Wow! I'm a Mr. Lemoncello addict. I ordered the Kindle, print, and audio version a while ago so I'd have all options to read it on the first day!
I loved book #4. Other than the first, it is my favorite I think, although it's hard to choose! I think re-reading them all again is on my list now!
I enjoy puzzles, crazy jokes, word-play, made up words, and riddles in real life which is one reason I enjoy these books so much. I'm also a librarian and avid reader of all genres so I thoroughly enjoy the quotes from other books and how they are used as clues. The brilliance of how Grabenstein includes other books and authors into each book as the kids solve clues to escape the library never ceases to blow my mind. He is so creative and pulls everything together so well. The great thing about this, I believe, is it helps children learn more about other books that they may gain an interest in reading. From Captain Underpants, to Wonder, to Percy Jackson, to To Kill a Mockingbird, he uses quotes and authors from mixed genres and reading levels. Include the added conflicts and competition, it makes an exciting adventure, as well as educational opportunities for all ages! He is so well-read in a range of books and brings that all in so perfectly.
This was a unique book out of the four in a way though. Some may not enjoy it as much because the adventure in the library itself is a bit more basic than previous versions, and the competition doesn't feel quite as strong. The style and elements, adventurism and wonkiness are similar, but the ending provided one of the most powerful lessons our society needs to learn. I truly hope kids will take it to heart and apply it to their lives on an ongoing basis. In what is mostly a fun-filled, creative, wacky book, I actually got teary eyed at the end with how he used one of the best quotes from To Kill A Mockingbird, one of my all-time favorites, to help kids think. With bullying being so prevalent in our society, this was so important. It is something that hit home for me personally as something I always try to remember and remind others of, knowing I've been on the "underdog" side my entire life.
The All-Star Break Out Game brings back many of the same characters as previous books, but includes a unique twist with new characters as well. This event is shorter in that the kids only have 2 hours to escape this time. It's based on fiction instead of non-fiction, and the different styles of fiction are included throughout. This includes historical, comic books, sports, and horror. But, within each of those, Grabenstein includes elements from other fiction books such as characters from fantasy books, history books, and funny books. It gives readers a chance to appreciate all kinds of ideas from books and authors from current times to classics. But, in the end it has a great lesson too which is so powerful and could change society if seriously taken to heart and applied to daily life.
I also have a feeling this book leaves an opening for #5. I suppose Grabenstein is going to keep that under cover for a while, but I'll be on the lookout!