2.5. Not as engaging as “Uncle Montague’s Tales of Terror,” and I missed having a frame story.
I also felt like several of the stories were incomplete in some way. Perhaps this is because the “ghoulish twist” was often explained after the fact, therefore many of the stories lacked tension during the telling. Though this technique can work to great effect in some cases, and Priestley wielded it well in ‘The Gilt Frame’ in “UMToT,” the ultimate reveals in this collection were not striking enough to have merited saving the explanation. The best of the bunch, to me, was ‘The Snowman,’ and I enjoyed the church choir tale—though a bit more backstory about singing in a graveyard would not have gone amiss there. The worst tale was ‘The Green Man,’ perhaps because it had so much potential, but several elements in the tale (such as Stephen’s visit to the hill) made little sense given the end.
Still, Priestley includes some striking images and the tales were enjoyable for the holiday season. These would be fun tales to share with your family around a Yule Log, or to listen to as an audiobook during holiday travels.