I’m a long-term fan of Peter Milligan’s comics, but he’s written some right stinkers lately, and I’ve never been too taken with Valiant’s serious stuff, so I didn’t pick up this Roman detective adventure on release. Bless Netgalley, then, for having it available as an ARC. First impression: Ryp’s art, which on his Avatar work can sometimes show more detail than soul, looks amazing with Jordie Bellaire colouring. Second impression: still not convinced Milligan is firing on all cylinders. Our hero is a centurion made into Rome’s first ‘detectioner’ by a codex the Vestal Virgins showed him; this ‘codex’ is persistently depicted as a scroll, which is a bit like repeatedly referring to a Kindle while having the hero shown flipping through a paperback. Also, this is apparently what makes him the only person in Rome who thinks in terms of cause, effect and motive rather than gods and superstitions. Which is interesting given, even more than Greece, I’d consider imperial Rome the first period when people were already starting to think in terms we’d recognise as rational, even if obviously their premises were a bit wobbly at times – just look at Cicero, and how much closer he seems to modern arguments than Aristotle, let alone that nut-job Plato.
And then the main plot sees our man sent to the fringes of Empire (as the title suggests) to fight monsters. So why bother painting him as anomalous in Rome itself when he's not going to be there long? The notion of the logical man from the big city fighting demons in the sticks recalls Tim Burton’s Sleepy Hollow, which I love but hardly needed a Roman remake; the idea of reason as another form of magic is potentially resonant, but also potentially tritely post-truth. And ultimately I get no sense of the wider point here, especially when compared to Milligan's last classical foray, the too-soon-cancelled Greek Street.