Gough’s book is well written, exciting, as well as creative and fresh. The scenes created, such as St. Grimm’s Hospital, are appealing and different from the typical locations often presented in novels about animal-human interaction. The characters invented, Will, Dr. Noctua, and especially the descriptions of the rest of the enchants, are interesting and almost believable. The incorporation of factual history into fiction is intriguing, and is written in in such a way that the history seems to explain away any of the plot holes that could have arisen. The character development was very thorough, but gradual, so that the reader receives the impression of getting to know the character, just as the protagonist Will does. The imagery used is compelling and vivid.
The plot seems to take a while to start after the initial surprise of Will’s new life. Many scenes feel like fillers that are placed there simply to take up time and relate the day-to-day things before the action starts. However, once the action does start it is very detailed and the descriptions become images, not words. The shocking plot twist at the end comes maybe a bit too suddenly, but it does tie up all the loose ends, and explains the mysteries that had been growing from the beginning. The large amount of acronyms and lists of things that needed to be known to understand the lingo occasionally made the conversations slightly difficult to follow.
I would recommend this book to anyone who enjoys stories of youth, mystery, animals, secret societies, and fantastic figurative language.