Sometimes the back of the books make it seem you are going to get an entirely different story. This seemed as if we were going to get a thriller about tennis players going after each other to win which might have been kind of interesting but...no.
Kathy Bardy comes from a family that isn't very rich but once they discover she is very talented at playing tennis, they set her up with a coach. That coach, Marty, works at a country club during the summer so Kathy gets a job there to be a lifeguard when she isn't practicing or going to school.
Marty isn't the nicest woman but Kathy likes having her as a coach. Her parents and coach put a lot on her to be the best so she can go pro, play Wimbledon, sell her own brand of rackets and be another Billie Jean King. Her younger sister Jody is clearly jealous of her sister getting all the attention but she's a pretty intelligent person it just happens to be her talent.
Kathy always thought about playing baseball for the Red Sox but being a fourteen year old girl she's expected to be more like Chris Evert, doing something less masculine though her mother has to sew her tennis outfits instead of buying expensive tennis whites and pleated skirts. It's a little easy to see why the family wants to ride on Kathy becoming famous though...
Kathy's grandmother had a stroke and had to be moved to a cheaper nursing home and her baby brother Bobby is always sick. Kathy's best friend since childhood, Julia, comes from a rich family but they could never ask for money or expect the Redmonds to treat the Bardy family like a charity case. Julia's mother is just crazy about Kathy as if she were her other daughter but the two teen girls never think about their different social standings.
Despite everything wrong, Kathy's life isn't that terrible. She meets a young man at the club who is also a lifeguard named Oliver English and he is cute, polite and charming enough that even Kathy's parents come to think of him as another son. That's not what Oliver really wants to hear but they are only teenagers and Kathy isn't thinking about serious dating at the moment.
Something else is far more important when Kathy comes across a new tennis player, a new girl she has to beat named Ruth Gumm. Ruth is not as feminine as Julia or even Kathy but she is strong and a pro player with an athletic yet stocky frame from being an expert swimmer as well.
Ruth becomes Kathy's biggest competition until the day she is found in the club's swimming pool...dead. She missed a match against Kathy before her body was found drowned and with Ruth gone, no one else is near Kathy's level.
It seems as if it were just a terrible accident but once there seems to be evidence of foul play, there are rumors and gossip. Kathy knows she didn't have anything to do with Ruth's death but the people around her and even Kathy's temper make it look easy to be murder...
All of this makes for an interesting plot but it is just weak red herrings and a whole lot of tennis talk. I know a few bits about the sport, I played it a few times in gym class but I am not that big of a fan. This was originally written in 1980 so only some casual knowledge about that time frame and I found myself mostly skimming pages unless actual character dialogue popped up.
Most of the characters aren't very interesting or they aren't very nice or they just seem so fake that you can't find anything likeable.
There isn't any kind of climax and you don't find out the truth until the very end. Even that isn't very clear cut and sometimes ambiguous works but...not here. There's a lackluster reveal and just still so much of an open ending that I was left feeling underwhelmed.
The only reason I didn't give it just one star is because I could feel a little sympathy for Kathy in having so much on her shoulders. The human part of Kathy and her friendship with Julia being the only person NOT getting something out of her success in tennis or coming down on her with either jealousy or frustration was this books saving grace IMHO.
When No One Was Looking is a perfect starter book to lend to your middle school age child to get them interested in the mystery genre and a kickstart toward Lois Duncan or Joan Lowery Nixon and other authors in that genre.
Unless you have someone in your home ages 11 to 18 you will be probably be bored with this one but luckily (and hopefully) in about a decade or so, who knows, this could be one of my daughter's favorite books?