A few hilariously funny anecdotal stories aside, this book by Michael Lewis is poison. While somewhat entertaining, and an extremely easy and quick read, this book provides little insight into 'real' fatherhood. It does little more than propagate the hideous fallacy that only mothers can be the true nurturers and care-givers for our children, and any attempts by a man to do so can only be inadequate. Furthermore, Lewis would have you believe if you are a father and you do feel confident in taking complete control of care-giving and child raising with confidence, well, then there must be something wrong with you. Because, after all,the men around you are only doing what is required of them, and begrudgingly at that, and like it this way. Well, I for one beg to vehemently disagree.
It has almost become cliche, this 'accidental guide'. The situation where the man is left with the children for only a short time, but manages to screw things up so badly that onlookers are left to wonder how the children will ever survive, only to be saved just in the nick of time by Mom. She swooshes in with her golden lasso and bullet deflecting bracelets and saves the day, but not without handing out a few back-handed comments about Dad's incompetence as a care-giver first. The crowd hardly notices Dad as he slinks off to the basement with his tail between his legs to "tinker" with something on his work bench or drink heavily in solitary confinement. No, this crowd of rubberneckers is too focused on Mom lavishing her children with copious amounts of love and affection after their near fatal incident, and think to themselves, as Mom thinks to herself, what a wonderful Mother she is, and how her children obviously "need" her every minute of everyday. Well, if I'm in this crowd of onlookers, I'm yelling "Bullshit!" at the top of my lungs. But it's this fallacy that Lewis calls Fatherhood and claims is normal.
While I agree there are obvious gender-based differences between men and women when it comes to being parents, I don't agree that it's these differences that make a Mom somehow more competent than Dad. That somehow Dad's are suppose to be less competent at providing for their children when Mom isn't around, and that's just how it is. However, I do believe, and often witness, Dad's being set-up by Mom's for failure, and when they do "fail" (or rather, just don't do things the exact same way Mom would have done them, without harm), they get chastised until they feel they are about as equipped to be a father as Pee Wee Herman. According to Lewis, with his experiences relayed in this book, that's just how it is. That may be, in your house Mr. Lewis, and in numerous households across this country, but it's not normal and NOT how it should be.
Or maybe it's the other way around. Maybe, it's really a self-depreciation that occurs with this dynamic, that allows a father to shirk his real responsibilities to his children without guilt. "Oh, well, experience has shown that she's better equipped to handle this, so I'll just let her take care of it." It seems to me this can only breed contempt in a relationship. Are you serious? Somebody actually pays you to write this dribble for a magazine. I shudder to think that there are probably thousands of readers out there who have read this excrement and thought because it was presented in a funny and witty way, that it was sound advice on fatherhood.
While I have enjoyed the previous two books I've read by Lewis on two subjects he is obviously well versed in, Home Game is a huge disappointment. A gentleman much wiser than me once told me that growing up and becoming a man involved a moment or a series of moments where you stopped doing things just for you and your personal satisfaction and started doing things for the benefit of those you care for and love. Not because some outsider said you are suppose to, but because you know deep down it's what is right and what you want the most. Given his personal past (2 divorces), Lewis might want to focus on his own personal development and maturation, before passing on his questionable at best advice on family life.