What do you think?
Rate this book
Where the Heart Lives #1
Belonging
In the high desert town of Frenchman's Bluff, Idaho, Felicia Kristoffersen has set out to create a future for herself that is better than her painful past. Alone in the world with only her faith to sustain her, she must prove herself as this tiny community's new school teacher. She cannot, must not, fail. But, there are those who never wanted her there to begin with.
Five years after the death of his wife, local merchant Colin Murphy cares about just one thing: raising his daughter, Charity. Colin wants to give her the educational advantages he never had. The new schoolmarm's inexperience doesn't sit well with him, and if this teacher up and marries like the last one did, Charity's heart will be broken once again.
A woman who hasn't known love. A man who lost the love he had. In the midst of the wide, sage-covered plains, each is about to discover that life's bitterest circumstances truly can work together for good.
Five years after the death of his wife, local merchant Colin Murphy cares about just one thing: raising his daughter, Charity. Colin wants to give her the educational advantages he never had. The new schoolmarm's inexperience doesn't sit well with him, and if this teacher up and marries like the last one did, Charity's heart will be broken once again.
A woman who hasn't known love. A man who lost the love he had. In the midst of the wide, sage-covered plains, each is about to discover that life's bitterest circumstances truly can work together for good.
327 pages, Library Binding
First published August 16, 2011
216 people are currently reading
2443 people want to read
About the author
Robin Lee Hatcher
121 books3,252 followersRobin Lee Hatcher is the author of over 95 novels and novellas with more than five million copies of her books in print. She is known for her heartwarming and emotionally charged stories of faith, courage, and love. Her numerous awards include the RITA® Award, Christy Award, Carol Award, HOLT Medallion, National Reader’s Choice Award, and the Faith, Hope & Love Reader’s Choice Award, and she is also the recipient of prestigious Lifetime Achievement Awards from both American Christian Fiction Writers and Romance Writers of America®. When not writing, she enjoys being with her family, spending time in the beautiful Idaho outdoors, Bible art journaling, reading books that make her cry, watching romantic movies, and decorative planning. A mother and grandmother, Robin makes her home on the outskirts of Boise, sharing it with a demanding Papillon dog.
Be sure to follow Robin on BookBub so you'll receive new book and special deal alerts:
https://www.bookbub.com/profile/robin...
Be sure to follow Robin on BookBub so you'll receive new book and special deal alerts:
https://www.bookbub.com/profile/robin...
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 208 reviews
October 21, 2016
OMG!!! I loved this book from the beginning. Maybe because it was about a teacher or maybe because the author is just so fabulous at what she does!!! This story is so amazing I don't know how to put it into words. First off I fell in love with the characters. (Besides Mrs. Summerville XD) Also I love that the main character was a teacher because when I grow up, I want to become a teacher! This story is about Felicia. She was an orphan when she was about 10 and then a couple adopted her but they didn't love her. She then goes to Idaho to become a teacher. Colin didn't want a new teacher. The last one left about a month later after she got here. But after a while he starts to open his heart to Felicia. I hope you guys love this book as much as I did!
January 11, 2012
i don't normally read christian fiction. i don't want to be preached at. although a christian of sorts, my beliefs are very different from the christian right, who usually write christian fiction.
that said, i read this because several years ago i also read one of the prolific ms. hatcher's books. i like historical american fiction. i thoroughly enjoyed this book. the story was believable, the dialogue realistic, the characters well developed. the christian references were not offensive to me. although the bible was quoted, it wasn't done awkwardly, nor was it preachy. it fit the character, and didn't detract from the story.
i highly recommend this book. it is an enjoyable read, and a quick read in spite of the length of 273 pages. although i am not overly upset by novels with sex scenes, those who do like sex-free novels/romances will enjoy this read.
that said, i read this because several years ago i also read one of the prolific ms. hatcher's books. i like historical american fiction. i thoroughly enjoyed this book. the story was believable, the dialogue realistic, the characters well developed. the christian references were not offensive to me. although the bible was quoted, it wasn't done awkwardly, nor was it preachy. it fit the character, and didn't detract from the story.
i highly recommend this book. it is an enjoyable read, and a quick read in spite of the length of 273 pages. although i am not overly upset by novels with sex scenes, those who do like sex-free novels/romances will enjoy this read.
Read
July 18, 2016What a delight to "help" (as the author) each of the three orphans in the Where the Heart Lives series find happiness. It's one of the perks of being a novelist.
November 11, 2018
I lost myself in this one, perhaps it was a little predictable but I enjoyed it thoroughly. A good Christian fiction with all the trappings.
June 6, 2012
I really enjoyed this story and read it quickly. There were a lot of things to like about it. First, there were Scriptures quoted by the heroine, Felicia, and her random thoughts about the Bible. This fit her personality so well that it seemed like a natural way for her to think. Sometimes in Christian novels the faith element feels a bit contrived or forced, but not so in this book. I loved the scene where the hero caught her praying. I could feel her joy and his wonder at the sight of her communing with God. I also felt his indignation when the town's busybody tried to insinuate things were less than pure in their relationship.
The hero, Colin, was amazing and hard not to fall for. I felt his pride when he was learning to read through his daughter's lessons. Also, the fact that the secondary character, Kathleen, had an occasional point of view helped me understand the other perspectives. I wanted to give Kathleen a high-five every time she stood up to her mother-in-law, and the same for Colin. It was hard not to root for Felicia's friendships because she'd finally found people who truly cared for the first time since she was orphaned.
Felicia was a very sympathetic character and precious in the way she interacted with people and the way she saw the world. Having met the author before, in some ways Felicia's personality reminds me of Robin's. She is genuine, caring, and sweet-spirited. It's hard not to admire someone like that. Felicia wanted to belong and she wanted to love the children in the town and teach them. It was impossible not to want that for her as a reader. I feel like we became friends as I read the story and I can't wait to read the next book in the series.
This was a sweet romance, but I felt the love developing between them and it was beautiful and emotionally moving to see the love slowly blossoming in their hearts for each other. When he finally kissed her...well, it left me a bit breathless. That was the most romantic scene in the book, and one of the most romantic scenes I've read in a long time. Sigh. Very emotionally satisfying story and I was sad when it ended. But there is another book coming out in the series, and I'm excited about it!
The hero, Colin, was amazing and hard not to fall for. I felt his pride when he was learning to read through his daughter's lessons. Also, the fact that the secondary character, Kathleen, had an occasional point of view helped me understand the other perspectives. I wanted to give Kathleen a high-five every time she stood up to her mother-in-law, and the same for Colin. It was hard not to root for Felicia's friendships because she'd finally found people who truly cared for the first time since she was orphaned.
Felicia was a very sympathetic character and precious in the way she interacted with people and the way she saw the world. Having met the author before, in some ways Felicia's personality reminds me of Robin's. She is genuine, caring, and sweet-spirited. It's hard not to admire someone like that. Felicia wanted to belong and she wanted to love the children in the town and teach them. It was impossible not to want that for her as a reader. I feel like we became friends as I read the story and I can't wait to read the next book in the series.
This was a sweet romance, but I felt the love developing between them and it was beautiful and emotionally moving to see the love slowly blossoming in their hearts for each other. When he finally kissed her...well, it left me a bit breathless. That was the most romantic scene in the book, and one of the most romantic scenes I've read in a long time. Sigh. Very emotionally satisfying story and I was sad when it ended. But there is another book coming out in the series, and I'm excited about it!
October 22, 2022
There is something about this book that I really didn't like, I don't know exactly what it is and it frustrates me so much. I think part of it was maybe how short the book was. It's decent size for a normal book, but I would have loved to spend more time on the characters... it all moved a bit too fast for my taste and I think I would have enjoyed this a lot better if it was longer.
The plot line itself was pretty nice, reminded me a bit of Christy by Catherine Marshall. But the characters, save for that nasty Mrs. Summerville, were just too nice. It sounds weird, but I wish there would have been only one or two characters (excluding the children) that liked her at first and then towards the end have everyone warm up to her. Or maybe have her dive more into her hardship with Daniel a bit more... I don't know. This book I think didn't really have an aim except to have Felicia and Colin end up together.
The characters were not as developed as I would have liked. For the reasons I mentioned above, and the fact that characters are introduced but really brought back into the story again. We never find out how they are doing, which isn't necessary for some books but for this one I would have liked to see that. They didn't feel real to me, honestly.
All in all, I may read this book again. But not if I others in my possession.
The plot line itself was pretty nice, reminded me a bit of Christy by Catherine Marshall. But the characters, save for that nasty Mrs. Summerville, were just too nice. It sounds weird, but I wish there would have been only one or two characters (excluding the children) that liked her at first and then towards the end have everyone warm up to her. Or maybe have her dive more into her hardship with Daniel a bit more... I don't know. This book I think didn't really have an aim except to have Felicia and Colin end up together.
The characters were not as developed as I would have liked. For the reasons I mentioned above, and the fact that characters are introduced but really brought back into the story again. We never find out how they are doing, which isn't necessary for some books but for this one I would have liked to see that. They didn't feel real to me, honestly.
All in all, I may read this book again. But not if I others in my possession.
December 19, 2022
A great introduction to a series of books about three orphaned siblings who left Chicago on the Orphan Train and came west to Wyoming. They were separated, and this story is about the middle girl, Felicia. She ended up with a couple who basically used her for hired help, and when they passed on, she was left alone and adrift, with only her skills as a teacher to depend on. Well, that and her faith in God. She answers an ad for a teacher in a small town in Idaho, eager to prove herself as a teacher, but not realizing she is stepping into a tangle of situations that will really try her faith.
I really enjoyed and appreciated the poems and scripture references the author used throughout the story, and the prayers offered up by Felicia and others. There were several great story lines, and some wonderful endearing characters. I'm looking forward to finding the next book in the series and reading about Felicia's brother Hugh.
I really enjoyed and appreciated the poems and scripture references the author used throughout the story, and the prayers offered up by Felicia and others. There were several great story lines, and some wonderful endearing characters. I'm looking forward to finding the next book in the series and reading about Felicia's brother Hugh.
April 3, 2013
I can't really say I enjoyed anything about this book. The plot, characters, everything has been done a million times before and better. Can no relationship be built without first being prejudiced against one another, then a bond over a child, and then *the clincher* falling in love over being rescued (most likely from a near-drowning)? Then of course, there is a misunderstanding, causing one to flee and another to follow after them, culminating in a undying love confession in a train station.
ugh.
The best stories have characters who change, who are flawed, real, relatable. They have plots and events that could happen to anyone, things that happen regularly. This had NONE of that.
If you want good historical fiction, try Lawana Blackwell's Gresham series. Sadly, I've not come across another like it.
ugh.
The best stories have characters who change, who are flawed, real, relatable. They have plots and events that could happen to anyone, things that happen regularly. This had NONE of that.
If you want good historical fiction, try Lawana Blackwell's Gresham series. Sadly, I've not come across another like it.
May 17, 2022
Felicia Kristopherson moves to Idaho to teach school. Leaving a past of being an orphan raised on a farm and her siblings who went MIA as children, she sets out on her own. The characters weren't overly characterized and the storyline moved along nicely. Narrator was good.
July 3, 2023
Se me ha hecho un poco pesada al final la parte de ficción cristiana. El resto, aunque yo sé que está un poco trillada la temática de "maestra va a pueblo del oeste", es un tipo de historia que a mí me gusta. Hubiera agradecido que hubieran desarrollado eso algo más con problemáticas de los alumnos y retos a los que se tuviera que enfrentar ella.
En resumen, no ha estado mal, pero esperaba más.
En resumen, no ha estado mal, pero esperaba más.
August 5, 2024
I absolutely loved this book. I finally got time Sunday to sit down and read. I finished most of the book in one day. I loved the faith content. I loved the slow burn romance.
If you want a book where the couple kisses before the halfway point, this is not it. I loved Charity as well. She was super cute. I couldn’t imagine having a hard time being able to read and have previous teachers basically say she should become a great cook.
I love the patience Felicia had for Charity. I love the build up of the relationship between Colin and Felicia. Will be reading more of Hatcher.
------
I am going to have to sit on my feelings. Not sure what to rate this yet.
If you want a book where the couple kisses before the halfway point, this is not it. I loved Charity as well. She was super cute. I couldn’t imagine having a hard time being able to read and have previous teachers basically say she should become a great cook.
I love the patience Felicia had for Charity. I love the build up of the relationship between Colin and Felicia. Will be reading more of Hatcher.
------
I am going to have to sit on my feelings. Not sure what to rate this yet.
July 30, 2024
4.1 your typical day western religious romance . Predictable but I enjoyed a light read.
In the high desert town of Frenchman's Bluff, Idaho, Felicia Kristoffersen has set out to create a future for herself that is better than her painful past. Alone in the world with only her faith to sustain her, she must prove herself as this tiny community's new school teacher. She cannot, must not, fail. But, there are those who never wanted her there to begin with.
Five years after the death of his wife, local merchant Colin Murphy cares about just one thing: raising his daughter, Charity. Colin wants to give her the educational advantages he never had. The new schoolmarm's inexperience doesn't sit well with him, and if this teacher up and marries like the last one did, Charity's heart will be broken once again.
A woman who hasn't known love. A man who lost the love he had.
In the midst of the wide, sage-covered plains, each is about to discover that life's bitterest circumstances truly can work together for good.
In the high desert town of Frenchman's Bluff, Idaho, Felicia Kristoffersen has set out to create a future for herself that is better than her painful past. Alone in the world with only her faith to sustain her, she must prove herself as this tiny community's new school teacher. She cannot, must not, fail. But, there are those who never wanted her there to begin with.
Five years after the death of his wife, local merchant Colin Murphy cares about just one thing: raising his daughter, Charity. Colin wants to give her the educational advantages he never had. The new schoolmarm's inexperience doesn't sit well with him, and if this teacher up and marries like the last one did, Charity's heart will be broken once again.
A woman who hasn't known love. A man who lost the love he had.
In the midst of the wide, sage-covered plains, each is about to discover that life's bitterest circumstances truly can work together for good.
September 5, 2017
Felicia Kristofferson leaves Wyoming after her parents' death when she finds out she was never legally adopted and can't therefore inherit their farm. She accepted a teaching position in a small town in Iowa. From the beginning she has to deal with the dislike of the town's 'elite'.
I'll admit I'm no more that much into historical fiction and only started this book because I needed one set in Iowa. After the first chapter I was hooked and loved the book very much. I loved the characters especially the both MCs, Charity (his daughter) and Kathleen (her friend) and their development within the story. The story was very interesting and I struggled to put the book down.
I rated the book 4 stars because there were parts that appeared not very realistic. Despite this little flaw I'm already looking forward to continue this trilogy.
I'll admit I'm no more that much into historical fiction and only started this book because I needed one set in Iowa. After the first chapter I was hooked and loved the book very much. I loved the characters especially the both MCs, Charity (his daughter) and Kathleen (her friend) and their development within the story. The story was very interesting and I struggled to put the book down.
I rated the book 4 stars because there were parts that appeared not very realistic. Despite this little flaw I'm already looking forward to continue this trilogy.
February 20, 2021
Captivating!! I got so lost in this book, I could not put it down! I’m usually not one for lovey dovey Christian fictions but this was truly great. I especially loved the scriptures that were quoted by the main character, Felicia, and all her random thoughts about God and the Bible. It was all written so well and fit her personality.
March 22, 2018
Hmm this is not really the type of book I would normally read, I will say it was well written but just too much Christianity and romance for me! Others will love it however not me - sorry!
March 19, 2019
Ive read " belonging " ,, a recommendation from @dhuhaaalhaddad 😍.. i wanted sweet christian fiction and it was indeed sweet ,, i enjoyed it so much 😍 i gave it 4 out of 5 stars
December 26, 2020
Enjoyable read, two lost people not looking for love but of course find it anyway. Happy ever after with some interesting teasers about the other two books in the series.
August 27, 2025
Nothing like a good Christian romance to calm the spirit. Robin is a great author!
October 27, 2011
Following the death of her parents, Felicia Kristoffersen chooses to embrace the opportunity she had to sacrifice in order to help the aging couple who once took her into their family. She starts over as the new schoolmarm in Frenchman's Bluff, Idaho. She's determined to make an impression upon those who didn't want her as the schoolmarm--especially Colin Murphy.
Colin Murphy voted against Miss Kristofferesen as the new schoolmarm. After all, the other single schoolmarms up and left after finding a husband and marrying, leaving behind school children who felt that loss--including his own daughter, Charity. He doesn't want to see his daughter hurt when this schoolmarm does the same thing. As he gets to know Felicia, he realizes he just may be wrong about her motives for taking the position . . .and his own feelings toward her start to change. . .so much so that he can no longer avoid the very thing he was once against . . .taking away the town's schoolmarm.
Belonging will keep you hanging on every word. I couldn't put it down. This novel is filled with sophisticated prose and writing, as well as outstanding characters and a compelling plot.
I have to admit the writing style and tone in this novel appears to be different from any of Robin Lee Hatcher's previous works--which is both enjoyable and refreshing. While I've enjoyed Robin Lee Hatcher's other stories, I took to the style of writing, and the story itself, more than her others.
I loved seeing the use of historical idiomatic phrases this story. If you aren't familiar with historical idiomatic phrases, some of them might have you scratching your head for half-a-second, but most--if not all--are fairly easy to figure out.
I wish the trouble maker in this story had been a little more fleshed out, as far as motive goes. While I can understand what drove her despicable actions, I'm not sure what drove the motive for her actions. The one given to us didn't seem entirely too realistic. With that said, this trouble maker accomplished getting under my skin. I even found myself wishing she weren't a fictional character so I could give her a piece of my own mind.
All in all, this has to be one of my favorites by Robin Lee Hatcher. I definitely recommend it. Fans of schoolmarm stories, will absolutely love Belonging.
I received a complimentary copy of this book from Zondervan Publishers, via NetGalley, in exchange for an honest review.
Colin Murphy voted against Miss Kristofferesen as the new schoolmarm. After all, the other single schoolmarms up and left after finding a husband and marrying, leaving behind school children who felt that loss--including his own daughter, Charity. He doesn't want to see his daughter hurt when this schoolmarm does the same thing. As he gets to know Felicia, he realizes he just may be wrong about her motives for taking the position . . .and his own feelings toward her start to change. . .so much so that he can no longer avoid the very thing he was once against . . .taking away the town's schoolmarm.
Belonging will keep you hanging on every word. I couldn't put it down. This novel is filled with sophisticated prose and writing, as well as outstanding characters and a compelling plot.
I have to admit the writing style and tone in this novel appears to be different from any of Robin Lee Hatcher's previous works--which is both enjoyable and refreshing. While I've enjoyed Robin Lee Hatcher's other stories, I took to the style of writing, and the story itself, more than her others.
I loved seeing the use of historical idiomatic phrases this story. If you aren't familiar with historical idiomatic phrases, some of them might have you scratching your head for half-a-second, but most--if not all--are fairly easy to figure out.
I wish the trouble maker in this story had been a little more fleshed out, as far as motive goes. While I can understand what drove her despicable actions, I'm not sure what drove the motive for her actions. The one given to us didn't seem entirely too realistic. With that said, this trouble maker accomplished getting under my skin. I even found myself wishing she weren't a fictional character so I could give her a piece of my own mind.
All in all, this has to be one of my favorites by Robin Lee Hatcher. I definitely recommend it. Fans of schoolmarm stories, will absolutely love Belonging.
I received a complimentary copy of this book from Zondervan Publishers, via NetGalley, in exchange for an honest review.
November 26, 2011
Reading Christian Fiction , like any genre can become a bit tiresome as it all starts to blend in together and the overall feeling of formula fiction kicks in every time you read . However, amongst all those books , there are a few authors that will bring out an amazing novel and will re-inforce and remind you why you read that genre continuously.
Belonging by Robin Lee Hatcher , the first in a new series Where the Heart Lives was one of those books that remind you why you read as it was an excellent story from the pace of the novel and the ability to capture the reader's attention as you moved swiftly from one page to the next. Belonging features a young woman named Felicia whose adopted parents have just passed and now she has been given the option to either leave and strike out on her own or marry her cousin Gunther. However, as the story goes along we can see that they never really gave her an option as she starts to receive threatening letters . As a young woman ,we read the prejudices that Felicia has to overcome as a young, unmarried woman and teacher in a world where men seemed to rule. What I loved about Belonging is that Felicia's background of being an orphan and travelling on the orphan train is weaved throughout the novel and we also read as she searches for her siblings which I hope to read the next books in the series to see if she will be reunited with her brother Hugh and sister Diana. Belonging reminded me of the novel by Kim Vogel Sawyer - My Heart Remembers.
Belonging by Robin Lee Hatcher , the first in a new series Where the Heart Lives was one of those books that remind you why you read as it was an excellent story from the pace of the novel and the ability to capture the reader's attention as you moved swiftly from one page to the next. Belonging features a young woman named Felicia whose adopted parents have just passed and now she has been given the option to either leave and strike out on her own or marry her cousin Gunther. However, as the story goes along we can see that they never really gave her an option as she starts to receive threatening letters . As a young woman ,we read the prejudices that Felicia has to overcome as a young, unmarried woman and teacher in a world where men seemed to rule. What I loved about Belonging is that Felicia's background of being an orphan and travelling on the orphan train is weaved throughout the novel and we also read as she searches for her siblings which I hope to read the next books in the series to see if she will be reunited with her brother Hugh and sister Diana. Belonging reminded me of the novel by Kim Vogel Sawyer - My Heart Remembers.
December 14, 2011
This one is quite possibly my favorite book by Ms. Hatcher so far. This book has it all, with an engaging, yet traditional story line that moves along swiftly and characters that move you, and easily draw one in.
Felicia is a schoolteacher in Idaho, during the late 1800's, determined to help her students learn. But there are some things--and people that stand in her way. What can she do to gain the trust of the town, and convince them to let her stay?
Well written, and very engaging, I loved this book from the get-go.
I was aurprisedd at how much I liked all three of the main characters, because often I only like one or none of them, but this time I loved them all! Each of the main characters was well written, with their own unique backstory. I was intrigued and drawn in by every single one of them. though if I had to choose which one I liked best I'm going to say that I really liked Kathleen and her story alot :) The side character were also amazing, though, of course I had to dislike the villian :)
Overall, I thoroughly enjoyed this story, it was exactily what I wanted out of this sweet romance. The plot was excellent as were the characters. The plot moved steadily, even to the point of keeping me up late! For me it was the perfect book at the perfect time and I enjoyed it immensely, and will most certainly be recommending this book :)
I received this book from the publisher in return for an honest review, which I have done my best to express here. Thanks :)
Felicia is a schoolteacher in Idaho, during the late 1800's, determined to help her students learn. But there are some things--and people that stand in her way. What can she do to gain the trust of the town, and convince them to let her stay?
Well written, and very engaging, I loved this book from the get-go.
I was aurprisedd at how much I liked all three of the main characters, because often I only like one or none of them, but this time I loved them all! Each of the main characters was well written, with their own unique backstory. I was intrigued and drawn in by every single one of them. though if I had to choose which one I liked best I'm going to say that I really liked Kathleen and her story alot :) The side character were also amazing, though, of course I had to dislike the villian :)
Overall, I thoroughly enjoyed this story, it was exactily what I wanted out of this sweet romance. The plot was excellent as were the characters. The plot moved steadily, even to the point of keeping me up late! For me it was the perfect book at the perfect time and I enjoyed it immensely, and will most certainly be recommending this book :)
I received this book from the publisher in return for an honest review, which I have done my best to express here. Thanks :)
November 26, 2011
Robin Lee Hatcher is sharing another wonderful story with us! She has gifted us with some wonderful characters that we can be absorbed into.
The Tale is set in Idaho in the late 1800's, Felicia Kistofferson has arrived in Frenchman's Bluff to become the Teacher. Her life hasn't been easy, she became an orphan, when her Mom died. Put into an orphanage in Chicago, she was put on the Orphan Train, and taken by a couple, that wanted a Housekeeper. She was under the impression that the Kristofferson's had adopted her, but sadly when they passed, she found out the truth!
Colin Murphy has been raising his daughter on his own, since his wife passed 5 years prior. He doesn't like the idea of a teacher with no experience, and figures she won't last.
The town, like most small towns has a busy body that rules!! You wonder if things will work out the way the one who rules wants, or the way God wants?
There is a lot warm fuzzy feelings in this book, loved how when things go wrong there is someone there to help. Makes you wish you lived there! Throughout the whole story I Loved the deepening relationships with God!
Included at the end of the book is an Epilogue...yes how I love that. You get to glimpse the future!
I received this book from Netgalley and the Publisher Zondervan, and was not required to give a positive review.
The Tale is set in Idaho in the late 1800's, Felicia Kistofferson has arrived in Frenchman's Bluff to become the Teacher. Her life hasn't been easy, she became an orphan, when her Mom died. Put into an orphanage in Chicago, she was put on the Orphan Train, and taken by a couple, that wanted a Housekeeper. She was under the impression that the Kristofferson's had adopted her, but sadly when they passed, she found out the truth!
Colin Murphy has been raising his daughter on his own, since his wife passed 5 years prior. He doesn't like the idea of a teacher with no experience, and figures she won't last.
The town, like most small towns has a busy body that rules!! You wonder if things will work out the way the one who rules wants, or the way God wants?
There is a lot warm fuzzy feelings in this book, loved how when things go wrong there is someone there to help. Makes you wish you lived there! Throughout the whole story I Loved the deepening relationships with God!
Included at the end of the book is an Epilogue...yes how I love that. You get to glimpse the future!
I received this book from Netgalley and the Publisher Zondervan, and was not required to give a positive review.
February 12, 2013
After losing their mother at a young age, Felicia and her two siblings board the orphan train in Chicago, bound for the West. Felicia lived on a farm in Wyoming with her new family, separated from her two siblings. After the death of her new parents, she moves to a small town in Idaho to become their schoolmarm.
Colin, the local mercantile owner, is part of the schoolboard and has offered his little cottage behind his store to the new school teacher, Felicia. As their lives intertwine, will loss from both of them in their past hold them back to love in the present? Will Felicia ever find a place to call home? You'll find out when opening up this delightful story set in the late 1800's Idaho Territory. A wonderfully quick read will delight you even after you turn the last page!
Colin, the local mercantile owner, is part of the schoolboard and has offered his little cottage behind his store to the new school teacher, Felicia. As their lives intertwine, will loss from both of them in their past hold them back to love in the present? Will Felicia ever find a place to call home? You'll find out when opening up this delightful story set in the late 1800's Idaho Territory. A wonderfully quick read will delight you even after you turn the last page!
April 10, 2013
In general this is an enjoyable light historical romance with Christian theme. The main storyline is a classic historic, romance between Felicia, the new school teacher, and Colin Murphy, a local merchant. The story is well written and really warm, too. Bible quotes were a bit to much, but were nicely integrated with the characters.
March 7, 2018
Feb. 2014: I'm so glad I found this series. I've enjoyed all 3- even reading them in reverse. Haha This was a sweet love story. A hot man, beautiful teacher, a lady I wanted to punch in the face... It was great. :)
March 2018: 4 stars Looking forward to reading this series again.
March 2018: 4 stars Looking forward to reading this series again.
March 25, 2012
I loved this book. A great story about a school teacher with no family who longs for love.
August 23, 2021
A good story and well written . I thought it was very enjoyable.
December 23, 2012
Belonging (Where the Heart Lives #1) by Robin Lee Hatcher
Page Count: 277
Release Date: 23 August 2011
Publisher: Zondervan
Source: Complimentary copy provided by publisher in exchange for an honest and unbiased review (thank you!!)
Review: At ten, Felicia Brennan Kristofferson was orphaned; at twenty-six, she was orphaned for the second time. The deaths of her adoptive parents leaves her completely independent—save the malicious "cousin" who wants her to marry into the Kristofferson family to face the fate of inevitable domestic houselife—so the teaching job that brings her to Frenchman's Bluff, Idaho, is a haven—a godsend.
The small, close-knit town welcomes Felicia with open arms, but there are a few who underestimate and actually disapprove of her position. Their suspicions are not without reason, however; the previous two schoolteachers each stayed less than one year each, before marrying off and ditching the children completely, so some parents are concerned she just may be taking advantage of the job, as the others did.
Felicia's incredible dedication to her career, her students, and to God, however, proves that she only has one motive to be in Frenchman's Bluff, and that is to serve the Lord and the children. Her heart contains nothing pureness, and maybe a few nostalgic bruises; she is determined to take this fresh start and make it right. I was amazed at how well and how deeply her character is explored. All of the characters are remarkably well-developed, secondary characters included. I loved the good guys and hated the bad; Hatcher makes it very easy to tap into the minds of each cast member, from the main character, to the antagonist, which I know is not an easy feat in and of itself.
The plot is tasteful and well-crafted, incorporating bits of Christian values smoothly. The storyline is not terribly exciting, but it's planned perfectly, and mighty clever. The development of Felicia's relationships with all the townspeople, as well as with Colin and Charity, is a real treat. While I did like how the inspirational messages weren't forced, I did feel sometimes the book was unreasonably preachy. Felicia silently prays or makes a plea to God at every ill thought and every remote turn in plan; not only is this slightly annoying, but it's also unnecessary. As a character, she's irritatingly sensitive; she tears up at every reminder of her past. I know it's sad, and I know she's a fragile woman, but that kind of behavior is girly (in a bad way) and weak. I would have liked to have seen more strength from Felicia—the kind of strength acquired over ten years, of overcoming the heartbreak of being torn apart from family at a young age. Colin's character is a bit more relatable; he too, has an upsetting past, but his safe, widowed, day-to-day life is his own way of recovery. His dedication to his daughter, especially, is incredibly real and hits close to home.
Stylistically, Hatcher is a gem. Her words flow smoothly and beautifully. The procession of the story moves seamlessly; I didn't have to plod through it at all! One thing that did irk me was the curtness of the dialogue: lots of one-worded responses from not just one, but all of the characters. Maybe this was the norm in 1897, but to me, it just sounds unwelcoming. The deep probing of—the scars, fears, and secrets of—each of the characters' minds makes up for it, though. I really have no complaints on how Hatcher chose to portray her characters fully.
I cannot confidently classify this as a romance novel. In the traditional sense, yes, it's a romance in that boy meets girl on the first page and boy gets girl by the last, but it's rather unorthodox. There is no attraction—in fact, there is unattraction—until about halfway throughout. Then small, totally non-sexual, tingly feelings rise in Colin and Felicia's stomachs whenever they see each other—more than a several times—and then they abruptly SPOILER get married and live happily ever after. I will say their relationship is complex, especially with Colin's initial reservations and Felicia's interaction with his young daughter, but it just didn't seem at all romantic to me. It bothered me that Colin's character is compromised when it is revealed that he never was in love with his wife. He loved her, of course, and is still grieving her death, but his marriage to her is described as "practical." I feel this is uncharacteristic and was only included so that his relationship could further with Felicia. Again, this makes the so-called romance unrealistic and a bit stilted. For a content advisory, there isn't one; the romance is 100% chaste (absolutely no sex, absolutely no physical interaction except at the end—in hindsight, this may be why I didn't enjoy it as much) because it sticks to traditional 19th century Christian values.
The power of staying faithful to God and leading life with a pure, wholesome outlook prove to be the key to happiness in Belonging. Through Felicia, readers understand and rejoice because, no matter what troubles and turmoils arise, God always saves and protects. Accidents will occur, plans will be ruined, and people will try to get in the way, but in the end, maintaining a loving, kind heart is what makes individuals truly belong.
Pros: Amazing character development // Easy, smooth flow to story; book moves and finishes quickly // Well-penned writing style // Colin and Felicia have a strong rapport, though not necessarily a romance // Strong morals on family and love // Believable situations and characters // Not too dense with historical information; fictional town and setting actually quite charming
Cons: Slightly preachy in religious message // Felicia is pathetic at times // Romance is poorly developed // Dialogue sometimes unrealistic and lacks emotion
Love: Kathleen could scarcely believe those words had come out of her mouth ... She must be losing her mind.
Or perhaps she was beginning to find it.
Verdict: Belonging is a heartwarming, clean, and gorgeously-crafted Christian historical that encompasses an absence—and a discovery—of belonging, a passion for God, and a huge misunderstanding, or rather: several small misunderstandings that constitute for one conflict of fate. By demonstrating the importance of determination, dedication, and faith, Belonging conveys the almighty power of love—for God, for family, and for oneself through one woman's search for a place to belong. The religious undertone is strong, and the characterization, stronger; Hatcher has succeeded in telling an inspirational, absorbing, and completely feel-good story.
8 hearts: An engaging read; highly recommended.
Page Count: 277
Release Date: 23 August 2011
Publisher: Zondervan
Source: Complimentary copy provided by publisher in exchange for an honest and unbiased review (thank you!!)
Review: At ten, Felicia Brennan Kristofferson was orphaned; at twenty-six, she was orphaned for the second time. The deaths of her adoptive parents leaves her completely independent—save the malicious "cousin" who wants her to marry into the Kristofferson family to face the fate of inevitable domestic houselife—so the teaching job that brings her to Frenchman's Bluff, Idaho, is a haven—a godsend.
The small, close-knit town welcomes Felicia with open arms, but there are a few who underestimate and actually disapprove of her position. Their suspicions are not without reason, however; the previous two schoolteachers each stayed less than one year each, before marrying off and ditching the children completely, so some parents are concerned she just may be taking advantage of the job, as the others did.
Felicia's incredible dedication to her career, her students, and to God, however, proves that she only has one motive to be in Frenchman's Bluff, and that is to serve the Lord and the children. Her heart contains nothing pureness, and maybe a few nostalgic bruises; she is determined to take this fresh start and make it right. I was amazed at how well and how deeply her character is explored. All of the characters are remarkably well-developed, secondary characters included. I loved the good guys and hated the bad; Hatcher makes it very easy to tap into the minds of each cast member, from the main character, to the antagonist, which I know is not an easy feat in and of itself.
The plot is tasteful and well-crafted, incorporating bits of Christian values smoothly. The storyline is not terribly exciting, but it's planned perfectly, and mighty clever. The development of Felicia's relationships with all the townspeople, as well as with Colin and Charity, is a real treat. While I did like how the inspirational messages weren't forced, I did feel sometimes the book was unreasonably preachy. Felicia silently prays or makes a plea to God at every ill thought and every remote turn in plan; not only is this slightly annoying, but it's also unnecessary. As a character, she's irritatingly sensitive; she tears up at every reminder of her past. I know it's sad, and I know she's a fragile woman, but that kind of behavior is girly (in a bad way) and weak. I would have liked to have seen more strength from Felicia—the kind of strength acquired over ten years, of overcoming the heartbreak of being torn apart from family at a young age. Colin's character is a bit more relatable; he too, has an upsetting past, but his safe, widowed, day-to-day life is his own way of recovery. His dedication to his daughter, especially, is incredibly real and hits close to home.
Stylistically, Hatcher is a gem. Her words flow smoothly and beautifully. The procession of the story moves seamlessly; I didn't have to plod through it at all! One thing that did irk me was the curtness of the dialogue: lots of one-worded responses from not just one, but all of the characters. Maybe this was the norm in 1897, but to me, it just sounds unwelcoming. The deep probing of—the scars, fears, and secrets of—each of the characters' minds makes up for it, though. I really have no complaints on how Hatcher chose to portray her characters fully.
I cannot confidently classify this as a romance novel. In the traditional sense, yes, it's a romance in that boy meets girl on the first page and boy gets girl by the last, but it's rather unorthodox. There is no attraction—in fact, there is unattraction—until about halfway throughout. Then small, totally non-sexual, tingly feelings rise in Colin and Felicia's stomachs whenever they see each other—more than a several times—and then they abruptly SPOILER get married and live happily ever after. I will say their relationship is complex, especially with Colin's initial reservations and Felicia's interaction with his young daughter, but it just didn't seem at all romantic to me. It bothered me that Colin's character is compromised when it is revealed that he never was in love with his wife. He loved her, of course, and is still grieving her death, but his marriage to her is described as "practical." I feel this is uncharacteristic and was only included so that his relationship could further with Felicia. Again, this makes the so-called romance unrealistic and a bit stilted. For a content advisory, there isn't one; the romance is 100% chaste (absolutely no sex, absolutely no physical interaction except at the end—in hindsight, this may be why I didn't enjoy it as much) because it sticks to traditional 19th century Christian values.
The power of staying faithful to God and leading life with a pure, wholesome outlook prove to be the key to happiness in Belonging. Through Felicia, readers understand and rejoice because, no matter what troubles and turmoils arise, God always saves and protects. Accidents will occur, plans will be ruined, and people will try to get in the way, but in the end, maintaining a loving, kind heart is what makes individuals truly belong.
Pros: Amazing character development // Easy, smooth flow to story; book moves and finishes quickly // Well-penned writing style // Colin and Felicia have a strong rapport, though not necessarily a romance // Strong morals on family and love // Believable situations and characters // Not too dense with historical information; fictional town and setting actually quite charming
Cons: Slightly preachy in religious message // Felicia is pathetic at times // Romance is poorly developed // Dialogue sometimes unrealistic and lacks emotion
Love: Kathleen could scarcely believe those words had come out of her mouth ... She must be losing her mind.
Or perhaps she was beginning to find it.
Verdict: Belonging is a heartwarming, clean, and gorgeously-crafted Christian historical that encompasses an absence—and a discovery—of belonging, a passion for God, and a huge misunderstanding, or rather: several small misunderstandings that constitute for one conflict of fate. By demonstrating the importance of determination, dedication, and faith, Belonging conveys the almighty power of love—for God, for family, and for oneself through one woman's search for a place to belong. The religious undertone is strong, and the characterization, stronger; Hatcher has succeeded in telling an inspirational, absorbing, and completely feel-good story.
8 hearts: An engaging read; highly recommended.
September 15, 2017
The "Where the Heart Lives" series tells the heart-breaking stories of siblings Felicia, Hugh, and Diana Brennan who are sent out west after their mother dies. The children are separated and the first novel, Belonging, recounts the story of Felicia's life, picking up the thread when she is an adult undertaking her first teaching job in a small town. As a teacher myself, Felicia's love for and dedication to her students resonated with me and provided a pleasant character with whom I could relate.
Further, Felicia's faith and doubts are portayed realistically and Hatcher deftly weaves scipture into her novel with truth and sincerety. In Colin and Charity, Hatcher provides a ready-made family for Felicia, but one that is a good fit and seems believable. The story is a lovely one about a tenacious woman who clings to her faith in an effort to overcome challenges and embrace the true life God has for her.
Further, Felicia's faith and doubts are portayed realistically and Hatcher deftly weaves scipture into her novel with truth and sincerety. In Colin and Charity, Hatcher provides a ready-made family for Felicia, but one that is a good fit and seems believable. The story is a lovely one about a tenacious woman who clings to her faith in an effort to overcome challenges and embrace the true life God has for her.
June 25, 2018
And easy read and a good first novel to series. Felicia story is probably all too common in that time period, being adopted by a family that are in need of her and not necessarily willing or able to love her. But into adulthood she moves beyond that and finds happiness. Collin start off as a semibetter widower who doesn’t necessarily wish to remarry. Though he does fall victim to a scheme by a local mother-in-law to secure a new husband for her daughter in law and her two grandchildren. Obviously this does not prevent the two main characters from coming together in the end. The subplot that I find most refreshing and almost more refreshing than the main plot was Kathleen and Oscar. That’s another story in itself. But the prevailing thread that we’ve through both stories and the book in general is that God will provide. Does the plat was somewhat simplistic, the writing was good and the character development was also quality. I look forward to reading more books in the series
Displaying 1 - 30 of 208 reviews