciendo y desarrollándose a través de las páginas,como cualquier adolescente esta en etapa de cambios, ha pasado por muchas en un día.
Sus padres son muy estrictos y no son como cualquier padres,son de una manera sus enseñanzas que se muestran,como su papa y mama que no tuvieran amigos de su edad para ella es dificil confiar en otros ademas de su familia,pero no hay otro modo de enfrentarse a lo que sigue,es un si o si en confiar en las personas que la cuidan a ellas y otros como ella, al principio pensé que no me iba a gustar,como vas progresando con la lectura
,te quedas de que esta pasando en ese momento,porque wow te quedas pasmado,o sea no me esperaba algunos eventos que sucedieran así, con un poco de comedia y misterio si se le puede decir así o suspenso,tratas de averiguar que es Tara,que especie es,lo recomiendo sino quieres una lectura pesada,denle una oportunidad, disfrutenla poco a poco como lo hice yo.
Profile Image for Lucia.
12 reviews
August 28, 2020
The story is very good, if what you want is a calm, relaxed story, without much rush to read it, this cartoon is the right one, both for children and adolescents, the protagonist grows and develops through the pages, like any teenager It is in a stage of changes, it has gone through many in one day.
Her parents are very strict and they are not like any parents, they are in a way their teachings that are shown, like her father and mother who did not have friends of her age for her it is difficult to trust others besides her family, but there is no other way of facing what follows, it is a yes or yes in trusting the people who take care of them and others like her, at first I thought that I was not going to like it, how do you progress with reading
, you are left with what is happening at that moment, because wow you are stunned, that is, I did not expect some events that would happen like this, with a bit of comedy and mystery if it can be said like that or suspense, you try to find out what Tara is , what species is it, I recommend it if you don't want a heavy reading.
Profile Image for Dontreadlikethem .
97 reviews1 follower
July 15, 2020
This graphic novel starts with a bang and then slowly settles into everyday life. After getting introduced to Tara's mundane isolated life for a couple of pages her routine is disrupted when she is covered in fire. Yes the cover is Tara sitting in school. We quickly transition to a secret government organization that enrolls Tara into an all women school for aliens. This is where the real story begins and is the setting for the rest of the book. Tara discovers even though she has the ability to start fresh, making friends and being honest isn't as easy as it sounds. As a reader you won't always agree with Tara's actions regardless of being human or alien. However, that what will ultimately connect the reader. She reminds us that we are all capable of hurting the people around us even if we think we are good people. I can't wait for the boy's school is book 2. My only small complainant is why can we have aliens but still only stick to two genders? Come on. Children ages 12 and up.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 100 reviews

Can't find what you're looking for?

Get help and learn more about the design.