What do you think?
Rate this book
Dear Nameless Stranger: A Pride and Prejudice Variation
“Please admire my docile and obedient nature. I will not thank you for providing us with a home, nor will I even breathe a word of gratitude for your provision of such funds as will feed us each quarter. I will not even write such platitudes as ‘You are very good,’ given that you have also provided us with respectability in the form of Mrs. Ingles. There. I am quite done now with not expressing my gratitude – I should not at all wish to prove tiresome.”
From the author of Tact, Dear Nameless Stranger is a heartwarming tale inspired by Jane Austen’s Pride and Prejudice and Jean Webster’s Daddy Long Legs. Tragedy has struck the Bennet sisters but they are greatly relieved when the anonymous kindness of a stranger means that they can remain together. In exchange for such charity, a monthly letter is required from each sister. It is a fortunate thing that Miss Elizabeth Bennet rather likes letter-writing, for she relishes the opportunity to relate to this unknown gentleman all her impressions and opinions regarding her changed circumstances.
With each passing month Elizabeth confides more in the nameless stranger, and by the time Netherfield Park is once again occupied by the amiable Mr. Bingley and his friend Mr. Darcy, she is quite frank in writing of her dismay.
From the author of Tact, Dear Nameless Stranger is a heartwarming tale inspired by Jane Austen’s Pride and Prejudice and Jean Webster’s Daddy Long Legs. Tragedy has struck the Bennet sisters but they are greatly relieved when the anonymous kindness of a stranger means that they can remain together. In exchange for such charity, a monthly letter is required from each sister. It is a fortunate thing that Miss Elizabeth Bennet rather likes letter-writing, for she relishes the opportunity to relate to this unknown gentleman all her impressions and opinions regarding her changed circumstances.
With each passing month Elizabeth confides more in the nameless stranger, and by the time Netherfield Park is once again occupied by the amiable Mr. Bingley and his friend Mr. Darcy, she is quite frank in writing of her dismay.
139 pages, Kindle Edition
Published December 20, 2019
49 people are currently reading
190 people want to read
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 113 reviews
June 15, 2024
“I have always depended on the kindness of strangers." ~ Tennessee Williams
In “Dear Nameless Stranger” the Bennet sisters have something in common with Blanche DuBois: they must depend on the kindness of a stranger.
Mr. and Mrs. Bennet pass within days of each other from a sudden illness. The un-beloved Longbourn heir takes advice from his beloved patroness and throws the five daughters out immediately without a shilling. Jane reads a letter from the Rev. Collins in despair. None of their relations will be able to support all five sisters. The sisters are making plans when a second letter is received. An attorney with an unlikely name makes an offer of a home and generous income from an anonymous client. The only requirement is that each sister must write a letter to the donor each month.
We read all of Elizabeth’s letters as she progresses from newsy chattering to “Dear Nameless Stranger” to sharing deeper parts of herself with her benefactor. She eventually regards him as a confidant. She, of course, is curious as to his identity. When, if ever, will she know?
The greatest good you can do for another is not just to share your riches but to reveal to him his own. ~ Benjamin Disraeli
“Dear Nameless Stranger” is divided into two books. I had supposed the second part was a separate story but no. It is the same story from a different POV – this time the thoughts belong to the anonymous benefactor.
The benefactor, of course, reads the letters from all five sisters. I especially enjoyed the insight into Kitty Bennet, who is revealed to have poetry in her soul. Mary Bennet surprises with a confrontation with a scoundrel. Lydia Bennet still knows fashion but learns economy. How will she react when Wickham rears his handsome head? Jane Bennet holds the family together, depending on Elizabeth and the companion hired by the benefactor.
With knowledge of all the sisters’ lives, the benefactor is able to respond to their needs with everything from sweet rolls to a doctor. He does a great service to the neighborhood with a remark made to the “not-so-good” Rev. Collins. I agree with another reviewer who wished for a greater consequence for Collins and more knowledge of Charlotte’s thoughts and actions. But that is my only criticism of an otherwise great story; unique in the world of JAFF.
If you haven't any charity in your heart, you have the worst kind of heart trouble. ~ Bob Hope
In “Dear Nameless Stranger” the Bennet sisters have something in common with Blanche DuBois: they must depend on the kindness of a stranger.
Mr. and Mrs. Bennet pass within days of each other from a sudden illness. The un-beloved Longbourn heir takes advice from his beloved patroness and throws the five daughters out immediately without a shilling. Jane reads a letter from the Rev. Collins in despair. None of their relations will be able to support all five sisters. The sisters are making plans when a second letter is received. An attorney with an unlikely name makes an offer of a home and generous income from an anonymous client. The only requirement is that each sister must write a letter to the donor each month.
We read all of Elizabeth’s letters as she progresses from newsy chattering to “Dear Nameless Stranger” to sharing deeper parts of herself with her benefactor. She eventually regards him as a confidant. She, of course, is curious as to his identity. When, if ever, will she know?
The greatest good you can do for another is not just to share your riches but to reveal to him his own. ~ Benjamin Disraeli
“Dear Nameless Stranger” is divided into two books. I had supposed the second part was a separate story but no. It is the same story from a different POV – this time the thoughts belong to the anonymous benefactor.
The benefactor, of course, reads the letters from all five sisters. I especially enjoyed the insight into Kitty Bennet, who is revealed to have poetry in her soul. Mary Bennet surprises with a confrontation with a scoundrel. Lydia Bennet still knows fashion but learns economy. How will she react when Wickham rears his handsome head? Jane Bennet holds the family together, depending on Elizabeth and the companion hired by the benefactor.
With knowledge of all the sisters’ lives, the benefactor is able to respond to their needs with everything from sweet rolls to a doctor. He does a great service to the neighborhood with a remark made to the “not-so-good” Rev. Collins. I agree with another reviewer who wished for a greater consequence for Collins and more knowledge of Charlotte’s thoughts and actions. But that is my only criticism of an otherwise great story; unique in the world of JAFF.
If you haven't any charity in your heart, you have the worst kind of heart trouble. ~ Bob Hope
January 4, 2020
5+ stars!
This is a marvelous premise first used in the classic Daddy Long Legs, adapted convincingly here in a Pride and Prejudice variation. (Readers must be familiar with the P and P plot.)
The book’s Prologue picks up after Elizabeth’s return from Kent to Hertfordshire. Serious illness has swept through Longbourn, taking the lives of both Mr. and Mrs. Bennet. The five sisters are in shock, with a bleak future on the horizon. Mr. Collins has already made it clear that he will not support them, and neither the Phillips nor the Gardiners have the means to take in all of them. The girls want to remain together, but it seems impossible; at the least, it seems Jane and Elizabeth must go into service.
Then a letter miraculously arrives from a London solicitor, Ignatius Z. Brigglewick. His anonymous client will provide a cottage for them in Meryton, with a household staff, Mrs. Ingles (a companion), and four hundred pounds per year to support them all. The only requirement is that each of the Bennet sisters must send their benefactor a letter every month without expecting any response.
Thus, Dear Nameless Stranger, like Daddy Long Legs, is comprised entirely of letters. These are Elizabeth Bennet’s monthly correspondence from June to February, ending with a very significant Epilogue. Her sparkling personality comes through on every page as she makes even mundane parts of her day seem delightful. She finds it increasingly easy to write as if it's a diary, confessing feelings and frustrations that she can't confess to anyone she knows personally. It's also heartwarming to see how the sobering experience of becoming orphans have obviously impacted Elizabeth's sisters.
This story is followed by a companion piece, An Unfair Advantage, which is even more engaging. While the first book tells its story through Elizabeth's letters, the second uses more conventional story-telling, this time limited to Mr. Darcy's point of view.
Yes, there's a happily ever after for our favorite couple, and yes, there's a good bit of romance even though Elizabeth and Darcy don't share a lot of page time together. The writing is wonderful, and the plot is really well executed.
I love it - It's the first one I'm placing on my GoodReads "2020 great books" shelf!
This is a marvelous premise first used in the classic Daddy Long Legs, adapted convincingly here in a Pride and Prejudice variation. (Readers must be familiar with the P and P plot.)
The book’s Prologue picks up after Elizabeth’s return from Kent to Hertfordshire. Serious illness has swept through Longbourn, taking the lives of both Mr. and Mrs. Bennet. The five sisters are in shock, with a bleak future on the horizon. Mr. Collins has already made it clear that he will not support them, and neither the Phillips nor the Gardiners have the means to take in all of them. The girls want to remain together, but it seems impossible; at the least, it seems Jane and Elizabeth must go into service.
Then a letter miraculously arrives from a London solicitor, Ignatius Z. Brigglewick. His anonymous client will provide a cottage for them in Meryton, with a household staff, Mrs. Ingles (a companion), and four hundred pounds per year to support them all. The only requirement is that each of the Bennet sisters must send their benefactor a letter every month without expecting any response.
Thus, Dear Nameless Stranger, like Daddy Long Legs, is comprised entirely of letters. These are Elizabeth Bennet’s monthly correspondence from June to February, ending with a very significant Epilogue. Her sparkling personality comes through on every page as she makes even mundane parts of her day seem delightful. She finds it increasingly easy to write as if it's a diary, confessing feelings and frustrations that she can't confess to anyone she knows personally. It's also heartwarming to see how the sobering experience of becoming orphans have obviously impacted Elizabeth's sisters.
This story is followed by a companion piece, An Unfair Advantage, which is even more engaging. While the first book tells its story through Elizabeth's letters, the second uses more conventional story-telling, this time limited to Mr. Darcy's point of view.
Yes, there's a happily ever after for our favorite couple, and yes, there's a good bit of romance even though Elizabeth and Darcy don't share a lot of page time together. The writing is wonderful, and the plot is really well executed.
I love it - It's the first one I'm placing on my GoodReads "2020 great books" shelf!
February 2, 2020
What a delightful story. I don't want to give away too much as there is a mystery of sorts in this variation and you must experience the pleasure of sorting it out for your self.
I will only reiterate basically what the blurb tells us. Mr. and Mrs. Bennet have died. Collins refuses to give any support and makes it clear the sisters will be "thrown out into the hedgerows". An anonymous person secures a cottage for them, gives them a stipend to live on and a companion to chaperone and guide the sisters. The only thing that is asked in return is a monthly letter from each sister, no thanks to be issued. So it is that we read first Elizabeth's letters and in the latter part of this tale we read about what the sisters also wrote and about each sister's behavior and reactions to the fate of their parents, having to move out of their home and the isolation their period of mourning forces upon them.
This was one of those stories that you don't want to put down. I highly recommend this story.
I will only reiterate basically what the blurb tells us. Mr. and Mrs. Bennet have died. Collins refuses to give any support and makes it clear the sisters will be "thrown out into the hedgerows". An anonymous person secures a cottage for them, gives them a stipend to live on and a companion to chaperone and guide the sisters. The only thing that is asked in return is a monthly letter from each sister, no thanks to be issued. So it is that we read first Elizabeth's letters and in the latter part of this tale we read about what the sisters also wrote and about each sister's behavior and reactions to the fate of their parents, having to move out of their home and the isolation their period of mourning forces upon them.
This was one of those stories that you don't want to put down. I highly recommend this story.
December 25, 2024
My Rating: 5*+
Love this novel! Would still love a sequel!!
Second Reading: Still sublime! Still wishing for a sequel! ☺️
" 'Desirous of remaining entirely anonymous' - I cannot think of anything more provoking!" (quote from the book)
I adored this novel!
Yes, it takes it's premise from 'Daddy Long Legs', which I have yet to read, but works just perfectly here! Mr. and Mrs. Bennet die from an illness shortly after the Hunsford disastrous proposal leaving the Bennet sisters orphans. When a 'nameless stranger' offers them a cottage, a chaperone and an income to live on, they are stunned but thankful that they will not be separated. However, there is one catch. They must each write a monthly letter telling him of what they have learned or what subjects interest them. At no point should they express gratitude or thanks.
This book is broken into two parts. The first half are Elizabeth's letters to 'Dear Nameless Stranger'. As each letter progresses, she reveals more of herself, as if she is writing in a diary. Such poignancy mixed with wit and impertinence.
"Joy can be found, I am discovering, even when all about us seems grey and hopeless." (quote from the book)
The second half is how the benefactor reacts to each of the sisters' letters and his actions in making their lives easier. It is here where we learn what the other sisters have written. I must say each sister endeared themselves not only to the benefactor but to me as well. I loved the poetical 'whimsy' of Kitty and the blunt, no nonsense approach of Lydia. Mary had her eyes opened and gave such a set down that I was cheering her on! Jane's poor heart has been battered, but she is fierce in her 'mothering' of her sisters.
"People think I do not notice things because I cannot always speak them and I wish I could tell them that the silent ones see more than anybody...Have you ever looked into the eyes of a cat?" (quote from the book)
As I have said before, I love epistolary novels or stories that have many letters in them as this one does. They lure the reader in with their intimacy and generally reveal more about the characters. These were so well done that I felt I was the recipient of each of them.
"It is the oddest thing, sir, that as blessed as we were when our parents were alive, it took the kindness of a stranger to make us aware of how fortunate we are even now." (quote from the book)
I can wholeheartedly recommend this beautiful and engaging novel to all. I also would like to ask the author if she would be so kind as to write a sequel to it. I feel I need to know more about the lives of the dear Bennet sisters. In the meantime, I will have to get the other two novels by this 'new to me' author!
Love this novel! Would still love a sequel!!
Second Reading: Still sublime! Still wishing for a sequel! ☺️
" 'Desirous of remaining entirely anonymous' - I cannot think of anything more provoking!" (quote from the book)
I adored this novel!
Yes, it takes it's premise from 'Daddy Long Legs', which I have yet to read, but works just perfectly here! Mr. and Mrs. Bennet die from an illness shortly after the Hunsford disastrous proposal leaving the Bennet sisters orphans. When a 'nameless stranger' offers them a cottage, a chaperone and an income to live on, they are stunned but thankful that they will not be separated. However, there is one catch. They must each write a monthly letter telling him of what they have learned or what subjects interest them. At no point should they express gratitude or thanks.
This book is broken into two parts. The first half are Elizabeth's letters to 'Dear Nameless Stranger'. As each letter progresses, she reveals more of herself, as if she is writing in a diary. Such poignancy mixed with wit and impertinence.
"Joy can be found, I am discovering, even when all about us seems grey and hopeless." (quote from the book)
The second half is how the benefactor reacts to each of the sisters' letters and his actions in making their lives easier. It is here where we learn what the other sisters have written. I must say each sister endeared themselves not only to the benefactor but to me as well. I loved the poetical 'whimsy' of Kitty and the blunt, no nonsense approach of Lydia. Mary had her eyes opened and gave such a set down that I was cheering her on! Jane's poor heart has been battered, but she is fierce in her 'mothering' of her sisters.
"People think I do not notice things because I cannot always speak them and I wish I could tell them that the silent ones see more than anybody...Have you ever looked into the eyes of a cat?" (quote from the book)
As I have said before, I love epistolary novels or stories that have many letters in them as this one does. They lure the reader in with their intimacy and generally reveal more about the characters. These were so well done that I felt I was the recipient of each of them.
"It is the oddest thing, sir, that as blessed as we were when our parents were alive, it took the kindness of a stranger to make us aware of how fortunate we are even now." (quote from the book)
I can wholeheartedly recommend this beautiful and engaging novel to all. I also would like to ask the author if she would be so kind as to write a sequel to it. I feel I need to know more about the lives of the dear Bennet sisters. In the meantime, I will have to get the other two novels by this 'new to me' author!
February 8, 2020
Lace up your stays, tighten you bonnet and button up your pelisse because you are going to want to be in a full regency state of mind for this story.
In an imaginative P&P what if Mr & Mrs. Bennet pass suddenly from a contagious illness leaving their 5 unmarried daughters destitute. Set after Lizzy's visit to Charlotte in Hunsford they are disappointed to learn that Mr. Collins is casting them out. When All hope seems lost a mysterious and anonymous benefactor comes forward with a cottage and stipend to support the girls until they marry. The only requirement is monthly letters apprising the person of their progress and activities but gratitude is forbidden.
So the first 1/3 of the book is is epistolary form of Lizzy's letters to her savior. This is what I sampled and I adore epistolary books so I was sold, literally and figuratively. After this section we get the story from the benefactor's perspective. As well as more detail about the other Bennet sisters. And as I have said numerous times I love books where the stereotypes break and the girls get to shine. And shine they do.
If I had any complaint it would be an unresolved subplot regarding Mr. Bennet having 2 solicitors that never gets explained. Or at least if I did I missed it.
Now for my other disclaimer: set in the Regency period and featuring beloved characters this is a sweet and romantic story. If you insist upon apply modern morality and opinions to it I realized it is very very very stalkerish. And voyeuristic and creepy. But luckily I had my bonnet and half boots on so I didn't notice until I was finished.
In an imaginative P&P what if Mr & Mrs. Bennet pass suddenly from a contagious illness leaving their 5 unmarried daughters destitute. Set after Lizzy's visit to Charlotte in Hunsford they are disappointed to learn that Mr. Collins is casting them out. When All hope seems lost a mysterious and anonymous benefactor comes forward with a cottage and stipend to support the girls until they marry. The only requirement is monthly letters apprising the person of their progress and activities but gratitude is forbidden.
So the first 1/3 of the book is is epistolary form of Lizzy's letters to her savior. This is what I sampled and I adore epistolary books so I was sold, literally and figuratively. After this section we get the story from the benefactor's perspective. As well as more detail about the other Bennet sisters. And as I have said numerous times I love books where the stereotypes break and the girls get to shine. And shine they do.
If I had any complaint it would be an unresolved subplot regarding Mr. Bennet having 2 solicitors that never gets explained. Or at least if I did I missed it.
Now for my other disclaimer: set in the Regency period and featuring beloved characters this is a sweet and romantic story. If you insist upon apply modern morality and opinions to it I realized it is very very very stalkerish. And voyeuristic and creepy. But luckily I had my bonnet and half boots on so I didn't notice until I was finished.
March 17, 2020
A wonderful,heartwarming story that I highly recommended.
February 12, 2025
Endearing
Reviewed in Canada on December 28, 2019
Oh, this was a wonderfully endearing variation. I loved the storyline, and the letters were delightfully worded. The author’s writing is very very good. Sweet, clean read. Highly recommend. I loved it all.
December 28, 2020 - One year to the day, I’m starting a second read by listening along with the audiobook which is beautifully narrated by Mandy Gasson.
October 13, 2023 - Audible re-listen. Some of these letters always make me cry. So moving.
January 11, 2025 - Audiobook re-listen for Audiobook of the Month
Reviewed in Canada on December 28, 2019
Oh, this was a wonderfully endearing variation. I loved the storyline, and the letters were delightfully worded. The author’s writing is very very good. Sweet, clean read. Highly recommend. I loved it all.
December 28, 2020 - One year to the day, I’m starting a second read by listening along with the audiobook which is beautifully narrated by Mandy Gasson.
October 13, 2023 - Audible re-listen. Some of these letters always make me cry. So moving.
January 11, 2025 - Audiobook re-listen for Audiobook of the Month
February 28, 2021
“Becoming an effective letter writer means analyzing each situation individually and choosing the form of correspondence accordingly.” –Scribendi, How to Write a Letter
Rating: clean: angst: low-to-medium: due to a break-in and burglary attempt. The story was in two parts, possibly three: Part one displayed Elizabeth’s letters to their guardian. Part two was the Nameless Stranger’s POV over the same time period and his reading the letters from all the sisters. Then the story switched back to the sisters and ended in our HEA [happy-every-after]. Recommend.
“Every body allows that the talent of writing agreeable letters is peculiarly female.” –Jane Austen, Northanger Abbey
I loved this story. Partly written in epistolary format, the letters were a hoot and the Nameless Stranger’s reaction to them was even more fun. What a delightful way to present this story. OMG! The fact Lizzy’s letters were read first set the stage for the others. I agree that keeping them separate was really a wise decision. I had to laugh at the Nameless Stranger’s reaction to the letters from the younger sisters. His analysis of their character was really revealing.
Mr. Collins was despicable. What a completely horrid person and human being. No, I can’t even call him a human being… he was a toad. No offense to the toads for throwing him in their lot. Charlotte had a fine line to walk and her friendship with the Bennet ladies was seriously damaged and was probably beyond repair. I could not blame the girls for the snub of their cousins.
The pace of the story really picked up when Bingley, along with M/M Hurst, returned to Netherfield with Mr. Darcy and Georgiana for the holidays. Caroline was not in the bunch. Whew! Thank goodness. I could certainly do without her. Bingley and Darcy had no idea Collins had so mistreated his Bennet cousins.
It ended rather abruptly and I had several questions. Many have been asked in other reviews. I’ll not ask them again. As far as inventory, not everything at Longbourn would have fallen under the entail. Some items [personal items, especially those not purchased with estate funds, items Mrs. Bennet brought to her marriage, some of Bennet’s books, etc.] should have been given to the girls. Did Collins keep them out of spite? There were several items that Elizabeth mentioned that she regretted not having from Longbourn. Why mention them if nothing was to be done about it? And then the story abruptly ended and that was it. No epilogue, nothing to say what happened with anyone.
Rating: clean: angst: low-to-medium: due to a break-in and burglary attempt. The story was in two parts, possibly three: Part one displayed Elizabeth’s letters to their guardian. Part two was the Nameless Stranger’s POV over the same time period and his reading the letters from all the sisters. Then the story switched back to the sisters and ended in our HEA [happy-every-after]. Recommend.
“Every body allows that the talent of writing agreeable letters is peculiarly female.” –Jane Austen, Northanger Abbey
I loved this story. Partly written in epistolary format, the letters were a hoot and the Nameless Stranger’s reaction to them was even more fun. What a delightful way to present this story. OMG! The fact Lizzy’s letters were read first set the stage for the others. I agree that keeping them separate was really a wise decision. I had to laugh at the Nameless Stranger’s reaction to the letters from the younger sisters. His analysis of their character was really revealing.
Mr. Collins was despicable. What a completely horrid person and human being. No, I can’t even call him a human being… he was a toad. No offense to the toads for throwing him in their lot. Charlotte had a fine line to walk and her friendship with the Bennet ladies was seriously damaged and was probably beyond repair. I could not blame the girls for the snub of their cousins.
The pace of the story really picked up when Bingley, along with M/M Hurst, returned to Netherfield with Mr. Darcy and Georgiana for the holidays. Caroline was not in the bunch. Whew! Thank goodness. I could certainly do without her. Bingley and Darcy had no idea Collins had so mistreated his Bennet cousins.
It ended rather abruptly and I had several questions. Many have been asked in other reviews. I’ll not ask them again. As far as inventory, not everything at Longbourn would have fallen under the entail. Some items [personal items, especially those not purchased with estate funds, items Mrs. Bennet brought to her marriage, some of Bennet’s books, etc.] should have been given to the girls. Did Collins keep them out of spite? There were several items that Elizabeth mentioned that she regretted not having from Longbourn. Why mention them if nothing was to be done about it? And then the story abruptly ended and that was it. No epilogue, nothing to say what happened with anyone.
April 5, 2020
Dear Nameless Stranger takes place after the disastrous proposal in Hunsford, where Elizabeth and Darcy quarrel when he proposes to her. Shortly afterwards, Elizabeth's parents die and Mr Collins demands Longbourn from them at once. This leaves the girls desperate and Mr Darcy secretly swoops in, as a nameless benefactor, with a cottage and chaperone to guard their respectability. All he asks for in return are monthly letters, in which the girls account for their progress in education and house management.
The first part of the book comprises Elizabeth's letters to her nameless benefactor. These letters are amusing enough, and while Darcy remains hidden in the background, only showing his hand when he reacts to the things Elizabeth writes, this was all quite cute. I particularly liked the way the author conveyed the Bennet girls' grief through these letters, it shone through and was genuinely touching.
Unfortunately, once the story is told to completion from Elizabeth's POV, the author then switches over to Darcy and here I started to get uncomfortable. Looking at it from Darcy's perspective, the unethical and frankly creepy nature of his request for the letters can't be ignored. Here the author explicitly tells us that Darcy forces the Bennet girls to write to him because he is obsessively curious about Elizabeth's inner life. He reads intimate details about her from these letters, deriving gratification from it (re-reading passages about what Lizzy feels like in bed etc.) and this is something Mr Darcy frankly would never do. It is obviously morally wrong.
He also displays a level of passion and obsession in this novel which doesn't strike me as romantic at all, tbh. It's just that unbelievable level of "love" that you only ever find in novels or in police reports.
Finally, after reading what happens in Elizabeth's portion of the story, Darcy's felt superfluous and I was, frankly, bored.
I know this is a much beloved story, and I wish I liked it better. I really wanted to. I have not read the Daddy Longlegs books this is inspired by, so possibly I'd have liked it better if I had read that.
The first part of the book comprises Elizabeth's letters to her nameless benefactor. These letters are amusing enough, and while Darcy remains hidden in the background, only showing his hand when he reacts to the things Elizabeth writes, this was all quite cute. I particularly liked the way the author conveyed the Bennet girls' grief through these letters, it shone through and was genuinely touching.
Unfortunately, once the story is told to completion from Elizabeth's POV, the author then switches over to Darcy and here I started to get uncomfortable. Looking at it from Darcy's perspective, the unethical and frankly creepy nature of his request for the letters can't be ignored. Here the author explicitly tells us that Darcy forces the Bennet girls to write to him because he is obsessively curious about Elizabeth's inner life. He reads intimate details about her from these letters, deriving gratification from it (re-reading passages about what Lizzy feels like in bed etc.) and this is something Mr Darcy frankly would never do. It is obviously morally wrong.
He also displays a level of passion and obsession in this novel which doesn't strike me as romantic at all, tbh. It's just that unbelievable level of "love" that you only ever find in novels or in police reports.
Finally, after reading what happens in Elizabeth's portion of the story, Darcy's felt superfluous and I was, frankly, bored.
I know this is a much beloved story, and I wish I liked it better. I really wanted to. I have not read the Daddy Longlegs books this is inspired by, so possibly I'd have liked it better if I had read that.
March 16, 2023
2023 - relisten. Beautiful, creative story. Narrator does an awesome job!
However the genius of this author's 'letter writing' between the Bennet girls to their generous Nameless Stranger/Darcy is literally the best part of the story.
Consequently I liked the first half much more than the second, in which we get Darcy's POV. His own torment following the failed Hunsford proposal, finding out about the Bennet's new situation and his reactions to the girls' letters. We get to see more letters of the sisters in this section and they are also beyond creative. the author gets the voice of each sister spot on.
Waited a while to read this. Highly recommend!
However the genius of this author's 'letter writing' between the Bennet girls to their generous Nameless Stranger/Darcy is literally the best part of the story.
Consequently I liked the first half much more than the second, in which we get Darcy's POV. His own torment following the failed Hunsford proposal, finding out about the Bennet's new situation and his reactions to the girls' letters. We get to see more letters of the sisters in this section and they are also beyond creative. the author gets the voice of each sister spot on.
Waited a while to read this. Highly recommend!
March 25, 2025
My second reading. It is such a good book, and beautifully done.
Mr Bennet and Mrs Bennet died, leaving the 5 Bennet girls orphans but soon a letter arrives that they now have a good Samaritan. The only thing the remaining Bennets should do is writing each month a letter to the stranger. (Yes, Mr Darcy wants to remain a stranger.)
The letters from Elizabeth were so good and really informative in this case. Chapter 1-9 is mostly from Elizabeth Point of View, 10-14 is Darcy‘s Point of View.
(At least on Scribd Audiobook.)
I liked Darcy‘s POV really well too. Everything well explained what happened in those months when the Bennet girls were writing the letters. And you get some insights of the remaining Bennets, even some of their letters 😊 Quite interesting.
I liked the narration, it was good done and kind of fitting for this book when it‘s mostly about girls.
I really recommend the book.
Mr Bennet and Mrs Bennet died, leaving the 5 Bennet girls orphans but soon a letter arrives that they now have a good Samaritan. The only thing the remaining Bennets should do is writing each month a letter to the stranger. (Yes, Mr Darcy wants to remain a stranger.)
The letters from Elizabeth were so good and really informative in this case. Chapter 1-9 is mostly from Elizabeth Point of View, 10-14 is Darcy‘s Point of View.
(At least on Scribd Audiobook.)
I liked Darcy‘s POV really well too. Everything well explained what happened in those months when the Bennet girls were writing the letters. And you get some insights of the remaining Bennets, even some of their letters 😊 Quite interesting.
I liked the narration, it was good done and kind of fitting for this book when it‘s mostly about girls.
I really recommend the book.
August 25, 2024
What a delightful book. Every single character (except the Collinses) were so loveable and the way Darcy gets to know the Bennet girls is so sweet. A definite mood booster whenever you'll need one.
23rd April 2022
I've just finished listening to the audiobook and every time I fall more in love with this book, this Darcy, this Elizabeth and the Bennet sisters and even Ms. Ingles and Mr. Briggs. This is really one of the best JAFFs I've ever read.
23rd April 2022
I've just finished listening to the audiobook and every time I fall more in love with this book, this Darcy, this Elizabeth and the Bennet sisters and even Ms. Ingles and Mr. Briggs. This is really one of the best JAFFs I've ever read.
January 12, 2020
Avid Reader
I loved the two stories written first from Elizabeth 's viewpoint and then Darcy 's viewpoint. I was saddened that the epilogue of the second book didn't end with Darcy 's and Elizabeth 's wedding. I always love it when Elizabeth sees Pemberly for the first time. This time it would have been what sisters.
I loved the two stories written first from Elizabeth 's viewpoint and then Darcy 's viewpoint. I was saddened that the epilogue of the second book didn't end with Darcy 's and Elizabeth 's wedding. I always love it when Elizabeth sees Pemberly for the first time. This time it would have been what sisters.
March 2, 2022
I really enjoyed this story. It's very innocent and very excellent.
March 4, 2020
This is one of the best JAFF's I've ever read. It was amazing. It was utterly engaging, I couldn't put it down. The love story is EXCELLENT, but there is more to it than that. The way the sisters were characterized, the way they were developed. It was so moving, so touching. The true love story here was the love these girls had for one another, and how it kept them going during a time of such sadness. I've never read a JAFF that respected the girls' original quirks and behaviours, yet made them more human, understandable, and likeable. This was brilliantly done. I can't say it enough. If you like P&P sequels this one is a must read.
March 13, 2022
What If the Bennet Sisters Had an Anonymous Guardian?
Rating: 5 out of 5 stars
Source: Austenesque Jolabokaflod!
TYPE OF NOVEL: Pride and Prejudice Variation
THE PREMISE: Soon after Elizabeth returns from Hunsford, tragic events occur that leave the five Bennet sisters orphaned and soon-to-be homeless (thanks for your decency and charity, Mr. Collins!). But then an unexpected and anonymous guardian sends them an offer of an available cottage of their very own plus a chaperon, and only asks for monthly letters from them in return…
WHAT I LOVED:
- The Premise: A startling change in circumstances, a story full of letters, a Regency homage to Daddy Long Legs – there is so much I love about Dear Nameless Stranger! Ms. Peneaux delivers such a heartwarming and genuine tale about kindness, compassion, and altruistic intentions. And our beloved cast of characters – especially the five Bennet sisters and Mr. Darcy are so lovingly and endearingly portrayed.
- Merry-Making: Even though there is grief and sad trials, it was lovely to see the Bennet sisters enjoy some simple pleasures and discover joy together in new ways. I loved the picnics, the gardening attempts, the furniture investigations, and the exquisitely touching Christmas scene. These lovely vignettes together felt somewhat reminiscent of Louisa May Alcott, and I loved the feelings of pure innocence and good cheer they evoked.
- Unique Voices: Through both their own letters and the retelling of events from various perspectives the Bennet sisters are each given a distinct voice. I loved all that we learned about each Bennet sister through their writings. The bulk of the letters readers see are Elizabeth’s, and they are brilliantly impudent and charming – she does not fail to make everyone fall in love with her. In addition, Kitty’s letters are a delightful surprise with her distracted ponderings and discerning observations. And through the other sisters’ various accounts, their personalities and perceptions are satisfyingly revealed.
- Mr Darcy: Love him, love everything he does, love every single one of his responses. In the second half of this story readers see the same events that took place in the first half, but from Mr. Darcy’s POV. And I loved the revelation of his thoughts and emotions behind his actions. His intentions are supremely magnanimous, his eagerness – completely adorable, and his thoughtfulness – incredibly moving.
- Growing Attachments: Through their strife and startling life changes, the Bennet sisters grow closer together. No more selfishness or peevish squabbling, instead there is staunch support and devotion. It was lovely to witness the harmonious bonds grow and the loyalty flourish between these sisters. Equally enjoyable was witnessing Mr. Darcy’s growing attachment and affection for each of the Bennet sisters – not just Elizabeth. He learns to appreciate each of them for their unique attributes and develops a brotherly love for them that matches his love for Georgiana.
WHAT I WASN’T TOO FOND OF:
Nothing! It is perfect.
CONCLUSION:
Dear Nameless Stranger is an exquisitely charming and absorbing story full of honesty, hope, and heart. I adored Jeannie Peneaux’s skillful execution of this premise, and her thoughtful portrayal of these characters! I’m so glad I finally got to read this one!
Austenesque Reviews
Rating: 5 out of 5 stars
Source: Austenesque Jolabokaflod!
TYPE OF NOVEL: Pride and Prejudice Variation
THE PREMISE: Soon after Elizabeth returns from Hunsford, tragic events occur that leave the five Bennet sisters orphaned and soon-to-be homeless (thanks for your decency and charity, Mr. Collins!). But then an unexpected and anonymous guardian sends them an offer of an available cottage of their very own plus a chaperon, and only asks for monthly letters from them in return…
WHAT I LOVED:
- The Premise: A startling change in circumstances, a story full of letters, a Regency homage to Daddy Long Legs – there is so much I love about Dear Nameless Stranger! Ms. Peneaux delivers such a heartwarming and genuine tale about kindness, compassion, and altruistic intentions. And our beloved cast of characters – especially the five Bennet sisters and Mr. Darcy are so lovingly and endearingly portrayed.
- Merry-Making: Even though there is grief and sad trials, it was lovely to see the Bennet sisters enjoy some simple pleasures and discover joy together in new ways. I loved the picnics, the gardening attempts, the furniture investigations, and the exquisitely touching Christmas scene. These lovely vignettes together felt somewhat reminiscent of Louisa May Alcott, and I loved the feelings of pure innocence and good cheer they evoked.
- Unique Voices: Through both their own letters and the retelling of events from various perspectives the Bennet sisters are each given a distinct voice. I loved all that we learned about each Bennet sister through their writings. The bulk of the letters readers see are Elizabeth’s, and they are brilliantly impudent and charming – she does not fail to make everyone fall in love with her. In addition, Kitty’s letters are a delightful surprise with her distracted ponderings and discerning observations. And through the other sisters’ various accounts, their personalities and perceptions are satisfyingly revealed.
- Mr Darcy: Love him, love everything he does, love every single one of his responses. In the second half of this story readers see the same events that took place in the first half, but from Mr. Darcy’s POV. And I loved the revelation of his thoughts and emotions behind his actions. His intentions are supremely magnanimous, his eagerness – completely adorable, and his thoughtfulness – incredibly moving.
- Growing Attachments: Through their strife and startling life changes, the Bennet sisters grow closer together. No more selfishness or peevish squabbling, instead there is staunch support and devotion. It was lovely to witness the harmonious bonds grow and the loyalty flourish between these sisters. Equally enjoyable was witnessing Mr. Darcy’s growing attachment and affection for each of the Bennet sisters – not just Elizabeth. He learns to appreciate each of them for their unique attributes and develops a brotherly love for them that matches his love for Georgiana.
WHAT I WASN’T TOO FOND OF:
Nothing! It is perfect.
CONCLUSION:
Dear Nameless Stranger is an exquisitely charming and absorbing story full of honesty, hope, and heart. I adored Jeannie Peneaux’s skillful execution of this premise, and her thoughtful portrayal of these characters! I’m so glad I finally got to read this one!
Austenesque Reviews
March 19, 2020
Delightful
While the premise for this story is sad (the deaths of Mr and Mrs Bennet). This story is wonderful. It is told mainly in letters and they reveal so much of the characters of the Bennet sisters. I loved this story and will definitely be reading it again.
While the premise for this story is sad (the deaths of Mr and Mrs Bennet). This story is wonderful. It is told mainly in letters and they reveal so much of the characters of the Bennet sisters. I loved this story and will definitely be reading it again.
April 24, 2023
Loved this. Daddy Long Legs was another of my favorite books. Quite the combination.
January 17, 2020
Thoroughly Enjoyable.
Pleasant variation. I liked that there was no over-the-top dramatics. Darcy slowly comes to see the true character of each of the Bennet girls, not just the outward impression that he had held previously. Many surprises were forthcoming in the letters. Some humor mixed in also. I couldn't put it down.
Pleasant variation. I liked that there was no over-the-top dramatics. Darcy slowly comes to see the true character of each of the Bennet girls, not just the outward impression that he had held previously. Many surprises were forthcoming in the letters. Some humor mixed in also. I couldn't put it down.
November 28, 2021
Jeannie Peneaux is a marvel.
She has a way with words; everything is the perfect amount of emotionally arresting angst.
She also has a wonderful way with plot: she does everything with little pretence - plot reveals occur in the most perfect ways because even if they are predictable, they are done so tastefully and charmingly. Case in point: she has managed to make each Bennet sister individually distinct and yet true to their original renditions, but more likeable. She has this way of making you care for every single character. They feel real and worth the attention they are given.
Can we talk about this being a novella that actually is of a proper length and exposition and yet still manages to impart thought and care into each character so that their inner monologue is still explored? I feel like many P&P novellas assume you know enough about the original tale that any sort of worthwhile character development to establish within the characters is unnecessary. This is not so! But Peneaux doesn’t do her readers dirty - she starts at a point where having prior knowledge of Austen’s work is ideal, but doesn’t assume you know enough about the characters that she doesn’t have to establish them such that in the altered events of this variation their character traits need not be affected.
The plot is simple because this tale is an exploration of the Bennet sisters’ characters. And it is beautifully done.
Can we end this by talking about how wonderfully wholesome this story is?
Especially that ending. If you listen carefully, you can hear me swoon, exhaling a sigh of my complete adoration and a heart full of wholesomeness, because THIS is how you write a Pride and Prejudice variation.
And a novella instead of a full length novel to boot?
I am not worthy Madam Peneaux, but I must shower you with praise regardless because reading this was AN EXPERIENCE of the most blessed kind.
She has a way with words; everything is the perfect amount of emotionally arresting angst.
She also has a wonderful way with plot: she does everything with little pretence - plot reveals occur in the most perfect ways because even if they are predictable, they are done so tastefully and charmingly. Case in point: she has managed to make each Bennet sister individually distinct and yet true to their original renditions, but more likeable. She has this way of making you care for every single character. They feel real and worth the attention they are given.
Can we talk about this being a novella that actually is of a proper length and exposition and yet still manages to impart thought and care into each character so that their inner monologue is still explored? I feel like many P&P novellas assume you know enough about the original tale that any sort of worthwhile character development to establish within the characters is unnecessary. This is not so! But Peneaux doesn’t do her readers dirty - she starts at a point where having prior knowledge of Austen’s work is ideal, but doesn’t assume you know enough about the characters that she doesn’t have to establish them such that in the altered events of this variation their character traits need not be affected.
The plot is simple because this tale is an exploration of the Bennet sisters’ characters. And it is beautifully done.
Can we end this by talking about how wonderfully wholesome this story is?
Especially that ending. If you listen carefully, you can hear me swoon, exhaling a sigh of my complete adoration and a heart full of wholesomeness, because THIS is how you write a Pride and Prejudice variation.
And a novella instead of a full length novel to boot?
I am not worthy Madam Peneaux, but I must shower you with praise regardless because reading this was AN EXPERIENCE of the most blessed kind.
September 9, 2022
9-9-22 Listened to audiobook this time. I loved this story even more this second time!
4.5 rounded up. This was a charming and delightful read and I found myself with a contented smile on my face more than once during the course of the book. Given that this book takes place right after the unexpected deaths of both Mr. and Mrs. Bennet, there is naturally some sadness and grief, but fortunately, that is not the focus of the book. This is a pretty light and easy read with very little angst. Perfect for those days when you desire a little happy pick me up!
The book is divided into two parts. The first part was the superior of the two, primarily in the form of letters. It is from Elizabeth's POV and contains all of the wit and liveliness that we would expect from her. The second part is Darcy's perspective and is a little more complex. Unlike Elizabeth, he has complete knowledge of the facts that puts him in a more delicate position, but he does not disappoint and once again proves to be the hero we all know and love! I also loved the glimpse this second part gave us of the other four Bennet sisters. I, along with Darcy, found much to appreciate about each of the Bennet sisters!
While it did not detract from my enjoyment of this book, I couldn't help but wonder why the five Bennet sisters seemed to be left utterly alone after the tragedy of losing both of their parents. The Gardiners nor the Phillips made any appearances. Not only was every relative absent, but there wasn't even any visible support from the community and friends they had known their whole lives when they found themselves homeless and in a quite desperate situation. I thought this a little strange.
I loved this book and will definitely read it again and would recommend it to any P&P lover out there!
4.5 rounded up. This was a charming and delightful read and I found myself with a contented smile on my face more than once during the course of the book. Given that this book takes place right after the unexpected deaths of both Mr. and Mrs. Bennet, there is naturally some sadness and grief, but fortunately, that is not the focus of the book. This is a pretty light and easy read with very little angst. Perfect for those days when you desire a little happy pick me up!
The book is divided into two parts. The first part was the superior of the two, primarily in the form of letters. It is from Elizabeth's POV and contains all of the wit and liveliness that we would expect from her. The second part is Darcy's perspective and is a little more complex. Unlike Elizabeth, he has complete knowledge of the facts that puts him in a more delicate position, but he does not disappoint and once again proves to be the hero we all know and love! I also loved the glimpse this second part gave us of the other four Bennet sisters. I, along with Darcy, found much to appreciate about each of the Bennet sisters!
While it did not detract from my enjoyment of this book, I couldn't help but wonder why the five Bennet sisters seemed to be left utterly alone after the tragedy of losing both of their parents. The Gardiners nor the Phillips made any appearances. Not only was every relative absent, but there wasn't even any visible support from the community and friends they had known their whole lives when they found themselves homeless and in a quite desperate situation. I thought this a little strange.
I loved this book and will definitely read it again and would recommend it to any P&P lover out there!
March 12, 2025
A really well crafted and wonderful read
This story takes place after Hunsford but with no Pemberley visit or elopement due to tragic events at Longbourn. It presents a point of view account from Elizabeth and then Darcy with letters playing major role (as they often do in P&P) and driving the narrative. I don't want to go too far into spoilers but the feel of this novel is excellent and authentic in my view, with no far fetched craziness (and a clean read). I highly recommend this book.
This story takes place after Hunsford but with no Pemberley visit or elopement due to tragic events at Longbourn. It presents a point of view account from Elizabeth and then Darcy with letters playing major role (as they often do in P&P) and driving the narrative. I don't want to go too far into spoilers but the feel of this novel is excellent and authentic in my view, with no far fetched craziness (and a clean read). I highly recommend this book.
February 1, 2020
Extremely enjoyable read. Would love if this was redone as a full novel. It left me wanting more with how short it was!
October 3, 2021
Now this is how a book should be written! Brilliant prose, excellent characterization, clever plot even if it's a borrowed one cleverly applied, seamless flow, absent of vices such as contrivances, suspension of disbelief, plot holes, etc. that are so common in JAFF these days, and quite well edited with an eye towards British and Regency correctness.
I won't write a synopsis since that's not my type of review. Instead, I'll review technical aspects that other reviewers miss but that add so much to the reading experience, readers subjectively judge the author on the book because of these faux pas.
My list above covers the bulk of the issues. The language of the book was quite well selected for the reader, without any words that had to be looked up. The only flaws included a misspelling of judgment for the application and a few contractions to pull the reader out of the Regency feel. However, the number of contractions was fewer than that used by Austen in Pride and Prejudice. There were no non-Regency words detected. Other authors can learn from this.
The author used filter words which meant for "telling" when "showing" makes for a better reader experience. She also used a non-Austen phrase "break our fasts" in the text of the novel. "Breakfast" would be the appropriate word.
I enjoyed how point of view was used in this novel to widen the perspective for the reader. Rather than use POV interspersed on a chapter-by-chapter basis like in many Regency romances, this author chose to write the entire story in Elizabeth's then Darcy's point of view, letting the reader revisit situations with knowledge from the first time but with an alternate sense of feeling. This was written with minimal redundancy to make it for an enjoyable experience that ended well, with a few tears in each book.
This is one of the few Austen Variations that truly requires one to have read Pride and Prejudice, and it would have benefited from a foreword to say so for the few that may have read it without knowledge of that fact. The allusions to canon are sparse and the author does not go over them in detail like many others do, instead counting on the reader to remember them. This is always a difficult choice for an Austenesque author to make. As a frequent JAFF reader, I appreciated it. But as I say, some who are less familiar with canon may have had some confusion over small points.
The cover is very pretty and different and does hearken to the content. I'm not certain if it would POP off the shelf next to all those other books, though. It's a bit too subtle in its beauty. I would notice it, though. I'm drawn to anything that's doesn't have blow-dried Darcy and polyester gown Elizabeth.
I've never read Daddy Long Legs but I get the idea since I also read another Austenesque book that used it as a jumping off point. I should get the book, as it sounds marvellous if this adaptation is any indication. Unless the author made Dear Nameless Stranger better! The epistolary format is easy to follow and shows so much that I'm tempted to try a book like this myself. Yet it doesn't look easy at all to write.
Five point five stars to a book that caught my interest from go and kept it with excellence in all the important aspects of writing that make a novel tight: plot, flow, characterization, consistency, authenticity, and genuine reader rapport. Thank you, Jeannie Peneaux.
Disclaimer: I am a JAFF author and my reviews might be considered a conflict of interest. However, I was a reader first, and this review is honest and impartial. It is written for the benefit of both the reader and the author.
I won't write a synopsis since that's not my type of review. Instead, I'll review technical aspects that other reviewers miss but that add so much to the reading experience, readers subjectively judge the author on the book because of these faux pas.
My list above covers the bulk of the issues. The language of the book was quite well selected for the reader, without any words that had to be looked up. The only flaws included a misspelling of judgment for the application and a few contractions to pull the reader out of the Regency feel. However, the number of contractions was fewer than that used by Austen in Pride and Prejudice. There were no non-Regency words detected. Other authors can learn from this.
The author used filter words which meant for "telling" when "showing" makes for a better reader experience. She also used a non-Austen phrase "break our fasts" in the text of the novel. "Breakfast" would be the appropriate word.
I enjoyed how point of view was used in this novel to widen the perspective for the reader. Rather than use POV interspersed on a chapter-by-chapter basis like in many Regency romances, this author chose to write the entire story in Elizabeth's then Darcy's point of view, letting the reader revisit situations with knowledge from the first time but with an alternate sense of feeling. This was written with minimal redundancy to make it for an enjoyable experience that ended well, with a few tears in each book.
This is one of the few Austen Variations that truly requires one to have read Pride and Prejudice, and it would have benefited from a foreword to say so for the few that may have read it without knowledge of that fact. The allusions to canon are sparse and the author does not go over them in detail like many others do, instead counting on the reader to remember them. This is always a difficult choice for an Austenesque author to make. As a frequent JAFF reader, I appreciated it. But as I say, some who are less familiar with canon may have had some confusion over small points.
The cover is very pretty and different and does hearken to the content. I'm not certain if it would POP off the shelf next to all those other books, though. It's a bit too subtle in its beauty. I would notice it, though. I'm drawn to anything that's doesn't have blow-dried Darcy and polyester gown Elizabeth.
I've never read Daddy Long Legs but I get the idea since I also read another Austenesque book that used it as a jumping off point. I should get the book, as it sounds marvellous if this adaptation is any indication. Unless the author made Dear Nameless Stranger better! The epistolary format is easy to follow and shows so much that I'm tempted to try a book like this myself. Yet it doesn't look easy at all to write.
Five point five stars to a book that caught my interest from go and kept it with excellence in all the important aspects of writing that make a novel tight: plot, flow, characterization, consistency, authenticity, and genuine reader rapport. Thank you, Jeannie Peneaux.
Disclaimer: I am a JAFF author and my reviews might be considered a conflict of interest. However, I was a reader first, and this review is honest and impartial. It is written for the benefit of both the reader and the author.
September 10, 2022
4.5 stars
I enjoyed it prodigiously except for the very end. Yes, having the story finishing with a letter was quite fitting but having ODC at a fair distance at end of the tale and without them being wed yet seemed a little awkward. I think perhaps having Lizzy writing a teasing love letter to her husband, of some time, that is down stairs or somewhere else close at hand would have been sweeter, a little more lighthearted. Idk...just a thought.
I enjoyed it prodigiously except for the very end. Yes, having the story finishing with a letter was quite fitting but having ODC at a fair distance at end of the tale and without them being wed yet seemed a little awkward. I think perhaps having Lizzy writing a teasing love letter to her husband, of some time, that is down stairs or somewhere else close at hand would have been sweeter, a little more lighthearted. Idk...just a thought.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
March 9, 2021
This is a book in two parts. First we read Elizabeth's letters to the nameless stranger who gave them a house after both Bennet parents died. These are wonderful, with the humorous voice very well captured.
In the second part we see Darcy's perspective of the same events, and read some more letters from the other Bennet sisters.
I loved this.
In the second part we see Darcy's perspective of the same events, and read some more letters from the other Bennet sisters.
I loved this.
February 6, 2020
One story, two viewpoints
Quite a different story. Part one is from Lizzy’s perspective and part two is from Darcy’s. It sounds boring but each of them only know a fraction of the story so the effect is much fun.
I recommend the story highly.
Quite a different story. Part one is from Lizzy’s perspective and part two is from Darcy’s. It sounds boring but each of them only know a fraction of the story so the effect is much fun.
I recommend the story highly.
January 15, 2020
Wonderful, well done book
This is a brilliantly written book that I highly recommend. After the death of both parents and being thrown out of Longbourn with nothing to live on, a nameless stranger provides a cottage in Meryton, a companion, and living stipend for the Bennet daughters. There is apparently a cook and servant. Naturally Lady Catherine advised Mr. Collins to take immediate control of his inheritance and tells about her deed in a letter. The only requirement is that each daughter write a monthly letter. Elizabeth is an especially good letter writer and so are her sisters. The first part of the book is mostly Elizabeth’s letters to the Nameless Stranger. The second part reveals him and the challenging journey. Jane Austen herself could have written something in this format. The anonymity was always a challenge especially when Lizzy fell seriously ill. This is one of my favorite variations. I highly recommend it.
This is a brilliantly written book that I highly recommend. After the death of both parents and being thrown out of Longbourn with nothing to live on, a nameless stranger provides a cottage in Meryton, a companion, and living stipend for the Bennet daughters. There is apparently a cook and servant. Naturally Lady Catherine advised Mr. Collins to take immediate control of his inheritance and tells about her deed in a letter. The only requirement is that each daughter write a monthly letter. Elizabeth is an especially good letter writer and so are her sisters. The first part of the book is mostly Elizabeth’s letters to the Nameless Stranger. The second part reveals him and the challenging journey. Jane Austen herself could have written something in this format. The anonymity was always a challenge especially when Lizzy fell seriously ill. This is one of my favorite variations. I highly recommend it.
October 8, 2022
I listened to the audible version & it was quite perfect in length for the drive I had. I wasn’t completely in love with the repetitiveness of the pov’s, however I understand the necessity of it. I did feel like it ended too soon.
May 21, 2023
Дуже симпатичний мешап "Гордості й упередження" та "Довгоногого дядечка". Люблю епістолярні романи, і цей виконано гарно.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 113 reviews