A wonderfully inventive and imaginative and entertaining set of fairy tales. They were all different and an absolutely amazing and a captivating read. They were like nothing I’ve ever read before from Grimm or anyone else. And I understand these are just retellings of traditional tales, but the writing it was just so brilliant and whimsical that you can’t help but give great praise to the writer, Anthony Minghella. I absolutely love the writing in this book!
1) “The Three Ravens” = This was a truly captivating tale, taking that whole evil witch/stepmother concept to a whole new level. I have no doubt that this tale might’ve been the basis of Snow White or even the product of it. Whatever it is, I still love it. You can’t help but get sucked into the sad plight of the Princess, having to escape the Witch not only once but twice. I’m telling you that despite the fact that I think Disney is an evil monster bend on taking over the entertainment world, I think that this fairy tale would make a magnificent Disney movie. And yes, it does have a happy ending.
2) “Hans My Hedgehog” = I didn’t quite know what to think of this strange and brilliant tale at first. It is Beauty and the Beast in nature in which a princess falls in love with a creature (Hans my hedgehog), but it was different than your Disney classic or even the Grimm original. Han was born a half man, half hedgehog creature and practically tricked a King into betrothing his daughter to him. Your feelings about Hans really go up and down. You first feel sorry for him, but then you think he’s cruel for tricking the King, and then you start to feel sorry for him again because you find out he is actually cursed and wants desperately to be love. Like I said, a bit strange and hard to have a definite opinion on. So therefore not really Disney material.
3) “The Soldier and Death” = Probably one of my favorites because it’s not a fairy tale that you would think of in the normal sense. There is no Princess or Prince or anything of that sort. But it is still very good. It’s about how you shouldn’t mess with Death because a “life protracted is protracted woe” (Samuel Johnson). And it’s also a warning to be careful for what you wish for, because if you don’t want death and try to stop him, then death won’t ever come back to you. You will live forever, always wondering between Heaven and Hell. And that’s exactly what happened to the Soldier. It’s sad, yes, but just a great story.
4) “The Luck Child” = This story was alright. It had your classic evil royalty and destined prince. But the boy (the Luck Child) that was supposed to overcome this evil King, just did so because of luck and the help of the Little Man. He didn’t really do much. He had it all done for him practically, so I didn’t really feel for him and therefore I couldn’t really like this story all that much. Nevertheless, the tale was, while the weakest of them all, still brilliantly written and quite a fun concept.
5) “The True Bride” = Another one of my favorites. It kind of had a Cinderella vibe to it (but not as much as a later story), what with a poor orphan girl having to work as a slave to cruel troll only to have the troll’s sister take away her Beloved. It was a very captivating story and one full of magic centering on a white lion (therefore reminding me of Narnia). The illustrations in this story are some of my favorite in the whole book, and I just adore this brilliant tale. It’s just different enough not to really fit any of the preset Disney molds, and I love it.
6) “Fearnot” = This was a fun story, and one of the few ones where the main character went through a major change. It’s about a boy (Fearnot) that’s not afraid of anything, and goes out to learn what fear is, and only after a few adventures where he beats terrible monsters he finds fear when his sweetheart almost dies. Fearnot is a great character. It’s all silly and just great fun. And I find it so cool that there’s a lot alliteration in this tale. And yes, I know that I’m a nerd.
7) “The Heartless Giant” = A wonderfully original and enchanting story. It’s not like anything else I’ve read in the fairy tale universe. It has a sad ending though, because after all the bad this Heartless Giant did, in the end he was willing to take back his heart and repent, but the angry villagers still killed him despite Prince Leo’s protests. Nevertheless, I still feel this is another great story, and the sad ending just gives it another note of originality.
8) “Sapsorrow” = Now this was the one that was most like Cinderella. In fact it was so close to the Disney version that we all know and maybe love, that it could’ve been a retelling of it instead of a whole brand new story. But that doesn’t mean it still wasn’t a fantastic fable. The only problem I have with it is the Prince. He is so pompous and proud, and I hate to say it but he doesn’t change much by the end. And because of this I have a hard time feeling for him.
9) “A Story Short” = This was the weirdest of all the stories. It harkens back or serves as a basis to the really odd and obscure Grimm’s fairy tales. The whole thing was like a dream, with all the strange magic and enchantments. And even stranger, is the fact that this tale is written in first person with is really weird for a fairy tale. Overall, possibly one of the most bizarre fairy tales I’ve ever read.
Now that I’ve talked about all of the tales I would like to say something about the thing that ties them all together beside the brilliantly magnificent writing: the illustrations. They are all wonderfully detailed and artistically beautiful. The colors are vivid and the expressions perfectly capture the mood of each scene they depict. They are done in the classic fairy tale style yet I haven’t seen anything like it. I absolutely love them.
Now, I will do what I do with all anthologies: rate the stories from most favorite to least favorite. Okay here it goes. “The Soldier and Death,” “The True Bride,” “The Three Ravens,” “The Heartless Giant,” “Sapsorrow,” “Fearnot,” “Hans My Hedgehog,” “A Story Short,” and “The Luck Child.”
And there you go. That’s really it. A bunch of truly wonderful, brilliant, original, beautiful, and amazing fairy tales. Probably my favorite set of fairy tales to date.