I began reading, admiring the down to earth and personal approach. It didn’t last.
The author encourages us to trust the farmers and the regulatory system. Even though I began to read sympathetically, I still don’t trust them. I realise she has experience and education. She tells us.
She also tells us about the down home nature of family farmers, many with two or more adorable children and a grandparent who started the ranch. But then I find they farm many thousands of acres, though as she says, the average in the country is under five hundred. And they use far less fertiliser and pesticide than they used to... and they love their animals... Such a rosy picture and so many straw men addressed.
I have seen 18 month old layer hens as my daughter adopts them. Pitiful- but capable of laying eggs and enjoying life still.
I have read about people living near pig farms where the amount of excrement makes nearby people suffer from respiratory diseases and drops their house value too.
Today the news reported a fire which killed 55thousand pigs. Disease can sweep through hen barns.
I have driven on I 5 in California past the acres of penned cattle readying for slaughter.
I know of crops ploughed in or sent to landfill because of the lack of (often undocumented) workers on whom the “family farms” rely.
My husband is allergic to additives in US food, but never has to read a label in Europe where many common US additives are banned. So the FDA and EPA an USDA appeals in the book don’t reassure me. Food borne illness in the US is not just you not washing your hands in your kitchen. Chemicals are not necessarily tested, and enforcement of healthy animal checks in processing are underfunded and inadequate.
Less pesticide is used than ten years ago, but has more damaging effects on insects, bees, butterflies, fish etc.
Topsoil is being eroded, whether the farmers quoted in the book claim to love the land or not.
I could go on. This is my top of the head list of issues not addressed to my satisfaction. I don’t think our agricultural policy is sustainable. I enjoy books that tell me of attempts to do otherwise, both small scale, like the small holdings of my British childhood, and high tech, as Israel and the Netherlands seem to be trying. US Corporations aren’t it.