Christmas Past - Iris Johansen - 3/5 - Zara is a gypsy (Rom) who grew up in Ireland and has come to Killara to claim a mirror, made by her people and given to the Delaney’s (with whom she also claims distant kinship). Since they’re not using it, she wants it back. But Kevin (Rising Star’s son) is lord of the manor now and he’s grown up hard and hurting. He hates having to be at Killara and fears the boredom if he can’t fulfill his lustful appetites in Hell’s Bluff. When he finds Zara in his attic, he makes a bargain with her. He’ll help her find the mirror if she’ll keep him “entertained.” She agrees because she wants the mirror more than anything. But time spent with Kevin deepens the connection that springs up between them and causes Kevin to look at his life and what he’s taking for granted. Pretty soon, he’s trying to get Zara to marry him, but how do you tame such a wild creature?
I wanted this story to be longer. I couldn’t help but feel this story suffered from being a novella. The sex scenes were all cut short except for the first one, which was intensely awkward and rushed. That’s the one where Kevin decides he’s done waiting for Zara to get comfortable with the idea of sex with him (part of his blackmail bargain) and decides he can make her want it. So he strips her, spreads her legs and discovers she’s a virgin. No matter - of course she loves it anyway. Then there isn’t a single loving scene between them later. As much as I don’t like heroes who go through with blackmail sex, I can at least appreciate the fact that he felt guilt and remorse for it later (but how much of that was because she was a virgin?) And the love more or less happens off screen, though you can see how there’s a friendship developing and that Kevin is sort of mellowing for Zara. That was nice. I also liked that he refused to give into his lust until she accepted his marriage proposal. Now Zara reminded me of Silver in her child-like mentality about dealing with the world, her straightforward attitude and directness and her refusal to admit to weakness or show vulnerability. In fact, Zara might as well have been Silver. Felt like the same character to me. This story has plenty of angsty feelings, at least enough to keep me reading, so that was good. I liked that Shamus and Malvina (and Josh for that matter) were finally dead. I can’t fathom how this author seems to think that Malvina was worthy of admiration. She’s talked up to be the worst monster alive (and she was pretty much in Fierce Splendor) and then Kevin says, “I never hated her, I admired her.” Honestly? He admired a woman who despised him because of his heritage? Ugh.
Christmas Present - Fayrene Preston - 3/5 - Bria is Burke Delaney’s daughter and she is head strong and fancy free for this story when she stumbles upon the mirror and glimpses the future. She sees a strange man who turns out to be Kells, a man her father is doing business with and the sparks fly instantly. Now that she believes what the mirror shows her, Bria becomes somewhat addicted, constantly going back to see visions of her and Kells kissing and making love and then trying to make them happen. As she falls in love with Kells and he with her, she keeps going back to the mirror. But then she sees a vision she doesn’t expect, Kells holding a smoking gun over her dead father. Will this vision come true as the others have?
I found this interesting...it’s kind of insta-lovey, but then that insta-love comes back to bite our couple in the ass because the trust that should build with a longer fall into love isn’t there and so Kells doesn’t believe Bria about the mirror and she doesn’t believe that he won’t kill her father. Which has me wondering, what kind of love is it without trust? It also felt like Bria was actually in full-on addiction mode with the mirror, which was pretty realistic. Can’t say I wouldn’t do the same thing with a find like that. But as interesting as this was, it didn’t do much for me in the romance department. These two were all fire and passion and anger (which makes for sexy scenes together) but not much tempered time together to really get to know each other.
Christmas Future - Kay Hooper - 3/5 - Brett Delaney walked away from his ruthless father and his Delaney heritage 10 years earlier after looking into the mirror and seeing the girl he loved marrying his father. He hasn’t looked back since. When he looks into the mirror again after his father’s death, he sees Killara’s destruction. This time, he’s determined to beat fate and do what it takes to save the place he knew as home. When he sees Cassie, the girl he loved who indeed married his father (after also seeing it in the mirror despite not being a Delaney), Brett is equally attracted and wanting to pick up where he left off and bitter about what he sees as her betrayal with his father. But she believes him about what he saw in the mirror and is willing to help however she can. Killara is as much her home as Brett’s.
This was probably my favorite of this anthology, probably because of how angsty it is and how the mirror really seems to take on the role of character here. And then there’s the whole fate vs. free will theme happening. Case in point, both Brett and Cassie look in the mirror and see Cassie marrying Brett’s father. This prompts Brett to leave Cassie without a word and break her heart (Side rant: and it takes a positive spin later when Cassie points out that Brett would be a whole lot more like his despised father if he hadn’t left...as much as I agree with this, I still don’t like it when they put positive spins on a guy leaving...Here Cassie focused on that and totally let go the fact that Brett left without a word to Cassie and broke her heart in the process). And because Brett, the man she loved, had left, Cassie has no idea what to do but when she sees herself marrying the father in the mirror, she decides that’s what she should do. If neither of them had looked, it never would have happened. I didn’t like that Brett was stubborn about not seeing that his leaving caused the very thing he didn’t want to happen. I also didn’t like the fact that he basically requires proof of her virginity to get over his anger of her marrying his father...despite her telling him she’d never slept with him in the first place. But I did appreciate that Cassie called him out on it and that he did feel at least some remorse about it. So good and bad, just like the others, but this was a much more entertaining read for me.