What do you think?
Rate this book
It Lurks in the Night
From the author of It Waits in the Forest comes Sarah Dass’s next stand-alone supernatural thriller—a lush and evocative tale of the rot that grows at the heart of even the most beautiful places. Perfect for fans of Angeline Boulley and Tiffany D. Jackson!
All Maya Woods wants is to reunite her three best friends, Pearl, Erica, and Lystra, for one last epic boat trip to the islands around their Caribbean home before they all graduate from high school. But the girls are forced to make an emergency landing on Annatto—an island avoided by locals and tourists alike because of the rumors of monsters and shadows that lurk in its depths—and their yearly tradition descends into darkness as Erica turns up dead and the girls are forced to leave her body behind.
Their tight-knit community is sent into a spiral of grief and suspicion, and Maya and her friends are at a loss to understand what happened: was it simply an accident or is there truth to the rumors about Annatto?
And while the community rejoices when Erica mysteriously returns alive and well a week later, Maya can’t seem to let go of her questions. What did they see that night? And who—or what—has Erica returned as? As old arguments and new betrayals rise to the surface, Maya and her friends can feel the shadows closing in on them. Something is lurking in the night, and they must be ready to face it.
Drawing from the darkest corners of Caribbean mythology, acclaimed author Sarah Dass delivers a supernatural thriller blends cultural nuance with monsters that go bump in the night, giving long-time Rick Riordan Presents fans the kind of story that will root into their hearts and awaken never their deepest fears.
Endorsed by Rick Riordan, author of the Disney+ hit series Percy Jackson and the Olympians.
All Maya Woods wants is to reunite her three best friends, Pearl, Erica, and Lystra, for one last epic boat trip to the islands around their Caribbean home before they all graduate from high school. But the girls are forced to make an emergency landing on Annatto—an island avoided by locals and tourists alike because of the rumors of monsters and shadows that lurk in its depths—and their yearly tradition descends into darkness as Erica turns up dead and the girls are forced to leave her body behind.
Their tight-knit community is sent into a spiral of grief and suspicion, and Maya and her friends are at a loss to understand what happened: was it simply an accident or is there truth to the rumors about Annatto?
And while the community rejoices when Erica mysteriously returns alive and well a week later, Maya can’t seem to let go of her questions. What did they see that night? And who—or what—has Erica returned as? As old arguments and new betrayals rise to the surface, Maya and her friends can feel the shadows closing in on them. Something is lurking in the night, and they must be ready to face it.
Drawing from the darkest corners of Caribbean mythology, acclaimed author Sarah Dass delivers a supernatural thriller blends cultural nuance with monsters that go bump in the night, giving long-time Rick Riordan Presents fans the kind of story that will root into their hearts and awaken never their deepest fears.
Endorsed by Rick Riordan, author of the Disney+ hit series Percy Jackson and the Olympians.
400 pages, Hardcover
First published January 27, 2026
10 people are currently reading
4413 people want to read
About the author
Sarah Dass
4 books304 followersSarah Dass was born in Trinidad but has lived in Tobago since she was two years old. A graduate of University College London, she works as an office administrator by day and writes stories about the Caribbean by night. When she’s not writing, she’s reading or taking walks with her dachshund.
Sarah’s debut novel is inspired by her childhood, spent in a seaside hotel.
Sarah’s debut novel is inspired by her childhood, spent in a seaside hotel.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 24 of 24 reviews
May 11, 2025
Both a riveting supernatural thriller and a touching exploration of friendship and family. It Lurks in the Night draws on Caribbean folklore for its sinister creature while simultaneously diving into the sort of horror that is uniquely human—and no less terrifying. I was in awe not only of the many-layered mystery but also of the deep connections between characters and discussions of how to find yourself when you’ve spent your life being defined by the lives of others. With a setting so vivid it feels real, characters who could be your best friends or worst enemies, and a monster that will keep you up at night, this book is a must-read!
April 11, 2025
IT LURKS IN THE NIGHT is a gripping story full of complicated characters with secrets as deep as the ocean itself. Between the palpable paranoia, supernatural superstition and viscerally tense friendship drama, this chilling thriller is guaranteed to pull you in and under.
Want to read
June 28, 2025pre release: can . . . can someone pls explain why the app is currently telling me this is coming out in 2079? im scared
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
I'd place this in the YA thriller category. Written by an author from Trinidad and Tobago, the book is full of Caribbean folk lore, supernatural, and terrorizing ghosts and goblins. I made the mistake of deciding I had to find out the ending at 11pm, which, you got it, made for a Pearl-like night of sleep. Read the book to figure out what Im talking about.
The primary character is Maya, and she and her three friends are about to graduate high school and go off in their separate ways to pursue their dreams. These characters are described so brilliantly that I could feel their angst. their emotions, go through some of their friendship. family, boyfriend drama as it weaved its way throughout the book either bringing them closer together or tearing them apart forever.
There were a lot of different supernatural situations introduced in the book, and the story really surrounds this. However. it took too long for this part of the story to develop. Also, other parts of the "twists" of this tale were not really even introduced even as crumbs until the very end. It would have been nice to see little trails along the way.
Overall, it is a great story of friendship. family. folklore rolled up in a thriller that has a frightening ending.
3 stars.
Thank you to NetGalley and Disney Hyperion for this ARC in exchange for an honest review.
The primary character is Maya, and she and her three friends are about to graduate high school and go off in their separate ways to pursue their dreams. These characters are described so brilliantly that I could feel their angst. their emotions, go through some of their friendship. family, boyfriend drama as it weaved its way throughout the book either bringing them closer together or tearing them apart forever.
There were a lot of different supernatural situations introduced in the book, and the story really surrounds this. However. it took too long for this part of the story to develop. Also, other parts of the "twists" of this tale were not really even introduced even as crumbs until the very end. It would have been nice to see little trails along the way.
Overall, it is a great story of friendship. family. folklore rolled up in a thriller that has a frightening ending.
3 stars.
Thank you to NetGalley and Disney Hyperion for this ARC in exchange for an honest review.
October 1, 2025
This supernatural thriller is absolutely gripping! I love the use of Caribbean folklore and culture. While there was never much mystery in this story, it did manage to include unexpected details in every corner. Maya was a fascinating character, the daughter of a politician, she so perfectly represented being on the edge of childhood and adulthood. The cast of characters was engaging and I loved the use of the scary stories as a way for us to learn more about the group and further the story.
I would say if you enjoy folk horror and female characters with lots of growth then you should definitely check this book out!
Thank you to NetGalley for the ARC.
I would say if you enjoy folk horror and female characters with lots of growth then you should definitely check this book out!
Thank you to NetGalley for the ARC.
August 12, 2025
What a rollercoaster this book was! I’d heard of Sarah Dass before, especially with the praise surrounding What It Hides in the Forest but hadn’t yet read anything by her until I was approved for It Lurks in the Night. And let me tell you, it did not disappoint.
This supernatural thriller blends the rich, eerie folklore of Trinidad and Tobago with the haunting presence of the soucouyant, a supernatural entity rooted in Caribbean myth. From the very first chapter, the atmosphere is thick with tension and mystery. The way the story and characters intertwine makes this book so engaging, each character adds their own spark to the narrative, creating a strong foundation for both the mystery and the supernatural elements.
The pacing is excellent! There’s never a dull or heavy moment. Dass’s writing is so smooth and immersive that before you realize it, you’re halfway through the book because you simply can’t put it down. The romance subplot, while a little underdeveloped at times, still adds a nice layer to the story. The main focus rightly stays on the characters’ determination to uncover what’s tormenting their lives, with the romance tying together more neatly toward the end.
I especially want to highlight Lystra and Maya’s friendship, their growth and resilience throughout the book were incredibly rewarding to read. As for the ending… let’s just say it had me rereading the last few pages multiple times like that meme cat going, “Huh?” It’s a bittersweet close that makes sense in the context of everything the characters endure, though I did feel the epilogue was a little rushed and jumped between moments too quickly.
This is a fantastic standalone for readers looking for a supernatural thriller steeped in folklore. With its spooky atmosphere, well-crafted characters, and captivating plot, It Lurks in the Night is perfect for Halloween or any time you’re in the mood for a dark, magical mystery. I highly recommend it to fans of cultural myths, eerie mysteries, and stories that balance suspense with heartfelt character moments. For me, this was a solid 5/5 stars.
This supernatural thriller blends the rich, eerie folklore of Trinidad and Tobago with the haunting presence of the soucouyant, a supernatural entity rooted in Caribbean myth. From the very first chapter, the atmosphere is thick with tension and mystery. The way the story and characters intertwine makes this book so engaging, each character adds their own spark to the narrative, creating a strong foundation for both the mystery and the supernatural elements.
The pacing is excellent! There’s never a dull or heavy moment. Dass’s writing is so smooth and immersive that before you realize it, you’re halfway through the book because you simply can’t put it down. The romance subplot, while a little underdeveloped at times, still adds a nice layer to the story. The main focus rightly stays on the characters’ determination to uncover what’s tormenting their lives, with the romance tying together more neatly toward the end.
I especially want to highlight Lystra and Maya’s friendship, their growth and resilience throughout the book were incredibly rewarding to read. As for the ending… let’s just say it had me rereading the last few pages multiple times like that meme cat going, “Huh?” It’s a bittersweet close that makes sense in the context of everything the characters endure, though I did feel the epilogue was a little rushed and jumped between moments too quickly.
This is a fantastic standalone for readers looking for a supernatural thriller steeped in folklore. With its spooky atmosphere, well-crafted characters, and captivating plot, It Lurks in the Night is perfect for Halloween or any time you’re in the mood for a dark, magical mystery. I highly recommend it to fans of cultural myths, eerie mysteries, and stories that balance suspense with heartfelt character moments. For me, this was a solid 5/5 stars.
Read
August 7, 2025This was absolutely impeccably written. The lore was incredible, and I was split down the middle with the focus on people pleasing, on fighting so desperately to keep things happy. Everything about it was fantastic.
October 14, 2025
Initial Thoughts:
With this being a Rick Riordan–endorsed novel, I was waiting for the mythology to leap from the page — and oh boy, did I wait. Sarah Dass took her time telling this story, as the plot dragged on meaninglessly for about 90% of the book. The fact that the synopsis spoiled an event that didn’t occur until over a hundred pages in shows just how slowly Dass was moving. Once things finally picked up, though, the story became engaging and exciting. I enjoyed the twists Dass threw Maya’s way and how her childhood friendships truly exploded off the page. Still, there were too many conversations that led nowhere and side quests that added nothing. A hundred pages shorter and with a faster pace, this could have been mesmerizing. Instead, I often found myself checking how many minutes were left in the chapter and rolling my eyes, debating whether to finish it before bed or save it for morning.
Plot and Writing:
Yes, Dass tends to write in circles before finally reaching the point we care about — but at least the writing itself is strong. She brings this Caribbean paradise vividly to life through descriptions of local culture, customs, the radiant ocean and islands, and the mythological powers at play. I truly felt like I was among the girls as they sailed into the Caribbean sun, and I shared their fear when they became stranded on the haunted island. Dass captures the shifting dynamics of female friendship beautifully, showing how these girls grow from teenagers into young women on the brink of change.
Maya’s desperation to keep her friend group — Lystra, Pearl, and Erica — together despite their diverging futures drives much of the story. Their final summer boat trip, meant to secure their bond, instead ends in disaster. I think that’s why Dass spent so much time on the pre-monster portion: to firmly establish these characters before Maya’s monster hunt begins. It also explains why she tried to keep the creature’s identity a mystery — though it was painfully obvious from the start. I grew frustrated watching Maya “guess” for pages on end when the truth was clear. And even after she figures it out, Dass drags out the resolution too long, though I’ll admit the ending was both fantastic and heart-wrenching.
Characters:
Honestly, I wish Maya hadn’t been the sole POV. Yes, she’s great — the glue holding the friendship together, willing to bend and break to keep the girls united. She’s strong and quietly confident, but I would have given anything to be in Pearl’s head during some of these moments, especially as she began to pull away. While this novel claims to center on all four girls, it really becomes a story of Maya and Lystra, as Erica and Pearl fade into the background after the accident. That’s disappointing because all of these girls, especially Pearl, had compelling backstories that Dass barely explored in favor of focusing on Maya (and secondarily, Lystra).
I loved Maya’s personal story — the way Dass connected it to her father and missing sister, and how she tied up those loose ends — but I wanted more interactions between Maya and Pearl, or Maya and Erica. Their relationships could have deepened the plot and moved it forward faster. Sure, they had moments together on the boat before the accident, but I wish those connections had been more evenly spread out across the story.
Conclusion:
The plot is fantastic, the characters are realistic with dynamic relationships, and the mythological creature is dark, eerie, and something Rick Riordan himself might shy away from. But Dass chose to write a journey rather than a thrill ride, and that choice buried a potentially brilliant story beneath pages of aimless conversations and unnecessary detours that ultimately dulled its impact.
With this being a Rick Riordan–endorsed novel, I was waiting for the mythology to leap from the page — and oh boy, did I wait. Sarah Dass took her time telling this story, as the plot dragged on meaninglessly for about 90% of the book. The fact that the synopsis spoiled an event that didn’t occur until over a hundred pages in shows just how slowly Dass was moving. Once things finally picked up, though, the story became engaging and exciting. I enjoyed the twists Dass threw Maya’s way and how her childhood friendships truly exploded off the page. Still, there were too many conversations that led nowhere and side quests that added nothing. A hundred pages shorter and with a faster pace, this could have been mesmerizing. Instead, I often found myself checking how many minutes were left in the chapter and rolling my eyes, debating whether to finish it before bed or save it for morning.
Plot and Writing:
Yes, Dass tends to write in circles before finally reaching the point we care about — but at least the writing itself is strong. She brings this Caribbean paradise vividly to life through descriptions of local culture, customs, the radiant ocean and islands, and the mythological powers at play. I truly felt like I was among the girls as they sailed into the Caribbean sun, and I shared their fear when they became stranded on the haunted island. Dass captures the shifting dynamics of female friendship beautifully, showing how these girls grow from teenagers into young women on the brink of change.
Maya’s desperation to keep her friend group — Lystra, Pearl, and Erica — together despite their diverging futures drives much of the story. Their final summer boat trip, meant to secure their bond, instead ends in disaster. I think that’s why Dass spent so much time on the pre-monster portion: to firmly establish these characters before Maya’s monster hunt begins. It also explains why she tried to keep the creature’s identity a mystery — though it was painfully obvious from the start. I grew frustrated watching Maya “guess” for pages on end when the truth was clear. And even after she figures it out, Dass drags out the resolution too long, though I’ll admit the ending was both fantastic and heart-wrenching.
Characters:
Honestly, I wish Maya hadn’t been the sole POV. Yes, she’s great — the glue holding the friendship together, willing to bend and break to keep the girls united. She’s strong and quietly confident, but I would have given anything to be in Pearl’s head during some of these moments, especially as she began to pull away. While this novel claims to center on all four girls, it really becomes a story of Maya and Lystra, as Erica and Pearl fade into the background after the accident. That’s disappointing because all of these girls, especially Pearl, had compelling backstories that Dass barely explored in favor of focusing on Maya (and secondarily, Lystra).
I loved Maya’s personal story — the way Dass connected it to her father and missing sister, and how she tied up those loose ends — but I wanted more interactions between Maya and Pearl, or Maya and Erica. Their relationships could have deepened the plot and moved it forward faster. Sure, they had moments together on the boat before the accident, but I wish those connections had been more evenly spread out across the story.
Conclusion:
The plot is fantastic, the characters are realistic with dynamic relationships, and the mythological creature is dark, eerie, and something Rick Riordan himself might shy away from. But Dass chose to write a journey rather than a thrill ride, and that choice buried a potentially brilliant story beneath pages of aimless conversations and unnecessary detours that ultimately dulled its impact.
September 16, 2025
Thank you NetGalley and Disney Hyperion for the ARC in exchange for an honest review!
Sarah Dass’s “It Lurks in the Night” is a supernatural YA thriller that combines eerie Caribbean folklore with the all-too-human horrors of fractured friendships, family secrets, and political corruption.
At the heart of the story is Maya, who’s struggling to keep her friend group together even as old resentments, betrayals, and melodrama threaten to tear them apart. When tragedy strikes and their friend Erica dies only to return not quite herself the story shifts into a dark mystery steeped in the folklore of Trinidad and Tobago, most notably the terrifying soucouyant. As Maya digs deeper, she uncovers chilling connections between the island’s history of missing people, a powerful political family, and her own sister’s disappearance.
The first part of the novel takes its time, focusing heavily on the dynamics of Maya and her three friends. The drama and toxicity in their group can feel melodramatic at times, but it sets the stage for the unraveling secrets that follow, and the behavior is realistic for teenagers, especially involving romance and the pressure of college and growing up. Once the supernatural mystery takes center stage, the pacing sharpens and the tension never lets up. From corrupt government cover-ups to vengeful folklore creatures, Dass layers supernatural chills with grounded, real-world horror.
One of the book’s greatest strengths is how vividly it brings the setting and mythology to life. The atmosphere is thick with dread, the folklore both fascinating and terrifying. While I did wish for more detail on the myths themselves, the folklore enriches the story and sets it apart from typical YA thrillers, especially when the folklore is tied in to corrupt politicians.
The character work is equally compelling. Maya grows from someone who constantly runs from conflict into a young woman ready to face the truth and fight for herself. Her friendship with Lystra is especially rewarding, showing resilience and growth against the chaos. There’s a hint of romance, but it never overshadows the real focus: friendship, courage, and survival.
The climax is action-packed and deeply satisfying, tying together the supernatural mystery, political intrigue, and Maya’s personal journey. The ending delivers both closure and bittersweet reflection, leaving space for you to sit with the haunting aftermath.
Though the early pacing leans heavily on friendship drama, “It Lurks in the Night” ultimately delivers a gripping, atmospheric mystery that balances supernatural horror with heartfelt character moments. With its unique Caribbean folklore, strong sense of place, and twisty layers of suspense, it’s a must-read for fans of YA thrillers who want something both spooky and meaningful.
Sarah Dass’s “It Lurks in the Night” is a supernatural YA thriller that combines eerie Caribbean folklore with the all-too-human horrors of fractured friendships, family secrets, and political corruption.
At the heart of the story is Maya, who’s struggling to keep her friend group together even as old resentments, betrayals, and melodrama threaten to tear them apart. When tragedy strikes and their friend Erica dies only to return not quite herself the story shifts into a dark mystery steeped in the folklore of Trinidad and Tobago, most notably the terrifying soucouyant. As Maya digs deeper, she uncovers chilling connections between the island’s history of missing people, a powerful political family, and her own sister’s disappearance.
The first part of the novel takes its time, focusing heavily on the dynamics of Maya and her three friends. The drama and toxicity in their group can feel melodramatic at times, but it sets the stage for the unraveling secrets that follow, and the behavior is realistic for teenagers, especially involving romance and the pressure of college and growing up. Once the supernatural mystery takes center stage, the pacing sharpens and the tension never lets up. From corrupt government cover-ups to vengeful folklore creatures, Dass layers supernatural chills with grounded, real-world horror.
One of the book’s greatest strengths is how vividly it brings the setting and mythology to life. The atmosphere is thick with dread, the folklore both fascinating and terrifying. While I did wish for more detail on the myths themselves, the folklore enriches the story and sets it apart from typical YA thrillers, especially when the folklore is tied in to corrupt politicians.
The character work is equally compelling. Maya grows from someone who constantly runs from conflict into a young woman ready to face the truth and fight for herself. Her friendship with Lystra is especially rewarding, showing resilience and growth against the chaos. There’s a hint of romance, but it never overshadows the real focus: friendship, courage, and survival.
The climax is action-packed and deeply satisfying, tying together the supernatural mystery, political intrigue, and Maya’s personal journey. The ending delivers both closure and bittersweet reflection, leaving space for you to sit with the haunting aftermath.
Though the early pacing leans heavily on friendship drama, “It Lurks in the Night” ultimately delivers a gripping, atmospheric mystery that balances supernatural horror with heartfelt character moments. With its unique Caribbean folklore, strong sense of place, and twisty layers of suspense, it’s a must-read for fans of YA thrillers who want something both spooky and meaningful.
February 9, 2026
3.75/5 stars ⭐️
the strained relationships in this story heavily contributed to the tension and suspense. like Maya, i went into this with a little naivety, believing that history, tradition, and shared memories meant people could be trusted and relationships could be mended. it sounds good, but not everything is resolved so simply.
Erica was a terrible friend. i was sick of her from the jump! during the boat trip, she just kept stacking up reasons for me to be ready for her exit. once she finally dropped dead, i did not feel bad about it AT ALL!! Maya was the glue that held everything together. you’d think that Erica would show even a shred of empathy towards her “best friend” wanting to keep the group close before graduation, especially since they’ve both experienced deep family losses. but noooooo! that heifer was committed to being selfish.
Pearl deserved so much better. my heart still aches for her. if i could have jumped into the pages to protect her, i would have! Lystra and Maya reconciling was one of my favorite moments. i genuinely don’t think they would’ve made it as far as they did without that shift. it was also relieving to see someone stick by Maya’s side during such a traumatizing experience. we already know she struggled with abandonment issues and it felt like everyone kept choosing to abandon her.
don’t even get me started on the parents and the adults in this book…a lot of the chaos and trauma that these kids endured was a direct result of their negligence. i want a round with each and every one of them in the boxing ring…
overall, this was a solid YA thriller and i’m glad i took my time with it. it’s wild to see the lengths people will go for success, status, and gratification, even if that means sacrificing the very people who love them.
the strained relationships in this story heavily contributed to the tension and suspense. like Maya, i went into this with a little naivety, believing that history, tradition, and shared memories meant people could be trusted and relationships could be mended. it sounds good, but not everything is resolved so simply.
Erica was a terrible friend. i was sick of her from the jump! during the boat trip, she just kept stacking up reasons for me to be ready for her exit. once she finally dropped dead, i did not feel bad about it AT ALL!! Maya was the glue that held everything together. you’d think that Erica would show even a shred of empathy towards her “best friend” wanting to keep the group close before graduation, especially since they’ve both experienced deep family losses. but noooooo! that heifer was committed to being selfish.
Pearl deserved so much better. my heart still aches for her. if i could have jumped into the pages to protect her, i would have! Lystra and Maya reconciling was one of my favorite moments. i genuinely don’t think they would’ve made it as far as they did without that shift. it was also relieving to see someone stick by Maya’s side during such a traumatizing experience. we already know she struggled with abandonment issues and it felt like everyone kept choosing to abandon her.
don’t even get me started on the parents and the adults in this book…a lot of the chaos and trauma that these kids endured was a direct result of their negligence. i want a round with each and every one of them in the boxing ring…
overall, this was a solid YA thriller and i’m glad i took my time with it. it’s wild to see the lengths people will go for success, status, and gratification, even if that means sacrificing the very people who love them.
December 22, 2025
⭐⭐⭐💫
IT LURKS IN THE NIGHT by Sarah Dass (Jan 27, 2026)
Thank you Netgalley and Disney Hyperion for the earc
When Maya and her friends go on their annual excursion, things aren't right. There's a rift in the friend group, and Maya hopes that she can repair it. Then Erica, one of Maya's friends, shows up d*ad (after a detour)...
IT LURKS IN THE NIGHT is a YA supernatural thriller.
This book is very mellow in the beginning. For the first 100+ pages or so, the only problem seems to be the rift in the friend group---all the drama. When that first problem arises, and the Erica d*es, everything takes a turn. As cruel as it may sound, it's for the better. Once that mark hit, and the pace quickened, it no longer felt as draining to read this (though, sadly, that feeling was not a stranger). Yes, I wanted to know why that rift had occurred, but I needed something to happen. When it did, I found the book to be much more interesting...but 400 pages is a lot. And there were times after this book piqued my interest that I found myself counting down the pages in a chapter, counting down until I was closer to the end. This is not a bad book, I just felt like it went on and on and on and on.
Once I made it to the end, and pieces fell into place, I looked back and saw that even though the journey was a lot, the ending made up for it. It was emotional and empowering. Satisfying and somehow unsatisfying at the same time (this comes from some of the revelations that I had hoped wouldn't be true).
IT LURKS IN THE NIGHT is unpredictable and eerie. It's very twisted and the plot runs deeper than I could have been imagined.
IT LURKS IN THE NIGHT by Sarah Dass (Jan 27, 2026)
Thank you Netgalley and Disney Hyperion for the earc
When Maya and her friends go on their annual excursion, things aren't right. There's a rift in the friend group, and Maya hopes that she can repair it. Then Erica, one of Maya's friends, shows up d*ad (after a detour)...
IT LURKS IN THE NIGHT is a YA supernatural thriller.
This book is very mellow in the beginning. For the first 100+ pages or so, the only problem seems to be the rift in the friend group---all the drama. When that first problem arises, and the Erica d*es, everything takes a turn. As cruel as it may sound, it's for the better. Once that mark hit, and the pace quickened, it no longer felt as draining to read this (though, sadly, that feeling was not a stranger). Yes, I wanted to know why that rift had occurred, but I needed something to happen. When it did, I found the book to be much more interesting...but 400 pages is a lot. And there were times after this book piqued my interest that I found myself counting down the pages in a chapter, counting down until I was closer to the end. This is not a bad book, I just felt like it went on and on and on and on.
Once I made it to the end, and pieces fell into place, I looked back and saw that even though the journey was a lot, the ending made up for it. It was emotional and empowering. Satisfying and somehow unsatisfying at the same time (this comes from some of the revelations that I had hoped wouldn't be true).
IT LURKS IN THE NIGHT is unpredictable and eerie. It's very twisted and the plot runs deeper than I could have been imagined.
January 12, 2026
If you’re just starting your murder mystery era or want a YA murder mystery that won’t completely wreck your brain but will hook you fast — this one’s for you.
The beginning grabs you immediately like: “okay but what actually happened though? It’s got that perfect mix of fast-paced chaos + slower moments that build the tension, and the whole setting lowkey gave me Shutter Island vibes in the best way.
What I loved most? The story doesn’t just focus on the mystery — it’s also about friendship drama, heartbreak, first relationships, and messy family stuff (aka real life). The friend group dynamic is so good — they’re all completely different but somehow it works. And let’s be real… we’re either a Maya or we all HAVE a Maya in our lives.
The way the Armitage story and the jumbies/soucouyants weave together??? So good. So “I’ll just read one more chapter” coded.
And those final scenes on the island with the compound and the jumbie had me like: 😳😳😳 glued to the pages.
Long story short: I will not be vacationing on any deserted islands anytime soon because absolutely not 😂
Thank you to NetGalley and Disney Publishing Worldwide for this ARC.
The beginning grabs you immediately like: “okay but what actually happened though? It’s got that perfect mix of fast-paced chaos + slower moments that build the tension, and the whole setting lowkey gave me Shutter Island vibes in the best way.
What I loved most? The story doesn’t just focus on the mystery — it’s also about friendship drama, heartbreak, first relationships, and messy family stuff (aka real life). The friend group dynamic is so good — they’re all completely different but somehow it works. And let’s be real… we’re either a Maya or we all HAVE a Maya in our lives.
The way the Armitage story and the jumbies/soucouyants weave together??? So good. So “I’ll just read one more chapter” coded.
And those final scenes on the island with the compound and the jumbie had me like: 😳😳😳 glued to the pages.
Long story short: I will not be vacationing on any deserted islands anytime soon because absolutely not 😂
Thank you to NetGalley and Disney Publishing Worldwide for this ARC.
October 15, 2025
ARC Review
I love any fantasy story that takes place in the Caribbean, and this was no exception. We follow Maya Woods who is still grieving her missing sister and her friends Erica, Pearl, and Lystra as they find themselves on the haunted island of Annatto after their annual boat trip goes awry leading to Erica being killed, and replaced by the vampire-esque creature known as a soucoyant. Now they must find out what this demonic entity wants as it makes its way off the island and follows the girls home.
What starts off as a simple horror novel premise, quickly becomes something much more. A feminine rage that burns so brightly it can only be described as supernatural. While the soucoyant has been warped into a monster by its hunger for vengeance, it is no less cathartic watching it achieve its vengeance successfully by destroying the powerful man who drove it to become a monster.
I will say that the ending was not as satisfying as I'd hoped however and Pearl's ending in particular was very glossed over. All in all though a stellar read.
I love any fantasy story that takes place in the Caribbean, and this was no exception. We follow Maya Woods who is still grieving her missing sister and her friends Erica, Pearl, and Lystra as they find themselves on the haunted island of Annatto after their annual boat trip goes awry leading to Erica being killed, and replaced by the vampire-esque creature known as a soucoyant. Now they must find out what this demonic entity wants as it makes its way off the island and follows the girls home.
What starts off as a simple horror novel premise, quickly becomes something much more. A feminine rage that burns so brightly it can only be described as supernatural. While the soucoyant has been warped into a monster by its hunger for vengeance, it is no less cathartic watching it achieve its vengeance successfully by destroying the powerful man who drove it to become a monster.
I will say that the ending was not as satisfying as I'd hoped however and Pearl's ending in particular was very glossed over. All in all though a stellar read.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
November 8, 2025
Maya wants one more best friends summer trip around some Caribbean islands near their home, friendships are strained but they all go for Maya. When they have to stop on the island of Annatto, a island even tourist avoid because it is said to be haunted and have monsters on it. The girls are forced to leave a dead friend behind and run for their lives. When officials go the retrieve the body it is no longer there. That is when the weirdness starts because all of a sudden, she is found at home but not quite the same. The friends must watch out for what is coming next because something is lurking in the night.
I like this as it is bound in Caribbean lore. The story has so much suspense you need to make sure you take breaths. The action is palpable and runs nonstop throughout the book. The characters work really well and keep the story together. I really liked this book and hope you do too.
Review copy provided by Edelweiss
I like this as it is bound in Caribbean lore. The story has so much suspense you need to make sure you take breaths. The action is palpable and runs nonstop throughout the book. The characters work really well and keep the story together. I really liked this book and hope you do too.
Review copy provided by Edelweiss
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
It Lurks in the Night is a fantastically written thriller that’ll grab and hold you until the very end. The characters are complicated just like their friendship/relationships. There’s plenty of mystery written within these pages. Never a dull moment. The story is packed with secrets and forbidden tales. Such an entertaining rollercoaster ride. The pacing was perfectly set all the way up until the epilogue where it felt slightly rushed through. Overall this was still a solid and fantastic read.
Thank you NetGalley & Disney Hyperion for the eARC. This review is that of my own.
Thank you NetGalley & Disney Hyperion for the eARC. This review is that of my own.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
(Actual rating: 2.5 stars)
This book took me far too long to read. Having read Daas' first book in the Rick Riordan Presents imprint, It Waits in the Forest, I knew not to expect a fantasy but rather a thriller with the hint of the fantastical or paranormal which is exactly what I got here. I struggled to engage with the narrative for several reasons. One, the friends of the main character felt far too interchangeable. Two, the insertion of scary stories in the first third disrupted the narrative. Three, i figured out the twist almost as soon as it happened. I should have DNF'd. Alas, I did not.
This book took me far too long to read. Having read Daas' first book in the Rick Riordan Presents imprint, It Waits in the Forest, I knew not to expect a fantasy but rather a thriller with the hint of the fantastical or paranormal which is exactly what I got here. I struggled to engage with the narrative for several reasons. One, the friends of the main character felt far too interchangeable. Two, the insertion of scary stories in the first third disrupted the narrative. Three, i figured out the twist almost as soon as it happened. I should have DNF'd. Alas, I did not.
January 31, 2026
Thanks to the publisher and NetGalley for letting me review this book. Rick Riordan Presents books are always a hit with me. I enjoy reading about myths and folklore and this one was a new one for me. Maya and her friends get together for one last hurrah before going their separate ways after graduation. They decide to check out a haunted island and get more than they bargain for. Some of the characters show that they’re willing to do anything to keep up appearances and how far they will go. How a decision years ago can still reverberate through the years.
I liked the bit of history at the end as well.
I liked the bit of history at the end as well.
August 17, 2025
E ARC provided by Edelweiss Plus
Since this is from the Rick Riordan imprint, I was expecting a middle grade, action adventure fantasy novel. This was more Young Adult, and was more of a mystery with supernatural elements. It was an engaging and well written story, but since it is 400 pages long and includes characters buying alcohol, I will pass on purchase for middle school.
Since this is from the Rick Riordan imprint, I was expecting a middle grade, action adventure fantasy novel. This was more Young Adult, and was more of a mystery with supernatural elements. It was an engaging and well written story, but since it is 400 pages long and includes characters buying alcohol, I will pass on purchase for middle school.
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
This shifted the horror into a modern Caribbean setting, and the friendship dynamics totally hooked me. What starts as a trip for closure becomes a terrifying exploration of grief and guilt. The mystery of a friend’s impossible return had me questioning everything; it's a slow-burn, emotional type of unsettling that lingers long after the final page.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
Rick Riordan Presents always picks the best books and this one is no exception. it's absolutely fantastically plotted, taut, and the supernatural horror works really well. 5 stars. tysm for the arc.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
A unique YA thriller with a monster schema based in Caribbean folklore. Maya was a great lead for a YA tale. I absolutely loved it!
January 29, 2026
4.5 ⭐
Erica was a bitch, even before she died.
Erica was a bitch, even before she died.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
January 31, 2026
I could not get into this. I didnt really like the writing style. I dont think this was a book for me. I think others will like it but not me sorry.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
CW: Stalking,Death, Drowning, Fear
Maya wants to reunite her somewhat estranged best friends, Pearl, Erica, and Lystra, for an unforgettable boat trip, reminiscent of their adventures around their Caribbean home before graduation. However, their journey takes an unexpected turn when they make an emergency landing on the mysterious Annatto Island, known for its eerie tales and tragic history. After the shocking death of Erica, the bond between the girls faces its greatest challenge, forcing them to confront their fears and find courage amidst the darkness. Will they be able to solve the mystery of what truly happened on Annatto, or will the burdens of the past prove too difficult to overcome? Dass masterfully weaves together elements of Caribbean folklore and mythology with a supernatural thriller, exploring the fears that lurk in the night. This title is an must read for anyone who appreciates the darker, thrilling aspects of folklore and mythology, featuring a gripping narrative pace, captivating characters, and an abundance of twists and turns that will keep you turning the page.
Note: Thank you to NetGalley for an ARC of this title.
Maya wants to reunite her somewhat estranged best friends, Pearl, Erica, and Lystra, for an unforgettable boat trip, reminiscent of their adventures around their Caribbean home before graduation. However, their journey takes an unexpected turn when they make an emergency landing on the mysterious Annatto Island, known for its eerie tales and tragic history. After the shocking death of Erica, the bond between the girls faces its greatest challenge, forcing them to confront their fears and find courage amidst the darkness. Will they be able to solve the mystery of what truly happened on Annatto, or will the burdens of the past prove too difficult to overcome? Dass masterfully weaves together elements of Caribbean folklore and mythology with a supernatural thriller, exploring the fears that lurk in the night. This title is an must read for anyone who appreciates the darker, thrilling aspects of folklore and mythology, featuring a gripping narrative pace, captivating characters, and an abundance of twists and turns that will keep you turning the page.
Note: Thank you to NetGalley for an ARC of this title.
Displaying 1 - 24 of 24 reviews