Original Review (08/02/2017):
Though it recycles a fair amount of "Post Office," "Ham on Rye," and "Factotum," "Notes of a Dirty Old Man" feels a little fresh for Bukowski. It at least has its own personality. You can tell he was pretty smashed while writing this shit - he'll segue from an MRA-style "women-are-conniving-rats" rant to a story about fucking a 5-foot tall, 350-pound prostitute.
It's raw stuff, with little to no care put in for structural cohesion. At one point, Bukowski states that he is aware that his narration is switching between tenses, and tells the reader that, if they care, they can "shove a nipple up their scrotum." This doesn't even make anatomical sense.
Yeah, you can see why the FBI kept a file on Charles Bukowski for this book. At one point, someone says to a Bukowski self-insert character, "It doesn't matter whether your stories are true," to which Bukowski replies "They are." This could all be bluffing, but if not, then Bukowski has raped and beaten a good few souls in this world. If he isn't bluffing, he has coasted from a childhood of abuse and hatred to an adulthood of boozing, rape, violence, and laziness, all while maintaining interiority and literary wit.
Of course, that doesn't make any of his literal and figurative woman-bashing acceptable, but it's part of the entrance fee for reading this shit.
There is a sequence in "Notes of a Dirty Old Man" where a painting instructor gives a young Bukowski brushes and paints (he didn't bring his own), and instructs him to paint a vase, just like his classmates. While they take hours, he is finished in five minutes. His color is sparse and basic, and the vase resembles shit more than slightly in its coloring. But his classmates are amazed and refuse to believe Bukowski has never painted before.
The inclusion of this story may sound pretentious, and that is probably because it is, but it is a good encapsulation of the Bukowski appeal. Even if it is all an act, all of the autobiographical shit, Bukowski still has the narrative perspective of a person who refused to be groomed by his parents, teachers, or lovers. An alcoholic, violent, reflective, melancholy, predatory, imaginative, brutal narrator. And "NOADOM" reads like a tour through his boundary-less mind.
"NOADOM" is good Bukowski, with his penchant for crushing realistic stories, his angels-and-demons-and-necrophilia stories, his putrid sex stories, and his politically nihilistic stories. It's the sort of gut-slice writing that you either devour or spit back out in disgust.
Update (12/19/2020):
I wrote this review in 2017 and reread a lot of Buk in 2020. Upon rereading "Notes of a Dirty Old Man," I am struck by how... immoral Bukowski can be. He admits to brutally raping a prostitute in this book, a story I alluded to in my original review. The story could be fictional, of course, but I've read a lot of Bukowski, and I feel like I can tell when he's BS'ing and when he isn't.
It doesn't feel like he is bluffing in the story about the prostitute.
I'm not telling you not to read this book. I’m not calling for anyone to “cancel” Bukowski. I’m just writing honestly about my feelings about this book and Buk in general.
I started reading him when I was in high school, and his feelings of alienation resonated with me. I don’t regret the affection I developed for his work. As I’ve grown older, I still feel that affection, but I am also more cognizant of the moral failings that I once excused and overlooked.
My original review did not emphasize enough the amount of pain Bukowski probably brought into the world through his actions. I felt compelled to rectify that problem by making this edit. I am leaving the original up because I think there is truth in what I said then and truth in what I say now.