"The Trials of Phillis Wheatley, America's First Black Poet and her Encounters with the Founding Fathers" by Henry Louis Gates, JR. tells the tale of an Negro women and how she is "othered". Phillis Wheatley was a thin, female, African American slave, who was roughly in her teens, and had composed many works of literature like poems. On October 8, 1772, in Boston, Massachusetts, Ms. Wheatley’s trial had begun. The prominence of this trial was to “...verify the authorship of her poems and to answer a much larger question: was a Negro capable of producing literature?” (pg 5)Some themes within this would be "othering", equality, skepticism, and religion. Many people, especially the founding fathers who were presiding as the gatekeepers of the trial, were skeptical about her works of literature. Thomas Jefferson even said that "Religion indeed has produced a Phillis Wheatley; but it could not produce a poet." Also, he thought that she was merely aping the bible and biblical verses and rewriting them, in essence she was plagiarizing. One person who would support Wheatley's works would be Mary, and Susanna who had taught her English, Latin and the Bible. Another would be George Washington, because in his letter to her he had written “I am with great respect, your obedient humble servant.” (pg. 38) George Washington had respected her greatly enough to be her servant, and called her works genius. During the trial, “She was auditioning for the humanity of the entire African people,” (pg 27) this was what was at stake. This trial would prove whether or not black were capable of imagination and creativity, and if they were, they would not be considered as sub-humans. Wheatley was even criticized even after her death. She was criticized at Margaret Walker’s bicentennial celebration of her poems at Jackson State College, by African-American writers and scholars for “not being black enough” (pg. 81) Phillis Wheatley was also criticized by white people in the 18th century for being too white, and by black people in the 20th century for being too white. This was all probably because she was a female slave, whom many people thought wasn’t capable of this type of literary talent. Additionally, through this reading, I realized that even the founding fathers would "other" people of African descent and would think of them as inferior, and not capable of high accomplishments. In the end this trial was alright to read, I mean there wasn't anything too special. I would recommend this to avid readers of African American literature and history.