What do you think?
Rate this book
Bunte Steine
Bunte Steine
Stifters Erzählungssammlung Bunte Steine erschien 1853 mit der berühmten Vorrede über das »sanfte Gesetz«. Die Erzählungen waren, mit Ausnahme von Katzensilber, bereits in Zeitschriften gedruckt, wurden jedoch für die Buchfassung gründlich überarbeitet. Die Sammlung enthält: Granit, Kalkstein, Turmalin, Bergkristall, Katzensilber und Bergmilch.
392 pages, Paperback
First published January 1, 1853
45 people are currently reading
1011 people want to read
About the author
Adalbert Stifter
467 books84 followersAdalbert Stifter was an Austrian writer, poet, painter, and pedagogue. He was especially notable for the vivid natural landscapes depicted in his writing, and has long been popular in the German-speaking world, while almost entirely unknown to English readers.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 60 reviews
October 19, 2023
As Adalbert Stifter belonged to the Biedermeier period he habitually depicted life conflictless and almost idyllic but due to originality of the plots and their cordiality his tales are quite remarkable.
All the stories in Motley Stones – directly or obliquely – concern children.
Granite is about wagon grease in the present and an outbreak of deadly plague in the past…
Limestone is about a poor and rigorously ascetic pastor who always tried to protect local children from the wrath of nature…
Tourmaline is about kindness and a peculiar orphaned girl…
In Rock Crystal two siblings are lost high in the mountains on Christmas Eve…
Cat-Silver meaning tiny mother-of-pearl flakes is about a mysterious swarthy girl, the terrible hailstorm and the conflagration…
Rock Milk is about the dwellers in the castle and the Napoleonic wars…
When humans abide by cordiality and not by cruelty there are peace and harmony.
All the stories in Motley Stones – directly or obliquely – concern children.
Granite is about wagon grease in the present and an outbreak of deadly plague in the past…
“Would you like to have your feet greased?”
Having always regarded the man as a great curiosity, I felt honored by his familiar manner, and held out both my feet. He dipped his spoon into the hole and went to work, laying one slow stroke on each of my feet. The liquid spread beautifully on the skin, extraordinarily clear and golden brown, and sent up its pleasant resinous fragrance.
Limestone is about a poor and rigorously ascetic pastor who always tried to protect local children from the wrath of nature…
…he went to the holy water stoup that hung beneath the beautifully carved little crucifix, sprinkled himself with the water, and left the room.
By the light of my candle I saw him lie down on the wooden bench in the shallow niche in the spacious vestibule, and place the Bible under his head as a pillow.
Tourmaline is about kindness and a peculiar orphaned girl…
“I was walking along the wide sidewalk, and I saw a raven sitting on the pavement. He wasn’t afraid, it seemed he couldn’t fly, and he walked along ahead of me when I followed him. I bent down, talked to him, reached for him, and he let me pick him up. Mother, I didn’t hurt him, I only petted him. Then a horribly big face looked out of the basement window of the Perron House and cried: ‘Stop, stop.’
“I looked over at the head, its eyes stared, it was very pale, and terribly big. I let the raven go, stood up, and ran home. Mother, I really didn’t hurt him, I only wanted to pet him.”
In Rock Crystal two siblings are lost high in the mountains on Christmas Eve…
After a time they saw crags. They loomed up dark and indistinct from the white and opaque light. As the children approached, they nearly ran into them. The crags rose like a wall, completely perpendicular, so that barely a snowflake could cling to their sides.
Cat-Silver meaning tiny mother-of-pearl flakes is about a mysterious swarthy girl, the terrible hailstorm and the conflagration…
The leaves were beaten down, the twigs were beaten down, the boughs were broken off, the grass was furrowed as though iron spikes had harrowed it. The hailstones were large enough to kill a grown person.
Rock Milk is about the dwellers in the castle and the Napoleonic wars…
When all had made themselves comfortable, when the two youngest children had fallen asleep, and the two oldest had huddled together near their mother by the stove, and the spinning wheels were purring, they fell to telling tales again, but today with great zeal they told tales of the war, each in the hues lent by their separate passions.
When humans abide by cordiality and not by cruelty there are peace and harmony.
sampled
October 3, 2021Had to return this early to the library because apparently someone else in my fair city was jonesing to read some Stifter, as translated by the stellar Isabel Fargo Cole, of Wolfgang Hilbig translation fame. So I read about 2 2/3 of the novellas collected here, having to skim the last third or so of 'Tourmaline' to my chagrin, as it had captivated me more than the others did. The other two I read were 'Granite' (not bad, probably about a three-star read) and 'Rock Crystal,' also previously published by NYRB. I'd been interested in reading the latter for years after reading various friends' reviews here and there, and perhaps built it up too much in my head. It certainly kept my interest, but maybe I just wasn't in the mood for Stifter's style. I very much would have liked to finish the entire book, but I'm having enough trouble finishing books on my own even without other library users cutting short my allotted lending period.
April 19, 2022
I read Stifter's Rock Crystal a couple of years ago and really enjoyed it, but I didn't realize it was actually a mere 1/6 of a larger work, presented here in its totality for what might be its first time in English.
Stifter was an Austrian writer whose life spanned basically Napoleon-to-Bismarck, so the most interesting parts of the Germanic world's long 19th century. However, he shies away from the usual tropes of the time and instead writes quiet and often weird little stories, the "motley stones" of his title. These are steeped in a sadly lost kind of grimm or rural-gothic aesthetic that I cherish. Think Caspar David Friedrich's paintings or maybe the album The Black Rider by Tom Waits and you'll know what I'm talking about. Stifter is more subtle though, letting the darkness simply lie in wait while his characters, mostly children, wander about the hills and dales.
Each story here has a stone as its title.
"Granite": a boy and his grandfather walk the mountains while the old man recounts stories of kids surviving the plague. "Limestone": a land surveyor keeps meeting a mysterious, forlorn pastor in the hills. "Tourmaline": a wealthy man and his daughter vanish into the countryside after his wife has an affair with an actor. "Rock Silver" I reviewed elsewhere, about two kids lost in a blizzard on Christmas Eve. "Cat-Silver": three kids in their manor in the country for the summer start encountering a wild little girl who saves them during a hailstorm. "Rock Milk": a crazy rich midget and his steward, with the latter's family, get accosted by white-cloaked soldiers during the night.
They're all excellent, beautiful, little curious things, hence the title, as Stifter explains in his Intro rebuffing his critics.
Stifter was an Austrian writer whose life spanned basically Napoleon-to-Bismarck, so the most interesting parts of the Germanic world's long 19th century. However, he shies away from the usual tropes of the time and instead writes quiet and often weird little stories, the "motley stones" of his title. These are steeped in a sadly lost kind of grimm or rural-gothic aesthetic that I cherish. Think Caspar David Friedrich's paintings or maybe the album The Black Rider by Tom Waits and you'll know what I'm talking about. Stifter is more subtle though, letting the darkness simply lie in wait while his characters, mostly children, wander about the hills and dales.
Each story here has a stone as its title.
"Granite": a boy and his grandfather walk the mountains while the old man recounts stories of kids surviving the plague. "Limestone": a land surveyor keeps meeting a mysterious, forlorn pastor in the hills. "Tourmaline": a wealthy man and his daughter vanish into the countryside after his wife has an affair with an actor. "Rock Silver" I reviewed elsewhere, about two kids lost in a blizzard on Christmas Eve. "Cat-Silver": three kids in their manor in the country for the summer start encountering a wild little girl who saves them during a hailstorm. "Rock Milk": a crazy rich midget and his steward, with the latter's family, get accosted by white-cloaked soldiers during the night.
They're all excellent, beautiful, little curious things, hence the title, as Stifter explains in his Intro rebuffing his critics.
May 15, 2022
An anthology of six stories, one of which, Rock Crystal, I read several years ago. The others here are as good, or close to such, as that. The first two are shorter and perchance slighter works, but the two longest stories, Limestone and, in particular, Cat-Silver, are impressive. That said, it has to be acknowledged that Stifter is not to everyone’s taste. Some may find the pace of his step-by-step prose a bit tedious, but once you acquire a taste he is very rewarding. I would say that anyone who enjoys Robert Walser will also enjoy Stifter.
September 25, 2019
non immaginavo che dentro le pagine di questo libro si nascondesse il capolavoro che cercavo da tempo. sono sei storie semplici (la prefazione è il manifesto estetico di Stifter) e il modo di guardare queste storie è, come ha detto citati, attraverso due figure simboliche: da una parte c'è un viandante che con bastone e sacco del pellegrino esplora le colline e le montagne, dà un nome agli alberi, insegna a un bambino i nomi delle piante e dei paesaggi; dall'altra parte, c'è un uomo seduto su di una antichissima pietra colorata, immobile. Entrambi hanno lo stesso sguardo: uno sguardo che guarda l'indefinito, soffermandosi qui e là, e rischiarando con la luce intensissima della narrazione di stifter il significato di un oggetto o di un ricordo. Dovunque guarda, però, il viandante contempla la Legge di Dio. Il sommarsi di gesti piccoli e insignificante e le grandi catastrofi del tempo. Tutta ha un suo equilibrio in questo mondo di incanto, eppure c'è qualcosa che incancrenisce quello sguardo, una sottile malinconia che è come una foschia davanti ai suoi occhi; alla maniera di Walser, di Sebald, di Keller, il tono elegiaco di Stifter ci fa capire che qualcosa nel mondo corrode le cose e le proietta nella polvere, ammette con disagio di non far parte di quella realtà "innegabile" di cui fanno parte alberi e pietre; sente la tremenda malinconia del suo essere vano e transitorio.
SEMPLICITÀ
Si apre il cancello del giardino
con la docilità della pagina
che una frequente devozione interroga
e all’interno gli sguardi
non devono fissarsi negli oggetti
che già stanno interamente nella memoria.
Conosco le abitudini e le anime
e quel dialetto di allusioni
che ogni gruppo umano va ordendo.
Non ho bisogno di parlare
né di mentire privilegi;
Bene mi conoscono quelli che mi attorniano,
bene sanno le mie ansie e le mie debolezze.
Ciò è raggiungere il più alto,
quello che forse ci darà il Cielo:
non ammirazioni, né vittorie
ma semplicemente essere ammessi
come parte di una realtà innegabile,
come le pietre e gli alberi.
JLB
SEMPLICITÀ
Si apre il cancello del giardino
con la docilità della pagina
che una frequente devozione interroga
e all’interno gli sguardi
non devono fissarsi negli oggetti
che già stanno interamente nella memoria.
Conosco le abitudini e le anime
e quel dialetto di allusioni
che ogni gruppo umano va ordendo.
Non ho bisogno di parlare
né di mentire privilegi;
Bene mi conoscono quelli che mi attorniano,
bene sanno le mie ansie e le mie debolezze.
Ciò è raggiungere il più alto,
quello che forse ci darà il Cielo:
non ammirazioni, né vittorie
ma semplicemente essere ammessi
come parte di una realtà innegabile,
come le pietre e gli alberi.
JLB
December 18, 2021
Motley Stones, a self-described “assortment of fancies for young hearts” first published in German in 1853, but translated and published in English for the first time this year, is a very strange book. Its six stories revolve around children and their families, but although you can tell that Stifter is trying, quite hard at times, to be sentimental, even to moralize—in that, and that alone, he mostly fails. And although only one story, Tourmaline, is nakedly dark, the darkness is never far from the surface.
Stifter is acutely attuned to nature and landscape, to the way that the world itself changes scale to match the human dramas that give it meaning, now intimate and close, now vast and unknowable. At the same time, he resists the urge to undercut the power and inscrutability of natural forces through personification or domestication.
I suspect that this would be rough going for a reader who wasn’t accustomed to the quirks of 19th-century fiction (on top of which Stifter has quite a few quirks all his own). But then again, perhaps not. Cat Silver, my favorite story in this collection—and one of my favorite things I’ve read in a long time—reminded me of nothing so much as Karin Tidbeck’s Reindeer Mountain, published a good 150 years later. Both stories are about strange women coming down from mountains. And neither story reminds me all that much of anything else I’ve read from the 150-year period that separates them.
Stifter is acutely attuned to nature and landscape, to the way that the world itself changes scale to match the human dramas that give it meaning, now intimate and close, now vast and unknowable. At the same time, he resists the urge to undercut the power and inscrutability of natural forces through personification or domestication.
I suspect that this would be rough going for a reader who wasn’t accustomed to the quirks of 19th-century fiction (on top of which Stifter has quite a few quirks all his own). But then again, perhaps not. Cat Silver, my favorite story in this collection—and one of my favorite things I’ve read in a long time—reminded me of nothing so much as Karin Tidbeck’s Reindeer Mountain, published a good 150 years later. Both stories are about strange women coming down from mountains. And neither story reminds me all that much of anything else I’ve read from the 150-year period that separates them.
Read
February 10, 2025There is a mode that Stifter is able to hit that very few others are able to – an absolutely perfect pastoral. Rock Crystal was in here, which I’d read before, and it was good to revisit in the context of all of these stories of life amid the lowing cows and ice-covered trails of rural Austria. I once commented, after a spell in the Austrian Alps, that the countryside thereabouts was redneck America – thick-necked farmers putting back a few beers at 5:00, gun racks on pickups – but with good public transit, and for that I loved it. And accordingly, Stifter’s stories are perfectly Old World Winesburg, Ohio.
May 21, 2025
There is something that comes across as rather conservative (or at least, conservationist) in Stifter's stories. Really they are attempts at true engagement with nature, in a sort of post-Romantic way. In these stories / novellas, there is always a tricky sort of balance set between the societal (economic) criteria of human life and the harsh and beautiful aesthetic found in nature, in the hills, in the mountains and valleys.
Sometimes rocks are symbols; when they aren't, well, so much worse for the rocks.
Sometimes rocks are symbols; when they aren't, well, so much worse for the rocks.
December 27, 2021
The Christmas Eve story, "Rock Crystal" was captivating to read and fun to ruminate on: the green and warm valley and the mountain with its glacier boulders stars and aurora; the way the mountain is dangerous but also holy; and how being lost on the mountain draws out strength and love from all the characters.
October 27, 2023
SHORT STORIES ARE NOT REALLY MY THING. THERE IS A FAIRY TALE FEEL TP THESE. I LKE BEST THE ONE TITLED GRANIT. THE AITHOR'S DESCRPTIONS OF NATURE ARE WELL DONE.
May 14, 2021
WOW
Holy ****, I had no idea this was coming and have been loving Stifter for years. I must have thrown in the towel on the vague hope that more novellas of Kafka's obese friend (who is in my estimation f/w/i/w lightyears beyond, in a single sentence, all of the findings re: Max Brod/trunk) would be charmingly translated, and lo! - - - collected!
Not to mention, this is without question second best book title of the year. I mean I myself have had four books published this year alone... and three of the four must be tied for first place (the other one is really just more formal for the Platonic Dialogue re: Thomism, Flannery O'Connor, et al),
but yeah, aside from 75% of my publications' titles in 2021, this one gets relatively close second.
I always said to myself, if I ever really needed a job and at the same time had a choice in the matter, it would be something like NYRB Classics. Books like this are cake and point.
Holy ****, I had no idea this was coming and have been loving Stifter for years. I must have thrown in the towel on the vague hope that more novellas of Kafka's obese friend (who is in my estimation f/w/i/w lightyears beyond, in a single sentence, all of the findings re: Max Brod/trunk) would be charmingly translated, and lo! - - - collected!
Not to mention, this is without question second best book title of the year. I mean I myself have had four books published this year alone... and three of the four must be tied for first place (the other one is really just more formal for the Platonic Dialogue re: Thomism, Flannery O'Connor, et al),
but yeah, aside from 75% of my publications' titles in 2021, this one gets relatively close second.
I always said to myself, if I ever really needed a job and at the same time had a choice in the matter, it would be something like NYRB Classics. Books like this are cake and point.
December 27, 2021
And when the oats had vanished at last from the fields, when the hazel bushes lost their color, and the leaves wrinkled and rolled up, when the white patches of stubble on the hills turned brown, when nothing was left in the fields but potatoes cabbage and turnips, when not an apple or a pear was left in the branches of the trees, when even the leaves of those trees were falling, when the flowers that the father had in pots outside the house were taken back into the hothouses, when the blue juniper berries turned bluer and bluer on their bushes, and the green ones swelled and took on a dewy film, when the gossamer spun out again, and the grandmother grew sadder and sadder, and stroked all the children's curls more and more tenderly—they knew that it was time, that they must soon part, gloomy autumn and fog would cover the surroundings, snow and cold would come, and it would be a long time before they could be together. [212]
April 3, 2025
These stories are like the early 1800s German version of Wes Anderson movies. Sentimental and fantastical and dare I say the "T" word? Some of these stories touch the border of being fairy tales. At the very least if you like reading about mountains, this book is full of them. But yeah, if you don't like the sweet stuff, it may rot your teeth.
Recommended reading if you're feeling blue, down in the dumps, in a funk or out of sorts.
Recommended reading if you're feeling blue, down in the dumps, in a funk or out of sorts.
May 18, 2024
I simply loved this book, these stories. They are filled with light, at least that is the impression in my mind. Such compassionate tales, filled with lyrical beauty, mostly unexpected endings, they simply warmed my heart, holding out hope that not all is lost, not all humans are dark and evil, that there is still much kindness in the world and everything need not be complex webs of deceit. Loved it.
June 15, 2021
Incredible. I sincerely hope this is the start of a translation trend for Stifter, though I doubt it. Cat Silver has entered my pantheon of favorite stories. All of them are totally unanticipated, radically strange, and completely gripping. There is nothing else quite like this writer that I have yet encountered, so I only crave more. If you like this, track down Indian Summer if you can…
November 2, 2012
This was a very enjoyable read. I love folk stories and this book provided me with six wonderful ones, all named after minerals and colorful stones found in the mountains. The titles of the separate story have a deeper meaning when you read the story attached to it.
I love them all, but Rockcrystal is an exceptionally wonderful story for Christmas times. I'm not going to spoil anybody interest by telling the content, read it yourself, enjoy it and I'm sure you're as eager as I'm to buy your own copy. I did!
I love them all, but Rockcrystal is an exceptionally wonderful story for Christmas times. I'm not going to spoil anybody interest by telling the content, read it yourself, enjoy it and I'm sure you're as eager as I'm to buy your own copy. I did!
November 21, 2025
What’s everyone’s favorite song by The Motley Stones: “Girls Girls Girls” or “Sympathy For The Devil”?
November 7, 2021
I finished this book yesterday and am still wrapping my head around this. On the surface, the books are extremely simple, and some may call them simplistic. The stories have no drama in them. They flow, from the beginning to the end. The stories are about simple folk, living in villages in Germany.
Yet, the stories are captivating, and the descriptions of nature are stunningly beautiful. The stories possess a gentle rhythm, and you must allow yourself to flow with the gentle tide.
Isabel Fargo Cole's translation is, in my view, magnificent. This is a beautiful book and must be on every storyteller's and story lover's bookshelf.
Read one story a day, no more. Then you will savor the beauty of these tales.
Yet, the stories are captivating, and the descriptions of nature are stunningly beautiful. The stories possess a gentle rhythm, and you must allow yourself to flow with the gentle tide.
Isabel Fargo Cole's translation is, in my view, magnificent. This is a beautiful book and must be on every storyteller's and story lover's bookshelf.
Read one story a day, no more. Then you will savor the beauty of these tales.
September 19, 2024
These stories really sucked me in with their amazing descriptions, multiple layers of narrative, and propelling plots. The translation felt awkward at times ("misfortune column" "Cat's silver"?), but on the other hand, the translator's intro was very strong.
June 9, 2022
Für Freunde gediegener Prosa!
August 27, 2025
Fairy tale-ish, sweet and strange and heartening. Imminent plans to move to the Austrian alps, call me Johnny Alpini
February 19, 2020
A beautiful collection of 6 short stories by an Austrian author Adalbert Stiftler.
The stories feel like folks tales and while there isn't much happening in them they still catch the reader and make them involved in the story. What matters in these stories is the nature. Each is named after a stone and they represent the mood of the story.
It takes place in beautiful Austrian landscapes and their description is absolutely perfect. In Kalkstein we have a landscape that doesn't have much in it, not many trees just a lot emptiness and limestone. It gets well together with the main character who lives a very simple life but has a rich character.
Bergkristal is one of the best stories. The purity and stillness of the snowy landscape where one can't see anything are felt through the whole story and makes one get into the mood of the children experiencing it.
Katzensilber is another one I loved the most. It seems to have most of action in the story and the warmth and brightness of the summer in the nature setting around the grandma's home is also very well felt.
A nice collection with beautiful language and a strongly felt motive of nature and human's place in it.
The stories feel like folks tales and while there isn't much happening in them they still catch the reader and make them involved in the story. What matters in these stories is the nature. Each is named after a stone and they represent the mood of the story.
It takes place in beautiful Austrian landscapes and their description is absolutely perfect. In Kalkstein we have a landscape that doesn't have much in it, not many trees just a lot emptiness and limestone. It gets well together with the main character who lives a very simple life but has a rich character.
Bergkristal is one of the best stories. The purity and stillness of the snowy landscape where one can't see anything are felt through the whole story and makes one get into the mood of the children experiencing it.
Katzensilber is another one I loved the most. It seems to have most of action in the story and the warmth and brightness of the summer in the nature setting around the grandma's home is also very well felt.
A nice collection with beautiful language and a strongly felt motive of nature and human's place in it.
May 26, 2021
Motley Stones is a collection of six tales that (with, perhaps, the exception of the final) feel like cozy bedtime stories for adults. With a focus on fine detailing of the pastoral and the slow, often, mundane every day occurrences, these stories feel appropriate for the time of day when you're winding down. Stifter's descriptions of landscapes and the beauty of the natural world are as pleasing as they are fully realized. In another's hands, these passages would bore and drag a narrative, but here, they are oddly compelling.
Even though, as Stifter himself pointed out in the preface, "It was once said against me that I fashion only small things, and that my people are ordinary people," you never feel constrained by the scope of his worlds. You are instead comforted to know and live among his creations. If only for a short time.
4 stars
Even though, as Stifter himself pointed out in the preface, "It was once said against me that I fashion only small things, and that my people are ordinary people," you never feel constrained by the scope of his worlds. You are instead comforted to know and live among his creations. If only for a short time.
4 stars
July 3, 2021
I am so grateful to NYRB Classics for introducing me to Stifter and for making a significant contribution to the much too short list of his works that have been translated into English. This writing overflows with all the graces, pagan and Christian. And literary. For all the praise I've read of Stifter, it didn't prepare me for what an emotional experience was in store. His catalog of human kindnesses can be overwhelming.
June 8, 2025
Habe nur Turmalin gelesen.
December 30, 2021
The narrators of these stories—the motley stones—are several generations removed from their tales, provided as descriptions of persons of remarkable character. Written in the mid-1800s, Stifter’s tales occur probably around the turn of the 18th century, when Germanic nations were primarily rural, and even the biggest cities were modestly sized by today’s standards. Although the natural world is lavishly described throughout, with eyes and insight worthy of Thoreau, Stifter is primarily interested in inflexible eccentricities. Stifter’s narrators clearly admire these people while also acknowledging that some readers may find them mere fools, while others—like the narrators—are marked for life by the encounters.
One such example is the nameless, ascetic parson in the story “Limestone.” (Spoiler alert!) The parson has a secret cause he’s been stowing away money for—to build, for safety reasons, a new school for the local children. For decades he scrimps and sacrifices, living just above beggary level. Late in the story, after he dies and his will is read, his bequest to the community is revealed—as is the fact that his 30+ years of savings isn’t nearly enough to cover costs. The well-to-do in the area rise to the occasion and raise the funds necessary to fulfill the requirements of the parson’s will.
Stifter does, or did, have his detractors for his attention to small people of small significance. And I can imagine them saying about “Limestone,” “Good lord. Generations of parents risked their children drowning to reach school during deluges on the floodplain. And even though the area had been settled for centuries, it wasn’t until an outsider to the community—the parson—noticed a much safer location for the school already existed—but he didn’t say a word about it until after his death. Who are these people?”
But its Stifter’s attention to minutiae that makes his writing fascinating, so that 50-page story about a boy punished for walking in the house with greased feet becomes a compelling meditation on geography, landscape, history, and human relationships in small communities. Even if we don’t understand a character’s motivation (Why does a cuckolded husband take his daughter and leave a community after his wife has run away? Why does he resign them to a life of poverty, living in the basement of a dilapidated apartment building?), the reactions these characters elicit in the other characters often brings out the best in human compassion. Stifter may be an idealist—not for acting as if the world is nothing but pureness and light—but for insisting there is more inherent good than evil in the world, and that goodness eventually irons out the bad.
One such example is the nameless, ascetic parson in the story “Limestone.” (Spoiler alert!) The parson has a secret cause he’s been stowing away money for—to build, for safety reasons, a new school for the local children. For decades he scrimps and sacrifices, living just above beggary level. Late in the story, after he dies and his will is read, his bequest to the community is revealed—as is the fact that his 30+ years of savings isn’t nearly enough to cover costs. The well-to-do in the area rise to the occasion and raise the funds necessary to fulfill the requirements of the parson’s will.
Stifter does, or did, have his detractors for his attention to small people of small significance. And I can imagine them saying about “Limestone,” “Good lord. Generations of parents risked their children drowning to reach school during deluges on the floodplain. And even though the area had been settled for centuries, it wasn’t until an outsider to the community—the parson—noticed a much safer location for the school already existed—but he didn’t say a word about it until after his death. Who are these people?”
But its Stifter’s attention to minutiae that makes his writing fascinating, so that 50-page story about a boy punished for walking in the house with greased feet becomes a compelling meditation on geography, landscape, history, and human relationships in small communities. Even if we don’t understand a character’s motivation (Why does a cuckolded husband take his daughter and leave a community after his wife has run away? Why does he resign them to a life of poverty, living in the basement of a dilapidated apartment building?), the reactions these characters elicit in the other characters often brings out the best in human compassion. Stifter may be an idealist—not for acting as if the world is nothing but pureness and light—but for insisting there is more inherent good than evil in the world, and that goodness eventually irons out the bad.
January 9, 2022
I had a book come out recently, and thought we got pretty good blurbs: Stifter’s blurbs are from Thomas Mann and Rilke. You can’t do much better than that.
I had never heard of Stifter before reading a review of this volume in the NYRB, but I can see why he was so beloved and influential. The stories- 6 in all, each named after a type of stone- are all somewhat gentle, mostly pastoral tales with a deep appreciation for the countryside, villages and the people that live there, as well as beautifully rendered descriptions of them.
The stories are fairly simple, plotwise, but there’s something deeply compelling about them. They have the edge of myth, of the Brothers Grimm, but are rooted so deeply in what might well be an imagined place that they draw you in. Their unfamiliarity means that you don’t know while reading that everything is going to be fine: but it always is. There are some light touches of the supernatural, especially in the fourth and fifth stories, but they’re largely humanist, especially the final story in the collection, which takes place during the Napoleonic Wars, and has a strong anti-war moral.
The stories are beautifully rendered, and Stifter’s tics- has anyone had more need, and less use, of commas?- add to the charm. It’s a fast read, but lives up to the reputation of a forgotten classic.
I had never heard of Stifter before reading a review of this volume in the NYRB, but I can see why he was so beloved and influential. The stories- 6 in all, each named after a type of stone- are all somewhat gentle, mostly pastoral tales with a deep appreciation for the countryside, villages and the people that live there, as well as beautifully rendered descriptions of them.
The stories are fairly simple, plotwise, but there’s something deeply compelling about them. They have the edge of myth, of the Brothers Grimm, but are rooted so deeply in what might well be an imagined place that they draw you in. Their unfamiliarity means that you don’t know while reading that everything is going to be fine: but it always is. There are some light touches of the supernatural, especially in the fourth and fifth stories, but they’re largely humanist, especially the final story in the collection, which takes place during the Napoleonic Wars, and has a strong anti-war moral.
The stories are beautifully rendered, and Stifter’s tics- has anyone had more need, and less use, of commas?- add to the charm. It’s a fast read, but lives up to the reputation of a forgotten classic.
August 16, 2024
BUNTE STEINE - Adalbert Stifter
Drei Novellen in einem Buch, verfasst im 19. Jahrhundert. Erlebt als Reclam-Hörbuch. 3/5 Sternen.
Stifter erzählt besondere Erzählungen aus dem Alltag der Menschen, wie man sie von Großeltern erzählt bekommt. Ganz normale, alltägliche Figuren, die unheimlich greifbar gemacht werden durch dieses Verhalten.
Stifter schafft es, dass ich diese Personen vor meinen inneren Auge greifen kann, wie es manch moderner Autor nicht schafft.
Die Pest, der Fortschritt der Zeit, Kindheit und Tod, Gott und Nächstenliebe, Erbschaften und verpasste Chancen sind einige Schlagwörter, die die Novellen beschreiben.
Mir springt ins Auge, wie passiv die Autoren dieser Zeit ihre Texte niederschreiben. Es ist eine originäre Schreibform; Zeitgeist. Außerhalb des Hörspieles könnte ich das nicht ertragen, es macht das Verfolgen der Handlung schwierig. Trotzdem liegt es mir am Herzen, es ist auf eine besondere Art und Weise sehr menschlich.
"Granit" wird mir lange Zeit in Erinnerung bleiben. Danke dafür, Stifter.
Ich ziehe einen Stern ab für den Schreibstil und die Länge, da dies ein persönliches Review ist und mir dies abstößt. Einen zweiten für die Novelle Turmalin, welche mir leider gar nicht zusagte.
Drei Novellen in einem Buch, verfasst im 19. Jahrhundert. Erlebt als Reclam-Hörbuch. 3/5 Sternen.
Stifter erzählt besondere Erzählungen aus dem Alltag der Menschen, wie man sie von Großeltern erzählt bekommt. Ganz normale, alltägliche Figuren, die unheimlich greifbar gemacht werden durch dieses Verhalten.
Stifter schafft es, dass ich diese Personen vor meinen inneren Auge greifen kann, wie es manch moderner Autor nicht schafft.
Die Pest, der Fortschritt der Zeit, Kindheit und Tod, Gott und Nächstenliebe, Erbschaften und verpasste Chancen sind einige Schlagwörter, die die Novellen beschreiben.
Mir springt ins Auge, wie passiv die Autoren dieser Zeit ihre Texte niederschreiben. Es ist eine originäre Schreibform; Zeitgeist. Außerhalb des Hörspieles könnte ich das nicht ertragen, es macht das Verfolgen der Handlung schwierig. Trotzdem liegt es mir am Herzen, es ist auf eine besondere Art und Weise sehr menschlich.
"Granit" wird mir lange Zeit in Erinnerung bleiben. Danke dafür, Stifter.
Ich ziehe einen Stern ab für den Schreibstil und die Länge, da dies ein persönliches Review ist und mir dies abstößt. Einen zweiten für die Novelle Turmalin, welche mir leider gar nicht zusagte.
June 6, 2025
A collection of rambling folktales that eventually back into their plots. Rock Crystal is the most memorable, about two children who get lost on a mountain range during an ice storm on Christmas Eve. Rather than focusing on their plots or even being about what they are about, each of the six stories is more interested in describing the environment; the natural landscapes and trees and plants and animals and the birdsongs. That makes them engrossing up to a point, but I ultimately got bored with this collection well before its conclusion. While Stifler's writing is eloquent and informed, this is not a work of nonfiction, and as works of fiction, these stories needed some pruning. If only Stifter could have written for National Geographic.
January 29, 2023
At first I found this rather odd and plotless, but its fable-like quality kept me going. But he's not writing traditional fables, either – there's also something pleasingly subversive about the morality (or amorality) of the stories. It's impossible to ignore the earnest religious belief that underpins a lot of the characters' actions, but I was always left unsure how serious Stifter himself was about it.
By the time I got a few stories in, and then to the last three, I was fully on board. I'm reminded of none other than Kim Stanley Robinson by Stifter's love of science and geography, mixed with deep-time storytelling.
By the time I got a few stories in, and then to the last three, I was fully on board. I'm reminded of none other than Kim Stanley Robinson by Stifter's love of science and geography, mixed with deep-time storytelling.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 60 reviews