On the bright side, these are three stories by well-established authors, so the writing is fluent and occasionally funny. I've read all the previous ducal anthologies, and they are good fun. However, the premise of this anthology is so fundamentally improbable (three dukes must pass incognito in the same small village) that each story starts with a handicap. The stories don't intertwine, so the same pattern of: disguise - love - self-justification - the big reveal - occurs three times, and really doesn't convince even the first time.
I should have remembered that the novella form does not suit Grace Burrowes' relaxed style of writing, and leisurely delineation of character. Her characters always jump into bed together earlier than with many other authors - acceptable in a long story, but off-putting in a novella. I found her story surprisingly weak - the H & h little more than puppets, with the hero in particular coming across as exceptionally spineless in his financial dealings with his family. It is also difficult for a hero to strike a heroic pose when he has accidentally been shot in the bottom - GB stacked the cards against him there. Having said that, I do like a really well-victimised heroine, and Julianna is properly ground down by the local Sir Jasper. There's a longish extract from the story GB'll contribute to another anthology with Mary Balogh, which looks very good - better than this novella, which is annoying!
The second story, by Susanna Ives, unfortunately echoes very closely the plot of Burrowes' story, with a second local Sir Jasper leering at a put-upon heroine. This is the weakest of the stories: the hero is again a man of little mental fortitude (outshone, unfortunately, by his more interesting valet) dallying with a Cinderella. Lucerne's overnight conversion from lout to sensitive tutor was meant, I think, to indicate his sterling qualities had been misjudged by all around; again, the conversion might work in a longer form, but is unbelievable in a novella. The humour is slapstick, interspersed with sentiment, so- while I enjoy Susanna Ives' other books - I did not care for this.
The final story was, to my surprise, the best of the three. It's got a simple plot - Claire is unable to say "no" to her family (in the interests of peace), and has found herself unable to say out loud that she won't marry an old man. She's persuaded to try being more assertive with the disguised third duke; the scenes where they cross swords are pleasantly and amusingly done. Thereafter, other than his disguise, there is really no conflict, and all ends happily. I've not read any of Emily Greenwood's other books, but would try one, on the basis of this story.
So, reluctantly - because I like these anthologies normally - this is one I shall definitely not go back to.