Dawn finds her infamous secret passage in this book, and discovers the legend of Jared Mullray. She also forms an odd bond with Nicky Pike, who uses her secret passage to escape from the triplets teasing, although that seems to be contained to this book only. This was one of the very first books I read (back when I still liked Dawn) and I read it while I was eating cheese popcorn, so my copy had cheese colored fingerprints on some of the pages.
Things I remember from reading this as a kid:
I was desperate to find a secret passage in my house, and was so upset when my mom pointed out that our house was brand new, and built by my parents, and therefore had no secret passage. Later, when my father added onto the house I tried to convince him to add a secret passage, but he wouldn't do it.
As a kid I didn't think the triplets were that bad to Nicky, and I actually remember thinking that he was kind of a baby. The Pikes have never been my favorite characters, and there was too much of their story wrapped up in this book.
I had no idea why Dawn and Jeff made so much fun of their mother's date, Theodore "Trip" Gwynne. They laughed and laughed at his name, and then made fun of his clothes, which I did not get when I read this for the first time when I was eight. But now. . .
Things I've considered since reading this as an adult:
I do understand why the idea of Trip is funny, and I think it's hilarious that Dawn's mother, who has spent the last twenty years in California, would consider going out with someone like him. I think it's telling that he's the son of a friend of Dawn's grandparents (the same ones who disapproved of Mary Anne's working class grandparents), who are obviously trying to get her to marry up.
Every once in a while in this series Dawn alludes to her parents "messy divorce", but she never goes into much detail, even in the Super Special The Baby Sitters Remember, when she tells the story of her parents' divorce. I would love to know how it was messy. I'm assuming her father cheated on her mother because her mother calls him a liar when he is hours late coming home.
Dawn says that she doesn't have to watch Jeff since he's ten, and doesn't really need a baby sitter. In this book, Mallory is considered the second baby sitter for her family for the first time. I'm kind of surprised that the triplets (who are the same age as Jeff) don't launch a rebellion against being baby sat until much, much later in the series.
Dawn gets so worked up about a ghost in her passage, and it's kind of ridiculous. She is sure someone was locked up to die and now haunts the passage, but where are the remains of a body? Later she is sure there's a ghost because she finds an ice cream cone, and an old nickle in the passageway after she checked it. Even later she finds peanut shells, a book, and a key. I have to say, my mind wouldn't have jumped to this being evidence of a ghost, but rather evidence of some creepy homeless person hanging out in the walls of my house. That's what would have concerned me, weird people hanging around behind the wall of my bedroom. I guess it makes sense that Dawn, who can be so morose, would let her imagination run away with her, and assume that every little creak in her house means there must a be a spirit hanging around. Later in the series Dawn seems anxious to find ghosts whenever she hears rumor of one, and the idea of people stirring up spirits to show evidence of them is completely disrespectful to me. If she is so eager to find a ghost, then she has no business getting so upset when one supposedly finds its way into her life. In this book, when it turns out the ghost was Nicky Pike, there is supposedly a loose thread because Nicky didn't leave the second key Dawn found. Which means there is another someone who found the passage and is using it to hide out, which doesn't sound very safe for the Schafers and Nicky.
I'm kind of mad that Nicky wasn't given a sterner talking to. I don't think its appropriate for him to sneak into Dawn's barn, much less part of her house. This is mentioned as an aside, but it really seems like a problem to me, although maybe not to the residents of Stoneybrook. Also, Nicky mentions something about hoping the triplets won't start hanging out in the secret passage also, which again, seems really weird. Would they just expect to constantly be hanging around Dawn's house? Although Nicky's fears about the triplets invading his secret place might make sense given that the triplets are good friends with Jeff, and therefore have more reason to show up unexpectedly at Dawn's house than Nicky. Dawn mentions that the passageway might be unsafe, which I think is a very valid concern. What if Nicky gets badly injured while playing in it? I didn't really like that Dawn says it's A-OK for Nicky to use the passage when he wants to, and that the adults all go along with it, especially considering two things: 1) in Dawn and the Impossible Three, Dawn's mother doesn't want Dawn and Jeff to play inside the barn because it might be unsafe, and 2) I thought they were going to find a way to lock the passage to prevent criminal types from using the passage, which would mean the neighborhood kids wouldn't be able to traipse in and out of the Schafers' home also. Maybe they do take Mrs Pike's suggestion, and check the condition of the passage, with the barn safety check thrown in for good measure.