I have now read five I Survived books. They all follow a predictable format with the main protagonist becoming stuck in the middle of a natural disaster or historic event, but we all know he/she will survive. As I write this review, I just realized the protagonists have all been boys, and it would be nice if Tarshis featured a girl for some of these. I also usually wish the books went into a little more depth, but I think she did a better job focusing on the event with this book.
I really appreciated the illustrations with this one. There was a full page illustration of the planes such as the B-17 bomber. I am not an aviation expert, so I liked getting to see these planes in such detail. At the end, Tarshis also included a timeline of Pearl Harbor with time stamps similar to the 9/11 book. This is a helpful reference for kids. She also answers several questions kids may have such as why the Japanese attacked. She sets the stage by giving a good amount of background information. She also gives light to how Japanese Americans were treated and adds, "The federal government officially apologized in 1983." Finally she discusses Pearl Harbor today with the memorial. "The memorial is built over the sunken battleship [Arizona], which rests in 40 feet of water at the bottom of the harbor. The ship still leaks drops of oil that rise to the surface of the water. ...The drops of oil made me think of the tears that are still shed over the lives lost in the Pearl Harbor attack, and the sorrows of the war that followed." It's hard to fathom 1,177 people were killed on the Arizona when over one million pounds of gunpowder exploded.
Overall, I think Tarshis did a nice job bringing this event to life and honoring the lives lost with her afterword and additional notes. I learned facts I didn't know such as there were several red flags before the attack and mistakes were made by not bringing attention to these. Sadly, this could have been avoided. Hopefully, we have learned from history. With the I Survived series, Tarshis shows kids the importance of history, and I would recommend this to young readers.