What do you think?
Rate this book
A Matter of Honor: A Pride & Prejudice Variation
Pride & Prejudice goes to Scotland!
When Fitzwilliam Darcy, still smarting from Elizabeth’s rejection, discovers she was forced to flee her home in disgrace owing to his actions, his course is clear. He must marry her. It is a matter of honor. All he has to do is find her and propose. Surely that will be simple enough.
But Elizabeth does not want to be found, especially not by Darcy. From the moment he entered her life, he has caused disaster after disaster. Now he has followed her all the way to Scotland, foolishly certain it is within his power to fix all her problems. But far more is at stake than Darcy knows, and Elizabeth is out of options.
Darcy’s quest for Elizabeth takes him from backstage at Edinburgh’s Theatre Royal to the wilds of the Scottish Highlands, where Highlanders prove both friend and enemy. And now his search risks exposing long-hidden secrets that threaten his happiness and her future.
On the run and in danger, Elizabeth is forced to make impossible choices to protect those whom she loves – including Darcy. Her growing attraction to him is at war with her need for caution, and the stakes are impossibly high. Can she trust him to continue to fight for her protection when he knows the whole truth? And if he does, will it be for love… or will it be merely a matter of honor?
Join bestselling author Abigail Reynolds as she transports the reader to the Scottish lochs and mountains in this sweeping Regency drama based on Jane Austen’s Pride and Prejudice!
When Fitzwilliam Darcy, still smarting from Elizabeth’s rejection, discovers she was forced to flee her home in disgrace owing to his actions, his course is clear. He must marry her. It is a matter of honor. All he has to do is find her and propose. Surely that will be simple enough.
But Elizabeth does not want to be found, especially not by Darcy. From the moment he entered her life, he has caused disaster after disaster. Now he has followed her all the way to Scotland, foolishly certain it is within his power to fix all her problems. But far more is at stake than Darcy knows, and Elizabeth is out of options.
Darcy’s quest for Elizabeth takes him from backstage at Edinburgh’s Theatre Royal to the wilds of the Scottish Highlands, where Highlanders prove both friend and enemy. And now his search risks exposing long-hidden secrets that threaten his happiness and her future.
On the run and in danger, Elizabeth is forced to make impossible choices to protect those whom she loves – including Darcy. Her growing attraction to him is at war with her need for caution, and the stakes are impossibly high. Can she trust him to continue to fight for her protection when he knows the whole truth? And if he does, will it be for love… or will it be merely a matter of honor?
Join bestselling author Abigail Reynolds as she transports the reader to the Scottish lochs and mountains in this sweeping Regency drama based on Jane Austen’s Pride and Prejudice!
485 pages, Kindle Edition
Published September 5, 2019
238 people are currently reading
230 people want to read
About the author
Abigail Reynolds
69 books783 followersAbigail Reynolds may be a nationally bestselling author and a physician, but she can’t follow a straight line with a ruler. Originally from upstate New York, she studied Russian and theater at Bryn Mawr College and marine biology at the Marine Biological Laboratory in Woods Hole. After a stint in performing arts administration, she decided to attend medical school, and took up writing as a way to retain her sanity during her years as a physician in private practice.
A life-long lover of Jane Austen’s novels, Abigail began writing variations on Pride & Prejudice in 2001, then expanded her repertoire to include a series of novels set on her beloved Cape Cod.Her most recent releases are A Matter of Honor, Mr. Darcy's Enchantment, and Conceit & Concealment. Her books have been translated into six languages. A lifetime member of JASNA, she lives on Cape Cod with her husband, her son and a menagerie of animals. Her hobbies do not include sleeping or cleaning her house.
A life-long lover of Jane Austen’s novels, Abigail began writing variations on Pride & Prejudice in 2001, then expanded her repertoire to include a series of novels set on her beloved Cape Cod.Her most recent releases are A Matter of Honor, Mr. Darcy's Enchantment, and Conceit & Concealment. Her books have been translated into six languages. A lifetime member of JASNA, she lives on Cape Cod with her husband, her son and a menagerie of animals. Her hobbies do not include sleeping or cleaning her house.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 79 reviews
November 13, 2019
In her recently released A Matter of Honor, Abigail Reynolds gives Darcy and Elizabeth some new obstacles. She mostly ignores Longbourn and Pemberley and, while Hunsford and Rosings loom large in the plot, her book goes to Kent only briefly, spending most of its time in Scotland.
The story begins six months after Elizabeth refused Darcy’s insulting marriage proposal and accepted his letter the following morning, but their paths haven’t crossed since. Mr. Bingley and Mr. Darcy are returning to Netherfield, each praying he can win the forgiveness and love of his respective Bennet sister. Both gentlemen are shunned by the entire Meryton community, and they’re turned away from Longbourn. When Bingley discovers the reason, he angrily confronts Darcy. “You ruined [Elizabeth], and with her, you ruined the woman I love. Because of you, Miss Elizabeth has had to leave Longbourn forever. The Bennets are in deep disgrace.”
Darcy didn’t do anything wrong, but he figures this is an easy fix: he’ll just talk to Mr. Bennet and offer to marry Elizabeth, which is what he’d planned to do anyway.
Nope. Mr. Bennet won’t budge. “Lizzy does not wish to marry you, and she will do so only over my dead body… She is out of your reach. I am the only person who knows where she is, and I will not tell you.”
But it’s Darcy he’s talking to here, and you just know he’s not giving up so easily. It’s a matter of honor, after all─honor and love. The search is on!
And a hugely entertaining search it is. It leads Darcy through the Edinburgh Theatre Royal, with one section of the book centered around the life of the “theatricals,” as the company members call themselves. Darcy does manage to find Elizabeth fairly early on, but she’s elusive, skittish, and eventually disappears again (after one steamy kiss), terrified that anyone in England might learn they have been together. What’s her problem? The full answer is complicated. This book contains plenty of secrets, danger, romance, and angst.
And humor! A housekeeper by the name of Mrs. MacLaren introduces the staff: “…May I present the butler of Kinloch House, Mr. MacLaren? And this is our steward, Mr. MacLaren.” Then we have Auld Jack (another MacLaren), who may or may not be a highwayman; he regularly threatens to kill Elizabeth. And there’s a crazy (yet remarkably credible) scene that, in Elizabeth’s words, is “…a wedding turned into a drawing-room comedy.”
I do believe this is Ms. Reynolds’ best story yet. Purists might argue that it’s too far off-canon to be considered a true P&P variation, but I contend that Darcy, Elizabeth and other characters from canon here are consistent with Jane Austen’s characterizations, which is my personal litmus test.
It’s a brilliantly woven tale filled with numerous subplots that all influence the primary story: Darcy’s resolve to overcome all obstacles and marry Elizabeth. Ms. Reynolds incorporates into her story the popularity of Walter Scott’s The Lady of the Lake, which is set in the Highlands and was first published in 1810. Not only do we learn about the suspicion with which the Highlanders of this era viewed all “Sassenach” (the British), but we get a history lesson explaining the roots of their mistrust, and it’s integral to the plot. Things are light and fun with the theatre group in the Lowlands, but the chapters in the Scottish Highlands are chilling…literally. Elizabeth lives there during the cold, dark, snowy winter, with the harsh weather providing both a fitting atmosphere and a significant effect on the trajectory of the story.
The author creates vivid characters, even minor ones like the children. Depictions of Mrs. MacLean, Jasper Fitzpatrick, and the other actors remind me of real people I met in a community theatre group. We see the confrontational side of Colonel Fitzwilliam, who’s unusually cranky. The various MacLarens might share the same name, but the clan chief and his son have distinctive personalities, as do many other clan members. I particularly enjoy the cantankerous Auld Jack.
As for romance, Abigail Reynolds has always been a master at building up the steam between Darcy and Elizabeth. At times, the angst-meter reaches excruciating levels. However, true love prevails, as we know it must.
And when it’s an Abigail Reynolds book, we know it’s a must-read. This one certainly is!
Full review can be read at Austenprose:
https://austenprose.com/2019/11/13/a-...
The story begins six months after Elizabeth refused Darcy’s insulting marriage proposal and accepted his letter the following morning, but their paths haven’t crossed since. Mr. Bingley and Mr. Darcy are returning to Netherfield, each praying he can win the forgiveness and love of his respective Bennet sister. Both gentlemen are shunned by the entire Meryton community, and they’re turned away from Longbourn. When Bingley discovers the reason, he angrily confronts Darcy. “You ruined [Elizabeth], and with her, you ruined the woman I love. Because of you, Miss Elizabeth has had to leave Longbourn forever. The Bennets are in deep disgrace.”
Darcy didn’t do anything wrong, but he figures this is an easy fix: he’ll just talk to Mr. Bennet and offer to marry Elizabeth, which is what he’d planned to do anyway.
Nope. Mr. Bennet won’t budge. “Lizzy does not wish to marry you, and she will do so only over my dead body… She is out of your reach. I am the only person who knows where she is, and I will not tell you.”
But it’s Darcy he’s talking to here, and you just know he’s not giving up so easily. It’s a matter of honor, after all─honor and love. The search is on!
And a hugely entertaining search it is. It leads Darcy through the Edinburgh Theatre Royal, with one section of the book centered around the life of the “theatricals,” as the company members call themselves. Darcy does manage to find Elizabeth fairly early on, but she’s elusive, skittish, and eventually disappears again (after one steamy kiss), terrified that anyone in England might learn they have been together. What’s her problem? The full answer is complicated. This book contains plenty of secrets, danger, romance, and angst.
And humor! A housekeeper by the name of Mrs. MacLaren introduces the staff: “…May I present the butler of Kinloch House, Mr. MacLaren? And this is our steward, Mr. MacLaren.” Then we have Auld Jack (another MacLaren), who may or may not be a highwayman; he regularly threatens to kill Elizabeth. And there’s a crazy (yet remarkably credible) scene that, in Elizabeth’s words, is “…a wedding turned into a drawing-room comedy.”
I do believe this is Ms. Reynolds’ best story yet. Purists might argue that it’s too far off-canon to be considered a true P&P variation, but I contend that Darcy, Elizabeth and other characters from canon here are consistent with Jane Austen’s characterizations, which is my personal litmus test.
It’s a brilliantly woven tale filled with numerous subplots that all influence the primary story: Darcy’s resolve to overcome all obstacles and marry Elizabeth. Ms. Reynolds incorporates into her story the popularity of Walter Scott’s The Lady of the Lake, which is set in the Highlands and was first published in 1810. Not only do we learn about the suspicion with which the Highlanders of this era viewed all “Sassenach” (the British), but we get a history lesson explaining the roots of their mistrust, and it’s integral to the plot. Things are light and fun with the theatre group in the Lowlands, but the chapters in the Scottish Highlands are chilling…literally. Elizabeth lives there during the cold, dark, snowy winter, with the harsh weather providing both a fitting atmosphere and a significant effect on the trajectory of the story.
The author creates vivid characters, even minor ones like the children. Depictions of Mrs. MacLean, Jasper Fitzpatrick, and the other actors remind me of real people I met in a community theatre group. We see the confrontational side of Colonel Fitzwilliam, who’s unusually cranky. The various MacLarens might share the same name, but the clan chief and his son have distinctive personalities, as do many other clan members. I particularly enjoy the cantankerous Auld Jack.
As for romance, Abigail Reynolds has always been a master at building up the steam between Darcy and Elizabeth. At times, the angst-meter reaches excruciating levels. However, true love prevails, as we know it must.
And when it’s an Abigail Reynolds book, we know it’s a must-read. This one certainly is!
Full review can be read at Austenprose:
https://austenprose.com/2019/11/13/a-...
September 19, 2024
The play’s the thing ~ William Shakespeare
“A Matter of Honor” is yet another in a long line of great books from the imagination of Abigail Reynolds.
The story begins as Darcy and Bingley return to Meryton some months after the Disastrous Hunsford Proposal. They are not welcomed by their former acquaintances and are denied entrance to Longbourn. The initial mystery is to discover the cause behind their rejection. When they learn that Elizabeth Bennet has been forced by scandal to leave her home, Darcy vows to find her, wherever she is and make the scandal disappear.
A clue leads him to Scotland where he discovers an absent member of the Fitzwilliam family who has found employment with a theatre troupe. That discovery leads directly to Elizabeth. Then, the mystery deepens.
Why does Elizabeth continue to reject Darcy’s proposal even after it seems obvious her feelings have changed?
Who is the woman who has welcomed Elizabeth into her home?
What is the threat to the Bennet family?
I enjoyed this story about Scottish Highland history and the concurrent story of the theatrical people in Edinburgh. The things you can learn from JAFF! For example, did you know the Kirk in Scotland did not celebrate Christmas? That was a surprise to me.
The story is well-written, proofread and researched. I loved it.
All the world's a stage,
And all the men and women merely players ~ William Shakespeare
“A Matter of Honor” is yet another in a long line of great books from the imagination of Abigail Reynolds.
The story begins as Darcy and Bingley return to Meryton some months after the Disastrous Hunsford Proposal. They are not welcomed by their former acquaintances and are denied entrance to Longbourn. The initial mystery is to discover the cause behind their rejection. When they learn that Elizabeth Bennet has been forced by scandal to leave her home, Darcy vows to find her, wherever she is and make the scandal disappear.
A clue leads him to Scotland where he discovers an absent member of the Fitzwilliam family who has found employment with a theatre troupe. That discovery leads directly to Elizabeth. Then, the mystery deepens.
Why does Elizabeth continue to reject Darcy’s proposal even after it seems obvious her feelings have changed?
Who is the woman who has welcomed Elizabeth into her home?
What is the threat to the Bennet family?
I enjoyed this story about Scottish Highland history and the concurrent story of the theatrical people in Edinburgh. The things you can learn from JAFF! For example, did you know the Kirk in Scotland did not celebrate Christmas? That was a surprise to me.
The story is well-written, proofread and researched. I loved it.
All the world's a stage,
And all the men and women merely players ~ William Shakespeare
October 8, 2019
This author is one of my favorites. Her variations were some of the very first I read back before I even owned a Kindle so that they are among the many paperbacks I own in JAFF.
We have that proposal at Hunsford but then things change from canon. Bingley and Darcy arrive back in Hertfordshire. Elizabeth is gone and Mr. Bennet is harsh and adamant that not only will he not approve Darcy's offer of his hand for the disgraced/compromised Elizabeth but he also refuses to discuss the matter and/or to give Darcy any information concerning her whereabouts. Darcy does not understand what is going on but he is determined to find Elizabeth and again offer his hand as it appears he compromised her when he met her alone at the parsonage and then gave her the letter the next day. (Who witnessed that?) His search for clues is intriguing in itself.
The author's blurb tells the reader that the pursuit goes into Scotland. Her research about the history of the clans and the areas she has included in this tale makes the story that much more interesting. She gives us a synopsis at the end of the variation.
(Mr. Gardiner comes into the story as a publisher in a unique way.)
Elizabeth has literally been dumped upon her aunt, her father's sister, who is an actress. Ironically one of Darcy's cousins is also among the theatricals in Edinburgh. The world of the theatre has its own rules and bonds. Darcy accidently espies Elizabeth there and is rebuffed. He also is surprised to find his "missing" cousin and that part of the story is a tale in and of itself.
As Elizabeth tries to again leave Darcy behind it seems everyone is named MacLaren in and around the estate, Kinloch House, to which Elizabeth has gone. The clan's bonds and endeavors to aid and protect all of their members makes for some, at first, confusing happenings. Elizabeth cannot determine the motives behind many acts and directives. Why are most paths she wants to walk off-limits - because of vicious dogs? Why are elderly persons working and not retired from service, etc.?
There is a mystery in this variation. Elizabeth's motive for not wanting ANY contact with Darcy is not revealed for much of the story. What hold does someone have over her and just who is that person or persons? There are hints that her father is in danger of even losing his life. Why? Darcy's family may be the culprit(s) but then who said what to whom? Do we have a new villain in this story other than that in canon?
This is a long story but one which kept me turning pages. I highly recommend it.
10-7-19: I won my own Kindle copy of this book from a blog tour raffle...thus I reread it to show my happiness with having won that prize. I would have reread it at some time but I must say it was just as intriguing the second time as it was the first. Great story with lots of interesting information from the author's research used in telling as well as explained at the end.
We have that proposal at Hunsford but then things change from canon. Bingley and Darcy arrive back in Hertfordshire. Elizabeth is gone and Mr. Bennet is harsh and adamant that not only will he not approve Darcy's offer of his hand for the disgraced/compromised Elizabeth but he also refuses to discuss the matter and/or to give Darcy any information concerning her whereabouts. Darcy does not understand what is going on but he is determined to find Elizabeth and again offer his hand as it appears he compromised her when he met her alone at the parsonage and then gave her the letter the next day. (Who witnessed that?) His search for clues is intriguing in itself.
The author's blurb tells the reader that the pursuit goes into Scotland. Her research about the history of the clans and the areas she has included in this tale makes the story that much more interesting. She gives us a synopsis at the end of the variation.
(Mr. Gardiner comes into the story as a publisher in a unique way.)
Elizabeth has literally been dumped upon her aunt, her father's sister, who is an actress. Ironically one of Darcy's cousins is also among the theatricals in Edinburgh. The world of the theatre has its own rules and bonds. Darcy accidently espies Elizabeth there and is rebuffed. He also is surprised to find his "missing" cousin and that part of the story is a tale in and of itself.
As Elizabeth tries to again leave Darcy behind it seems everyone is named MacLaren in and around the estate, Kinloch House, to which Elizabeth has gone. The clan's bonds and endeavors to aid and protect all of their members makes for some, at first, confusing happenings. Elizabeth cannot determine the motives behind many acts and directives. Why are most paths she wants to walk off-limits - because of vicious dogs? Why are elderly persons working and not retired from service, etc.?
There is a mystery in this variation. Elizabeth's motive for not wanting ANY contact with Darcy is not revealed for much of the story. What hold does someone have over her and just who is that person or persons? There are hints that her father is in danger of even losing his life. Why? Darcy's family may be the culprit(s) but then who said what to whom? Do we have a new villain in this story other than that in canon?
This is a long story but one which kept me turning pages. I highly recommend it.
10-7-19: I won my own Kindle copy of this book from a blog tour raffle...thus I reread it to show my happiness with having won that prize. I would have reread it at some time but I must say it was just as intriguing the second time as it was the first. Great story with lots of interesting information from the author's research used in telling as well as explained at the end.
October 14, 2019
This is sort of a P&P mystery that turns everything after Hunsford on its ear and keeps the reader guessing for much of the book.
In this variation when Darcy & Bingley return to Meryton in the fall the Bennets are not a home to them, after several frustrating days they learn that Miss Elizabeth Bennet was ruined by Mr. Darcy. Obviously this shocks Darcy and appalls Bingley who sends him packing. Darcy begins a quest to track down and marry Miss Elizabeth.
The author has loads of twists in this tale, Mr. Bennet at his most indolent, Lady Catherine at her most imperious and Wickham making new depths is dastardliness. And she has new characters for us to enjoy including the theatrical community in Edinburgh, some new Fitzwilliams, a Scottish clan chief, a highway man and a three legged dog.
Any details would require extensive nested spoiler tags so I am just going to say it is highly recommended. It is a clean story over all.
There's just one thing that bugged me a little while I was reading and after the end.
Edited to add: Darcy makes an observation that Edinburgh isn't that large but according to in 1811 the population was 103,143 and the 3rd most populace city in Britain was Edinburgh. http://www.edinphoto.org.uk/1_edin/1_... I know totally nerdy nitpick but it bugged me.
In this variation when Darcy & Bingley return to Meryton in the fall the Bennets are not a home to them, after several frustrating days they learn that Miss Elizabeth Bennet was ruined by Mr. Darcy. Obviously this shocks Darcy and appalls Bingley who sends him packing. Darcy begins a quest to track down and marry Miss Elizabeth.
The author has loads of twists in this tale, Mr. Bennet at his most indolent, Lady Catherine at her most imperious and Wickham making new depths is dastardliness. And she has new characters for us to enjoy including the theatrical community in Edinburgh, some new Fitzwilliams, a Scottish clan chief, a highway man and a three legged dog.
Any details would require extensive nested spoiler tags so I am just going to say it is highly recommended. It is a clean story over all.
There's just one thing that bugged me a little while I was reading and after the end.
Edited to add: Darcy makes an observation that Edinburgh isn't that large but according to in 1811 the population was 103,143 and the 3rd most populace city in Britain was Edinburgh. http://www.edinphoto.org.uk/1_edin/1_... I know totally nerdy nitpick but it bugged me.
July 8, 2020
Lizzy in Scotland
Table of Contents works
The X-ray feature works, always a plus
I recommend this book highly.
SPOILERS
The main what-if makes a lot of sense. After the bad proposal, what if Lady Catherine figures out that Darcy has feelings for Lizzy and decides to force them apart. The way she works on Lizzy to leave Darcy alone is pretty original. It’s also illegal but non-lawyers would probably not know that so Lizzy can’t take any chances. Lots of bad guys but the main problem is Mr. Bennet.
The only negative I have for the story was Lizzy forgiving him at all.
Table of Contents works
The X-ray feature works, always a plus
I recommend this book highly.
SPOILERS
The main what-if makes a lot of sense. After the bad proposal, what if Lady Catherine figures out that Darcy has feelings for Lizzy and decides to force them apart. The way she works on Lizzy to leave Darcy alone is pretty original. It’s also illegal but non-lawyers would probably not know that so Lizzy can’t take any chances. Lots of bad guys but the main problem is Mr. Bennet.
The only negative I have for the story was Lizzy forgiving him at all.
January 11, 2024
What happens when Darcy inadvertently compromises Elizabeth by a letter and his family decides to hold no punches and threaten her whole entire family?
A Scottish adventure!
Que Theatricals, Kilts and Old Jack the highwayman. Add the spice of Darcy's enduring love, and you got a fantastic story. Politics, Money and Family drama courtesy of Lord Fitzwilliam brings much to inflame an already complex situation.
But will Darcy get his Elizabeth in the end?
Listened on audiobook, after reading a couple of times. Great narration (even tho she isn't my fave) her accents were awesome!
A Scottish adventure!
Que Theatricals, Kilts and Old Jack the highwayman. Add the spice of Darcy's enduring love, and you got a fantastic story. Politics, Money and Family drama courtesy of Lord Fitzwilliam brings much to inflame an already complex situation.
But will Darcy get his Elizabeth in the end?
Listened on audiobook, after reading a couple of times. Great narration (even tho she isn't my fave) her accents were awesome!
July 2, 2020
Honor, Highlands, and Hidden Motives
Rating: 4.5 out of 5 stars
TYPE OF NOVEL: Pride and Prejudice Variation
TIME FRAME: Begins around six months after Darcy’s Hunsford proposal
SYNOPSIS: What if Mr. Darcy discovered Elizabeth was accused of improper behavior with him and as a result her family has been ostracized and disgraced?
What if Elizabeth accepted ruination and removal from her family and no one, except a belligerent Mr. Bennet, knows where she has gone?
What if a determined and (still besotted) Mr. Darcy sets out to rescue Elizabeth Bennet, reclaim her honor, and earn her love only to discover that she will continue to evade and run from him?
What if Mr. Darcy and Elizabeth Bennet wound up in Scotland?!?
WHAT I LOVED:
- A Wee Tour of Scotland: If I wasn’t already hankering to visit Scotland, this armchair travel adventure would have me convinced me to make Scotland one of the next countries I visit! From the bustling city of Edinburgh and the Theatre Royal to the wild ways of the Highlands filled with lochs and castles – it was quite the tour! I know Abigail Reynolds must have researched Scotland during the Regency era extensively to portray it with such descriptive detail. I especially enjoyed how Ms. Reynolds wove in some real history with Walter Scott being a fan of the Theatre Royal and his inspiring poetry and prose reviving interest Scotland.
- Scots, Clans, and Sassenach: Oh my! We aren’t in England anymore…different customs, different laws, and a strong mistrust of the English – especially English aristocrats. Having grown so accustomed to all things Regency English, it was refreshing to learn more about Scottish customs and history. I loved witnessing the fierce loyalty and devotion in clans, and it was interesting to learn about the responsibilities and weighty duties of the chieftain.
- Determined and Ardent: Mr. Darcy is persistent, passionate, and on a mission. His love for Elizabeth and sense of honor are unstoppable forces. His capable handling of all the obstacles he faces, his growing understanding for the wishes and needs of others, and his strong and resilient love all made me fall irrevocably in love with Mr. Darcy.
- Scottish Family and Scotland Family: Many members of the MacLaren clan are introduced in this tale, and I fell in love with all the engaging, opinionated, and admirable members of this family – especially Mr. Jack and Duncan. In addition, I loved the family that Lizzy adopted (or that adopted Lizzy!) while she was in Scotland. Each of these characters were well-drawn, dynamic, and completely endearing! It was so lovely to see Lizzy’s (and Darcy’s) interactions with each of these original characters.
- Amongst Theatricals: Lizzy ends up spending a bit of time amongst actors and actresses of the Theatre Royal in Edinburgh. As a theatre-lover myself, I enjoyed the discussions of acting, the practicing of lines, and the viewing of various performances peppered throughout this tale. I also enjoyed seeing the relaxed propriety and loyal kinship that develops amongst these “theatricals.”
WHAT I WASN’T TOO FOND OF:
Small Quibbles: There was significant bit of time where I was wishing could spend more time in Mr. Darcy’s head. Some important events took place, but at the time we remained only in Elizabeth’s perspective. In addition, towards the last quarter of the book the Fitzwilliam clan seemed to take over just a wee bit, and I found myself wishing for more of Darcy and Elizabeth. And lastly, it felt like there may have been a confrontation/comeuppance missing with some of the antagonists in this tale. There was some explained events/consequences discussed, but I guess I felt it needed more.
CONCLUSION:
Och! Admirers of Abigail Reynolds and her Pride and Prejudice variations dinnae want to miss out on this enthralling and momentous romantic adventure in Scotland! With A Matter of Honor, Abigail Reynolds delivers a story that is diverse, encompassing, and full of important lessons on following your heart and protecting what you love. I highly recommend!
Austenesque Reviews
Rating: 4.5 out of 5 stars
TYPE OF NOVEL: Pride and Prejudice Variation
TIME FRAME: Begins around six months after Darcy’s Hunsford proposal
SYNOPSIS: What if Mr. Darcy discovered Elizabeth was accused of improper behavior with him and as a result her family has been ostracized and disgraced?
What if Elizabeth accepted ruination and removal from her family and no one, except a belligerent Mr. Bennet, knows where she has gone?
What if a determined and (still besotted) Mr. Darcy sets out to rescue Elizabeth Bennet, reclaim her honor, and earn her love only to discover that she will continue to evade and run from him?
What if Mr. Darcy and Elizabeth Bennet wound up in Scotland?!?
WHAT I LOVED:
- A Wee Tour of Scotland: If I wasn’t already hankering to visit Scotland, this armchair travel adventure would have me convinced me to make Scotland one of the next countries I visit! From the bustling city of Edinburgh and the Theatre Royal to the wild ways of the Highlands filled with lochs and castles – it was quite the tour! I know Abigail Reynolds must have researched Scotland during the Regency era extensively to portray it with such descriptive detail. I especially enjoyed how Ms. Reynolds wove in some real history with Walter Scott being a fan of the Theatre Royal and his inspiring poetry and prose reviving interest Scotland.
- Scots, Clans, and Sassenach: Oh my! We aren’t in England anymore…different customs, different laws, and a strong mistrust of the English – especially English aristocrats. Having grown so accustomed to all things Regency English, it was refreshing to learn more about Scottish customs and history. I loved witnessing the fierce loyalty and devotion in clans, and it was interesting to learn about the responsibilities and weighty duties of the chieftain.
- Determined and Ardent: Mr. Darcy is persistent, passionate, and on a mission. His love for Elizabeth and sense of honor are unstoppable forces. His capable handling of all the obstacles he faces, his growing understanding for the wishes and needs of others, and his strong and resilient love all made me fall irrevocably in love with Mr. Darcy.
- Scottish Family and Scotland Family: Many members of the MacLaren clan are introduced in this tale, and I fell in love with all the engaging, opinionated, and admirable members of this family – especially Mr. Jack and Duncan. In addition, I loved the family that Lizzy adopted (or that adopted Lizzy!) while she was in Scotland. Each of these characters were well-drawn, dynamic, and completely endearing! It was so lovely to see Lizzy’s (and Darcy’s) interactions with each of these original characters.
- Amongst Theatricals: Lizzy ends up spending a bit of time amongst actors and actresses of the Theatre Royal in Edinburgh. As a theatre-lover myself, I enjoyed the discussions of acting, the practicing of lines, and the viewing of various performances peppered throughout this tale. I also enjoyed seeing the relaxed propriety and loyal kinship that develops amongst these “theatricals.”
WHAT I WASN’T TOO FOND OF:
Small Quibbles: There was significant bit of time where I was wishing could spend more time in Mr. Darcy’s head. Some important events took place, but at the time we remained only in Elizabeth’s perspective. In addition, towards the last quarter of the book the Fitzwilliam clan seemed to take over just a wee bit, and I found myself wishing for more of Darcy and Elizabeth. And lastly, it felt like there may have been a confrontation/comeuppance missing with some of the antagonists in this tale. There was some explained events/consequences discussed, but I guess I felt it needed more.
CONCLUSION:
Och! Admirers of Abigail Reynolds and her Pride and Prejudice variations dinnae want to miss out on this enthralling and momentous romantic adventure in Scotland! With A Matter of Honor, Abigail Reynolds delivers a story that is diverse, encompassing, and full of important lessons on following your heart and protecting what you love. I highly recommend!
Austenesque Reviews
September 7, 2019
Avid Reader
What a wonderful story! Darcy and Elizabeth weren't the only ones hiding from the ton and London society. Lady Catherine, Wickham, and Mr. Collins went too far. Elizabeth was betrayed by Wickham, Mr. Collins, and her father. Elizabeth realized almost at the end of the book that Darcy lived her more than her father ever could because Darcy had followed her to Scotland and almost died looking for her. Mr. Bennet had been too selfish and lazy to write one letter. He left Elizabeth on her aunt 's doorstep with no goodbye or hug. Richard and Jasper suffered at the hands of their father. Lady Matlock managed along with Duncan Maclauren and Mrs. Emmaline Maclauren to save the day. Even Georgina had a happily ever after. I read this book non-stop!
What a wonderful story! Darcy and Elizabeth weren't the only ones hiding from the ton and London society. Lady Catherine, Wickham, and Mr. Collins went too far. Elizabeth was betrayed by Wickham, Mr. Collins, and her father. Elizabeth realized almost at the end of the book that Darcy lived her more than her father ever could because Darcy had followed her to Scotland and almost died looking for her. Mr. Bennet had been too selfish and lazy to write one letter. He left Elizabeth on her aunt 's doorstep with no goodbye or hug. Richard and Jasper suffered at the hands of their father. Lady Matlock managed along with Duncan Maclauren and Mrs. Emmaline Maclauren to save the day. Even Georgina had a happily ever after. I read this book non-stop!
July 29, 2021
A Scottish Tale
I loved the Scottish backdrop for most of this story. Elizabeth runs to Scotland in an effort to avoid Darcy, but we know from the start he will search for her. We’re given hints as to the reason she did so, but of course it will take a while to unravel why she feels she had to hide. Some new characters, and only mentions of the usual P&P cast makes this non-canon storyline an interesting page turner. Highly recommend.
July 28-29, 2021 - Audiobook
This book is also excellent on audio with a very good narration by Elizabeth Klett. I am not that familiar with a Scottish accent, but she carries it off well. Happy to also recommend the audiobook version.
I loved the Scottish backdrop for most of this story. Elizabeth runs to Scotland in an effort to avoid Darcy, but we know from the start he will search for her. We’re given hints as to the reason she did so, but of course it will take a while to unravel why she feels she had to hide. Some new characters, and only mentions of the usual P&P cast makes this non-canon storyline an interesting page turner. Highly recommend.
July 28-29, 2021 - Audiobook
This book is also excellent on audio with a very good narration by Elizabeth Klett. I am not that familiar with a Scottish accent, but she carries it off well. Happy to also recommend the audiobook version.
September 8, 2019
Drama, Comedy, Mystery and Romance
A page turner of a novel, transporting our favorite estranged coup!e to Scotland, center stage with a great cast of original supporting characters. All the mainstays make, at least or at most, cameo appearances in an intricate plot that keep questions and a lover's undaunted pursuit in the spot!ight. A very good read.
A page turner of a novel, transporting our favorite estranged coup!e to Scotland, center stage with a great cast of original supporting characters. All the mainstays make, at least or at most, cameo appearances in an intricate plot that keep questions and a lover's undaunted pursuit in the spot!ight. A very good read.
October 11, 2020
It's an Abigail Reynolds book, so one has an expectation of brilliance, and we get it. The other reviewers will have revealed the synopsis with spoilers, so I don't need to go down that route, and I never waste space in my reviews for overviews in any case.
I have no complaints regarding the plot, style, flow, continuity, voice, POV, dialogue/narrative balance, or most of those high-level writing technical areas. They were carefully managed and well accomplished. In the simplest terms, this is a really, really excellent book.
Now down to the nitty gritty: what I didn't like. There were some non-Regency words: "staff" in the context of the servants of the home, and "neckline." Abigail's use of language is superb otherwise. In addition, there was that weird bit about Mr. Bennet breaking the entail that had no place in the book and has no backing historically without some backstory that wasn't there. WTF? Cut that bit out! Yet, that's it. The sum total of the flaws of this book. Pretty short list. Minus 1/4 star.
Now for the brilliant parts. The actors! The travel!! The scenery!!! The haunting feelings!!!! The angst!!!!! Wow, what a novel! Thank you, Abigail Reynolds, for writing some of the best books in JAFF and holding on to the quality standards over and over again. I strongly recommend this novel.
Disclaimer: I'm a JAFF writer and a friend of Abigail Reynolds, so there may be some who would say that any review I would write for this book would be a conflict of interest. Heck, I've been a fan of hers since before I bought JAFF books! But I'm fastidiously honest and impartial when it comes to recording my opinion on a book I've read, and I won't make any exceptions.
I have no complaints regarding the plot, style, flow, continuity, voice, POV, dialogue/narrative balance, or most of those high-level writing technical areas. They were carefully managed and well accomplished. In the simplest terms, this is a really, really excellent book.
Now down to the nitty gritty: what I didn't like. There were some non-Regency words: "staff" in the context of the servants of the home, and "neckline." Abigail's use of language is superb otherwise. In addition, there was that weird bit about Mr. Bennet breaking the entail that had no place in the book and has no backing historically without some backstory that wasn't there. WTF? Cut that bit out! Yet, that's it. The sum total of the flaws of this book. Pretty short list. Minus 1/4 star.
Now for the brilliant parts. The actors! The travel!! The scenery!!! The haunting feelings!!!! The angst!!!!! Wow, what a novel! Thank you, Abigail Reynolds, for writing some of the best books in JAFF and holding on to the quality standards over and over again. I strongly recommend this novel.
Disclaimer: I'm a JAFF writer and a friend of Abigail Reynolds, so there may be some who would say that any review I would write for this book would be a conflict of interest. Heck, I've been a fan of hers since before I bought JAFF books! But I'm fastidiously honest and impartial when it comes to recording my opinion on a book I've read, and I won't make any exceptions.
March 23, 2020
I was so bored. I tried to love this--I tried really hard!
September 10, 2019
Nice
Being a fan of this author, I'm relieved that the story finally started to get interesting about halfway through the book. The first half was a plodding, melodramatic tale that was depressing and frustrating.
The story begins some time after the failed proposal at Hunsford, when Darcy is trying to reunite Bingley with Jane, and they arrive at Longbourn to find the Bennett family in disgrace and Elizabeth gone with no trace. Mr. Bennett is hostile to the two gentlemen, and refuses to offer any information about the reason for this state of affairs. Darcy, not willing to accept that Elizabeth is gone without some explanation, embarks on a quest to discover what happened to her. After much time and effort, his search leads to Scotland where he eventually finds not only Elizabeth, but much more.
I was annoyed for the first part of the story by the silly choices that Elizabeth made. She agrees to an ultimatum, presented by the idiot Mr. Collins, on behalf of Lady Catherine, requiring her to basically disappear from existence in order to separate her from Darcy and to preserve her family's reputation. The whole concept is presented as if this makes perfect sense, rather than an annoyingly melodramatic dumb idea. Why would anyone with any intelligence agree to this without some investigation or resistance, especially since at that point in the story Elizabeth is not yet in love with Darcy? Our feisty Lizzy is not supposed to give in to pressure like this.
Also, Mr. Bennett is portrayed as a contender for worst father of the decade. Actually, both Mr. and Mrs are terrible, and that is another depressing factor. I'm not fond of these variations that feature a borderline abusive family life for Elizabeth. Between that and this ultimatum that she faces, it's a little too bleak.
Things pick up when Darcy gets to Scotland and several new and fascinating characters are introduced. I like Elizabeth's aunt Emmaline, Jasper, Mr. Jack, and MacClaren the younger, among many others. Although Elizabeth is still acting annoyingly stupid for a good long while, many things start to happen to distract from her behavior, and the way finally becomes clearer for a resolution. Our good Mr. Darcy's devotion is sorely tested in this story, not only by Elizabeth's behavior, but also by many circumstances and situations that normally would have had him running in the opposite direction.
The story is well written and well edited. I recommend it.
Being a fan of this author, I'm relieved that the story finally started to get interesting about halfway through the book. The first half was a plodding, melodramatic tale that was depressing and frustrating.
The story begins some time after the failed proposal at Hunsford, when Darcy is trying to reunite Bingley with Jane, and they arrive at Longbourn to find the Bennett family in disgrace and Elizabeth gone with no trace. Mr. Bennett is hostile to the two gentlemen, and refuses to offer any information about the reason for this state of affairs. Darcy, not willing to accept that Elizabeth is gone without some explanation, embarks on a quest to discover what happened to her. After much time and effort, his search leads to Scotland where he eventually finds not only Elizabeth, but much more.
I was annoyed for the first part of the story by the silly choices that Elizabeth made. She agrees to an ultimatum, presented by the idiot Mr. Collins, on behalf of Lady Catherine, requiring her to basically disappear from existence in order to separate her from Darcy and to preserve her family's reputation. The whole concept is presented as if this makes perfect sense, rather than an annoyingly melodramatic dumb idea. Why would anyone with any intelligence agree to this without some investigation or resistance, especially since at that point in the story Elizabeth is not yet in love with Darcy? Our feisty Lizzy is not supposed to give in to pressure like this.
Also, Mr. Bennett is portrayed as a contender for worst father of the decade. Actually, both Mr. and Mrs are terrible, and that is another depressing factor. I'm not fond of these variations that feature a borderline abusive family life for Elizabeth. Between that and this ultimatum that she faces, it's a little too bleak.
Things pick up when Darcy gets to Scotland and several new and fascinating characters are introduced. I like Elizabeth's aunt Emmaline, Jasper, Mr. Jack, and MacClaren the younger, among many others. Although Elizabeth is still acting annoyingly stupid for a good long while, many things start to happen to distract from her behavior, and the way finally becomes clearer for a resolution. Our good Mr. Darcy's devotion is sorely tested in this story, not only by Elizabeth's behavior, but also by many circumstances and situations that normally would have had him running in the opposite direction.
The story is well written and well edited. I recommend it.
February 21, 2023
Status: Read December 8-13, 2022
via kindle & audible editions
Rating: ⭐⭐⭐⭐
My Library Notes:
A Matter of Honor: A Pride & Prejudice Variation
by Abigail Reynolds
Kindle Edition, 485 pages
Published September 5, 2019 by White Soup Press (first published September 1, 2019)
ASIN: B07WFK92FQ
Pride & Prejudice goes to Scotland!
When Fitzwilliam Darcy, still smarting from Elizabeth’s rejection, discovers she was forced to flee her home in disgrace owing to his actions, his course is clear. He must marry her. It is a matter of honor. All he has to do is find her and propose. Surely that will be simple enough.
But Elizabeth does not want to be found, especially not by Darcy. From the moment he entered her life, he has caused disaster after disaster. Now he has followed her all the way to Scotland, foolishly certain it is within his power to fix all her problems. But far more is at stake than Darcy knows, and Elizabeth is out of options.
Darcy’s quest for Elizabeth takes him from backstage at Edinburgh’s Theatre Royal to the wilds of the Scottish Highlands, where Highlanders prove both friend and enemy. And now his search risks exposing long-hidden secrets that threaten his happiness and her future.
On the run and in danger, Elizabeth is forced to make impossible choices to protect those whom she loves – including Darcy. Her growing attraction to him is at war with her need for caution, and the stakes are impossibly high. Can she trust him to continue to fight for her protection when he knows the whole truth? And if he does, will it be for love… or will it be merely a matter of honor?
A Matter of Honor: A Pride & Prejudice Variation
by Abigail Reynolds, Elizabeth Klett (Narrator)
Audible Audio, Unabridged, 14 pages
Published June 26, 2020 by Abigail Young (first published September 1, 2019)
ASIN: B08BQ9676T
Listening Length: 13 hours and 34 minutes
via kindle & audible editions
Rating: ⭐⭐⭐⭐
My Library Notes:
A Matter of Honor: A Pride & Prejudice Variation
by Abigail Reynolds
Kindle Edition, 485 pages
Published September 5, 2019 by White Soup Press (first published September 1, 2019)
ASIN: B07WFK92FQ
Pride & Prejudice goes to Scotland!
When Fitzwilliam Darcy, still smarting from Elizabeth’s rejection, discovers she was forced to flee her home in disgrace owing to his actions, his course is clear. He must marry her. It is a matter of honor. All he has to do is find her and propose. Surely that will be simple enough.
But Elizabeth does not want to be found, especially not by Darcy. From the moment he entered her life, he has caused disaster after disaster. Now he has followed her all the way to Scotland, foolishly certain it is within his power to fix all her problems. But far more is at stake than Darcy knows, and Elizabeth is out of options.
Darcy’s quest for Elizabeth takes him from backstage at Edinburgh’s Theatre Royal to the wilds of the Scottish Highlands, where Highlanders prove both friend and enemy. And now his search risks exposing long-hidden secrets that threaten his happiness and her future.
On the run and in danger, Elizabeth is forced to make impossible choices to protect those whom she loves – including Darcy. Her growing attraction to him is at war with her need for caution, and the stakes are impossibly high. Can she trust him to continue to fight for her protection when he knows the whole truth? And if he does, will it be for love… or will it be merely a matter of honor?
A Matter of Honor: A Pride & Prejudice Variation
by Abigail Reynolds, Elizabeth Klett (Narrator)
Audible Audio, Unabridged, 14 pages
Published June 26, 2020 by Abigail Young (first published September 1, 2019)
ASIN: B08BQ9676T
Listening Length: 13 hours and 34 minutes
December 6, 2019
I nearly stopped reading this Pride and Prejudice variation in the first chapter, because everyone in Meryton is so hostile towards Mr. Darcy. Even Bingley, and even while Darcy is trying to help him win Jane Bennet's hand. No one will tell Darcy what has become of Elizabeth Bennet. She seems to have vanished. The town has shunned the entire Bennet family, and Bingley thinks it's because of some dishonorable behavior on Darcy's part. I couldn't believe he could think that of Darcy, and I almost dumped the book, because I had some other stresses going on and wanted some lighter reading. But I kept reading because this is a favorite JAFF author of mine.
After a while things get a little better. Darcy journeys to Scotland, locates Elizabeth and learns she is fine, and then he meets up with his cousin Jasper, one of my favorites in this book. Elizabeth seems implacable, though, once Darcy locates her, in her unwillingness to be friends or even socialize with him, and her unwillingness to explain why. And yet he can see that her feelings towards him have changed, warmed. She goes off into the highlands to her aunt's estate in order to avoid him. He follows, at her aunt's veiled suggestion, and is set upon by someone, possibly highwaymen.
Things seem bleak at this point, but I am glad that I kept reading, because it was worth it. This story has something of a mystery to it, and the resolution is exactly what it needs to be. The characterizations and changes in relationships and circumstances here are touching. I'm happy to have read it.
After a while things get a little better. Darcy journeys to Scotland, locates Elizabeth and learns she is fine, and then he meets up with his cousin Jasper, one of my favorites in this book. Elizabeth seems implacable, though, once Darcy locates her, in her unwillingness to be friends or even socialize with him, and her unwillingness to explain why. And yet he can see that her feelings towards him have changed, warmed. She goes off into the highlands to her aunt's estate in order to avoid him. He follows, at her aunt's veiled suggestion, and is set upon by someone, possibly highwaymen.
Things seem bleak at this point, but I am glad that I kept reading, because it was worth it. This story has something of a mystery to it, and the resolution is exactly what it needs to be. The characterizations and changes in relationships and circumstances here are touching. I'm happy to have read it.
October 15, 2019
Abigail Reynolds never fails to touch my heart in the best way as she writes her Pride and Prejudice variations. Elizabeth has been dropped of in Scotland by her father for a perceived reputation issues. Darcy manages to track her down and needs to break through her defenses.
Set in the background of Scotland rather than England, I love the author's expressions of the highlands, tartans, clan life, kilts, and love of all kinds.
Set in the background of Scotland rather than England, I love the author's expressions of the highlands, tartans, clan life, kilts, and love of all kinds.
February 5, 2022
I enjoyed this take on Pride and Prejudice, I loved them completely leaving the country and the misgivings that they both have because the other assumes and it isn't until after Col. Fitzwilliam shows up do they finally get to the bottom of everything.
We have some mystery and misguided engagement and hiding from family as well as deception from family.
It was a great variation on the original.
We have some mystery and misguided engagement and hiding from family as well as deception from family.
It was a great variation on the original.
March 9, 2021
Good book
Loved this story, sixteenth villains had got more punishments. Mr Bennett was so bad and unconcerned. Glad no Lydia elopement.
Loved this story, sixteenth villains had got more punishments. Mr Bennett was so bad and unconcerned. Glad no Lydia elopement.
March 19, 2020
Dear Reader,
If you are in the mood for an enjoyable,in depth and compelling story,one that centred on devious, Machiavellian type schemes,then look no further than this wonderful book.
From the theatricals in Edinburgh to the lairds in the Scottish Highlands,we encounter a desperate Darcy in search of Elizabeth,who has fled her home and all she holds dear for anonymity in far off climes.
This was a deeply satisfying tale weaving disparate and tangential threads into a comprehensive and addictive multi textured saga.
I loved it and highly recommend it.
If you are in the mood for an enjoyable,in depth and compelling story,one that centred on devious, Machiavellian type schemes,then look no further than this wonderful book.
From the theatricals in Edinburgh to the lairds in the Scottish Highlands,we encounter a desperate Darcy in search of Elizabeth,who has fled her home and all she holds dear for anonymity in far off climes.
This was a deeply satisfying tale weaving disparate and tangential threads into a comprehensive and addictive multi textured saga.
I loved it and highly recommend it.
May 7, 2022
I love the unique storyline. I'm actually reading it now for the second time.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
May 24, 2022
I enjoyed reading this variation, where a new cast of characters was introduced and made believable.
January 18, 2020
Sensational
A wonderfully original story that takes us to visit Scotland and gives us a taste of what it was like to live there at the time. The love story of our beloved couple is full of unexpected twists and turns. Thoroughly enjoyable!
A wonderfully original story that takes us to visit Scotland and gives us a taste of what it was like to live there at the time. The love story of our beloved couple is full of unexpected twists and turns. Thoroughly enjoyable!
September 17, 2019
Abigail Reynolds is one of my favourite authors so I couldn't wait to get my hands on this and it did not disappoint. The premise is an unusual one - following Darcy's Huntsford proposal, Lady Catherine learns if his feelings for Elizabeth and makes a dastardly plan to keep them apart. Darcy knows none of this until he returns to Merton with Bingley to find himself cut and Elizabeth vanished with no one being prepared to speak about where she is. Of course, he is desperate to find her and she is desperate to stay hidden. The tale is mainly set in the Highlands of Scotland where we are introduced to a host of new characters - all called MacLaren!
This is a fab story with lots of really original ideas. There is a fair amount of angst too which I wasn't expecting and wasn't sure for a time what would happen with regards to whether we would even get a happy ever after! The view of Mr Bennet here is a good one - I felt really sorry for Lizzy when she starts to see her father through the eyes of others.
This is quite a long book - a lot happens!! It's a real adventure and definitely something different. Another great read from Abigail Reynolds.
This is a fab story with lots of really original ideas. There is a fair amount of angst too which I wasn't expecting and wasn't sure for a time what would happen with regards to whether we would even get a happy ever after! The view of Mr Bennet here is a good one - I felt really sorry for Lizzy when she starts to see her father through the eyes of others.
This is quite a long book - a lot happens!! It's a real adventure and definitely something different. Another great read from Abigail Reynolds.
January 9, 2023
Bravo for Ms Abigail Reynolds! This is another quite masterful storyline that she has written. Darcy's tenacity in trying to win Elizabeth Bennet is amazing. I am glad it pays off so ODC can have their HEA.
September 7, 2019
A Scottish Tale
I wasn't sure about the location change from England to Scotland but the story soon drew me in. The "Theatricals" were amusing.
I wasn't sure about the location change from England to Scotland but the story soon drew me in. The "Theatricals" were amusing.
September 26, 2019
I wasn't a fan of this book mostly because of Elizabeth. I didn't recognize her in the character.
January 1, 2020
3.5-4
I could do with some more of P&P set in Scotland (and places other than England) tbh
I could do with some more of P&P set in Scotland (and places other than England) tbh
May 17, 2020
Excellent Diversion from Typical Variations
As usual, Ms. Reynolds weaves a beautiful story in yet another P&P variation. However, were it not for the back history of the Darcy & Elizabeth characters, this well and truly could stand alone as a non-P&P book! The only downsides are the length of time spent introducing some new characters and the frustratingly annoying lengths Elizabeth takes to run away from Darcy, though even these can be overlooked once the real story starts to unfold. The depths of deception are so pronounced and unexpected, making it difficult to figure out who is behind what until May. Reynolds is ready to reveal all. As for the characterizations, Richard & Georgiana take on refreshing personas, the former almost until the point of reader dislike until his motivation is known and the latter blossoming on the pages into a future idyllic heroine. Mr. Gardiner is as lovable and caring as ever, but Mr. Bennett is almost villainous (another refreshing take on his character). Then there are the new characters who become beloved like the Ramsays, Emmaline, Jasper, Jack, Duncan, and the other MacLarens. Being introduced to each and seeing them come into three-dimensional life was especially delightful. The beauty and culture of the Scottish Highlands is well captured, to the point that not only does the reader want Darcy & Elizabeth to stay, but also wish he or she could jump into the pages to live there with them. About 3/4 through the book, the reader is reminded that all the events stemmed from Darcy’s proposal at Hunsford. However, Elizabeth has led a life so departed and enriched since Longborn that it is difficult to believe she came from a family of 5 daughters born to a low country gentleman and a nervous mother with connections in trade. In short, this variation is so departed from the typical P&P formula as to provide hours of enjoyment in a wild ride of intrigue, twists, and turns. I truly wish I had read it sooner!
As usual, Ms. Reynolds weaves a beautiful story in yet another P&P variation. However, were it not for the back history of the Darcy & Elizabeth characters, this well and truly could stand alone as a non-P&P book! The only downsides are the length of time spent introducing some new characters and the frustratingly annoying lengths Elizabeth takes to run away from Darcy, though even these can be overlooked once the real story starts to unfold. The depths of deception are so pronounced and unexpected, making it difficult to figure out who is behind what until May. Reynolds is ready to reveal all. As for the characterizations, Richard & Georgiana take on refreshing personas, the former almost until the point of reader dislike until his motivation is known and the latter blossoming on the pages into a future idyllic heroine. Mr. Gardiner is as lovable and caring as ever, but Mr. Bennett is almost villainous (another refreshing take on his character). Then there are the new characters who become beloved like the Ramsays, Emmaline, Jasper, Jack, Duncan, and the other MacLarens. Being introduced to each and seeing them come into three-dimensional life was especially delightful. The beauty and culture of the Scottish Highlands is well captured, to the point that not only does the reader want Darcy & Elizabeth to stay, but also wish he or she could jump into the pages to live there with them. About 3/4 through the book, the reader is reminded that all the events stemmed from Darcy’s proposal at Hunsford. However, Elizabeth has led a life so departed and enriched since Longborn that it is difficult to believe she came from a family of 5 daughters born to a low country gentleman and a nervous mother with connections in trade. In short, this variation is so departed from the typical P&P formula as to provide hours of enjoyment in a wild ride of intrigue, twists, and turns. I truly wish I had read it sooner!
January 29, 2025
I wasn't sure about the premise, but WOW.
It's official. Abigail Reynolds is my favourite JAFF author. This is the 7th book of hers I've read and I've given 6 of them 5 stars. Her style, her attention to detail, her complex characters with their witty banter and her well-rounded plot without stupidly long misunderstandings or shaky loopholes... I LOVE IT. She does great angst with just enough light heartedness and comedic detail to make the book a delight to read.
This book had all of the above, PLUS the additional benefit of a glimpse into true history. I know Duncan was fictional, of course, but it's so fascinating to read "first-hand" about the struggles of the Scots losing their culture and the land, and so Ms Reynolds manages to provoke thought and present alternative perspectives without making the book a depressing, painfully dull read.
Also, I liked that this book was fade-to-black. Ms Reynolds writes wonderful steamy novels too, but I sometimes find too much attention on lustful imaginings detracts from the plot (and eventually gets a little draggy to plough through, particularly when set in the regency era with its attendant expectations and strictures).
It's official. Abigail Reynolds is my favourite JAFF author. This is the 7th book of hers I've read and I've given 6 of them 5 stars. Her style, her attention to detail, her complex characters with their witty banter and her well-rounded plot without stupidly long misunderstandings or shaky loopholes... I LOVE IT. She does great angst with just enough light heartedness and comedic detail to make the book a delight to read.
This book had all of the above, PLUS the additional benefit of a glimpse into true history. I know Duncan was fictional, of course, but it's so fascinating to read "first-hand" about the struggles of the Scots losing their culture and the land, and so Ms Reynolds manages to provoke thought and present alternative perspectives without making the book a depressing, painfully dull read.
Also, I liked that this book was fade-to-black. Ms Reynolds writes wonderful steamy novels too, but I sometimes find too much attention on lustful imaginings detracts from the plot (and eventually gets a little draggy to plough through, particularly when set in the regency era with its attendant expectations and strictures).
Displaying 1 - 30 of 79 reviews