Rating this book fairly was a challenge for me, and I finally decided on the good old 3-star fallback simply because I didn't want to rate it overly high or overly low. This book took me forever to finish, but I can't decide whether that's attributable to a flaw in the book or whether it's just circumstantial that I'm not seeing any clients right now who seem right for this approach. The book is informative and clearly lays out a way of doing therapy with couples; unfortunately, the session scripts seemed so hokey that I couldn't see myself applying the concepts or imagine any of my clients embracing these interventions so readily and pouring forth with insight and emotion the way the ones in the book do.
A typical example (I just opened the book randomly and got this):
Therapist: So can you ask her, please, "I want you to start to get out of your tank. I want to be close."
Martin (to the therapist): Yes, I do want that. After all, then everything would be better -- and the problems with her family would be...
Therapist: Martin, can I interrupt you? Can you look at your wife and tell her that please -- that you want her to get out of her tank and let you in?
Martin (turns to his wife and looks at her): Yes, I want that -- for you to let me in, and I'm not going anywhere. I want to be beside you, not in the next yard. I want some tenderness, and I want to give it back.
Therapist: How does it feel to say that, Martin?
Martin: It feels good, like it's real, and I feel taller for saying it. (Therapist nods and smiles)
Therapist: What is it like for you to hear that, Susan?
Susan: It's a bit scary, but, well, I think I like it, and (to her partner) I really like that you wanted to say it enough to risk it; it's different. It's more like when we were first together.
As an aside, I started reading a different one of these case illustrations to my husband and he stopped me after two lines with, "Please, you're making me want to puke." But in all seriousness, I don't know whether it's just that I'm an inexperienced therapist, but I can't imagine the above dialogue taking place with any of my clients; they are SO not at that place. Maybe the book felt it would be a waste of time to include dialogue from the earlier sessions where the clients are screaming at each other and it's all the therapist can do to simply contain them, but it might have been helpful for me to see more dialogues where the session wasn't going so well, the hostility was high and the insight was low, and to see how the emotionally focused therapist deals with a couple who isn't smoothly going along with the process. I also couldn't help wondering, if they were that emotionally in-tune and insightful, why would they need me? Is it my goal to get my clients to sound like they're in some touchy-feely film like "Stepmom?" And is that at all realistic?