Well, I didn't know that this book existed until it fell into my hands after I mentioned that I wouldn't mind reading one of the dialogues for Alan Bennett's "Talking Heads". The Talking Heads dialogues aren’t there anyway and I still don't know whether the lady in “Nights in the Garden of Spain” said “love” or “life” at a crucial stage in her journey to realisation, but, gosh, once I’d started “Writing Home” I was hooked on Bennett’s incisive, down-to-earth writing, and especially his pithy endings to each section. I found myself wondering in advance what witty and relevant comment was awaiting me in the last line. I’ve said before that I love when the final note of a piece of writing sums it up (and takes one further), and Alan Bennett certainly knows how to do that with aplomb. Sometimes this requires a bit of familiarity, though, with the world of British film and theatre, and also some knowledge of the twentieth century in Britain. An illustration of this was at the end of a parody and satire of the fan élite of the Bloomsbury Set – the piece is entitled, “Say Cheese, Virginia!”. After dismissing Lady Ottoline as “Dusty (Springfield) to a T” (in case Ken Russell wants to make a film about Lady O) he points out that this role “isn’t one for Glenda”. You need to have some knowledge of Glenda Jackson (a Labour politician as well as an unpretentious and gritty actress) in order to appreciate this sort of comment.
The book is enhanced by black and white photographs, including some of Miss Shepherd and her van. “The Lady in the Van” is in this book and I loved it. I’ve reviewed it separately. Ian commented on Alan Bennett’s decency in having allowed this disreputable old lady to live in his drive in her smelly old van for fifteen years. AB prefaces this series of diary extracts with this quotation from William Hazlitt (“On the Knowledge of Character”):
“Good nature, or what is often considered as such, is the most selfish of all virtues; it is nine times out of ten mere indolence of disposition.”
Sorry, Mr Bennett, I’m not having that. It was a kind thing that you did.
Lots of this book is self-deprecating, including many embarrassing moments, one of which, at Magdalen College Oxford, rivalling those in “Lucky Jim”. Alan Bennet mercilessly analyses his own motives and reactions, and his outspoken criticism always includes himself as onlooker or participant. The diary entries (1980 to 1995) are mordant. He hated former Prime Minister Mrs Thatcher, and gives cause, particularly the mine closures and the Falkands War. However, the diaries also contain poignant references to his mother, who is in a care home. I am still wondering whether caring for Miss Shepherd went a small way towards easing the inescapable guilt of having ‘put away’ his own mother. Visiting his father’s grave, he says there are things he would like to send him, but not his mother’s address.
There are portraits of many well-known figures from the British stage, and I think he seems fondest of Sir John Gielgud; although for me the far more interesting portrait was George III as played by Nigel Hawthorne (from the section entitled, “Prefaces to Plays”. The part I liked least was “Books and Writers” , where he reviews other people’s biographies of famous writers, because I don’t read biography. I’d rather accept someone’s writing at face value. I found myself unable to complete the section on Philip Larkin (who must have been a very objectionable character) until, by one of those happy coincidences, I was reminded on GR of a quotation I myself had selected, from Hašek, that an educated person should be able to read anything. (Thanks to Théodore for that!). So back I went to Philip Larkin and was edified to discover, as did Bennett, that the poems “emerge unscathed, just as," he says, “with Auden and Hardy, who have taken a similar biographical battering."
I think I’ll just end on a sycophantic note worthy of the great man’s cynical attention; one of the photographs shows him as a child sitting on some steps at Filey in Yorkshire. Just think! I have sat on those very same steps . . . .