Thank you so much to Publisher Spotlight and Jenna Guillaume for an ARC of this title in exchange for an honest review.
"You Were Made For Me" by Jenna Guillaume describes the story of sixteen-year-old Katie Camilleri who just created a boy with Libby, her best friend and at-home scientist. Katie hasn't had her first kiss yet, but that's because she wants it to be with the perfect boy, so she can have the perfect first kiss. And that's where the boy they created, Guy, comes in. Guy had beautiful blue eyes, lips perfect for kissing, blond hair, and a great body. And after Katie and Libby realize they've created a boy, Katie starts to date Guy, and everything seems perfect. But having a fumbled human creation as a boyfriend is pretty complicated since Katie still needs to figure out her feelings toward him and if he actually wants to be with her for who she is, or because he was born made to love her.
This wasn't my favorite read. I was very frustrated while reading this, so I couldn't enjoy this as much as I wanted to. But this novel still had kind of cute moments and little character development that made this somewhat redeemable.
The plot of this novel wasn't very complex at all, but it was still intriguing, at first. Now when I started reading a few pages of this, it felt exactly like the Disney movie "How To Build A Better Boy" and the movie "Weird Science". There were similar themes from both those movies, which makes sense because this novel was inspired by "Weird Science". But even though I was intrigued by the plot and how it was inspired by a movie at the beginning, I got bored and frustrated quick. The whole plot is based on this minuscule problem that is solved when Guy is made, yet it felt like problems kept arising just to add to a flat plot. This isn't horrible, but the problems that arose felt useless and could be easily solved. But of course, they couldn't be because of how Katie handles them.
And the writing only made my problems with the plot worse. I didn't like how even though Katie was narrating the story from a 1'st person perspective, Libby would cut in between certain thoughts to add her opinion or comment. And while I did agree with some of Libby's opinions, I still think that it wasn't needed. And when Katie is the main narrator, she makes juvenile comments that made this harder to read. An example of this is at about 2% through the novel.
"We have the kind of friendship where you can tell the other person anything -anything- and we won't take offense or judge each other.
I mean, we even fart around each other.
That's how you know it's real friendship (Libby)"
This felt juvenile to me, and reminded me of something I would've said in the 4'th grade. This is a recurring theme in this novel, which didn't make it enjoyable. But other than that, the writing wasn't horrible. If anything, it was pretty mediocre and just told the story.
Katie
was my least favorite character, and I have a lot to say about her. She was a messy girlie, but not in a good way. Katie always said how she wanted her first kiss to be perfect, and she wanted it with her perfect boyfriend. But when she finally gets this, she's unsatisfied (for some reason), and starts doing all this stuff and gets messy when her life is literally perfect. And one of the messes she started was with Libby when she paid less attention to her, and more to Guy because he was devoted to her and didn't want her to leave. Because of this, Katie didn't even notice what was going on with Libby. Katie has a perfect life, yet she always has to find more and more to satisfy her, when all she needs is right in front of her, and she just needs to open her eyes.
Also, Katie doesn't have a personality or a backbone. All Katie does is fantasize about her perfect kiss with the perfect boyfriend and paint. Oh, and she works at a pharmacy or something. That's it. Other than that, she was just an insecure person who let the stereotypical mean girl, Mikayla, walk all over her. Even though I liked that Libby helps Katie stand up to Mikayla towards the end, I wish that Katie actually believed in how she was and knew what she deserved. Katie's character did evolve towards the end, but not very much.
Libby
was a good character who cared for her friend and liked science, but that's about it. There is something revealed towards the end of the book that tells us Libby's sexuality, and I was glad to have that type of representation, but she wasn't really anything else. I was actually more interested in her life than Katie's because we didn't get to learn enough about her personality and who she was without Katie.
Theo
was probably my favorite character in the novel because it seemed like his personality actually had substance. He had a tough past and a lot of grief following him, so he really depended on his friendship with Katie. Theo really cared for Katie and always helps her, even when she didn't deserve it and I wouldn't have helped her. But I couldn't stand how I think about two times, the weight he lost was brought up negatively. As in, they were trying to make him feel bad about gaining weight in the past. Theo deserved a lot better than what he got.
Guy
knew how to cook, had a "nice body", and was attached to Katie. He didn't have any personality, which is expected since he was magically made in a kitchen by two teenage girls. Guy was made solely for the purpose of giving Katie her first kiss, but he did help her figure out what she wanted. He didn't really develop because there was nothing to develop from the jump.
Supporting Characters
Most of these supporting characters were added to give substance to the story, so they had no personality whatsoever. Alex was Katie's co-worker who was also gay, so yay, ✨representation✨. He was just nosy and wanted to get in Katie's business, which is understandable because she was messy. Mikayla was just a bitter, stereotypical mean girl who messed with Katie for no reason. I didn't understand her motives, and she was just annoying and sad. Declan Bell Jones was a douchebag who excused Mikayla's horrible actions because of her past. He used Katie, and I don't care about him at all. Luke was Katie's older brother, and he was there just to snitch on her, but then remind her he loved her. Katie's parents seemed sexist to me because they gave Katie all these rules about dating Guy (stuff about sex and keeping the door open when they're together), but they didn't do that to Luke when he was dating a year earlier than she was. They just got on my nerves.
Overall, I just wasn't feeling this book. There were too many things that frustrated me in this book or left me feeling blank to be ignored. The characters weren't great, the plot had no substance, and I didn't like the writing or the narrator(s). I would recommend this to someone who wants a quick read with a protagonist who complains about minuscule problems and bland characters.
↠ 3 stars