I feel like this book is really, really hard on mentally ill people. But then again, many of the narrating protagonists are prejudiced in some way bearing on their stories–often sanist or ableist. I think I get what Enriquez was trying to do with it all, but it was hard to read. Was that the point?
Don't get me wrong–this is really good fiction, and I recommend it. Buy consider this my content warning for sanism, ableism, ageism, and racism.
Full review:
Thank you to the author Mariana Enriquez, publishers Hogarth, and NetGalley for an advance digital copy of A SUNNY PLACE FOR SHADY PEOPLE. All views are mine.
“Yes, they know the basement was used for torture. But the place was a lot of other things, too. A summer house for those rich people, who by the way made all that cheese you ate last night, so you’ve already got Evil in you. p101
A SUNNY PLACE is my third read from Mariana Enriquez, and I just love her work. She always challenges me, both emotionally and intellectually, which is what reading is all about for me. I want to feel and think in New ways as a result of what I've read. Enriquez always delivers.
This collection felt personal to me because of the frequency with which it centered disability and mental illness. I wasn't always comfortable with her treatment of these subjects, as a reader affected by both topics. But I really felt like she was challenging me to empathize with characters and thought systems that I didn't understand. I just don't see how that's bad.
I always recommend Enriquez's work, and this collection is no different. But this collection fairly demands the right readers. I recommend this for fans of weird horror/fiction, pink horror, feminist horror, diverse horror authors, settings, and characters.
Reading Notes
Three (or more) things I loved:
1. Her handling of Gothic elements is just chef's kiss omg.
2. This is how you do a run-on! He always told me he liked Hispanic women because they seemed strong and maternal and I’d get mad, that awful gringo stereotype, and he laughed and I never again saw a laugh like that, with those beautiful teeth that the street and the madness couldn’t ruin, all the joy that lit up every one of his features and made his eyes shine, he who was always so somber and blue, except when he turned manic and life seemed beautiful to him, but that was just as heartbreaking because it was only a chemical reaction, he had no idea what he was feeling or saying. p36
Three (or less) things I didn't love:
This section isn't only for criticisms. It's merely for items that I felt something for other than "love" or some interpretation thereof.
1. I've seen this author do it before, rely on mental health stigma as a horror element. I hate it, it's bullshit. But she writes great horror otherwise. *edit I think Enriquez is not promoting the prejudices she presents in her characters and stories, but challenging them.
2. She seemed beyond saving to me: some people just let themselves go for too long, and one day they wake up crazy and monstrous. That’s how Julie was. Full-on abandonment. And we didn’t even know exactly what was wrong with her. p64 This ableism clearly originates with the narrating character, but it's a common trope and one I've seen Enriquez use before. In reality, the mysteriously ill are not beyond saving. No sick or disabled person is beyond saving, because no person is. *edit: It’s not easy to differentiate between a bad mood and returning depression. But I know: it’s a bad mood. I think of last night, when we’d f*cked and gone to sleep with the window open, waiting for the black storm over the mountains, and yes, it’s a bad mood. p96 This is brilliant mental health rep, and it makes me think when she is ableist, even though that is often, that she means to be for a literary reasons.
3. Many of the stories here end on an extremely abstract note. It's hard to say what Enriquez is trying to say with this repeated technique.
Rating: 🧛♂️🧛♂️🧛♂️🧛♂️ /5 clever monsters
Recommend? Yes!
Finished: Aug 27 '24
Format: Digital arc, NetGalley
Read this book if you like:
👻 spooky stories
👨👩👧👦 family stories, family drama
🦾 disability and ableism
❤️🩹 pink / feminist horror
📚 diverse authors, settings, characters
A few words about the stories:
1. "My Sad Dead" - a creepy, sad ghost story about how ghosts haunt the pitiless, but never remorse: Would I have opened the door? Or would I have acted like all the others?” “Maybe you wouldn’t have opened,” he answered. “But you would have at least called the police. They didn’t even do that?” “They didn’t even do that,” I replied. p26
2. "A Sunny Place For Shady People" - A complex story about grief and the inability to let go.
3. "Face of Disgrace" - Holy crap I am never going to hear a whistle the same way again! This story is haunting.
4. "Julie" - I started to appreciate Julie’s elegance, the grace in how she rejected all her parents’ hopeless vulgarity. In how she had ruined her body until it was grotesque as demonstration of the fact that even so, it was beautiful in a place that we couldn’t reach and she could. Did I admire her? I don’t know. I envied her a little. I didn’t want her to be abandoned, but I didn’t want to be her caretaker, either. p68 Horror stories about disability are common; what isn't, are stories like this one that are built on empathy for disability.
5. "Night Birds" - On the shores of this river, all the birds that fly, drink, perch on branches, and disturb siestas with the demonic squawking of the possessed— all those birds were once women. p73 What a great concept! Turns into a story about a character with a "rotting disease," like leprosy. More ableism in this one.
6. "Metamorphosis" - A piece about identity, the body, and modern medicine from traditional and nontraditional sources.
7. "Hyena Hymns" - “He talks shit about Argentina nonstop, says stuff like ‘I would understand if my kids left,’‘They can go if they want, they have passports.’” “Eighty percent of Argentines will say the same thing, and then the minute they hear a zamba they’ll start bawling.” p I love stories that explore the meaning of "home" and the various attitudes we hold about a place we need so much.
8. "Different Colors Made of Tears" - I know I can’t say this in public and I certainly shouldn’t feel it, and I know old people have plenty of problems, solitude and meager pensions and cruel children and getting sick and losing their minds, but I just don’t like them— I don’t like old people. I don’t know what I’ll do when I’m old myself: I hope I die before I get there. It’s a strange feeling: I get the sense that they’re faking. That the aches and pains, the plodding steps, the constant chatter about illnesses and doctors, the smell of their skin, the false or decayed teeth, the same anecdotes told and retold— it’s all an act put on to irritate. p109 I thought I knew what this story was going to do with such blatant ageism on part of the narrator, but I was wrong. I'm not sure at all why it's there.
9. "A Suffering Woman" - A story about sickness, our fear of sickness, and how we are affected emotionally by others' sickness.
10. "The Refrigerator Cemetery" - This is definitely my favorite story in the collection. It's heartbreaking though, and once ago, there's a touch of illness.
11. "A Local Artist" - Some fascinating art content in this one. Enriquez is excellent with description!
12. "Black Eyes" - Just a really excellent twist on the classic vamp.