This is a very . . . cozy book. Soft. Quiet.
It’s going to be very boring for many. There are some friends and mutuals I have here who I know wouldn’t like this because I know they’d need more . . . Action. More heavy details. Conflict. And this doesn’t have any.
One thing to know from the start is that it is entirely character driven, and the “plot” really focuses on the crew, getting to know them, and seeing them build their friendship. Sometimes things happen, but not for long. This is very important for people to know beforehand, as it can either ruin the reading experience for you or make it better. While I knew this beforehand, I think the length of the novel started getting to me, and the last 100 pages or so started to drag. This really could’ve done with less pages, as there were many moments where it felt like nothing was happening in terms of plot or characters, and many pages of text felt incredibly useless and added nothing to the story. There is no conflict, hardly ever, and sometimes we would go from an agonizing event back to the sweetness of the crew. Everyone, from the characters to the world, are very nice, despite their differences in personalities and cultures. Even when there’s a conflict happening around, the resolution of it happens quickly. I wasn’t always a fan of this, as I would have liked to have seen more of the progression of the story. Maybe that was the point of the author, but sadly for me it ruined parts of the reading experience, as I am generally not a fan of non-linear stories, and don’t like it when we don’t really see the timeline of events happening. I got bored, in all honesty, as these character driven books feel like they drag sometimes because they become repetitive. I also have to add, I found the relationship between Sissix and Rosemary very random and quite honestly, unnecessary. I understand what the author was trying to do, especially as we learn more about Sissix’s culture and family, but it felt so random and out of the blue. I’m really not sure if the author was really trying to portray them as a romantic pair, but there was no chemistry at all. We get the impression that they are sleeping together, and Rosemary says she does find Sissix attractive, but it just felt so…unexplored.
“We cannot blame ourselves for the wars our parents start. Sometimes the very best thing we can do is walk away.”
But besides that, the story offers a beautiful and rich world-building, amazing and detailed characters, loving and educational messages, and a nice break from the usual, heavy sci-fi readers tend to go for. This can either rip or make the story for you, but for me it worked really well simply because I am not an avid sci-fi reader. Okay, that’s a lie. I’m not a sci-fi reader at all. So to read this story in a mellow tone instead of having to highly focus on a lot of sci-fi elements was a nice thing to not worry about. Most of the time, sci-fi bores me, as the whole focus of space/atmospheres/engineering/physics and all that galore tires me out due to the heavy world building and large made up concepts. I only recently read Dark Matter, and I did enjoy it, but I did have my usual issues with it that did have to do a bit with the genre.
I found the characters to be uniquely lovely. I felt like Chambers did an amazing job of describing each one, giving them all their own voice. I appreciated how we don’t learn everything about them from the start but instead we are slowly but surely revealed more of their lives. Comparing it to real life is interesting, as it offers a world view of modern times, even. Themes like colonization, racism, xenophobia, same-sex relationships, polyamory, etc., which I have seen some describe as “social justice warrior,” but I think a lot of people tend to forget that sci-fi really builds up from that, historically. I loved the differences in the characters, finding the ideas of Chambers super interesting and unique. The concept of Earth no longer existing and people leaving and moving to another planet (immigration, refugees, foreigners, etc,.) is beautifully done. Every character has their own distinction, their own culture, their own traits, their own language.
Again, I think it really depends how one takes this book. For a sci-fi newbie like me who is very okay with reading quiet stories featuring quiet moments where people and characters don’t have conflict, it’s nice for me because it offers a very new and very different feeling from real life and just from other books. I’m not always a cynic, and having a break from torment and suffering is nice. I read to escape the real world, and sometimes that means reading quiet stories where not much of anything happens, and you know what, that works for me. But for someone who wants action, conflict, plot, arguments, and more than just meaning, this might not be for you. While this did work for me for the most part (even if it started boring me towards the end), I still enjoyed it. Character driven stories are a nice break from the heavy plot type. Consider me a fan of Becky Chambers. I will definitely be checking out the rest of the series and her other books!
“All you can do, Rosemary — all any of us can do — is work to be something positive instead. That is a choice that every sapient must make every day of their life. The universe is what we make of it. It’s up to you to decide what part you will play. And what I see in you is a woman who has a clear idea of what she wants to be.”