Right from the beginning, I was absolutely wowed by a snappy opening. A good sign, I thought, and it was. That said, there were a few things I didn’t like about the book, so I’ll touch on them first.
There are only about five grammatical errors in the novel, most of them dealing with the treatment of tense – as in, staying in the proper tense. The narrator had a tendency to occasionally drift from present to past and back, sometimes within the same sentence – a glitch that I find almost face-slappingly annoying. However, since most people aren’t quite as strict on their grammar-nazi-ishness, I’d like to focus on what I thought was the novel’s greatest failure – its ending. Miller has really set up a well-told novel, and by the time I got to the last ten percent, I would have stabbed a man to read what happened next and figure out how this all got wrapped up. The ending, while it did tie off the ends, also relied on a bit of blanket-over-the-eye-pulling twist. I was pretty disappointed – a little foreshadowing would have gone a loooooong way here.
So, moving on, let’s talk about the good. First off, Anthony Miller has a way with description. Take the following passage,
An earnest-looking student wearing an earnest-looking sweater raised his hand. Satan turned to stare at the young man. ”Yes,” he said. ”What is your problem?”
The student spoke with a slowness that was the result of some neurological deficiency or having been raised in the South.
Or how about this?
He shook his head with the special kind of condescension that comes from knowing more about current events than someone else.
I mean, this stuff is brilliant. Although at times over the top, most of the novel is crazy funny, chock-full of razor sharp metaphors that are astoundingly fresh, many of them rendered by a well-voiced semi-omniscient narrator. The characters, while caricatures, are well-rounded and convincing, and the setting – Texas?? – is wildly appropriate. (Or, you know, inappropriate, but in a good way). The overall premise is thought-provoking and the execution is engaging and entertaining.
Overall Rating: 4 stars – Highly polished, sarcastic, and laugh out loud funny; the ending could use a bit of work.
P.S. Without trying to spoil anything, I would definitely recommend this as a gift for all of your car aficionados out there.