Overall, this got a 7.71, which is a 4 star!
Characters (8) - The characters in this were generally well rounded, and I enjoyed the arcs they underwent. Lina was a sweet and firey 11 year old, with a heart full of love and determination. The love she has for Bogdan and her general quick witted-ness was completely endearing! Similarly, Bogdan, although a little more mysterious, stuck me as a very honourable character. After reaching rock bottom when he ended up in Prison Camp 9, it seems that all that was left for him to do was the very best he could.
Svetlana's arc was simple, but very well rounded. I appreciated that it explained her reasoning and mindset so clearly, and it justified such a quick change in attitude. She was the embodiment of the manifestation of emotional trauma and I enjoyed reading her from start to finish.
Other minor characters, like Zima and Katya, were less well rounded, despite playing an important roll in Lina's own story, and the overall plot. Zima's behaviour is loosely 'excused' towards the end with a simple 'power can go to your head' line, and I was a tad disappointed by this. While the lack of development for Katya and Zima didn't necessarily take away from the book, it was definitely a missed opportunity to make Lina's emotional drive stronger.
Atmosphere (7) Overall the atmosphere was very well captured. Up in the wintry wastes of Siberia was Prison Camp 9, suitably dreary and cold. In parts, I almost found myself shivering along with Lina, and curling my toes into a blanket at the mention of her almost frost-bitten feet. The presents of ghost wolves was also suitably eerie, and the whole experience was very easily visualised. There were some bits that were a little jumpy, and I struggled with immersion. For example, the magical cloak travelling was too skimmed over the first time, and I had to flick back and reread because I thought I had missed something.. But there definitely was a strong whimsical, cold and magical atmosphere overall.
Writing (7) The writing style was enjoyable. Orton's descriptions made her world very vivid and true, and I enjoyed the exploration of heritage and emotions throughout this book. One thing I will say is that I very much enjoyed the magic sub-plot that takes place. The first time it was mentioned, I expected it to be a very in-your-face identity crisis that is such a common trope in fantasy books. However, it was delicately woven into the beginning, and slowly came to be more prevalent as the book went on.
Plot (8) The plot was very enjoyable. Not only was it a story about breaking out of a high security Siberian prison, it was a story about family and origin, and finding where you belong. It was a different story for everyone involved and it was beautifully connected. For Lina, it was a story about finding her Grandmother and rescuing her Mama. for Bogdan, it was a story about an exciting prison break with his best friend. For Svetlana, it was a story about emotional trauma and grief. The way these plot lines came together was so sweet and beautifully done.
Intrigue (8) The desire to keep reading this was so strong, almost entirely the whole way through. With such a gripping atmosphere and likeable characters, the short chapters made the 'just one more chapter' trap all the more dangerous. It took a great deal of will power to set the book down and go about the tasks in my day.
Logic (7) I am always in awe at the prospect of eleven year olds surviving so many ordeals, but in general, these were well done. It took a while for certain bits to make sense, such as the cloak travelling which was very skimmed over the first time, but all in all the story flowed quite well. I also felt the 'power goes to your head' justification for Zima was a bit of a cop out, but other than those two things, it was a well written, well rounded story.
Enjoyment (9) I adored reading this book! From the little illustrations at the beginning of the chapters, to the deep emotional pain of grief that was a big theme of this book... The whole experience was beautiful, with historical and whimsical vibes that made cuddling under a blanket, listening to the rain, and reading the PERFECT way to spend my evening.