First of all, I must say right up front that I am a big fan of Stieg Larsson’s Millennium trilogy and consider it some of the best mystery/suspense genre that I have ever read. I loved reading those books and was deeply saddened by his unexpected passing and ensuing estate battles between his father/brother and his longtime girlfriend. I personally think she got robbed and mistreated in ways that I cannot express without getting downright angry. Mostly, I miss Stieg not getting to continue writing his wonderful series and further developing his unique characters.
Putting that aside, I had very mixed feelings when it was announced that the father/brother were hiring another writer to continue the series. In my mind no one could come anywhere near capturing the magic that Stieg produced. In 2015, a new author, David Lagercrantz, wrote “The Girl in the Spider’s Web” and I read it. In 2017, he followed it up with “The Girl Who Takes an Eye for an Eye” and I read it. Now in 2019, his third Millennium novel – “The Girl Who Lived twice” - has been published and I just finished reading it on vacation.
Lagercrantz treated his three books – numbers four through six in the series – as a second trilogy in the millennium series, using the final one to wrap up his storylines of exploring Lisbeth’s family history and her personal feud with her evil twin, Camilla
“The Girl Who Lives Twice” starts off with the disappearance of our fearless hero and protector of the mistreated, Lisbeth Salander. The girl with the Dragon tattoo has sold her Stockholm apartment and gone quiet on all social media and electronic platforms. No one knows where she, how to contact her, or what she is up to. The truth she is has decided to move from the hunted to the hunter in her ongoing cat and mouse fight with her sister, and is planning to strike first.
Salander’s absence is a big problem for Mikael Blomkvist, news writer, and probably the only friend she has ever had. Blomkvist needs to her help to figure out the identity of a homeless man who lived and died on the public streets of Stockholm. Blomkvist has a mystery thrust on him to resolve. The homeless man does not exist in any of the official government records and his last words before dying involved damning knowledge of leaders in the highest levels of government and in the business world. A crumpled piece of note paper with Blomkvist’s personal phone number was found written on it and Mikael has no idea why.
As expected, Lagercrantz weaves the two plots - Blomkvist’s investigation and Lisbeth’s deadly hunt – in a parallel manner, using each to help the other until the two are forced to come together to achieve their separate outcomes. Unfortunately, Camilla, along with her GRU and criminal connections realizes that the way to get Lisbeth to come to her, is through her friends, and Blomkvist is the perfect target for apprehension and torture, forcing Lisbeth to willingly surrender herself and her life for his.
Lagercrantz has now written three Millennium series books. I found the first one to really take a long time to get moving and the new author to find his rhythm and understanding of the characters. I felt that the second book was much better and pleasantly surprised me. The story kicked off right away with easier to follow plotlines and it seemed like Lagercrantz figured out how to mirror the Stieg plotting pace and style better than I expected. I believe he brings that same momentum into the third and final book of his trilogy. For the most part, he successfully bounces back and forth between various scenes and activities, building to moments of key revelation and conflict, and pushing things towards final outcomes and payoffs. He hits a good stride and his words flow well, moving from one scene to another with confidence. His characters and conversations are natural and organic as the story unfolds. There were moments when he laid down some excellent clues and transitioned well between scenes and characters.
I read through several national reviews and noted many major publications considered this book to be less than stellar and rather messy in its delivery. I think my review is more favorable for a different but very important reason. I think that that the cause of the negative views is not due to Lagercrantz as a writer, but rather to limitations he has to work within to write in the Millennium universe and it’s already established characters.
Let’s face it, even ignoring the public fighting between Larsson’s girlfriend and family, Lagercrantz is really limited to what he can do when playing in the Blomkvist and Salander world. He cannot kill them and he cannot change them or their histories. He has to find how to develop the unorthodox and multi-faceted relationship between Mikael and Lisbeth – are they friends or more? It must be extremely hard to expand on what Stieg’s already created and established.
I actually think that the creation of Lisbeth’s sister, Camilla, and expanding their family history and criminal network was a pretty creative approach to take. I am not sure what more a writer could do to deliver something new that adds to what’s already been told. In my mind, after a rough start, Lagercrantz was able to get his footing and find a way to build on Stieg’s foundation, deliver a three-book arc that provided them as much conflict, tension, and development as he could muster, and provide a strong enough ending for everyone involved.
Overall, I was really surprised by Lagercrantz’s marked improvement from his first book through to third. Let’s be honest, taking on Stieg’s Millennium series has a bar so high that it is virtually impossible for anyone to come close to his unique ability to tell an intricate and layered story that draws heavily on our emotions. That is no insult. It is the truth. Still, I believe that Lagercrantz was able to successfully capture a bit of the Stieg magic and make it work.
After reading in multiple interviews that Lagercrantz is done with writing Millennium books, I would even go one step further and make a recommendation. Rather than find another author to take up the mantle of writing of further stories, I suggest that the Larsson family allow Blomkvist and Lisbeth to rest in peace. I cannot really think there’s much left to discover in these characters that hasn’t already been shared. Don’t continue publishing stories that start repeating themselves and lessen or demean the quality of Stieg Larsson’s legacy. Please don’t do that.