OzAThon Book 11
Well, the last one was not really an Oz Book at all and just adjusted to fit within the great scheme of things, this one is back to being about Oz through and through, yet it thankfully breaks the same old, same old formula.
What I mean is that we don’t have a person getting lost in Oz and encounter different parts and crazy inhabitants on their way and end up in the Emerald City with a big party, but something resembling an actual plot. I can’t remember the last time that actually happened.
And the plot is not even that uninteresting.
One morning Dorothy discovers that Ozma is missing, along with her magic picture, the Wizard‘s magic tool box and Glinda‘s all-knowing book. Parallel to that, in a different corner of Oz, a cook named Cayke is missing her magical frypan. Dorothy and group set out to find their missing Princess and magical items, while Cayke and her companion, the Frogman, do the same to find the frypan. For a while those two storylines run parallel, until they finally come together and mix in surprisingly well.
One thing that’s already a plus point from the beginning is Ozma‘s absence for most of the book, which leads to less praises of her awesomeness and smug behavior. I really needed that break from her. It also showcases that the characters are actually capable of doing something without relying too much on Little Miss Perfect.
The villain is relatively interesting, because he fulfills at least to some extant some of my favorite villain tropes, namely the matter of perception. He doesn’t see any evil in his doings and thinks he is right in his methods and doesn’t that make for more interesting conflicts? Sadly, Baum doesn’t really work with it as much as he could have, but whatever dude, I‘ll take that over confusing nonsense all day.
On the negative side, Baum again falls victim to the deus ex machina ending and I start to wonder if he simply never thought his stories through or just got bored along the way and wanted a fast, nice wrap up. The villain is defeated so easily and all the build up seems to be for nothing. An ending like this can work, but mostly when it’s played for laughs and not like it is written here. Basically, for eight books Dorothy has no clue how to properly use the magic belt until she suddenly does, because it’s convenient for the plot. Yeah, whatever.
There is also a whole ton of exposition and repetitions. I get to repeat some aspects of the story once in a while, and Baum always did that, but here he went overboard. I don’t need to be reintroduced to the characters every second chapter and thank you even kids can remember what happened like three chapter earlier, they are not that long.
Button-Bright is also back and I still have no fucking clue why. His character serves no purpose, he isn’t funny or cute, he is just annoying and takes up space that could’ve been used for more interesting characters or plot points.
And finally, there is the stupidest side-plot yet, Toto loses his growl and then suddenly finds it again and it beats me why this is part of the book. It doesn’t fit into the narrative, makes no sense and doesn’t even go anywhere. The dog was a better character when still barked instead of talked.
Despite some huge criticism, I still say it’s one of the better books, and being it just for a real storyline and the lack of a stereotypical formula.