What do you think?
Rate this book
Fair Stands the Wind
We all know that in Jane Austen’s Pride and Prejudice, Mr Darcy is proud and prejudiced because he is a wealthy landowner who believes himself above his company; and that Elizabeth Bennet can afford to be proud and prejudiced because she believes she has the freedom to make choices for herself.
But what if Mr Darcy is the second son, sent to sea at a young age? What if Elizabeth is trapped by circumstances, with an ill father on one side and an understandably desperate mother on the other?
Meet Captain Darcy of the Royal Navy, a successful frigate captain, with ample prize-money and a sister he needs to provide for while he is at sea. Meet Elizabeth Bennet, who needs a husband and is trying to resign herself to Mr Collins, the worst “least worst alternative” in the history of literature.
But what if Mr Darcy is the second son, sent to sea at a young age? What if Elizabeth is trapped by circumstances, with an ill father on one side and an understandably desperate mother on the other?
Meet Captain Darcy of the Royal Navy, a successful frigate captain, with ample prize-money and a sister he needs to provide for while he is at sea. Meet Elizabeth Bennet, who needs a husband and is trying to resign herself to Mr Collins, the worst “least worst alternative” in the history of literature.
Unknown Binding
Published January 1, 2017
51 people are currently reading
120 people want to read
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 82 reviews
September 5, 2017
4 stars!
Review, Excerpt and Giveaway at Of Pens and Pages.
Mr. Darcy has the privilege of being the first son of a wealthy gentleman. But have you imagined what he would be like if he was the second son? Would he be a member of the clergy or a military man like Colonel Fitzwilliam? In Fair Stands the Wind, the people of Hertfordshire do not meet a Mr. Darcy of Pemberley, but they do meet Captain Darcy of the Royal Navy.
(So, kind of like Captain Frederick Wentworth, another Austen favorite.❤️ Their profession, success at sea, and swoon-worthiness are the only similarities though)
Darcy is not the only one living a different life. The Bennet ladies—especially the two eldest daughters—are in more desperate need of a husband since Mr. Bennet is terribly ill and might die sooner than they are prepared. Jane is more resigned to her mama’s matchmaking schemes, and Elizabeth has accepted the fact she might marry Mr. Collins once he proposes.
There is no “she is not handsome enough to tempt me…” statement thrown so casually, but there are whispers of Captain Darcy’s drinking habits and ways of a sailor that make Elizabeth cautious of him, although time spent at Netherfield when Jane was sick is enough to appease those fears/apprehensions.
Marriage is not in Captain Darcy’s sights, but circumstances involving his younger sister’s guardianship makes him need it, even more so now that he has to go back to sea. When Elizabeth was in Netherfield taking care of Jane, Darcy saw it first hand what a kind, compassionate, and a lady of good sense she was, and upon hearing about their circumstances, believed they could enter a marriage of convenience to help each other. It was not what Elizabeth imagined, but it was much better than marrying Mr. Collins, and so the two wed.
The two are separated shortly after they are married and only have the chance to get to know each other more through letters. It is easy to see their affection growing even when they’re apart, and it made me anticipate their reunion with each page!
It is certainly a different take on Pride and Prejudice, but it’s still gripping and sweet. Darcy is just as giving and selfless. He will do anything for those he loves, even letting them go if he thinks it would be better for them. It’s not surprising I fell for Captain Darcy. He’s so sweet in his own way.
The story is more focused on Captain Darcy and Elizabeth, but there are familiar faces here and there, although they don’t impact the story as much as the original. There are a few new characters here, mostly Captain Darcy’s crew, but they’re fun, endearing, and protective of Elizabeth and Georgiana.
I would have loved to read more scenes where these two are together, to see their love grow more when they’re reunited. Although the epilogue was absolutely adorable! If you enjoy what-if stories of Pride and Prejudice, you might enjoy Fair Stands the Wind as much as I did.
It is not an easy happily ever after for Captain Darcy and Elizabeth, but it was a pleasure to read their journey into finding it.
Tropes: Marriage of Convenience
POV: Third Person, Female POV
Standalone: Yes
*ARC received in exchange for an honest review.
Blog | Facebook | Twitter | Instagram
Review, Excerpt and Giveaway at Of Pens and Pages.
Mr. Darcy has the privilege of being the first son of a wealthy gentleman. But have you imagined what he would be like if he was the second son? Would he be a member of the clergy or a military man like Colonel Fitzwilliam? In Fair Stands the Wind, the people of Hertfordshire do not meet a Mr. Darcy of Pemberley, but they do meet Captain Darcy of the Royal Navy.
(So, kind of like Captain Frederick Wentworth, another Austen favorite.❤️ Their profession, success at sea, and swoon-worthiness are the only similarities though)
Darcy is not the only one living a different life. The Bennet ladies—especially the two eldest daughters—are in more desperate need of a husband since Mr. Bennet is terribly ill and might die sooner than they are prepared. Jane is more resigned to her mama’s matchmaking schemes, and Elizabeth has accepted the fact she might marry Mr. Collins once he proposes.
There is no “she is not handsome enough to tempt me…” statement thrown so casually, but there are whispers of Captain Darcy’s drinking habits and ways of a sailor that make Elizabeth cautious of him, although time spent at Netherfield when Jane was sick is enough to appease those fears/apprehensions.
Marriage is not in Captain Darcy’s sights, but circumstances involving his younger sister’s guardianship makes him need it, even more so now that he has to go back to sea. When Elizabeth was in Netherfield taking care of Jane, Darcy saw it first hand what a kind, compassionate, and a lady of good sense she was, and upon hearing about their circumstances, believed they could enter a marriage of convenience to help each other. It was not what Elizabeth imagined, but it was much better than marrying Mr. Collins, and so the two wed.
The two are separated shortly after they are married and only have the chance to get to know each other more through letters. It is easy to see their affection growing even when they’re apart, and it made me anticipate their reunion with each page!
It is certainly a different take on Pride and Prejudice, but it’s still gripping and sweet. Darcy is just as giving and selfless. He will do anything for those he loves, even letting them go if he thinks it would be better for them. It’s not surprising I fell for Captain Darcy. He’s so sweet in his own way.
The story is more focused on Captain Darcy and Elizabeth, but there are familiar faces here and there, although they don’t impact the story as much as the original. There are a few new characters here, mostly Captain Darcy’s crew, but they’re fun, endearing, and protective of Elizabeth and Georgiana.
I would have loved to read more scenes where these two are together, to see their love grow more when they’re reunited. Although the epilogue was absolutely adorable! If you enjoy what-if stories of Pride and Prejudice, you might enjoy Fair Stands the Wind as much as I did.
It is not an easy happily ever after for Captain Darcy and Elizabeth, but it was a pleasure to read their journey into finding it.
Tropes: Marriage of Convenience
POV: Third Person, Female POV
Standalone: Yes
*ARC received in exchange for an honest review.
Blog | Facebook | Twitter | Instagram
February 4, 2021
I read this as an unpublished story and am posting my review from that version here. And now have reread this lovely story as a published book.
This story is full of differences. Darcy has not had a childhood of privilege nor does he think he is above anyone. But circumstances cause Elizabeth to think he is not exactly respectable.
While Captain Darcy dances with one of his party and Charlotte Lucas, upon espying him having to be helped into a carriage to leave the Meryton Assembly, Elizabeth thinks he is a man who imbibes early in the evening and can't hold his liquor. And when again she hears of him being assisted upstairs at Netherfield in the middle of the day, she can't make out his character. And he is wearing darkened glasses - why?
Mr. Bennet lies gravely ill and the ladies of the family hold little hope that he will recover. Bingley visits to make use of some surveyor's maps in Mr. Bennet's library and brings Darcy who understands maps better than he. Opportunities to observe or converse with the captain cause Elizabeth's thoughts to comprehend that "It was not that he was curt, nor that he was haughty or ill-mannered, more that he seemed ill-at-ease." And when that man leaves but then returns to Netherfield with his half-sister, Georgiana, and his step-mother it is Elizabeth he turns to for aid in determining her discomfort one morning and also to take her shopping to replace a worn out and outgrown wardrobe.
What happens at the Netherfield Ball clinches Captain Darcy's resolve to ask Elizabeth to marry him. But it is an arrangement to give succor to both sides of the coin. He needs someone to care for and protect his sister while he is at sea. She needs someone to provide relief from, first of all, Mr. Collins' intentions to marry one of sisters and secondly to provide financial relief as Longbourn has been poorly managed, credit from merchants has been cut off and Mr. Bennet's health portends the family being cast out into the hedgerows. Darcy will not impose himself upon her but will be leaving the day after the ceremony.
In all the arranging of matters we learn a great deal about how Darcy and his sister came to be in need of this arrangement. Darcy is a second son. His older brother...well, you are going to have to read this for yourself.
Correspondence between the couple, her father's condition and then the facts of war at sea come to a climax and he makes another offer. What kind of man is this? Is he dismissing me? Elizabeth researches and comes to some conclusions and a solution all her own.
This is a short story but it drew me in immediately and kept my nose in the book until the very end. I loved it. It is not canon but we have all those people inhabiting P&P with a few new ones thrown in. Captain Darcy's crew are the best and his wife works well with them. You will absolutely love and deeply admire this man, this Darcy. Well done.
This story is full of differences. Darcy has not had a childhood of privilege nor does he think he is above anyone. But circumstances cause Elizabeth to think he is not exactly respectable.
While Captain Darcy dances with one of his party and Charlotte Lucas, upon espying him having to be helped into a carriage to leave the Meryton Assembly, Elizabeth thinks he is a man who imbibes early in the evening and can't hold his liquor. And when again she hears of him being assisted upstairs at Netherfield in the middle of the day, she can't make out his character. And he is wearing darkened glasses - why?
Mr. Bennet lies gravely ill and the ladies of the family hold little hope that he will recover. Bingley visits to make use of some surveyor's maps in Mr. Bennet's library and brings Darcy who understands maps better than he. Opportunities to observe or converse with the captain cause Elizabeth's thoughts to comprehend that "It was not that he was curt, nor that he was haughty or ill-mannered, more that he seemed ill-at-ease." And when that man leaves but then returns to Netherfield with his half-sister, Georgiana, and his step-mother it is Elizabeth he turns to for aid in determining her discomfort one morning and also to take her shopping to replace a worn out and outgrown wardrobe.
What happens at the Netherfield Ball clinches Captain Darcy's resolve to ask Elizabeth to marry him. But it is an arrangement to give succor to both sides of the coin. He needs someone to care for and protect his sister while he is at sea. She needs someone to provide relief from, first of all, Mr. Collins' intentions to marry one of sisters and secondly to provide financial relief as Longbourn has been poorly managed, credit from merchants has been cut off and Mr. Bennet's health portends the family being cast out into the hedgerows. Darcy will not impose himself upon her but will be leaving the day after the ceremony.
In all the arranging of matters we learn a great deal about how Darcy and his sister came to be in need of this arrangement. Darcy is a second son. His older brother...well, you are going to have to read this for yourself.
Correspondence between the couple, her father's condition and then the facts of war at sea come to a climax and he makes another offer. What kind of man is this? Is he dismissing me? Elizabeth researches and comes to some conclusions and a solution all her own.
This is a short story but it drew me in immediately and kept my nose in the book until the very end. I loved it. It is not canon but we have all those people inhabiting P&P with a few new ones thrown in. Captain Darcy's crew are the best and his wife works well with them. You will absolutely love and deeply admire this man, this Darcy. Well done.
September 18, 2017
I read this book on a ff site a few weeks back and now read its finished version since I didn't notice a huge difference I am recycling my previous review (aren't I green )
Here a profoundly ill Mr. Bennet is unintentionally influencing his daughter's behavior. Mr. Darcy is named George and Fitzwilliam Darcy is know as Captain, as in the Royal Navy. His friendship with Bingley is explained in a new way. He is suffering from an unknown illness that makes Lizzy suspect he is a drunkard. However he isn't disdainful and when both he and Lizzy have seemingly insurmountable problems he suggests marriage as a solution and because that marriage comes with a bunch of money she acquiesces. I am not saying Lizzy is mercenary, she is however pragmatic. It seems that her family will lose its home any day and faced with the choice of cousin or captain she chooses WISELY. Her marriage does come with a few strings in the form of Captain Darcy's half sister, Georgiana, and her mother. Lizzy and her new family set up housekeeping with the assistance of several of the Captain's former sailors who suffer from various injuries. Darcy had to spirit Georgiana and her mother away from Pemberley and his older brother because of neglect and a plot to wed Georgie to Wickham and share her dowry. Lizzy will be required to use her big brain to keep Georgie safe, Mrs. Darcy satisfied and her husband, far away in the Med. happy.
If you are looking for a traditional Lizzy Darcy love story you won't find it here, but if you are willing to risk a story of two virtual strangers falling in love through their letters this is a joyous read.
Here a profoundly ill Mr. Bennet is unintentionally influencing his daughter's behavior. Mr. Darcy is named George and Fitzwilliam Darcy is know as Captain, as in the Royal Navy. His friendship with Bingley is explained in a new way. He is suffering from an unknown illness that makes Lizzy suspect he is a drunkard. However he isn't disdainful and when both he and Lizzy have seemingly insurmountable problems he suggests marriage as a solution and because that marriage comes with a bunch of money she acquiesces. I am not saying Lizzy is mercenary, she is however pragmatic. It seems that her family will lose its home any day and faced with the choice of cousin or captain she chooses WISELY. Her marriage does come with a few strings in the form of Captain Darcy's half sister, Georgiana, and her mother. Lizzy and her new family set up housekeeping with the assistance of several of the Captain's former sailors who suffer from various injuries. Darcy had to spirit Georgiana and her mother away from Pemberley and his older brother because of neglect and a plot to wed Georgie to Wickham and share her dowry. Lizzy will be required to use her big brain to keep Georgie safe, Mrs. Darcy satisfied and her husband, far away in the Med. happy.
If you are looking for a traditional Lizzy Darcy love story you won't find it here, but if you are willing to risk a story of two virtual strangers falling in love through their letters this is a joyous read.
June 15, 2022
Ever wonder how a story will go if you take the career of one Austen hero and give it to another? I hadn't been curious until I spotted this intriguing variation story by a new to me author. Mr. Darcy as a second son and Naval captain? I do love a sailor story so no surprise I was eager for this one.
Fair Stands the Wind begins where Jane Austen's original Pride and Prejudice does when Charles Bingley lets the Netherfield Estate and he and his party comes into contact with the Bennet family. But, there are differences right in the beginning. First, Mr. Bennet's health is precarious so his family are more clear-eyed and sober about their own future. Jane Bennet has to think with her head as well as her heart and the rest are resigned to a sadder fate. There is then the introduction of a tall officer of the navy who has prize money, but not the master of a grand estate.
Not long after, she goes from prickly to curious about Captain Darcy, Elizabeth meets his skittish step-mother and half sister who are now in his care. Seeing him look after his relations with tenderness and care right about the time her father's smug and insufferable cousin Collins arrives makes her able to welcome a marriage of convenience. Elizabeth faces life with fortitude and somewhere along the way finds she is able to dream of her own happiness too.
Fair Stands the Wind was a tender, slow-burn love story at its heart. They barely know each other when they agree on a marriage. There is respect and even some esteem, but it is their letters that start them on the road to something more. I was well pleased to see the letters as I do love a correspondence romance. The story included some memorable and recognizable P&P scenes and most of the characters from the original appear in some form or another. However, I found the story was all it's own and I enjoyed it as such.
Elizabeth was a redoubtable young woman who had to grow up fast and shoulder responsibilities so I had no trouble seeing her running a household and protecting her new husband's sister and step-mother from the trouble that followed them. I loved seeing her make her own circle of friends and allies from Fitzwilliam's naval friends and later she impresses even more august people of his acquaintance.
But, the highlight of this story is Darcy as a naval captain. This Darcy has earned his way to position and sees privilege and respect as something also to be earned. He is intuitive about people as a good captain must be and this serves him well when it comes to spotting the treasure that is Elizabeth and treating her as such while respecting her sense and intellect.
The conflict of this story comes mostly from without, but there is an intense and emotional crisis moment that had me thoroughly engaged and reading quickly to find out what happened next.
I loved the writing style, the character portrayals, and the flow of the plot. It was a feel-good romance set against a well drawn historical backdrop and a classic story. I can recommend it to those who enjoy sweet historical romances, age of sail romances, and Austenesque stories.
Fair Stands the Wind begins where Jane Austen's original Pride and Prejudice does when Charles Bingley lets the Netherfield Estate and he and his party comes into contact with the Bennet family. But, there are differences right in the beginning. First, Mr. Bennet's health is precarious so his family are more clear-eyed and sober about their own future. Jane Bennet has to think with her head as well as her heart and the rest are resigned to a sadder fate. There is then the introduction of a tall officer of the navy who has prize money, but not the master of a grand estate.
Not long after, she goes from prickly to curious about Captain Darcy, Elizabeth meets his skittish step-mother and half sister who are now in his care. Seeing him look after his relations with tenderness and care right about the time her father's smug and insufferable cousin Collins arrives makes her able to welcome a marriage of convenience. Elizabeth faces life with fortitude and somewhere along the way finds she is able to dream of her own happiness too.
Fair Stands the Wind was a tender, slow-burn love story at its heart. They barely know each other when they agree on a marriage. There is respect and even some esteem, but it is their letters that start them on the road to something more. I was well pleased to see the letters as I do love a correspondence romance. The story included some memorable and recognizable P&P scenes and most of the characters from the original appear in some form or another. However, I found the story was all it's own and I enjoyed it as such.
Elizabeth was a redoubtable young woman who had to grow up fast and shoulder responsibilities so I had no trouble seeing her running a household and protecting her new husband's sister and step-mother from the trouble that followed them. I loved seeing her make her own circle of friends and allies from Fitzwilliam's naval friends and later she impresses even more august people of his acquaintance.
But, the highlight of this story is Darcy as a naval captain. This Darcy has earned his way to position and sees privilege and respect as something also to be earned. He is intuitive about people as a good captain must be and this serves him well when it comes to spotting the treasure that is Elizabeth and treating her as such while respecting her sense and intellect.
The conflict of this story comes mostly from without, but there is an intense and emotional crisis moment that had me thoroughly engaged and reading quickly to find out what happened next.
I loved the writing style, the character portrayals, and the flow of the plot. It was a feel-good romance set against a well drawn historical backdrop and a classic story. I can recommend it to those who enjoy sweet historical romances, age of sail romances, and Austenesque stories.
February 8, 2025
I absolutely loved it!
A bit darker but not really angsty, it was more of the thrill of suspense that kept turning the pages. I loved the ambiance in this book and the deliciously emotional moments. I want more though, would love a sequel.
In this Pride and Prejudice variation, Darcy is the second son with an older brother that inherited Pemberley.
Elizabeth's situation was difficult due to Mr Bennet being severely ill.
Captain Darcy entered Meryton society as in canon but it soon deviated from the original as Darcy fetched his sister and stepmother to join the party.
It was soon clear that not all was as it should at Pemberley.
Meanwhile, Collins has come to Longbourne at the behest of an ailing mr Bennet.
Mrs Bennet made the prefered matches of her daughters known at the Netherfield ball which gave Darcy an idea for another solution to the dire straits the daughters of Longbourne was facing...
Heartily recommend this book!
A bit darker but not really angsty, it was more of the thrill of suspense that kept turning the pages. I loved the ambiance in this book and the deliciously emotional moments. I want more though, would love a sequel.
In this Pride and Prejudice variation, Darcy is the second son with an older brother that inherited Pemberley.
Elizabeth's situation was difficult due to Mr Bennet being severely ill.
Captain Darcy entered Meryton society as in canon but it soon deviated from the original as Darcy fetched his sister and stepmother to join the party.
It was soon clear that not all was as it should at Pemberley.
Meanwhile, Collins has come to Longbourne at the behest of an ailing mr Bennet.
Mrs Bennet made the prefered matches of her daughters known at the Netherfield ball which gave Darcy an idea for another solution to the dire straits the daughters of Longbourne was facing...
Heartily recommend this book!
May 25, 2018
What If Mr. Darcy Was Captain Darcy?
Rating: 4.5 out of 5 stars
TYPE OF AUSTENESQUE NOVEL: Pride and Prejudice Variation, Novella
TIME FRAME: Begins with the Meryton Assembly
SYNOPSIS: In this Pride and Prejudice variation two very significant aspects of Jane Austen’s beloved story are altered. Mr. Darcy is a second son who, after years of bravery and duty, has advanced to the status of Captain in the Royal Navy. Not close with his older brother, Captain Darcy has not returned to Pemberley in years and instead visits his friend Charles Bingley while he recovers from a recent malady. In addition, Mr. Bennet who contracted pneumonia, is not in the best of health and sadly, his family does not expect him to live for many more months. This changes things for Elizabeth and Jane. Their dreams of marrying for love are relinquished as they adopt more practical aspirations and focus on ways to ensure their family’s future security. Although it is in almost every way unpalatable, Elizabeth feels her only option may be to marry her father’s heir, Mr. Collins…but what if there was another way?
WHAT I LOVED:
- Captain Darcy: Starting off with the most obvious! I loved the uniqueness of seeing Mr. Darcy in a profession. As expected, he is everything that is honorable, dutiful, and admirable, and I found his disciplined, forthright manner and admitted discomfort conversing with women endearing! His selfless care for others yet surprise when others show care and concern for him made my heart melt. <3
- Friendship: While Elizabeth does question some aspects of Captain Darcy’s behavior and manner, their relationship is not fraught with the usual pride, prejudice, and infamous first impression. Instead it blossoms into a friendship as Captain Darcy seeks Elizabeth’s help with his sister, Georgiana. After that first initial request, Darcy and Elizabeth start to grow close as they are both facing serious predicaments in their lives – Elizabeth with her father’s failing health, and Darcy with what to do for his sister and stepmother. To see these two interact in a mutually beneficial and amiable relationship is a rather dynamic change, but one I enjoyed thoroughly.
- A Heroine of Strength and Fortitude: In this tale, not only does Elizabeth acts in a manner to save and protect her family, which already earns her our admiration and respect, but she goes to great lengths to protect and ensure the safety of those under her custody. I loved seeing Lizzy’s fearlessness – how she stands up to those who threaten her and cleverly devises schemes that thwart their objectives. It is all the more equally admirable because she is thrust into a situation that she wasn’t quite prepared for, yet handles it competently and gracefully.
- Correspondence: I love to see letters exchanged! In this story we see quite a few and I love how the author conveyed the importance of these letters to those that serve their country away from home – even when all they do is communicate the mundane affairs of home life. It was lovely to see some feelings develop during these exchanges of letters and I adored learning that one correspondent
possesses some hidden skills as an artist.
WHAT I WASN’T TOO FOND OF:
- Left Me Wanting More: I truly loved so much of this unique story, that the only thing I would want is to add a few chapters more! This tale does move at a faster pace, which was well-suited. However, I would have liked a little more time at the resolution to digest all that took place. In addition, I did find myself wanting to hear more about Jane, Bingley, and the rest of the Bennets before the Epilogue.
CONCLUSION:
Fair Stands the Wind is a remarkably imaginative Pride and Prejudice tale that has our beloved characters traversing some treacherous seas, navigating through unchartered waters, and adjusting their sails to weather life’s unpredictable storms. I delighted in seeing a nautical-inspired Pride and Prejudice and dearly hope we will see many more novels published by Catherine Lodge in the future!
Austenesque Reviews
Rating: 4.5 out of 5 stars
TYPE OF AUSTENESQUE NOVEL: Pride and Prejudice Variation, Novella
TIME FRAME: Begins with the Meryton Assembly
SYNOPSIS: In this Pride and Prejudice variation two very significant aspects of Jane Austen’s beloved story are altered. Mr. Darcy is a second son who, after years of bravery and duty, has advanced to the status of Captain in the Royal Navy. Not close with his older brother, Captain Darcy has not returned to Pemberley in years and instead visits his friend Charles Bingley while he recovers from a recent malady. In addition, Mr. Bennet who contracted pneumonia, is not in the best of health and sadly, his family does not expect him to live for many more months. This changes things for Elizabeth and Jane. Their dreams of marrying for love are relinquished as they adopt more practical aspirations and focus on ways to ensure their family’s future security. Although it is in almost every way unpalatable, Elizabeth feels her only option may be to marry her father’s heir, Mr. Collins…but what if there was another way?
WHAT I LOVED:
- Captain Darcy: Starting off with the most obvious! I loved the uniqueness of seeing Mr. Darcy in a profession. As expected, he is everything that is honorable, dutiful, and admirable, and I found his disciplined, forthright manner and admitted discomfort conversing with women endearing! His selfless care for others yet surprise when others show care and concern for him made my heart melt. <3
- Friendship: While Elizabeth does question some aspects of Captain Darcy’s behavior and manner, their relationship is not fraught with the usual pride, prejudice, and infamous first impression. Instead it blossoms into a friendship as Captain Darcy seeks Elizabeth’s help with his sister, Georgiana. After that first initial request, Darcy and Elizabeth start to grow close as they are both facing serious predicaments in their lives – Elizabeth with her father’s failing health, and Darcy with what to do for his sister and stepmother. To see these two interact in a mutually beneficial and amiable relationship is a rather dynamic change, but one I enjoyed thoroughly.
- A Heroine of Strength and Fortitude: In this tale, not only does Elizabeth acts in a manner to save and protect her family, which already earns her our admiration and respect, but she goes to great lengths to protect and ensure the safety of those under her custody. I loved seeing Lizzy’s fearlessness – how she stands up to those who threaten her and cleverly devises schemes that thwart their objectives. It is all the more equally admirable because she is thrust into a situation that she wasn’t quite prepared for, yet handles it competently and gracefully.
- Correspondence: I love to see letters exchanged! In this story we see quite a few and I love how the author conveyed the importance of these letters to those that serve their country away from home – even when all they do is communicate the mundane affairs of home life. It was lovely to see some feelings develop during these exchanges of letters and I adored learning that one correspondent
possesses some hidden skills as an artist.
WHAT I WASN’T TOO FOND OF:
- Left Me Wanting More: I truly loved so much of this unique story, that the only thing I would want is to add a few chapters more! This tale does move at a faster pace, which was well-suited. However, I would have liked a little more time at the resolution to digest all that took place. In addition, I did find myself wanting to hear more about Jane, Bingley, and the rest of the Bennets before the Epilogue.
CONCLUSION:
Fair Stands the Wind is a remarkably imaginative Pride and Prejudice tale that has our beloved characters traversing some treacherous seas, navigating through unchartered waters, and adjusting their sails to weather life’s unpredictable storms. I delighted in seeing a nautical-inspired Pride and Prejudice and dearly hope we will see many more novels published by Catherine Lodge in the future!
Austenesque Reviews
March 24, 2021
Excellent story, well written and solid reimagining. Elizabeth is not so snarky having been burdened by responsibilities, Jane has a more pragmatic outlook on their future prospects, and this Darcy is warm if still quiet.
I wish it had been longer. I would have loved to see how the author might have fleshed the whole story out if it had been a full on epic novel. ODC deserved more courtship and a little more than half a day of marriage. Not to mention the half hearted kidnap attempt, Lady C, and almost no Col. F!
4.5* I was disappointed in the very quick ending and in some of how it came about. Needed to remind myself this was not a Darcy who's very makeup was Pemberley ingrained, but a man of the sea.
I wish it had been longer. I would have loved to see how the author might have fleshed the whole story out if it had been a full on epic novel. ODC deserved more courtship and a little more than half a day of marriage. Not to mention the half hearted kidnap attempt, Lady C, and almost no Col. F!
4.5* I was disappointed in the very quick ending and in some of how it came about. Needed to remind myself this was not a Darcy who's very makeup was Pemberley ingrained, but a man of the sea.
October 24, 2017
What a delightful new twist to Pride & Prejudice. This variation also has less pride and prejudice between our beloved characters. I would say it's more practical and pragmatic. However, Captain Darcy and Elizabeth Bennet are both dealing with difficult situations. Captain Darcy has to provide for his young sister while he is at sea and Elizabeth has a desperately ill father and Mr. Collins looming over her. What would you do?
Having Darcy as a second son and a Captain in the Royal Navy, did change the dynamics of the story. I really enjoyed the development of his and Elizabeth's relationship through their letters. Elizabeth is charged with protecting his sister, Georgiana and she does it brilliantly. As usual, Lady Catherine must have her share in the conversation. She and Mr. Collins descend on Elizabeth and are properly routed by her.
This is a not a long story and the angst level minimal or dealt with quickly. I did enjoy it, but once the tension started mounting near the end, I felt here it was resolved too quickly...there should have been more. I was happy with the epilogue but again, I wanted more.
The cover art (back and front) on the paperback deserve kudos as well...gorgeous!
Having Darcy as a second son and a Captain in the Royal Navy, did change the dynamics of the story. I really enjoyed the development of his and Elizabeth's relationship through their letters. Elizabeth is charged with protecting his sister, Georgiana and she does it brilliantly. As usual, Lady Catherine must have her share in the conversation. She and Mr. Collins descend on Elizabeth and are properly routed by her.
This is a not a long story and the angst level minimal or dealt with quickly. I did enjoy it, but once the tension started mounting near the end, I felt here it was resolved too quickly...there should have been more. I was happy with the epilogue but again, I wanted more.
The cover art (back and front) on the paperback deserve kudos as well...gorgeous!
January 14, 2021
In the navy
This is a new author to me. Hope to hear more from her. Great read, a real page turner. The characters aren’t as close to the original P&P as in lots of other variations but pretty close considering all the changes to canon.
Darcy is a second son who goes into the navy. His brother is a Wickham type character and Wickham has the Krypton living. Yikes!
Mr. Bennet is pretty ill. Georgiana and Mrs. Darcy are in danger from George, the first son and George the Wickham.
Darcy needs a wife that his mom and sister can stay with in safety and Lizzy needs a husband because her father may die.
A pretty good story ensues.
I recommend this book.
This is a new author to me. Hope to hear more from her. Great read, a real page turner. The characters aren’t as close to the original P&P as in lots of other variations but pretty close considering all the changes to canon.
Darcy is a second son who goes into the navy. His brother is a Wickham type character and Wickham has the Krypton living. Yikes!
Mr. Bennet is pretty ill. Georgiana and Mrs. Darcy are in danger from George, the first son and George the Wickham.
Darcy needs a wife that his mom and sister can stay with in safety and Lizzy needs a husband because her father may die.
A pretty good story ensues.
I recommend this book.
December 23, 2020
“A sailor chooses the wind that takes the ship from a safe port. Ah, yes, but once you’re aboard, as you have seen, winds have a mind of their own. Be careful, Charlotte, careful of the wind you choose.” –Avi, The True Confessions of Charlotte Doyle
Rating: clean until the last chapter: one scene took the reader into the bedroom. It was suggestive and mildly descriptive but the camera pulled back: 17-chapters + an epilogue: angst level: medium.
This was a different Pride and Prejudice and a very different Fitzwilliam Darcy. Parts of it reminded me of Anne Elliot and her Captain Wentworth [‘Persuasion’]. In this variation or reimagining, Pemberley was not a warm and loving place. The Elder Darcy was a cold hard man. Fitzwilliam, a second son, was sent to the Navy at an early age [nine-years-old]. While he was at sea, Lady Anne died, his father remarried, and Darcy now had a sister, Georgiana. After the death of their father, the eldest son became master, although, he could care less about the running of the estate.
Captain Darcy, recovering from an injury sustained during a sea battle, returned to Pemberley and discovered his sister Georgiana and her mother in deplorable conditions. His desolate brother had turned Pemberley into his very own pleasure palace… my words… while the SBRB Wickham [who had been given the living… those poor parishioners] was sniffing around his younger sister. She still had a substantial dowry but it was diminished somewhat.
Darcy quickly gathered them up and arrived on the doorsteps of Netherfield with them in tow. Caroline was not best pleased. The Darcy ladies had arrived shabbily dressed and not what Caroline or the ton would consider haute couture for ladies of their station. Darcy asked Elizabeth if she would help in getting a new wardrobe for his sister. He figured since she had younger sisters, she would best know what young ladies needed in that area. He didn’t think he could trust Caroline.
The writing mainly focused on Elizabeth and Darcy as they grew to know each other. Then, like concentric circles around them, we branched out to secondary and tertiary characters. Many events we simply heard about when our characters received letters or an express detailing a crisis or Navy orders. In some situations, I would have liked a bit more information. Although there was an epilogue, I still have questions like… what the heck happened to you-know-who? Maybe we were left to wonder the same as our characters. Life sort of happened around them and we just heard about it with them.
“History and man […] made each other.” –Mokokoma Mokhonoana
Note to those who love the P&P Darcy. This was not him. If you study nature vs nurture… this Darcy grew up with a boatload of men as his example. His speech was laced with nautical terms and was a bit rough at times. Thankfully, he had served under a good captain that insisted his young men learn their letters and conduct themselves properly. Again, this was a nod to ‘Persuasion’ as Captain Wentworth oversaw Dick Musgrove writing letters to his family. I had to laugh. So, our Darcy was now a hardened sea Captain himself and could command a boatload of men that looked up to him as their leader. He was still a powerful presence but he was a cross between Wentworth [Ciarán Hinds or Rupert Penry-Jones] and Colin Firth.
Darcy had been waiting for his orders from the Admiralty. It was a mission that he knew was going to be dangerous and would possibly not succeed. After he left, Elizabeth and her guards were also fighting dangerous waters back home.
What I liked: Loved the cover and the supporting cast of characters from Darcy’s ship. Those crew members were a hoot and they actually made the story enjoyable.
What I didn’t like: I didn’t mind that our author departed from our canon story-line although some will not like what happened to our characters. The writing felt disjointed at times due to jumping from one thing to another without telling us how they got there. Also, there was a lot that happened off the page and we learned about it along with the characters.
“Air, I should explain, becomes wind when it is agitated.” –Lucretius, On the Nature of Things
10-30-20 I received a copy from Meryton Press with no expectations of a review. I volunteered to review this book and the views and opinions expressed are my own. I highly recommend this different take on our Pride and Prejudice couple.
Rating: clean until the last chapter: one scene took the reader into the bedroom. It was suggestive and mildly descriptive but the camera pulled back: 17-chapters + an epilogue: angst level: medium.
This was a different Pride and Prejudice and a very different Fitzwilliam Darcy. Parts of it reminded me of Anne Elliot and her Captain Wentworth [‘Persuasion’]. In this variation or reimagining, Pemberley was not a warm and loving place. The Elder Darcy was a cold hard man. Fitzwilliam, a second son, was sent to the Navy at an early age [nine-years-old]. While he was at sea, Lady Anne died, his father remarried, and Darcy now had a sister, Georgiana. After the death of their father, the eldest son became master, although, he could care less about the running of the estate.
Captain Darcy, recovering from an injury sustained during a sea battle, returned to Pemberley and discovered his sister Georgiana and her mother in deplorable conditions. His desolate brother had turned Pemberley into his very own pleasure palace… my words… while the SBRB Wickham [who had been given the living… those poor parishioners] was sniffing around his younger sister. She still had a substantial dowry but it was diminished somewhat.
Darcy quickly gathered them up and arrived on the doorsteps of Netherfield with them in tow. Caroline was not best pleased. The Darcy ladies had arrived shabbily dressed and not what Caroline or the ton would consider haute couture for ladies of their station. Darcy asked Elizabeth if she would help in getting a new wardrobe for his sister. He figured since she had younger sisters, she would best know what young ladies needed in that area. He didn’t think he could trust Caroline.
The writing mainly focused on Elizabeth and Darcy as they grew to know each other. Then, like concentric circles around them, we branched out to secondary and tertiary characters. Many events we simply heard about when our characters received letters or an express detailing a crisis or Navy orders. In some situations, I would have liked a bit more information. Although there was an epilogue, I still have questions like… what the heck happened to you-know-who? Maybe we were left to wonder the same as our characters. Life sort of happened around them and we just heard about it with them.
“History and man […] made each other.” –Mokokoma Mokhonoana
Note to those who love the P&P Darcy. This was not him. If you study nature vs nurture… this Darcy grew up with a boatload of men as his example. His speech was laced with nautical terms and was a bit rough at times. Thankfully, he had served under a good captain that insisted his young men learn their letters and conduct themselves properly. Again, this was a nod to ‘Persuasion’ as Captain Wentworth oversaw Dick Musgrove writing letters to his family. I had to laugh. So, our Darcy was now a hardened sea Captain himself and could command a boatload of men that looked up to him as their leader. He was still a powerful presence but he was a cross between Wentworth [Ciarán Hinds or Rupert Penry-Jones] and Colin Firth.
Darcy had been waiting for his orders from the Admiralty. It was a mission that he knew was going to be dangerous and would possibly not succeed. After he left, Elizabeth and her guards were also fighting dangerous waters back home.
What I liked: Loved the cover and the supporting cast of characters from Darcy’s ship. Those crew members were a hoot and they actually made the story enjoyable.
What I didn’t like: I didn’t mind that our author departed from our canon story-line although some will not like what happened to our characters. The writing felt disjointed at times due to jumping from one thing to another without telling us how they got there. Also, there was a lot that happened off the page and we learned about it along with the characters.
“Air, I should explain, becomes wind when it is agitated.” –Lucretius, On the Nature of Things
10-30-20 I received a copy from Meryton Press with no expectations of a review. I volunteered to review this book and the views and opinions expressed are my own. I highly recommend this different take on our Pride and Prejudice couple.
May 12, 2022
It was different seeing Darcy as a second son but he was better for it. He still stayed true to his deeper character though. I enjoyed it I read it all the way through.
January 8, 2021
I Needed this to be Longer
Reviewed in Canada on May 20, 2019
A wonderful short story. I wish it had been a bit longer to see a life at Pemberley, but well done. Really enjoyed it. Some questions left unanswered for me (Wickham, although I often complain about too much of him).
The second read was just as good!
Reviewed in Canada on May 20, 2019
A wonderful short story. I wish it had been a bit longer to see a life at Pemberley, but well done. Really enjoyed it. Some questions left unanswered for me (Wickham, although I often complain about too much of him).
The second read was just as good!
December 30, 2017
This is a JAFF classic, and for good reason. It's beautifully written, with subtleties in characters' words and movements that invite you to read between the lines for what's really going on in their heads and hearts. Because of circumstances, Elizabeth and Darcy aren't quite as proud or as prejudiced as they are in canon, but these are not big shifts -- you can see how and why their respective situations would have altered them from canon (Mr Bennet's illness has made E more patient and empathetic, though she still has her judgy moments; Darcy as a second son being sent to sea as a child has made him less arrogant and somewhat more at ease in social situations), so they still feel true to Austen's characters. Captain Darcy is swoony, and Elizabeth is as forthright and brave as ever. This is a gorgeous story, and I'm so glad it's finally in print!
April 7, 2022
Superb. Love the characters. The plot is a little low angst, but it's excellent and well worth the read.
March 12, 2021
Dear Reader,
This was a wonderful story that I really enjoyed.
Based on the premise of Darcy being a second son and naval captain,we see a much humbler man who appreciates how inherently strong and impressive Lizzy can be.
Faced with the imminent demise of her beloved father,and the equally frightening prospect of a betrothal to Mr C. Lizzy accepts the hand of Darcy and overnight becomes mistress of a very different household.
Strong,admirable and buoyed by a supportive circle of friends,we witness Darcy and Elizabeth surmount challenges and weave a distinctly new path for themselves. Highly recommended.
This was a wonderful story that I really enjoyed.
Based on the premise of Darcy being a second son and naval captain,we see a much humbler man who appreciates how inherently strong and impressive Lizzy can be.
Faced with the imminent demise of her beloved father,and the equally frightening prospect of a betrothal to Mr C. Lizzy accepts the hand of Darcy and overnight becomes mistress of a very different household.
Strong,admirable and buoyed by a supportive circle of friends,we witness Darcy and Elizabeth surmount challenges and weave a distinctly new path for themselves. Highly recommended.
October 3, 2017
What a delightful book
This seemingly improbable plot twist is just wonderful! I enjoyed it very much and will doubtless read it again. That's very high praise as I seldom am that taken with any book. Look forward to more from this author.
This seemingly improbable plot twist is just wonderful! I enjoyed it very much and will doubtless read it again. That's very high praise as I seldom am that taken with any book. Look forward to more from this author.
January 23, 2022
This one is so original I fell in love with it. Sure I will reread in the future.
March 15, 2023
Solid
This novel was solid - well paced and easy to read (not awkward). Ending was fine. Epilogue was a little too precious.
This novel was solid - well paced and easy to read (not awkward). Ending was fine. Epilogue was a little too precious.
February 5, 2025
4.5*
A very well written and thought out story. There is real depth in the characters with a very recognisable Darcy in a very different situation. The Bennets were far more true to Austen than is often the case in a variation and this always pleases me immensely.
At the beginning it felt a little as though the author was in too much of a rush to get to the meat of the plot but this was not a significant issue and I heartily recommend this book.
A very well written and thought out story. There is real depth in the characters with a very recognisable Darcy in a very different situation. The Bennets were far more true to Austen than is often the case in a variation and this always pleases me immensely.
At the beginning it felt a little as though the author was in too much of a rush to get to the meat of the plot but this was not a significant issue and I heartily recommend this book.
September 18, 2017
Classic JAFF. I will read it again ... and again.
I've read this story before and I will read it again ... and again. Our beloved characters, personas intact, transported into a totally original, intriguing altered scenario. Fitzwilliam Darcy - Sea Captain: Oh swoon right there. A wonderful afternoon of romance.
I've read this story before and I will read it again ... and again. Our beloved characters, personas intact, transported into a totally original, intriguing altered scenario. Fitzwilliam Darcy - Sea Captain: Oh swoon right there. A wonderful afternoon of romance.
September 19, 2017
Wonderful new adaptation
This is an entirely different variation of Pride and Prejudice. In this version Fitzwilliam Darcy is the second son and had been sent to sea at a very young age. Lizzy is dealing with her father's illness and probably having to marry Mr. Collins. The relationship between Captain Darcy and Lizzy begins very pragmatically, but grows from there through a series of letters. I did not want to put this book down, and when I finished it I was left with a warm glow. This book is not to be missed.
This is an entirely different variation of Pride and Prejudice. In this version Fitzwilliam Darcy is the second son and had been sent to sea at a very young age. Lizzy is dealing with her father's illness and probably having to marry Mr. Collins. The relationship between Captain Darcy and Lizzy begins very pragmatically, but grows from there through a series of letters. I did not want to put this book down, and when I finished it I was left with a warm glow. This book is not to be missed.
June 30, 2022
This "variation" of Pride and Prejudice where Darcy is the second son and a captain in the navy was a fun read. Lizzie had spunk and Darcy was kind almost immediately. It was a much shorter story as the rest of the Bennet family were only side characters with different storylines, but that left more focus on Lizzie. It was a great start to Jane Austen July 2022 (even when completely in June!).
September 6, 2017
So I went into this story very apprehensive as I had never read this author before and didn't know what her writing style was like. This story didn't really seem to have a lot of conflicts which to me made it a long read even though the story is quite short. Anything that happened seemed to be fixed very quickly and made the story very fast paced. Also at one point, Lizzy bowed to Caroline. Um... she should have curtsied not bowed. This book is worth a read but I'm not sure if I'll re-read it.
October 17, 2017
Wonderful!!
I enjoyed this story so so much! It was such a wonderful, heartfelt story. I love Darcy as a second son, and seeing what that does to his personality! Mrs Reynolds said he was such a sweet boy, and without the pressures of society life and early responsibilities as Master, his goodness is less concealed and his sweetness more easily accessed. He is so good to Lizzy! He is rarely present in the flesh in the story, mostly through letters, as he is a Naval Captain, but presence is constant nonetheless. Beautiful and interesting read!
I enjoyed this story so so much! It was such a wonderful, heartfelt story. I love Darcy as a second son, and seeing what that does to his personality! Mrs Reynolds said he was such a sweet boy, and without the pressures of society life and early responsibilities as Master, his goodness is less concealed and his sweetness more easily accessed. He is so good to Lizzy! He is rarely present in the flesh in the story, mostly through letters, as he is a Naval Captain, but presence is constant nonetheless. Beautiful and interesting read!
November 12, 2017
Mr. Darcy in Uniform? Yes, Please
It was a different tale with a different but intriguing Darcy. Not many details regarding the new characters (I.e., Mrs. Darcy), but an overall good story.
It was a different tale with a different but intriguing Darcy. Not many details regarding the new characters (I.e., Mrs. Darcy), but an overall good story.
February 5, 2023
Almost nothing of cannon, but still beautiful & entertaining all the same!
October 16, 2017
4.5 stars... almost 5 stars! This book pulled me in right from the start. It's a far cry from canon but a great storyline. It just seemed a tad too rushed especially the ending. A great read!
February 17, 2021
Captain Darcy
Captain Darcy was sent to sea at age nine comes to Meryton as a grown man to be with friends and continue his recovery from an injury during a battle. He is the mysterious, handsome, and tall man who is not often in company that intrigues Elizabeth Bennet. Fates collide as Captain Darcy takes his younger sister and her much too young mother from Pemberley to save them from their older and morally bankrupt brother. He finds himself in need of a wife as he is going out to sea again. Elizabeth is being forced to marry Mr. Collins as her father is gravely ill. Captain Darcy proposes to Elizabeth giving her a home and a sister to care for while he takes Mr. Bennet abroad to help him recover from his illness.
Along the way the couple learn about each through letter writing while the war with France continues.
It’s is told through Elizabeth’s point of view and we get to see how she manages her responsibilities and grow to love her husband and his family. There are challenges as it would not be a very interesting book otherwise. I have to say I loved Darcy as a second son and a Captain even if he is not prominent in the story.
Captain Darcy was sent to sea at age nine comes to Meryton as a grown man to be with friends and continue his recovery from an injury during a battle. He is the mysterious, handsome, and tall man who is not often in company that intrigues Elizabeth Bennet. Fates collide as Captain Darcy takes his younger sister and her much too young mother from Pemberley to save them from their older and morally bankrupt brother. He finds himself in need of a wife as he is going out to sea again. Elizabeth is being forced to marry Mr. Collins as her father is gravely ill. Captain Darcy proposes to Elizabeth giving her a home and a sister to care for while he takes Mr. Bennet abroad to help him recover from his illness.
Along the way the couple learn about each through letter writing while the war with France continues.
It’s is told through Elizabeth’s point of view and we get to see how she manages her responsibilities and grow to love her husband and his family. There are challenges as it would not be a very interesting book otherwise. I have to say I loved Darcy as a second son and a Captain even if he is not prominent in the story.
September 22, 2017
Avid Reader
This is the best book that have read in quite some time. I simply could not out of down. I actually stopped reading another book in order to read this one. I love this adventurous Darcy and intrepid Elizabeth. Elizabeth gives Lady Catherine a marvelous set down that leaves her speechless and Mr. Collins lake and shaken.
This is the best book that have read in quite some time. I simply could not out of down. I actually stopped reading another book in order to read this one. I love this adventurous Darcy and intrepid Elizabeth. Elizabeth gives Lady Catherine a marvelous set down that leaves her speechless and Mr. Collins lake and shaken.
December 17, 2022
Spoilers in review>>>>>>
Well written and edited just not for me.
I enjoyed this book until the the terrible ending. I can’t stand when Darcy ends up horribly scarred. It’s a no go zone for me and I had completely forgotten the horrific injuries he suffered. Never again.
Well written and edited just not for me.
I enjoyed this book until the the terrible ending. I can’t stand when Darcy ends up horribly scarred. It’s a no go zone for me and I had completely forgotten the horrific injuries he suffered. Never again.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 82 reviews