I’ll admit I was torn about whether to read this book. I found myself pretty disappointed by the first volume in this prequel trilogy, and while this and the final book are both short, I wasn’t sure whether it was worth spending my time on it. The fact that this book and book 3 are written by a different author than the first one gave me some hope, and surprisingly that hope was rewarded. This still isn’t quite as good as the main series, and I still have some quibbles, but it’s a marked improvement over the first book.
The biggest change for the better is that these stories feel like they actually matter. The first book was random events from the early days of three Travelers, and I wondered in my review why we couldn’t see something more interesting and relevant about them learning they’re travelers. Lo and behold, each story in this book has the future Traveler meet Uncle Press and learn about Halla and their destiny. This really helps me feel like these stories have an actual reason for existing and aren’t just a cash grab.
On the other hand, it’s still clear that these three stories aren’t a good jumping on point for those not already familiar with the main series. Press’s conversations with the new Travelers are generally glossed over, and there’s also no attempt to explain anything about the territories the Travelers are native to. This isn’t too much of an issue in Alder’s tale; as I noted in my review of Merchant of Death, Denduron is a pretty typical medieval world and Alder’s quest to become a knight is easy to understand for the average fantasy fan. But Aja’s story never bothers to explain what Lifelight is, and since I haven’t reread The Quillan Games yet, I had to do my best to figure out Elli’s world from the context in the story.
But if you are already familiar with Pendragon and the Territories, these stories are fun. Aja’s is a bit too much like the Spader one from the first book, as it also involves her dealing with a school rival, but it somewhat addresses my big issue with The Reality Bug. Whereas Bobby was content to play a fantasy version of his own life, here Aja is forced into a dungeon crawler video game where she has to use her brain to figure out how to escape. If The Reality Bug had shown more things like this, I might have liked it better. Though on the other hand the school rival turns out to be working for Saint Dane, a plot thread I’m almost certain will never go anywhere because he doesn’t appear in the main series.
The Elli Winter story is probably the most interesting of the three. Elli is the second oldest Traveler, as she’s a middle aged mother, and she’s just lost her husband to the cruel corporation that runs her Territory. She winds up becoming the janitor for a literally underground resistance base where the treasures of the past are protected from the megacorp. Whereas Gunny’s story felt like it didn’t really fit his character, Elli’s was interesting because she really plays into the invisibility of being seen as just the cleaning lady. And yet she has an almost supernatural ability to find the lost pieces of art that have been buried and has committed herself to memorizing the various books that are recovered. This story made me interested in getting to the Quillan Games in the main series, especially because I remember nothing about it from the first time I read the books as a kid, and I think Elli will be an interesting character to see more of.
Alder’s story wasn’t bad, but it felt a bit more generic than the other two. It’s well written and engaging, as it shows Alder going from the kid that’s made fun of at the knight academy to a real knight. But the story feels like it could be in a part of any number of other kid’s fantasy series, from Tortall to Ranger’s Apprentice. I think the whole thing suffers from the fact that Denduron, being the starting territory, is significantly less out there than the others, and Alder really doesn’t get much screen time in Merchant of Death, which leaves the author little to build from. He’s not a bad character, but there’s really nothing about him that made me want more of him.
Of course, while I enjoyed this more than the first book, I’m not sure I can really recommend it. If you like one or more of the characters in this book and want more of them, then it may be worth reading, but this definitely isn’t a good jumping on point to the series, and I don’t think it’s worth slogging through the first volume - though the short story format means there’s no reason you can’t just skip that. I will be reading the third and final Book of the Travelers in the near future, but that’s more for completeness’s sake, and I don’t know I’d miss these books if they didn’t exist.