6/10
*spoilers*
This was such a touching story, which I wasn’t expecting. I thought the book was going to be quite process-driven, just describing trades from a paperclip up, and I was also expecting it to be 100 or something trades, and all material things such as a pen for a book, a book for a printer, a printer for a camera etc. So I was surprised that it was just 15 trades and many of which were conceptual things (like an afternoon with Alice Cooper). I also expected it to be a 10+ year project. Maybe my guess is also a possibility for an experiment (and coexisting book!).
The journey Kyle went on to find each trade, the unexpected huge media attention and fame that came from it and his own personal journey which is vulnerably shared throughout the book all made for fascinating reading. It was such a simple idea, and certainly a case of ‘right place, right time’. There’s no way you could achieve this now, the internet is too much of a minefield and there are too many ‘original/novel ideas’ constantly that this would get lost in the density of what’s going on out there. I love that Kyle found a new town to live in, one that sounded Hollywood-film quintessential, it was very fitting that the town’s motto is “Where if becomes reality” and I love that they even declared a ‘One Red Paperclip Day’!
It was a feel-good story, some quotes from the book to demonstrate this sentiment:
- Stories like this are water to the soul.
- Winston Churchill once said, “The pessimist sees difficulty in every opportunity. The optimist sees the opportunity in every difficulty.” And some of us can see a house in a paperclip.
- The attitude we take in our approach to life literally defines our days. For even though we may go through seasons of difficulties, those with a positive attitude will always end up stronger and more resilient.
Kyle was our main character, I’m sorry but overall I don’t like him. He’s bright-eyed and bushy-tailed and naive (even for a 26-year-old) - “If popular music has taught me anything, it’s that there’s nothing as cool as staying up all night until the break of dawn. Nothing.”, far too happy-go-lucky for me to be on board with, in other words, he’s a total cheeseball. He seems to find some fundamental things in life unachievable and/or mind-blowing. Other characters included his family and friends, who are all good people and very supportive, also possibly a little basic and not very worldly. The media people who appeared in the story were very colourful and entertaining.
The setting was across Canada and various places in America that Kyle ventured to for his trades, these gave good contrast and diversity to the story. The infamous place of Yahk was very intriguing! I wonder how much attention was brought to it and also Kipling following the story and this book.
Themes: non-fiction (which I like), rags-to-riches, a lot of life philosophy - which is up my street but definitely not in the way that Kyle portrays it, to the extent of his basic knowledge and understanding of the world. His sentiments were on point but things I very much already know. There was a theme of coming of age for Kyle, he started out as a pretty undesirable, low-achieving person, by the end he seemed to have really grown into himself and have significant self-pride and motivation. He went from a self-proclaimed bum (“maybe a little bit, uh, non-committal. Why put total commitment into something that isn’t meant to be, right?”) to achieving all the above.
The writing style was abominable, this definitely knocked off a good number of points from the overall score of the book. He just couldn’t write for shit, and so much of it was very eye-rolling, some quotes to exemplify his terrible writing:
- I made a confident face, and looked even further into the distance, as though it would help.
- Not just glad, super glad.
- Yep, another inane line for you to overthink about. But think about it for a second. It’s true.
- CNN pretty much has the best cameras around, so you know they pretty much broadcast the best news.
- But it was much more fun to stay awake and talk about stuff. That’s the thing about stuff, it’s just so much better than sleep.
- It was the perfect situation for a high five. But I was too excited about chicken burgers for any of that nonsense.
I guess my dislike of Kyle as a person and his writing style are intertwined and not easy to separately criticise.
Some quotes I did enjoy from the book:
- Why complain when you can do something about it?
- We all see color differently. What may be less green to someone else might be greener to you.
- If you can imagine something, it can be real. What do you imagine? How will you make it real?
I did like his invention of the word “funtential”. I did not like his stupid horse-whinnying ringtone and all the quips he made about this.
The ending was my favourite part of the book, and so sweet, it actually brought tears to my eyes! The giant housewarming/street party was so lovely and touching - although why did he have to call it ‘the biggest housewarming party ever’. He painted a picture of a jovial time, the whole event seemed so fun and it was a great ending to this unique journey and story. I absolutely did not see it coming that he was going to propose to Dom, and it was such a sweet moment, although cringe that he used the original paper clip and bent it out of shape, some might find this super sweet, I found it super sickly. More eye-rolling.
I would definitely recommend this book to people as an inspiring story of a unique idea and an example that anything is achievable if you put your mind to it (and have some ‘right place/right time luck’). I would give a clear warning of the painful writing style, and for anyone who is even more of a book snob than me - they might not be able to see past that. For a lighthearted, feel-good read, it’s a good fit.