Let's see, overall enjoyable, these stories are somehow sinister and ridiculous at the same time, but uneven...
Tell-tale heart -4.5* but 5* for nostalgia & satisfaction that a guilty conscience is the downfall of even the most twisted mind, but really
The mask of the red death - 0* for me. I couldn't follow it. I think I'd have to read it in a physical book and look up some info
The black cat - 4.5*+ I don't know why this story is not more famous, I guess the tell tale heart is more appealing, but they're centered on the same theme of guilt and the past coming back to haunt you. There's the added element of schadenfreude when the killer shows off to the cops, which is his downfall.
The Raven, 3.5* but 4*+ for nostalgia, I actually preferred it when I was in high school. Probably because the teacher explains some of the symbolism and there were questions that made me think about it, but the rhythm of the poem is still moving
The cask of Amontillado 3.75*, basically the same reaction as the Raven, but with the addition of annoyance (in a good way) at Montrésor for being an unreliable narrator, what did Fortunato do? Are either of them really resting in peace at the end?
Berenice 2*, like the red death, I had a hard time following and might read it in physical form.