I have...mixed feelings. But rounding 3.5 stars up to 4 because I want to preface this with two things 1) my mood has been off and I've been struggling to read and that may have colored my experience of this book, and I kinda woke up weirdly grumpy today before even finishing this book, and 2) one aspect I personally disliked really strongly but it is a personal thing that others may disagree with my interpretation of. That's fine, you don't need to, just walk on by and ignore me. It's also why this review is so long winded.
SHORT VERSION: though this had some weaknesses and I really didn't like how this series handled the Ruminors family dynamic, but the romance storylines were good, story was overall interesting, worldbuilding was great, and the ending was essentially satisfying. I mostly recommend this series (TW for toxic/abusive/problematic parents and some subtle messaging of "but they're still family").
Full version:
So we come at last to the end. Now, I'm usually all for upping stakes and making things worse, but 5 books into making things worse, I got sort of fatigued with things getting worse. This book practically was apocalyptic in nature with the amount of destruction and I'm frankly surprised the kingdoms recover all.
There's some minor continuity issues like vanishing horses, a point where it felt like two characters were forgotten about until finally the book is like "oh, yeah, by they way, they're fine," and Siv was prepared to give a speech and was cut off so many times I'm beginning to suspect Rivet just hates writing speeches.
In the forth book and especially in this one it turned into a Chosen One story and I'm meh on that trope. Personal taste.
I felt like some developments and resolutions were so obvious it was annoying how long it took to get there, but again...my mood was off so I was kinda forcing myself to finish this before my KU expired.
I didn't like how much pressure Siv put on Dara with his blind trust, especially in the beginning. Maybe because I've been in the position where people just are like "duh you'll do the thing and be great and not fail" while I wasn't so sure and my second-hand discomfort and insecurity and overwhelm on Dara's behalf was intense.
I got a bit annoyed with Sora a couple times in this, and also figured out her eventual course/ending like 1/4 of the way through the book, so the drama after the final battle was obnoxious.
There are some plot weaknesses and I agree with other critiques of Vine fixing things all the time.
But there were good things! The romances are all great (aside from some moments of Siv being a bit unperceptive and stupid--oh, and Vine/Vex, I keep blocking that one out of my mind, it doesn't count...). There are other moments I really loved Sora. Selivia really shone in this one. Siv grew so much (I mean, I went from "IDK if Siv should be king" to "give this man his crown back already"). Dara kicked butt and overcame the temptation of power. The ending was overall satisfying (aside from my "how are they not worse off than this"--not that I wanted them to be, but it seems like the population of the world was liked, halved?) and happy. (Minor spoilers: I was gonna be salty if after 5 books of this all the MCs and their love interests didn't make it, and that didn't happen, so yay!)
The magic was pretty cool. The worldbuilding was really good (even though I tired of the in-world animals metaphors. For real. As tired as a hybernating cullmoran or something, idk, haha). There's some good moments and lines. Overall, the story itself is solid and I'd recommend it with a caveat of "you might have issues with or experience triggers in the series if you've struggled with being estranged from problematic family members." I AM interested in trying more from Rivet eventually, so there's that.
But there is one thing that really annoyed me. SPOILERS PAST THIS POINT for this series and this book and trigger warning for abuse and a rant warning:
The Ruminors. I believe I've mentioned in reviews of the previous books I didn't like how Dara was so hung up on "but they're my parents 🙁," but I chalked it up to trauma. Well, this book clarified it wasn't just Dara's aching for love but gave the message of "but they're still your family/parents so you aren't allowed to hate or dislike them, you are required to love your abusive family member because family."
Rafe and Lima were abusive to Dara specifically in the second book (emotional and verbal, and I'd argue she experienced emotional neglect and some abuse her entire life) and Rafe tries to kill her at least 3 times. Both are horrible people in general who have committed many heinous crimes that Dara feels sick contemplating.
So why in the heck is Dara's reticence to kill Rafe not about disliking death (she doesn't like it but kills when necessary), not about the possibility of more violence resulting, and not even framed as the fear of abandonment or longing for love or such that abuse victims often feel toward their abusers? (It is in the first couple books, but by now, Dara is well aware she doesn't need or really want her parents' love or acceptance.) It's barely even framed as unhealthy, only as sadly impossible (as if it's understandable Dara wants to reconnect and such a shame her parents can't stop being evil and if they'd repented they could have all moved on as a happy family as if none of the abuse and murder and war had happened...). Dara and Rafe work together for a short while and she trusts him (bad idea), and Dara walks "next to" Lima up the Fissure when there was absolutely no reason for that, and it undermined her "I don't need Lima's approval or love" thing when Dara is walking beside her apparently by choice and later asks Siv not to have Lima executed. It isn't even just "I don't want to kill them myself," which I would understand--she balks at the notion of them dying AT ALL. At one point, Dara literally thinks "Even after everything her father had done, she still hoped to stop him without actually killing him" and entertains hopes he'll be redeemed and "atone" for what he's done. Dara remembers (I think something Rafe said, possibly right before trying to kill her the first time, or a Vertigonian saying) "You are my flesh and blood and fire." Dara is sad when Rafe finally dies for his crimes. Other characters talk a bit about how awful Rafe is to everyone else is but little is done to help Dara with her personal hurts or to break free of the idea she owes Rafe anything because he is "the man who raised her." I'll allow that at least it wasn't Dara wanting nothing to do with her parents and other people telling her "but they're still your parents" and in the end, Dara does decide her parents have no power over her, but FIVE BOOKS worth of "but they're my parents" came across to me as abuse-enabling "[abuser] is still your family" and "blood is more important" and "overlook everything when it's family." There are definitely good moments of "I don't need their validation or love to be happy or fulfilled," but to me the emphasis is off and there's still hints of codependency right up until the end. As someone who thinks family relationships are not a right and people don't need to keep positive feelings toward people who hurt them because of arbitrary DNA because people's behavior matters regardless of blood status, the handling of Dara's relationship with her abusive, murdering, manipulative, power-hungry parents just rubbed me the wrong way personally. 🤷♀️