When I first saw the announcement from Entangled Teen about this forthcoming book from Alyxandra Harvey, I was immediately intrigued. I knew right away that I wanted to read it, so when I saw the invitations for the cover reveal and then blog tour from Chapter by Chapter I jumped at the chance to participate. I’m so glad I did, because I loved the book!
My only experience with the fairy tale of the swan sisters, at least recently, is with Feather Bound by Sarah Raughley. I really liked that book, and I was intrigued by the idea of the women who can turn into swans, but who lose their magic if their feathers are stolen. That limited experience is what led me to be so excited to read Love Me, Love Me Not, and I love how Harvey interpreted the fairy tale in this novella. The characters were all great, and she was able to give them all distinct characteristics and personalities so that I never felt, even in the relatively short space of the novella, that the secondary characters blended together or were superfluous. Each of the cousins and aunts stood on their own in my mind, and I never mixed them up. And of course I loved both Ana and Pierce, her best friend. Okay, I’ll admit it, I had a wee bit of a book crush on Pierce! He was just … adorable, and sweet, and responsible, and strong, and oh so many things that I love in a boy :) I just adored Pierce and the way he treated Ana! I also loved how strong Ana was, how she seemed to be the only sane one in her family, who knew that the continuing feud with the Renards (the foxes!) was all kinds of messed up and needed to come to an end. Ana was a great character, and totally believable in her actions and her feelings.
I will confess that I normally don’t care for novellas (or short stories), because I usually find that they are bare bones and often cold. In other words, stories that needed to be fleshed out more to work, and that should have been full novels. Fair or not, I often feel like the author got lazy or just didn’t know how to really flesh out the story in the right way, leading to a short novella that doesn’t work well. However, that is so not the case with LMLMN! It was really the perfect length for the story that Harvey wanted to tell. I think in large part this is due to the fact that Ana’s best friend, Pierce, already knew about her ability to transform. If we’d had to go through the reveal process, with Pierce just finding out about Ana and her magical family, it would have been a completely different story. I absolutely applaud Harvey’s choice to tell THIS story instead, even if it resulted in a shorter read for me! Truthfully, she was able to eliminate a lot of the angst that you usually find in contemporary YA with that one choice, and I wholly approve of that decision :)
Overall, I give this story 4 stars. I really enjoyed reading it, and although the story was full and complete and there is nothing to indicate that there would be another story with Ana and Pierce, I will readily admit I’d love to read more of them! I would be interested in knowing what’s next for them and their relationship. But then, I might just have to use my imagination to tell that part of Ana and Pierce’s story. And that’s okay!
Thanks to Entangled Teen and Ms. Harvey for allowing me to read an early copy of this great novella, and to Chapter by Chapter for having me on the blog tour!