What do you think?
Rate this book
Vatican Secret Archive #7
The Confessions of Pope Joan
In the heart of the English countryside, a discovery is made that threatens to overturn centuries of Church history. When Father Michael Dominic uncovers a cryptic diary leading to a lost 1st century Gospel, he is thrust into a labyrinth of deceit, murder, and controversy. Alongside Hana Sinclair, a savvy journalist, Michael sets out to unravel a mystery buried deep within the Church's past. The Confessions of Pope Joan is a gripping tale of courage and faith, charting their quest against a powerful adversary seeking to keep the truth hidden. Their journey reveals the existence of Pope Joan, the first and only female Pope whose reign has been obscured by time and conspiracy. As they traverse the intricate tapestry of deceit and power, they must confront a society unwilling to relinquish its patriarchal hold. Meanwhile, Detective Inspector Grace Dempsey, assigned to a seemingly unrelated murder case in England, stumbles upon a thread that binds her to the historic revelation. Their paths converge, creating a thrilling narrative that intertwines past and present, fact and fiction. As the Vatican's secrets unfold, Pope Ignatius, Michael's ailing father, battles his own legacy. Torn between preserving the Church's past and shaping its future, his decisions become paramount in the struggle for truth. The Pope’s radical stand for change, embodied in two Apostolic Constitutions, sets the stage for a new era in the Church while challenging long-standing beliefs and traditions. The Confessions of Pope Joan is an intriguing blend of historical revelation, suspenseful mystery, and human resilience. It delves deep into the heart of the Catholic Church, unearthing secrets hidden for centuries. Through engaging characters, intertwined plotlines, and poignant insights, this novel offers readers an engrossing journey through a world where the past bleeds into the present, reshaping the future. With every turn of the page, The Confessions of Pope Joan forces readers to question the known and grapple with the unimagined, making it a must-read for fans of historical thrillers.
242 pages, Paperback
Published September 21, 2023
564 people are currently reading
190 people want to read
About the author
Gary McAvoy
38 books479 followersGary McAvoy is an American novelist known for internationally bestselling thrillers that blend historical intrigue, religious scholarship, and modern suspense. A lifelong researcher of rare manuscripts and Church history, he draws on extensive archival study to craft narratives rooted in authentic detail. His work includes the Vatican Secret Archive Thrillers, the Magdalene Chronicles, and the Vatican Archaeology Thrillers. Before turning to fiction, McAvoy built a distinguished career as an entrepreneur, technology consultant, and collector of historical documents. He now writes full time from the Pacific Northwest, where he continues to explore the shadowed crossroads of faith, power, and history.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 93 reviews
September 16, 2023
First and foremost, a large thank you to Reedsy Discovery and Gary McAvoy for providing me with a copy of this publication, which allows me to provide you with an unbiased review.
Always eager to read the work of Gary McAvoy, I gladly accepted this ARC, the latest in the Vatican Secret Archive series. The story pulls on yet another aspect of early Christianity that is sure to rock the modern Christian world. McAvoy writes not only to educate on these revelations, but is able to produce a thriller that holds up against many of the other authors in the genre. McAvoy’s book provides some strong arguments for the inclusion of these newly unearthed views, which adds a subtle political element to the larger Vatican reaction. McAvoy’s ability to mix fact and fiction is second to none, forcing the reader to posit what might be truth and where the fabrication commences. Another great piece in this strong series with a gripping final few chapters.
While visiting a friend in the English countryside, Father Michael Dominic makes an unusual discovery when he comes across an old riddle that points to an ancient church. When Father Dominic and his entourage discover the cryptic diary of an old figure long thought to be a fallacy in the Catholic world, they are stunned. This is only further exacerbated when the 1st century Gospel found alongside it reveals new thoughts long buried by early biblical scribes. The diary of Pope Joan, long-thought a 9th century rumour, explores a voice for women that was far from common (or permitted) at the time. The purported Gospel of Salome, an early follower of Jesus, shows a completely different perspective for women and the means of understanding sin in its earliest form. Father Dominic and his close friend, sharp-witted journalist Hana Sinclair, know that they have something intense on their hands now. They are sure it will also cause many waves should it see the light of day.
When news of the discovery makes its way to Lord Lucius Pelham, a powerful Englishman with numerous connections, the concern over the documents increases. Lord Pelham leads a secret group within the Catholic Church, the Order of Papal Guardians, and vows to ensure neither of these relics see the light of day, promising he will stop at nothing to have them destroyed. When a local vicar is found murdered, Detective Inspector Grace Dempsey finds herself on the scene to explore what’s happened. Father Dominic and his entourage are questioned, as they were on site, though they are soon cleared by DI Dempsey. Still, it is a warning in an ongoing game of cat and mouse, as they return with the relics to the Vatican, in hopes of showing the current pontiff.
As Pope Ignatius learns of the diary and gospel document, he is deeply concerned. He knows that his time is short and hopes to shape his legacy, but is also not sure how the Church will handle the news of Pope Joan’s existence and what the Gospel of Salome might mean for future teachings. Father Dominic can only imagine that it is burden that could have heavy consequences.
While Lord Pelham seeks to capture the two relics and see one of Father Dominic’s close friends framed for murder, he will have to do more than simply wish it into being. DI Dempsey is aware of Pelham’s antics and history for meddling, using his powerful connections to get what he desires. Pope Ignatius must also decide how to handle the news of the diary and Gospel, as well as what it means for the future of the Church. Whatever he decides, there will be those on both sides of the argument sure to press him to turn their way. All the while, Father Dominic has an epiphany of his own involving Hana Sinclair, something that has been brewing for a while. All this, with a pending political cloud looming over the Holy See, which could change its perspective significantly. Gary McAvoy pulls the reader into a handful of poignant moments in the series, sure to intrigue those who have followed along from the very beginning.
The detailed writing of Gary McAvoy makes this series and the larger group of books related to Father Michael Dominic not only a joy to read, but provides numerous points of educational insight. While the books are deeply rooted in Christian history and the role played by the Catholic Church, they are not meant to inculcate the reader into believing a set of views espoused by the author. Rather, they seek to provide moments of thought as McAvoy hopes to leave the reader with some introspection.
McAvoy offers the reader a strong narrative foundation, permitting them to follow the story with relative ease. There is a mixture of action and education woven into each page, as things progress and the reader is highly entertained. Within the narrative is a building, not only of the subject matter at hand, but the connections between the characters and role of the Church in society. The characters, many of whom have been around for numerous books, help shape the story as well. Some work to build the thriller angle, while others push a deeper religious perspective, both of which are essential to better understand the book and the series, The Dominic-Sinclair connection, which has been a matter of some interest to series fans, gets a lot of time as well, though some of it more subtly than might be wanted. This enriching of the larger story can be appreciated by those who have a firm grasp of the series. Plot twists emerge and build on one another with ease. McAvoy has long been known to add moments of action and religious curiosity, both of which fuel the plot developments and keep the story from becoming too predictable. There is a strong sense of something extreme coming in the near future, which I am sure McAvoy has been planning for a few novels, I cannot wait to see how the cliffhanger at the end will play into the next novel and what role Father Michael Dominic might have moving forward.
Kudos, Mr. McAvoy, for another chilling thriller. I love your views, your insights, and your ability to grip the reader so effectively.
Love/hate the review? An ever-growing collection of others appears at:
http://pecheyponderings.wordpress.com/
Always eager to read the work of Gary McAvoy, I gladly accepted this ARC, the latest in the Vatican Secret Archive series. The story pulls on yet another aspect of early Christianity that is sure to rock the modern Christian world. McAvoy writes not only to educate on these revelations, but is able to produce a thriller that holds up against many of the other authors in the genre. McAvoy’s book provides some strong arguments for the inclusion of these newly unearthed views, which adds a subtle political element to the larger Vatican reaction. McAvoy’s ability to mix fact and fiction is second to none, forcing the reader to posit what might be truth and where the fabrication commences. Another great piece in this strong series with a gripping final few chapters.
While visiting a friend in the English countryside, Father Michael Dominic makes an unusual discovery when he comes across an old riddle that points to an ancient church. When Father Dominic and his entourage discover the cryptic diary of an old figure long thought to be a fallacy in the Catholic world, they are stunned. This is only further exacerbated when the 1st century Gospel found alongside it reveals new thoughts long buried by early biblical scribes. The diary of Pope Joan, long-thought a 9th century rumour, explores a voice for women that was far from common (or permitted) at the time. The purported Gospel of Salome, an early follower of Jesus, shows a completely different perspective for women and the means of understanding sin in its earliest form. Father Dominic and his close friend, sharp-witted journalist Hana Sinclair, know that they have something intense on their hands now. They are sure it will also cause many waves should it see the light of day.
When news of the discovery makes its way to Lord Lucius Pelham, a powerful Englishman with numerous connections, the concern over the documents increases. Lord Pelham leads a secret group within the Catholic Church, the Order of Papal Guardians, and vows to ensure neither of these relics see the light of day, promising he will stop at nothing to have them destroyed. When a local vicar is found murdered, Detective Inspector Grace Dempsey finds herself on the scene to explore what’s happened. Father Dominic and his entourage are questioned, as they were on site, though they are soon cleared by DI Dempsey. Still, it is a warning in an ongoing game of cat and mouse, as they return with the relics to the Vatican, in hopes of showing the current pontiff.
As Pope Ignatius learns of the diary and gospel document, he is deeply concerned. He knows that his time is short and hopes to shape his legacy, but is also not sure how the Church will handle the news of Pope Joan’s existence and what the Gospel of Salome might mean for future teachings. Father Dominic can only imagine that it is burden that could have heavy consequences.
While Lord Pelham seeks to capture the two relics and see one of Father Dominic’s close friends framed for murder, he will have to do more than simply wish it into being. DI Dempsey is aware of Pelham’s antics and history for meddling, using his powerful connections to get what he desires. Pope Ignatius must also decide how to handle the news of the diary and Gospel, as well as what it means for the future of the Church. Whatever he decides, there will be those on both sides of the argument sure to press him to turn their way. All the while, Father Dominic has an epiphany of his own involving Hana Sinclair, something that has been brewing for a while. All this, with a pending political cloud looming over the Holy See, which could change its perspective significantly. Gary McAvoy pulls the reader into a handful of poignant moments in the series, sure to intrigue those who have followed along from the very beginning.
The detailed writing of Gary McAvoy makes this series and the larger group of books related to Father Michael Dominic not only a joy to read, but provides numerous points of educational insight. While the books are deeply rooted in Christian history and the role played by the Catholic Church, they are not meant to inculcate the reader into believing a set of views espoused by the author. Rather, they seek to provide moments of thought as McAvoy hopes to leave the reader with some introspection.
McAvoy offers the reader a strong narrative foundation, permitting them to follow the story with relative ease. There is a mixture of action and education woven into each page, as things progress and the reader is highly entertained. Within the narrative is a building, not only of the subject matter at hand, but the connections between the characters and role of the Church in society. The characters, many of whom have been around for numerous books, help shape the story as well. Some work to build the thriller angle, while others push a deeper religious perspective, both of which are essential to better understand the book and the series, The Dominic-Sinclair connection, which has been a matter of some interest to series fans, gets a lot of time as well, though some of it more subtly than might be wanted. This enriching of the larger story can be appreciated by those who have a firm grasp of the series. Plot twists emerge and build on one another with ease. McAvoy has long been known to add moments of action and religious curiosity, both of which fuel the plot developments and keep the story from becoming too predictable. There is a strong sense of something extreme coming in the near future, which I am sure McAvoy has been planning for a few novels, I cannot wait to see how the cliffhanger at the end will play into the next novel and what role Father Michael Dominic might have moving forward.
Kudos, Mr. McAvoy, for another chilling thriller. I love your views, your insights, and your ability to grip the reader so effectively.
Love/hate the review? An ever-growing collection of others appears at:
http://pecheyponderings.wordpress.com/
November 16, 2023
I look forward to each new book by GARY MCAVOY. Fortunately, my wait is never more than a few months. His books follow the exploits of Father Michael Dominic, head of the Vatican Secret Archives. Father Michael has a not-so-secret secret. His mentor is Pope Ignatius (born Enrico Petrino, a World War II hero and a member of the French Resistance). Book 10 in the historical/Catholic Church adventures is THE CONFESSIONS OF POPE JOAN. Yes, Pope Joan.
Apparently, early in the 9th Century, a young woman, Johanna Anglicus, disguised herself as a man in order to satisfy her craving for knowledge. This takes place in what is now Mainz, Germany. With the help of a monk, Johanna enters an order of monks to learn all she can. She is a voracious student and wants more. She goes first to Athens (Greece) and then Constantinople (Turkey) to gather more information. Eventually, Johanna (now called John) ends up in Rome and the Vatican in 847. Because of her knowledge, she becomes personal secretary to Pope Leo IV. When he dies, Johanna is elected Pope. She takes the name Pope John VIII. Here is where fact and fiction become murky.
Flash-forward to the present day. Robert Anglicus (“Robbie”) is a new professor at Loyola University of Chicago’s Rome branch teaching medieval history. His friend, Aaron Pearce, had laid the groundwork for his appointment to the staff at age 31. Aaron is a good friend and former college roommate of Father Michael. When Robbie meets Michael, they, too, become friends. Robbie mentions that his family owns the Codex Anglicus, a family bible dating to the 9th Century. It is a true copy of 4th Century Codex Vaticanus, which resides in Michael’s Vatican Secret Archives. Robbie invites Michael, Hana, Aaron and 2 members of the Vatican’s Swiss Guards (Sergeants Karl Dengler and Lukas Bischoff) to visit him in England to see the Codex.
While looking at Robbie’s Codex, Michael finds a note that had not previously been found by the family. The note leads Team Michael to Sherborne Abbey located near Sherborne Castle (owned by Sir Walter Raleigh in the 16th Century). There they meet Reverend Warren Andrews and Lord Lucius Pelham. The former is the Abbey’s vicar and the latter is a wealthy landowner. Both are members of the Order of Papal Guardians. They become the new villains that Michael and his team have to face.
Lord Pelham demands he has the right to own the two explosive documents that Michael and his team discover. One is a 9th Century book that contains Pope Joan’s story/confession. The other is a document written by St. Salome, a follower/contemporary of Jesus Christ. And the chase is on. From the British Museum to a secret monastery outside of Rome, the two forces battle over the documents that could tear the Catholic Church asunder.
As in his previous books, author McAvoy explains what is fact and what is fiction. Along the way, he tells a fascinating and fast-paced historical story. I have enjoyed the series so far. There is more to come according to the author. I cannot wait for the next installment. This is a fun way to learn a little history. I give the books my highest recommendation: EXTREMELY HIGHLY RECOMMENDED.
GO! BUY! READ! NOW!
Apparently, early in the 9th Century, a young woman, Johanna Anglicus, disguised herself as a man in order to satisfy her craving for knowledge. This takes place in what is now Mainz, Germany. With the help of a monk, Johanna enters an order of monks to learn all she can. She is a voracious student and wants more. She goes first to Athens (Greece) and then Constantinople (Turkey) to gather more information. Eventually, Johanna (now called John) ends up in Rome and the Vatican in 847. Because of her knowledge, she becomes personal secretary to Pope Leo IV. When he dies, Johanna is elected Pope. She takes the name Pope John VIII. Here is where fact and fiction become murky.
Flash-forward to the present day. Robert Anglicus (“Robbie”) is a new professor at Loyola University of Chicago’s Rome branch teaching medieval history. His friend, Aaron Pearce, had laid the groundwork for his appointment to the staff at age 31. Aaron is a good friend and former college roommate of Father Michael. When Robbie meets Michael, they, too, become friends. Robbie mentions that his family owns the Codex Anglicus, a family bible dating to the 9th Century. It is a true copy of 4th Century Codex Vaticanus, which resides in Michael’s Vatican Secret Archives. Robbie invites Michael, Hana, Aaron and 2 members of the Vatican’s Swiss Guards (Sergeants Karl Dengler and Lukas Bischoff) to visit him in England to see the Codex.
While looking at Robbie’s Codex, Michael finds a note that had not previously been found by the family. The note leads Team Michael to Sherborne Abbey located near Sherborne Castle (owned by Sir Walter Raleigh in the 16th Century). There they meet Reverend Warren Andrews and Lord Lucius Pelham. The former is the Abbey’s vicar and the latter is a wealthy landowner. Both are members of the Order of Papal Guardians. They become the new villains that Michael and his team have to face.
Lord Pelham demands he has the right to own the two explosive documents that Michael and his team discover. One is a 9th Century book that contains Pope Joan’s story/confession. The other is a document written by St. Salome, a follower/contemporary of Jesus Christ. And the chase is on. From the British Museum to a secret monastery outside of Rome, the two forces battle over the documents that could tear the Catholic Church asunder.
As in his previous books, author McAvoy explains what is fact and what is fiction. Along the way, he tells a fascinating and fast-paced historical story. I have enjoyed the series so far. There is more to come according to the author. I cannot wait for the next installment. This is a fun way to learn a little history. I give the books my highest recommendation: EXTREMELY HIGHLY RECOMMENDED.
GO! BUY! READ! NOW!
September 25, 2023
More of the same from the immensely capable Gary McAvoy, quite simply one of the most prolific writers it has ever been my good fortune to review. If you haven’t read Gary’s work before, you’ve missed a treat, and you are strongly advised to go back to the beginning of this long-running saga and get to know the characters from their first case together. The author is the real star of this series. His writing is eloquent and intelligent, his narrative craftwork flawless. He researches and curates theological and procedural information as good if not better than any author I have read, cleverly constructing fictional tales around real-life historical artefacts and their legendary backstories. To put it simply, he gives Indiana Jones the Dan Brown treatment, solving complex puzzles rather than buckling swashes – although, occasionally the action erupts, its swift resolution left to the Swiss Guard element of the ensemble, Karl and Lukas, while primary protagonists Father Michael and Hana do what they do best: travel to ancient religious sites and museums solving murderous, high-level corruption mysteries.
In The Confessions of Pope Joan, their ecclesiastical sleuthing adventures continue, though the entry – seventh in the series, I believe – is a little lighter in said action than previous versions, which is a bit of a shame, because among McAvoy’s many excellent strings is the ability to craft tense, gritty and all-business action sequences involving the relevant military professionals of the piece. Indeed, this book is an altogether less energetic entry than previous outings. The complexity isn’t as profound and there really isn’t any genuine threat or suspense to speak of. The narrative has perhaps a more progressive premise than the others, as it explores the possible reality of the rumoured story of Pope Joan, who is believed by many to have sat on the papal throne in the 9th century under the guise of a man, until her discovery when giving birth, and her tenure quickly covered up. This is a timely book as, in keeping with the current trend, history is hence questioned and reinterpreted; Joan’s ascension becomes the mechanism for profound change in the structure and progress of the whole Catholic Church, creating a schism between progressives and purists – very topical indeed.
The positive about this, without wishing to spoil the end, is that it appears there might be a glimmer of resolution to the long-running “will-they-won’t-they” saga, in respect of the forbidden but barely concealed love between the two main characters. I have to say, and I may have mentioned this before when reviewing the series, but this particular element has been stretched far beyond the capacity to care; by now you just want them to either get it on or call it off, and move on with other sub-plots. In fact, it is fair to harshly say that the franchise could perhaps do with a jump-start. The characters meander along doing what they do, but their irrefutable decency, loyalty and goodness don’t really bring any new challenges for them beyond the case they are solving. I would like, certainly by now, to see the core characters start to show flaws, layers of depth, personal demons and faults; I want them to be wrong, do bad things, make selfish decisions – to put it bluntly, I want them to show destructive human characteristics, for their unwavering virtue feels a touch too safe by now. After seven books, Gary really should consider shattering the formula; tear open the characters’ dark side, rather than always keeping them in the light. The law enforcement characters are also just a touch too conveniently efficient and conscientious – indeed, I couldn’t help thinking that Gary has a great deal more faith in the diligence of the British police than anyone I know over here. There are not enough challenges beyond that of the bad guys – and those bad guys, relative to the good guys, are just a little too unambiguous.
But I don’t want to disparage Gary McAvoy in any way. I can’t sufficiently emphasize how good he is, and he has my utmost respect as a writer, a researcher, an academic and a teacher of history. Read his books in order if you are able, but do read them.
In The Confessions of Pope Joan, their ecclesiastical sleuthing adventures continue, though the entry – seventh in the series, I believe – is a little lighter in said action than previous versions, which is a bit of a shame, because among McAvoy’s many excellent strings is the ability to craft tense, gritty and all-business action sequences involving the relevant military professionals of the piece. Indeed, this book is an altogether less energetic entry than previous outings. The complexity isn’t as profound and there really isn’t any genuine threat or suspense to speak of. The narrative has perhaps a more progressive premise than the others, as it explores the possible reality of the rumoured story of Pope Joan, who is believed by many to have sat on the papal throne in the 9th century under the guise of a man, until her discovery when giving birth, and her tenure quickly covered up. This is a timely book as, in keeping with the current trend, history is hence questioned and reinterpreted; Joan’s ascension becomes the mechanism for profound change in the structure and progress of the whole Catholic Church, creating a schism between progressives and purists – very topical indeed.
The positive about this, without wishing to spoil the end, is that it appears there might be a glimmer of resolution to the long-running “will-they-won’t-they” saga, in respect of the forbidden but barely concealed love between the two main characters. I have to say, and I may have mentioned this before when reviewing the series, but this particular element has been stretched far beyond the capacity to care; by now you just want them to either get it on or call it off, and move on with other sub-plots. In fact, it is fair to harshly say that the franchise could perhaps do with a jump-start. The characters meander along doing what they do, but their irrefutable decency, loyalty and goodness don’t really bring any new challenges for them beyond the case they are solving. I would like, certainly by now, to see the core characters start to show flaws, layers of depth, personal demons and faults; I want them to be wrong, do bad things, make selfish decisions – to put it bluntly, I want them to show destructive human characteristics, for their unwavering virtue feels a touch too safe by now. After seven books, Gary really should consider shattering the formula; tear open the characters’ dark side, rather than always keeping them in the light. The law enforcement characters are also just a touch too conveniently efficient and conscientious – indeed, I couldn’t help thinking that Gary has a great deal more faith in the diligence of the British police than anyone I know over here. There are not enough challenges beyond that of the bad guys – and those bad guys, relative to the good guys, are just a little too unambiguous.
But I don’t want to disparage Gary McAvoy in any way. I can’t sufficiently emphasize how good he is, and he has my utmost respect as a writer, a researcher, an academic and a teacher of history. Read his books in order if you are able, but do read them.
September 24, 2023
The Confessions of Pope Joan is Gary McAvoy’s long-awaited novel addressing the seriously controversial issues of women in the Catholic Church hierarchy, as well as the taboo subject of Catholic priests being able to marry and remain ordained priests within the Church. I will confess that as a good and well brought up Catholic schoolgirl from grades 1 through 12, I was quite sheltered by the nuns who carefully worded everything around us girls. I can tell you categorically that there was never even a hint of someone called Pope Joan, or a female pretending to be a Pope, or a Priest, Brother, or even a Deacon for that matter, when I was being educated. Not even whispers or rumors about such a thing having ever occurred came anywhere near my schools. So when I read the premise for Mr. McAvoy’s latest novel, I was beyond intrigued, I became a bit obsessed to learn as much as I could about this purportedly fictional character in history. And I learned a great deal of information, sufficient enough to state categorically that Mr. McAvoy’s research skills are unparalleled! He found every minute detail I was able uncover about Pope Joan and then some! I do not embellish his talent or ability to discern the facts from the fictional account of each and every point supporting the proposition that Pope Joan was in fact a real person from history! From my humble research, Mr. McAvoy did her justice in describing the angst and turmoil she must have experienced during a time when women were barely tolerated and never taken seriously enough to ever be able to attain such a lofty position as Pope while being female, which fact in its own way supports the credibility of the claim. Such a preposterous notion of a woman masquerading as a man, let alone her having to successfully fooling countless men of the Church in order to be elevated to such a position, would have been in her favor. Because no man would have thought a mere woman capable of such an act! That would have been laughable, and any such attempt at impersonating a Priest, Bishop, or Cardinal would have angered the males in charge of the Church, sufficiently to have them put to death without hesitation. And her time frame would have been around the time that the Church could examine parishioners and question them to death without repercussions.
This story reunites my favorites and then some new people into the lives of F. Michael Domenic and Hana Sinclair, along with Pope Ignatius, and the Swiss Guardsmen Karl and Lukas. Hana and F. Michael are closer than ever in some respects in this installment, and at the same time they could not be more distant one from the other! I will admit to my ongoing frustration that neither one of them has taken the bull by the horns (so to speak) and moved their relationship to either side of the fence they are both straddling. As with every Gary McAvoy novel in this series, you will be moved to the edge of your seat, hanging by a mere thread, waiting for the outcome of a shootout to learn who takes a bullet, a drive that endangers life and limb (as they are exiting the highway, I thought I was going over a cliff or smashing into a mountain), and all manner of intrigue among the players trying to figure out who are the bad guys, the good guys, and the innocents caught by surprise! And please don’t make the mistake of thinking that this is a run of the mill thriller, this one is exceptional, and the reader will feel its uniqueness with every word consumed!
Because I am tired of saying that Mr. McAvoy “did it again” with another best seller, I will also admit that I did not believe him capable of writing any better novels than the ten I have already inhaled to date. I stand in awe and corrected for even allowing one iota of a doubt to invade my thoughts to make me forget the limitless capacity of a brilliant mind to conjure and create an even better story than his previous works. As I recall, I placed several of Mr. McAvoy’s previous novels within the category of “perfection.” So, if he has exceeded perfection with Pope Joan, which he has, where does that place him? Sublime? Ideal? Magnificent? Well, whatever the politically correct word is for what he has achieved with this beyond-perfect-novel, The Confessions of Pope Joan MUST BE READ!
This story reunites my favorites and then some new people into the lives of F. Michael Domenic and Hana Sinclair, along with Pope Ignatius, and the Swiss Guardsmen Karl and Lukas. Hana and F. Michael are closer than ever in some respects in this installment, and at the same time they could not be more distant one from the other! I will admit to my ongoing frustration that neither one of them has taken the bull by the horns (so to speak) and moved their relationship to either side of the fence they are both straddling. As with every Gary McAvoy novel in this series, you will be moved to the edge of your seat, hanging by a mere thread, waiting for the outcome of a shootout to learn who takes a bullet, a drive that endangers life and limb (as they are exiting the highway, I thought I was going over a cliff or smashing into a mountain), and all manner of intrigue among the players trying to figure out who are the bad guys, the good guys, and the innocents caught by surprise! And please don’t make the mistake of thinking that this is a run of the mill thriller, this one is exceptional, and the reader will feel its uniqueness with every word consumed!
Because I am tired of saying that Mr. McAvoy “did it again” with another best seller, I will also admit that I did not believe him capable of writing any better novels than the ten I have already inhaled to date. I stand in awe and corrected for even allowing one iota of a doubt to invade my thoughts to make me forget the limitless capacity of a brilliant mind to conjure and create an even better story than his previous works. As I recall, I placed several of Mr. McAvoy’s previous novels within the category of “perfection.” So, if he has exceeded perfection with Pope Joan, which he has, where does that place him? Sublime? Ideal? Magnificent? Well, whatever the politically correct word is for what he has achieved with this beyond-perfect-novel, The Confessions of Pope Joan MUST BE READ!
September 24, 2023
"The Confessions of Pope Joan" is not merely a historical fiction novel but a spiritual journey of mankind. It speaks to my heart and soul of the Divine presence in all of us which in and of itself makes us all equal. Sin is only a misconstrued concept of “missing the mark.” Your ability to capture the essence of the Divine and Truth in Pope Joan’s Diary and St. Salome’s Gospel reminds me, to name a few, of the writings of Manly Palmer Hall, Emma Curtis Hopkins, and Joseph Campbell. Your spiritual insights are truly brilliant and not of this dimension.
The plot never waivers even though you throw in distractors with new characters coming out of no where and each time I thought “Uh oh, what’s next? Are they the good guys or the bad guys?” The different agendas of each scenario eventually blend into the message you’re sharing. Two years ago, I retired as a RN; however, as they say ‘once a nurse, always a nurse’. I still think in algorithms and the manner in which you merge truth, fiction, each individual, each agenda, each group, challenges to long standing church dogma, new insights, papal decrees, etc. into the ‘whole’ of the novel reminds me of algorithms or sticky notes all over the wall. Definitely your best novel to date.
The plot never waivers even though you throw in distractors with new characters coming out of no where and each time I thought “Uh oh, what’s next? Are they the good guys or the bad guys?” The different agendas of each scenario eventually blend into the message you’re sharing. Two years ago, I retired as a RN; however, as they say ‘once a nurse, always a nurse’. I still think in algorithms and the manner in which you merge truth, fiction, each individual, each agenda, each group, challenges to long standing church dogma, new insights, papal decrees, etc. into the ‘whole’ of the novel reminds me of algorithms or sticky notes all over the wall. Definitely your best novel to date.
November 25, 2023
From McAvoy's Mouth to God's Ears!
McAvoy seems to have saved his best and most hard-hitting work for .... Well, at least for now. (The end of THIS book is a cliffhanger like his previous books.) Many will likely agree with the storyline, many won't. However, the concerns enumerated by what McAvoy has written DO seem to be legitimate and require change.
Having said that I am not Catholic, though I have lived at least a few lifetimes as a Catholic, sometimes as a willing participant, and at other times NOT so willing.
Kudos, Gary! Looking forward to the next installment, especially to see what happens with Michael and Hana, as well as to see how the changes proposed by Pope Ignatius materialize!
McAvoy seems to have saved his best and most hard-hitting work for .... Well, at least for now. (The end of THIS book is a cliffhanger like his previous books.) Many will likely agree with the storyline, many won't. However, the concerns enumerated by what McAvoy has written DO seem to be legitimate and require change.
Having said that I am not Catholic, though I have lived at least a few lifetimes as a Catholic, sometimes as a willing participant, and at other times NOT so willing.
Kudos, Gary! Looking forward to the next installment, especially to see what happens with Michael and Hana, as well as to see how the changes proposed by Pope Ignatius materialize!
November 5, 2023
Great Read!
I love this book and the series, an the writing style of Gary McAvoy. The characters are so human, that I feel I know them well enough to sit and have a friendly conversation, over a cup of coffee. I love the historical aspects intertwined with fiction. Finally, I can't wait for Gary to write the next book in the series!
I love this book and the series, an the writing style of Gary McAvoy. The characters are so human, that I feel I know them well enough to sit and have a friendly conversation, over a cup of coffee. I love the historical aspects intertwined with fiction. Finally, I can't wait for Gary to write the next book in the series!
October 23, 2023
Loved the museum exhibit they were setting up.
But this one made me cry.
But this one made me cry.
October 20, 2023
Enjoyed It
Another great story from this writer. It draws you in and immerses you in the possibility it could all be true.
Another great story from this writer. It draws you in and immerses you in the possibility it could all be true.
October 29, 2023
Historical fiction at it's finest !!!
The whole Magdalene Chronicles is a look at the Roman Catholic church as what many would hope it to be. The adventures and relics at the center of each book are historically accurate, though the details around each story are by and large the imagination of the author. Compelling reading.
The whole Magdalene Chronicles is a look at the Roman Catholic church as what many would hope it to be. The adventures and relics at the center of each book are historically accurate, though the details around each story are by and large the imagination of the author. Compelling reading.
November 20, 2023
Disappointing
Too much introspection, internal dialog, and exposition, with very little plot, conflict or action. The entire story is buried under flowery sentiment and unnecessary emotion. This author is off my list.
Too much introspection, internal dialog, and exposition, with very little plot, conflict or action. The entire story is buried under flowery sentiment and unnecessary emotion. This author is off my list.
September 28, 2023
I first came across Gary McAvoy’s work a couple years ago during the summer of 2021. My personal life was a bit stressful at the time, and I ordered The Magdalene Deception from a Facebook ad hoping it would provide a nice distraction. I got completely immersed in the adventures of Michael Dominic, and I’ve now read all ten books in the series, with The Confessions of Pope Joan being one of the strongest entries.
The Confessions of Pope Joan again follows Father Michael Dominic and his circle of friends as they travel to England and come across a cryptic poem hidden in the pages of an ancient Bible. The clues in the poem lead them to Sherborne Abbey, where they uncover an old diary written by Joan Anglicus, the only female pope in church history whose existence before this discovery was thought by most to be a myth. Within this diary, they stumble upon yet another document leading them to the long-lost Gospel of St. Salome. Together, Pope Joan’s diary and Salome’s Gospel paint a compelling picture of influential women shaping the Catholic Church’s history, a revelation that runs counter to accepted church doctrine and has the potential to completely upend the church’s current power structure. Naturally, there are parties intent on suppressing this information at all costs. It is up to Michael and his newfound allies in the Fellowship of the True Faith to protect this discovery from the machinations of Lord Pelham, an English aristocrat and head of the Order of Papal Guardians, who seeks to seize these artifacts for his own ends.
Gary McAvoy’s latest book seamlessly mixes adventure/discovery and action sequences while addressing important issues in the Catholic Church that have been whitewashed over for centuries. As social norms have evolved over the last two millenia, much of church doctrine has become archaic and obsolete. The requirement that priests remain unmarried and celibate very likely has contributed to many of the priest-related scandals we have seen in recent decades. The patriarchal power structure of the church has led to teachings that are out of step with modern sensitivities. The Confessions of Pope Joan offers us a glimpse of what a new and improved Catholic Church could look like where priests are allowed to marry and women are given prominent leadership roles.
The scenes where Michael Dominic and company follow clues to discover Pope Joan’s diary and St. Salome’s Gospel could be right out of a National Treasure movie, and one particular car chase scene is reminiscent of the Fast & Furious films. The ending is especially poignant as we witness the death of a long beloved character, while at the same time, Michael and Hana are finally free to pursue the relationship they’ve been wanting for the previous nine books.
All in all, The Confessions of Pope Joan hits all the right notes and should not be missed.
The Confessions of Pope Joan again follows Father Michael Dominic and his circle of friends as they travel to England and come across a cryptic poem hidden in the pages of an ancient Bible. The clues in the poem lead them to Sherborne Abbey, where they uncover an old diary written by Joan Anglicus, the only female pope in church history whose existence before this discovery was thought by most to be a myth. Within this diary, they stumble upon yet another document leading them to the long-lost Gospel of St. Salome. Together, Pope Joan’s diary and Salome’s Gospel paint a compelling picture of influential women shaping the Catholic Church’s history, a revelation that runs counter to accepted church doctrine and has the potential to completely upend the church’s current power structure. Naturally, there are parties intent on suppressing this information at all costs. It is up to Michael and his newfound allies in the Fellowship of the True Faith to protect this discovery from the machinations of Lord Pelham, an English aristocrat and head of the Order of Papal Guardians, who seeks to seize these artifacts for his own ends.
Gary McAvoy’s latest book seamlessly mixes adventure/discovery and action sequences while addressing important issues in the Catholic Church that have been whitewashed over for centuries. As social norms have evolved over the last two millenia, much of church doctrine has become archaic and obsolete. The requirement that priests remain unmarried and celibate very likely has contributed to many of the priest-related scandals we have seen in recent decades. The patriarchal power structure of the church has led to teachings that are out of step with modern sensitivities. The Confessions of Pope Joan offers us a glimpse of what a new and improved Catholic Church could look like where priests are allowed to marry and women are given prominent leadership roles.
The scenes where Michael Dominic and company follow clues to discover Pope Joan’s diary and St. Salome’s Gospel could be right out of a National Treasure movie, and one particular car chase scene is reminiscent of the Fast & Furious films. The ending is especially poignant as we witness the death of a long beloved character, while at the same time, Michael and Hana are finally free to pursue the relationship they’ve been wanting for the previous nine books.
All in all, The Confessions of Pope Joan hits all the right notes and should not be missed.
February 3, 2024
SOUL STIRRING & EMOTIONAL
OMG! What a pleasure it was to read this latest Book of the Vatican Archive series.
The author, having a flair for combining researched history with fictional narrative, has created yet another captivating and enthralling eye opener.
From Rome to Sherborne to London he takes us on a fascinating expedition filled with riddle solving, excitement, mystery, danger and spirited action.
Inspiring and powerfully moving, Gary McAvoy has done a fantastic job of enlightening us about the historical account of the legendary ninth century female Pope Joan. We get a glimpse of the tragic suppression of women’s voices in the Church throughout the ages, despite the fact that they did play a vital role in the growth of early Christianity.
The usual main characters Father Michael Dominic, Hana Sinclair, Swiss guards Karl and Lukas excel in their sensational exploits to fight for truth and justice. Together with detective Dempsey and others, they must now deal with those radical fundamentalists who will go to great lengths, including murder, to have a newly discovered but crucial journal and an early gospel manuscript destroyed.
This is such a compelling read, the effects of which stay with you long after you have turned the last page. I found this particular one to be quite soul stirring and emotional.
At the end of it all, many wrongs were made right by Papal decree. I got to thinking of how amazing it would be if some of the ‘fictional’ in this story were to actually become ‘factual’ in this day and age. You have ignited a spark Gary McAvoy!
OMG! What a pleasure it was to read this latest Book of the Vatican Archive series.
The author, having a flair for combining researched history with fictional narrative, has created yet another captivating and enthralling eye opener.
From Rome to Sherborne to London he takes us on a fascinating expedition filled with riddle solving, excitement, mystery, danger and spirited action.
Inspiring and powerfully moving, Gary McAvoy has done a fantastic job of enlightening us about the historical account of the legendary ninth century female Pope Joan. We get a glimpse of the tragic suppression of women’s voices in the Church throughout the ages, despite the fact that they did play a vital role in the growth of early Christianity.
The usual main characters Father Michael Dominic, Hana Sinclair, Swiss guards Karl and Lukas excel in their sensational exploits to fight for truth and justice. Together with detective Dempsey and others, they must now deal with those radical fundamentalists who will go to great lengths, including murder, to have a newly discovered but crucial journal and an early gospel manuscript destroyed.
This is such a compelling read, the effects of which stay with you long after you have turned the last page. I found this particular one to be quite soul stirring and emotional.
At the end of it all, many wrongs were made right by Papal decree. I got to thinking of how amazing it would be if some of the ‘fictional’ in this story were to actually become ‘factual’ in this day and age. You have ignited a spark Gary McAvoy!
January 10, 2024
Gary McAvoy’s latest Vatican novel with Father Michael Dominic, Hana Sinclair, and new addition, Robbie Anglicus involves the discovery of documents found within a Codex Anglicus within the Anglicus family in Sherbourn, England. This discovery opens a “Pandora’s Box.” This leads to the discovery of a 9th century female pope’s (Joan) diary, and uncovers a hidden document, the scripture of St. Salome. Each of these items have the potential to create havoc within the Catholic Church.
Attempting to keep St Joan’s writings and St. Salome scripture hidden is Lord Pelham and the Order of Papal Guardians (OPG). OPG’s concern is that bringing this information to light would create a dramatic shift in church doctrine and practice. It could create a loss of trust for the church.
The novel moves smoothly both as a thriller and injecting religious historical information. The arguments for and against the issues of concern are presented well.
Attempting to keep St Joan’s writings and St. Salome scripture hidden is Lord Pelham and the Order of Papal Guardians (OPG). OPG’s concern is that bringing this information to light would create a dramatic shift in church doctrine and practice. It could create a loss of trust for the church.
The novel moves smoothly both as a thriller and injecting religious historical information. The arguments for and against the issues of concern are presented well.
September 26, 2023
The Confessions of Pope Joan, the latest installment in the Vatican Secret Archives series, is another thrilling combination of history, mystery, and action. This time, Father Michael Dominic and his friends team up to protect the diary of a 9th-century pope and a lost 1st-century gospel, both of which challenge Church tradition and just might prove to be catalysts for unparalleled but overdue changes within the Church itself. An enjoyable read on all counts! – Donna Marie West, author of The Mud Man.
January 30, 2024
Revealing
Politics in the Vatican, politics in the Catholic Church, Rome, England, the US, all reaching. And once again Father Michael and Hana stumble into a new quest. In England for a showing of the churches throughout the ages the group go to a friends estate to see his ancient family bible. Within the pages Father Michael finds a sheet of paper tuck in the spine which reveals a poem puzzle sending them to a nearby chapel. Then the race begins, murder, ancient gospel, ancient diary, attempted murder, deceit, espionage, death and some very enlightening moments. There is a very heartfelt ending. Once again, Fact or Fiction is very much appreciated. Great job. Thank you. Can't wait for Book 8.
Politics in the Vatican, politics in the Catholic Church, Rome, England, the US, all reaching. And once again Father Michael and Hana stumble into a new quest. In England for a showing of the churches throughout the ages the group go to a friends estate to see his ancient family bible. Within the pages Father Michael finds a sheet of paper tuck in the spine which reveals a poem puzzle sending them to a nearby chapel. Then the race begins, murder, ancient gospel, ancient diary, attempted murder, deceit, espionage, death and some very enlightening moments. There is a very heartfelt ending. Once again, Fact or Fiction is very much appreciated. Great job. Thank you. Can't wait for Book 8.
February 10, 2024
Intelligent, riveting and well crafted tale!
Excellent adventure featuring characters that are driven, honorable and very human as they navigate the complex challenges they find themselves confronted with. I was impressed and mesmerized by the verbatim of ancient diaries featured in the story. They are beautifully written, conveying the heart and passion of the characters they represented.
Their messages are so appropriate and true that one can’t help but wish they were real. Kudos to the author!
Excellent adventure featuring characters that are driven, honorable and very human as they navigate the complex challenges they find themselves confronted with. I was impressed and mesmerized by the verbatim of ancient diaries featured in the story. They are beautifully written, conveying the heart and passion of the characters they represented.
Their messages are so appropriate and true that one can’t help but wish they were real. Kudos to the author!
October 3, 2023
Fabulous series of books. I loved each one and am now sad that I have to put the characters away.
I loved Gary's tales of the machinations of the Vatican. Good and bad. I'm sure it's probably near the truth. I have long felt Mary Magdalene was not a prostitute. So, Dan Brown and Gary McAvoy are amongst my favourite authors. If only we could all see into the archives. What stories....
These books are murder mystery, political, criminal and an enduring love story.
I loved Gary's tales of the machinations of the Vatican. Good and bad. I'm sure it's probably near the truth. I have long felt Mary Magdalene was not a prostitute. So, Dan Brown and Gary McAvoy are amongst my favourite authors. If only we could all see into the archives. What stories....
These books are murder mystery, political, criminal and an enduring love story.
November 23, 2023
Another great read
I've read the Pope Joan story numerous times, never with the baby twist, and looked a bit into it. Seems to me a female Pope really did exist, possibly 2 since it's said that Lucrezia Borgia took over for her father for a day or two. Something Gary might want to look into for his next story since Borgia cabinets are talked about often.
Enjoyed the book very much, ready to find out what's next.
I've read the Pope Joan story numerous times, never with the baby twist, and looked a bit into it. Seems to me a female Pope really did exist, possibly 2 since it's said that Lucrezia Borgia took over for her father for a day or two. Something Gary might want to look into for his next story since Borgia cabinets are talked about often.
Enjoyed the book very much, ready to find out what's next.
September 23, 2023
This was absolutely absorbing and tantalizing book so far. The subject of priests' marriage and women' service at the church is a hot theme. I loved how seamlessly the author put fiction and real history together and created fast paced historical thriller. I was so sad for the pope Joan and all the obscured facts during the Christian era. But there is always a hope. Michael and Hana are my favorite team. I cannot wait for their next adventure.
Gary, Thank you for another absorbing and interesting story.
Gary, Thank you for another absorbing and interesting story.
October 1, 2023
PLEASE! Tell me this is NOT THE LAST BOOK!
I have read and loved each and every one of Gary McAvoy’s books about Father Michael and Hana. THE STORY MUST CONTINUE!
Not being Catholic, but Lutheran, these books have so enlightened me. I highly recommend starting the series at the first book and reading them all. You’ll find mystery, intrigue, love and excitement!
I have read and loved each and every one of Gary McAvoy’s books about Father Michael and Hana. THE STORY MUST CONTINUE!
Not being Catholic, but Lutheran, these books have so enlightened me. I highly recommend starting the series at the first book and reading them all. You’ll find mystery, intrigue, love and excitement!
October 23, 2023
I sincerely wish the Catholic Church would adopt the reforms mentioned in this book, although I doubt it will ever happen. Women deserve equality in the church in every way. Priests should be allowed to marry. They should also still choose a chaste life. There have been far too many Priest who have secretly broken their pledge of chastity and many who fathered children. That should end.
November 11, 2023
Pope Joan
This installment was very much to my liking. I enjoy the good guys, and despise the bad ones. I was very happy tho, when one of the bad guys saw the light. The ending changes for the Church are hard to imagine in the absence of the fictitious evidence presented in the book, but are sure to create heavy discussion should such evidence be found. Great characters, fine story!
This installment was very much to my liking. I enjoy the good guys, and despise the bad ones. I was very happy tho, when one of the bad guys saw the light. The ending changes for the Church are hard to imagine in the absence of the fictitious evidence presented in the book, but are sure to create heavy discussion should such evidence be found. Great characters, fine story!
September 30, 2023
McAvoy does it again
The latest book by Gary McAvoy is another in a long line of amazing books! Fast moving, gripping and beautifully written. The characters and story are compelling.
The latest book by Gary McAvoy is another in a long line of amazing books! Fast moving, gripping and beautifully written. The characters and story are compelling.
October 3, 2023
Pope Joan
I have read stories that there was a female Pope.They go along with this story.In fact they are in the list of Popes(not an error as imagined)! I believe that this story could have happened as written.Fact is fiction that has been proven.
I have read stories that there was a female Pope.They go along with this story.In fact they are in the list of Popes(not an error as imagined)! I believe that this story could have happened as written.Fact is fiction that has been proven.
October 5, 2023
This is a timely subject that brings up very important matters to be faced by the church. I enjoy all of Gary s books
But this is now my favorite
Thank you envisioning such an enlightened church. I will recommend it to others to read
But this is now my favorite
Thank you envisioning such an enlightened church. I will recommend it to others to read
October 8, 2023
Yet another well done book in the Vatican Secret Archives series. This one was especially well done, not focused so much on car chases and harrowing escapes, but instead focused very well on the reality of the Catholic Church's stance on women. Wouldn't it be remarkable if indeed we had men with the wisdom shown in this book to understand and celebrate the contributions of women as equal to that of men? Sadly, the patriarchy does not move in this direction. The book shows such a remarkable and desirable change that will not happen any time soon. And that is sad.
October 25, 2023
Father Michael Dominic is a complex, but loveable character!
When the most surprising and challenging mystery presents itself to Father Michael Dominic and his friends in Olde England, a fatality occurs to mar their vacation!
When the most surprising and challenging mystery presents itself to Father Michael Dominic and his friends in Olde England, a fatality occurs to mar their vacation!
October 30, 2023
Easy Read
Having been raised Catholic I never understood why as a girl couldn't be a server since I was smarter than most of the boys. I liked this book for it's optimism and gentle push for equality.
Having been raised Catholic I never understood why as a girl couldn't be a server since I was smarter than most of the boys. I liked this book for it's optimism and gentle push for equality.
November 27, 2023
Another Great Story in the Vatican Secret Archives
Mr. McAvoy has created another gem in The Vatican Secret Archives series. The continuity of the base characters continues with enough new characters to build the plot.
I, personally, loved the storyline and all the twists and turns getting to the conclusion.
Mr. McAvoy has created another gem in The Vatican Secret Archives series. The continuity of the base characters continues with enough new characters to build the plot.
I, personally, loved the storyline and all the twists and turns getting to the conclusion.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 93 reviews