What do you think?
Rate this book
Ferals #1
Ferals: The Crow Talker
THE NIGHT BELONGED TO HIM.
HE WORE ITS SHADOWS, TASTED ITS SCENTS.
In a city ravaged by crime, an orphaned boy, Caw survives alone. Only Caw is never really alone - because he is the crow Feral, with the power to talk to the birds that are his sole companions.
When escaped prisoners swarm the city of Blackstone, Caw realises that they too are Ferals - but with a dark mission to restore the dangerous spider Feral, the Spinning Man, to power.
Now Caw and his crows must join forces with other good Ferals and take on the spreading evil, or darkness will fall...
...and bite
HE WORE ITS SHADOWS, TASTED ITS SCENTS.
In a city ravaged by crime, an orphaned boy, Caw survives alone. Only Caw is never really alone - because he is the crow Feral, with the power to talk to the birds that are his sole companions.
When escaped prisoners swarm the city of Blackstone, Caw realises that they too are Ferals - but with a dark mission to restore the dangerous spider Feral, the Spinning Man, to power.
Now Caw and his crows must join forces with other good Ferals and take on the spreading evil, or darkness will fall...
...and bite
256 pages, Paperback
First published January 1, 2015
113 people are currently reading
2600 people want to read
About the author
Jacob Grey
26 books95 followersLittle is known of the mysterious Jacob Grey. He is said to live in a big city in the USA, where he wanders the streets at night dreaming up his dark and twisted tales. He has a deep love of animals and even talks to crows himself . . . although no one knows if he understands their replies.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 387 reviews
November 27, 2014
You know what's really hard? It is to read a book from a certain demographic that gave you a migraine, just right after you read another book from the same category that made you fly the heavens because of absolute ecstasy. There is always that voice in your head comparing the two, asking why is it like this when the other one did it better? More often than not, your mind fools itself to think that the book is actually worse than it is. I know I have to take that into account, but I can't deny that my feelings right now are leaning towards a particular end of the stick... the one where a raging She-Hulk is preparing to throw a couple of knuckle sandwiches.
With that said, please, please, please take my review with a grain of salt. All words from here henceforth are of my own subjective opinion only, with a little bias along the way because I recently read Omega City by Diana Peterfreund which was awesome as hell and it's just hard for any book under the same category to live up to it.
So, Ferals. The moment I learned it had a boy with the power to command black birds of death and destruc --- I mean, crows --- I was so excited. I've always been a lover of animals, and having the ability to ask them to do your bidding, having them as an extension of you... come on, that just spells AWESOME with a capital and exploding "A". And while crows are creepy as hell (I always imagine them to be evilly chuckling when they put their dark gaze upon you), they are interesting birds, involved in a number of mythologies across several cultures and civilizations.
That's why it really killed me that I found myself not enjoying it. There were times my eyes glazed over, and times I was looking forward to the next page because it meant it was one page less to the end, which I started viewing as the light at the end of the tunnel. I desperately wanted to like this. I willed every fiber of my mortal body to like it. For the love of fucking crows, damnit! Alas, the more I tried, the more frustrated I got, and it was like awakening to a new spring when I finally finished it.
Trust me, I was really guilty.
...
Okay, maybe not.
I simply just couldn't get into the writing. It was all full of active sentences one after another, producing a very monotonous tone that provided no atmosphere, no emotions, no... spark or whatever... that would make me want to sympathize with the main character. Caw woke up dreaming. Caw is dreaming. Caw gripped the parapet. Then proceed a wall of text detailing every minute detail of what his body is doing. Honestly, after a while, the book started looking like a compilation of "How Many Verbs Can You Put in a Page?"
Do you see what I'm getting at?
It was so telling than showing. What he's doing, what the others are doing, what he's supposedly feeling without any other exposition. Succeeding scenes happen without any build-up, without any good transition, which honestly left me bored and detached. In an effort to make the reading experience even slightly interesting, I tried reading aloud with a rather dramatic voice, but even my voice couldn't escape the dull feeling this book was giving. I know that this is considered Middle Grade, that its market are kids, but you know a book is good when even adults enjoy it. And besides, Harry Potter started as an MG and the first book was just so good. There's Omega City, and A Monster Calls, and A School for Good and Evil - all MG but written so cleverly, so emotionally, so good, that you know even Ferals could have been written better.
Because of the writing and the lack of build-up, some scenes started becoming so contrived to me. When we get to know the origins of Caw's power and how he's so special, I couldn't help but roll my eyes. It's a cliché, yes, but clichés can be memorable if written right. There was this scene where a veteran Feral is talking about how transforming into your animal is close to impossible, that not even he, who has trained and trained for years and has more experience than our special hero, can do it, but in a span of a page, our Caw, who just recently woke to the potential of his abilities, who had no meritable training or whatsoever, he can suddenly do it? BESTING THE ONE WHO TRIED FOR SO LONG AND EVEN FOUGHT IN A GODDAMN WAR?! I just couldn't buy it! It was such a painful moment for me that I started muttering obscenities under me breath, while clutching the blankets to restrain myself from leaving my E-Reader and walking out of my own bloodydamn room.
All in all, the writing made everything suffer. The atmosphere was nonexistent, the hero was as dull as cardboard, and many of the scenes felt really contrived. I wish I could like it, but the only redeeming factor it had for me was that it had animals. And animals are pretty much "love" in a nutshell. However, as I disclaimed earlier, my thoughts here are also influenced by the fact I read a far superior book not long ago, and it's simply hard not to compare the two. If the blurb interests you, please don't hesitate to try it out, for yourself or for your kids. Maybe it could teach them young ones that crows aren't really all that bad!
With that said, please, please, please take my review with a grain of salt. All words from here henceforth are of my own subjective opinion only, with a little bias along the way because I recently read Omega City by Diana Peterfreund which was awesome as hell and it's just hard for any book under the same category to live up to it.
So, Ferals. The moment I learned it had a boy with the power to command black birds of death and destruc --- I mean, crows --- I was so excited. I've always been a lover of animals, and having the ability to ask them to do your bidding, having them as an extension of you... come on, that just spells AWESOME with a capital and exploding "A". And while crows are creepy as hell (I always imagine them to be evilly chuckling when they put their dark gaze upon you), they are interesting birds, involved in a number of mythologies across several cultures and civilizations.
That's why it really killed me that I found myself not enjoying it. There were times my eyes glazed over, and times I was looking forward to the next page because it meant it was one page less to the end, which I started viewing as the light at the end of the tunnel. I desperately wanted to like this. I willed every fiber of my mortal body to like it. For the love of fucking crows, damnit! Alas, the more I tried, the more frustrated I got, and it was like awakening to a new spring when I finally finished it.
Trust me, I was really guilty.
...
Okay, maybe not.
I simply just couldn't get into the writing. It was all full of active sentences one after another, producing a very monotonous tone that provided no atmosphere, no emotions, no... spark or whatever... that would make me want to sympathize with the main character. Caw woke up dreaming. Caw is dreaming. Caw gripped the parapet. Then proceed a wall of text detailing every minute detail of what his body is doing. Honestly, after a while, the book started looking like a compilation of "How Many Verbs Can You Put in a Page?"
Do you see what I'm getting at?
It was so telling than showing. What he's doing, what the others are doing, what he's supposedly feeling without any other exposition. Succeeding scenes happen without any build-up, without any good transition, which honestly left me bored and detached. In an effort to make the reading experience even slightly interesting, I tried reading aloud with a rather dramatic voice, but even my voice couldn't escape the dull feeling this book was giving. I know that this is considered Middle Grade, that its market are kids, but you know a book is good when even adults enjoy it. And besides, Harry Potter started as an MG and the first book was just so good. There's Omega City, and A Monster Calls, and A School for Good and Evil - all MG but written so cleverly, so emotionally, so good, that you know even Ferals could have been written better.
Because of the writing and the lack of build-up, some scenes started becoming so contrived to me. When we get to know the origins of Caw's power and how he's so special, I couldn't help but roll my eyes. It's a cliché, yes, but clichés can be memorable if written right. There was this scene where a veteran Feral is talking about how transforming into your animal is close to impossible, that not even he, who has trained and trained for years and has more experience than our special hero, can do it, but in a span of a page, our Caw, who just recently woke to the potential of his abilities, who had no meritable training or whatsoever, he can suddenly do it? BESTING THE ONE WHO TRIED FOR SO LONG AND EVEN FOUGHT IN A GODDAMN WAR?! I just couldn't buy it! It was such a painful moment for me that I started muttering obscenities under me breath, while clutching the blankets to restrain myself from leaving my E-Reader and walking out of my own bloodydamn room.
All in all, the writing made everything suffer. The atmosphere was nonexistent, the hero was as dull as cardboard, and many of the scenes felt really contrived. I wish I could like it, but the only redeeming factor it had for me was that it had animals. And animals are pretty much "love" in a nutshell. However, as I disclaimed earlier, my thoughts here are also influenced by the fact I read a far superior book not long ago, and it's simply hard not to compare the two. If the blurb interests you, please don't hesitate to try it out, for yourself or for your kids. Maybe it could teach them young ones that crows aren't really all that bad!
September 23, 2018
Recenzia completă: https://bit.ly/2DAL0G7
„- Ar fi trebuit să-ți spun că aterizarea e greu de stăpânit.”
În timp ce oscilam între două romane YA, o serie fantasy de 12 volume şi Potopul, de Sienkiewicz, Thomas, motanul meu cel slăbănog, veşnic nemulţumit de viaţa „dificilă” pe care o are alături de mine, s-a suit pe birou şi mi-a dărâmat câteva cărţi, ca să îmi atragă atenţia. Nici nu a clipit când m-am luat de manierele sale. M-a privit în continuare, cu ochii mijiţi, la un pas să se lungească pe laptop şi să adoarmă acolo, cu speranţa că poate mi se face milă de el şi îl las să stea cu mine, cât citesc.
Cum nu îi pot rezista şi e şi Thomas un „sufleţel”, l-am luat în braţe, moment în care ochii mi-au căzut pe cartea care alunecase sub birou: Neîmblânziţii. Abia terminasem Berlin I şi II şi voiam ceva diferit, să mă distanţez de seriile în care protagoniştii sunt copii, dar cum nu reuşisem să mă decid în treizeci de minute asupra unui roman, iar teancul de cărţi ameninţa să se prăbuşească din nou de pe birou, am înhăţat cartea, cu motanul adormit pe umăr, minunându-mă, pentru a nu-știu-câta-oară, de cât de deosebită este copertă, de la cei trei corbi încăpăţânaţi şi mereu pregătiţi de ceartă (pe care i-am adorat), la păianjenii care vorbesc despre moarte, răpiri şi Vara Întunecată.
Deşi povestea nu este foarte complexă, iar Jacob Grey îţi oferă indicii din belşug pentru a dezlega aura de mister care învăluie primul volum al trilogiei, am închis ochii în fața asemănărilor cu alte serii şi m-am bucurat de lectură, savurând cu un entuziasm neaşteptat cartea, cu ajutorul lui Caw, un personaj uimitor, cu care abia aştept să mă întâlnesc în volumele următoare.
Trăieşte într-un parc părăsit, într-un cuib improvizat, de care este foarte mândru. Se hrăneşte cu resturi, atunci când găseşte ceva comestibil prin gunoaie şi reuşeşte să scape de cei care vor să îi fure mâncarea şi să îi facă rău, doar pentru că este mic şi firav. Are o haină lungă şi neagră, care îi acoperă îmbrăcămintea murdară şi ruptă. Se fereşte şi se teme de oameni; preferă compania celor trei corbi, care îl însoţesc pretutindeni şi au grijă de el. Iubeşte înălţimile şi mereu caută cea mai rapidă cale prin care picioarele lui pot atinge acoperişul: o bârnă rezistentă, o scară de incendiu, o ţeavă suficient de stabilă încât să-i susţină greutatea. Pentru că el mereu va alege să fie mai aproape de cer şi cât mai departe de pământ. El este Caw. Şi are doar treisprezece ani.
„- Ar fi trebuit să-ți spun că aterizarea e greu de stăpânit.”
În timp ce oscilam între două romane YA, o serie fantasy de 12 volume şi Potopul, de Sienkiewicz, Thomas, motanul meu cel slăbănog, veşnic nemulţumit de viaţa „dificilă” pe care o are alături de mine, s-a suit pe birou şi mi-a dărâmat câteva cărţi, ca să îmi atragă atenţia. Nici nu a clipit când m-am luat de manierele sale. M-a privit în continuare, cu ochii mijiţi, la un pas să se lungească pe laptop şi să adoarmă acolo, cu speranţa că poate mi se face milă de el şi îl las să stea cu mine, cât citesc.
Cum nu îi pot rezista şi e şi Thomas un „sufleţel”, l-am luat în braţe, moment în care ochii mi-au căzut pe cartea care alunecase sub birou: Neîmblânziţii. Abia terminasem Berlin I şi II şi voiam ceva diferit, să mă distanţez de seriile în care protagoniştii sunt copii, dar cum nu reuşisem să mă decid în treizeci de minute asupra unui roman, iar teancul de cărţi ameninţa să se prăbuşească din nou de pe birou, am înhăţat cartea, cu motanul adormit pe umăr, minunându-mă, pentru a nu-știu-câta-oară, de cât de deosebită este copertă, de la cei trei corbi încăpăţânaţi şi mereu pregătiţi de ceartă (pe care i-am adorat), la păianjenii care vorbesc despre moarte, răpiri şi Vara Întunecată.
Deşi povestea nu este foarte complexă, iar Jacob Grey îţi oferă indicii din belşug pentru a dezlega aura de mister care învăluie primul volum al trilogiei, am închis ochii în fața asemănărilor cu alte serii şi m-am bucurat de lectură, savurând cu un entuziasm neaşteptat cartea, cu ajutorul lui Caw, un personaj uimitor, cu care abia aştept să mă întâlnesc în volumele următoare.
Trăieşte într-un parc părăsit, într-un cuib improvizat, de care este foarte mândru. Se hrăneşte cu resturi, atunci când găseşte ceva comestibil prin gunoaie şi reuşeşte să scape de cei care vor să îi fure mâncarea şi să îi facă rău, doar pentru că este mic şi firav. Are o haină lungă şi neagră, care îi acoperă îmbrăcămintea murdară şi ruptă. Se fereşte şi se teme de oameni; preferă compania celor trei corbi, care îl însoţesc pretutindeni şi au grijă de el. Iubeşte înălţimile şi mereu caută cea mai rapidă cale prin care picioarele lui pot atinge acoperişul: o bârnă rezistentă, o scară de incendiu, o ţeavă suficient de stabilă încât să-i susţină greutatea. Pentru că el mereu va alege să fie mai aproape de cer şi cât mai departe de pământ. El este Caw. Şi are doar treisprezece ani.
May 31, 2017
I liked this book even though it could be too childish at times for me. I know I probably would've really loved the book when I was in second grade. I can't really say too much about it because of spoilers but I would recommend it to younger people that like fantasy, and people who like animals.
December 17, 2020
عرف انها تحاول فقط مواساته ، لكنه أدرك في قرارة نفسه ان شيئاً لن يعود مثلما كان قبلاً . إنه يسير في طريق لا مجال فيه للعودة . وفي النهاية ، توجد الحقيقة أو الانتقام ، أو القدر نفسه الذي لاقاه والداه
فكرتها مختلفة وعجبتني
المراجعة بس تخلص السلسة
فكرتها مختلفة وعجبتني
المراجعة بس تخلص السلسة
April 4, 2015
Pretty good. Fast paced book. Finished it within one night shift. Lol.
June 19, 2016
خب با توجه به رده ی سنی مخاطبش احتمالاً یه هفت سال پیش باید می خوندمش :)
و خب با مقیاسهای همون زمانم نمرده دادم
البته یک فانتزی خون باید هرچی فانتزی هست بخونه، بدون در نظر گرفتن رده ی سنیش
ایده ی خوبی داشت و مهم تر از اون پرداخت موفقیت آمیز نویسنده بود
مشتاق خوندن جلد دومش با ترجمه ی خوب آقای قصاع هستم
و خب با مقیاسهای همون زمانم نمرده دادم
البته یک فانتزی خون باید هرچی فانتزی هست بخونه، بدون در نظر گرفتن رده ی سنیش
ایده ی خوبی داشت و مهم تر از اون پرداخت موفقیت آمیز نویسنده بود
مشتاق خوندن جلد دومش با ترجمه ی خوب آقای قصاع هستم
May 29, 2020
Šo var lasīt tikai bērnībā.
Tāds pašvaks Potera fanfiks.
Tāds pašvaks Potera fanfiks.
May 12, 2015
Ferals by Jacob Grey is the new middle grade read that is sure to please young readers looking for a darker and grittier story. The writing in Ferals is filled with great atmosphere as the young hero Caw discovers his ability as a Feral and sets out to rescue his friend and city from the evil clutches of The Spinning Man.
The Boy Who Could Call the Crows
Caw is a brave and clever young hero with the ability to call the Crows to him when he needs help. Raised by three crows whom he communicates with, Caw has a sweet and almost naivety to him that I thought was very endearing. When the city is threatened by The Spinning Man and his renegade Ferals, and his new friend Lydia is taken by them, Caw realizes he may be the only one strong enough to stop them.
Friendships: A sweet hero and feisty heroine
The friendship between Caw and Lydia is sweet, making this a fun read for both boys and girls who will be easily drawn to them both. Lydia is a feisty and determined young lady and I adored how she was so protective over Caw. As the story unfolds, readers will be treated to Caw training, fighting and learning the truth about his lost parents.
Crows, Snakes, Cockroches and Spiders ... Oh My
One thing is for sure, there is no shortage of Ferals to delight and disgust as a horde of helpers from both the hero's and villain's sides battle it out. From clever foxes, diving doves to wriggling centipedes the story is filled with creature helpers, both good and bad making the action and danger very appealing. And, darker and gritty ... there is casualties both to the humans and ferals. I think the thrills and chills are going to be a big hit as spiders and other creepy crawlers threaten and the powers of the ferals are discovered. Action and danger keep the pace going, making for a fast and fun read.
Dastardly Villains, Chills and Fun Ickiness
Ferals combines action and danger with a gritty setting and intriguing new hero to escape to. I enjoyed Caw and his fellow Ferals as they fought against the evil of The Spinning Man. A sweet friendship kept the story balanced and not too dark. Recommended to older, middle grade readers who like dastardly villains, chills and fun ickiness in their reads.
My Rating: 4 stars. I really liked it!
PLEASE NOTE: A courtesy review copy of this book was provided by HarperCollins in exchange for my fair review. Thank you, HarperCollins for the review opportunity!
The Boy Who Could Call the Crows
Caw is a brave and clever young hero with the ability to call the Crows to him when he needs help. Raised by three crows whom he communicates with, Caw has a sweet and almost naivety to him that I thought was very endearing. When the city is threatened by The Spinning Man and his renegade Ferals, and his new friend Lydia is taken by them, Caw realizes he may be the only one strong enough to stop them.
Friendships: A sweet hero and feisty heroine
The friendship between Caw and Lydia is sweet, making this a fun read for both boys and girls who will be easily drawn to them both. Lydia is a feisty and determined young lady and I adored how she was so protective over Caw. As the story unfolds, readers will be treated to Caw training, fighting and learning the truth about his lost parents.
Crows, Snakes, Cockroches and Spiders ... Oh My
One thing is for sure, there is no shortage of Ferals to delight and disgust as a horde of helpers from both the hero's and villain's sides battle it out. From clever foxes, diving doves to wriggling centipedes the story is filled with creature helpers, both good and bad making the action and danger very appealing. And, darker and gritty ... there is casualties both to the humans and ferals. I think the thrills and chills are going to be a big hit as spiders and other creepy crawlers threaten and the powers of the ferals are discovered. Action and danger keep the pace going, making for a fast and fun read.
Dastardly Villains, Chills and Fun Ickiness
Ferals combines action and danger with a gritty setting and intriguing new hero to escape to. I enjoyed Caw and his fellow Ferals as they fought against the evil of The Spinning Man. A sweet friendship kept the story balanced and not too dark. Recommended to older, middle grade readers who like dastardly villains, chills and fun ickiness in their reads.
My Rating: 4 stars. I really liked it!
PLEASE NOTE: A courtesy review copy of this book was provided by HarperCollins in exchange for my fair review. Thank you, HarperCollins for the review opportunity!
March 23, 2017
Read this book with my friend Mitra
خب میدونم الان همه متعجبن که چرا 5 دادم :|
درواقع میخواستم 3 و نیم یا 4 بدم. ولی این کتاب رو به اندازه ی کافی دوستش داشتم که دلم نخواست 4 بدم :دی
بیشترین چیزی که راجع به این کتاب دوست داشتم ایده ش بود
و منکر این نیستم که با این ایده ی جالبی که داشت نویسنده میتونست این کتاب رو خیلی خیلی بهتر بنویسه
طوری که...چطور بگم... مثلا بعد از مدت ها هم آدم یادی از کتاب بکنه و باهاش خاطره داشته باشه!
کتاب فقط طوری بود که با لذت میخونیش و تموم میشه و میره
دومین چیزی که دوست داشتم، این بود که کتاب رو راحت خوندم. خیلی خیلی راحت
به معنای واقعی کلمه a good read بود
کلا این کتاب رو به کوچیکتر از خودم پیشنهاد میکنم زیر پانزده سال :دی بزرگتر ها هم اگه میخوان کتابی بخونن که لذت ببرن میتونن بخوننش
خب میدونم الان همه متعجبن که چرا 5 دادم :|
درواقع میخواستم 3 و نیم یا 4 بدم. ولی این کتاب رو به اندازه ی کافی دوستش داشتم که دلم نخواست 4 بدم :دی
بیشترین چیزی که راجع به این کتاب دوست داشتم ایده ش بود
و منکر این نیستم که با این ایده ی جالبی که داشت نویسنده میتونست این کتاب رو خیلی خیلی بهتر بنویسه
طوری که...چطور بگم... مثلا بعد از مدت ها هم آدم یادی از کتاب بکنه و باهاش خاطره داشته باشه!
کتاب فقط طوری بود که با لذت میخونیش و تموم میشه و میره
دومین چیزی که دوست داشتم، این بود که کتاب رو راحت خوندم. خیلی خیلی راحت
به معنای واقعی کلمه a good read بود
کلا این کتاب رو به کوچیکتر از خودم پیشنهاد میکنم زیر پانزده سال :دی بزرگتر ها هم اگه میخوان کتابی بخونن که لذت ببرن میتونن بخوننش
April 4, 2017
I found myself wishing it was real.
September 7, 2015
Istyria book blog ~ B's world of enchanted books
This book was so awesome! I started this right before I went to bed. I snuggled up under my blanket (it was winter and cold when I read this), thinking I'd read a bit to see if it was something I liked and before I knew it, it was almost three hours later and I was more than 60% through. I forced myself to go to sleep and yes it was painful to do. Ferals is fantastic.
Eight years ago, a wave of violence and crime called the Dark Summer swept through the city of Blackstone, once a thriving metropolis, and left a boy called Caw to fend for himself on the streets. His only companions is a small group of crows. Caw doesn't know why he can understand the crows, but after he saves a girl named Lydia from a vicious attack, he soon discovers others like him. Ferals, humans who can speak to certain animals. And some of them are dangerous. Now the most sinister feral of all, the Spinning Man, the man behind the Dark Summer, is on the move again. To save Lydia, her family and everyone in Blackstone Caw has to master abilities he never knew he had and fight a darkness he never could have imagined.
One of the best things of this story is of course the writing. Jacob has created a dark and gritty atmosphere and I could feel it right from the first page. It reminded me of the feeling I get from movies like Batman Begins, The Dark Knight and The Crow. And the TV show Gotham. That sort of dark and gritty. I loved it! For some reason I think this book would be awesome as a black and white comic book-style movie or an anime. It was fantastic, seriously. I was hooked and I loved every second of it. I'll be honest, though, I don't think it's for everyone. But then again, that goes for every book.
Next to great writing and world building, this book has great characters. The side characters were all awesome and I would love to get to know them better in the rest of the series! Crumb, Pip, Lydia... all awesome! But of course, the main character takes the central stage. Caw is such a great person. I felt for him and I rooted for him. He's shy and antisocial and doesn't trust people easily, but he's very brave and loyal to those he does trust. He can be quite stubborn too. He crows currently living with him were awesome. Milky, Glum and Screech were such great and loyal friends to Caw and they were funny too! Love them!
Ferals is an amazingly written and very original book. I could not put it down once it was in my hands. I recommend it to fans of the movies I mentioned before. And also everyone else that loves a good Middle Grade/Young Adult Fantasy novel. It's just that good. Go read it!
This review is also (or -soon- will be) posted on Istyria book blog
August 11, 2020
في مدينة دمّرها الفساد والجرائم، لا يملك اليتيم كاو، ابن الثلاثة عشر عاماً، أي أصدقاء باستثناء مجموعة الغربان التي عاش معها منذ أن تخلى عنه والداه وهو في الخامسة من عمره فقط، يعيش كاو في عش في أعلى شجرة في حديقة عامة مهجورة، ويتواصل فقط مع غربانه الثلاثة، إلا أن فرار بعض المساجين يجبره على التواصل مع بشر آخرين، ولا سيما فتاة تدعى ليديا تتعرض للاعتداء من قبل السجناء الفارين وينقذها كاو. يدرك كاو أن هؤلاء السجناء الفارين متوحشون يملكون قواسم مشتركة معه أكثر مما يريد فهم أيضاً خارقون مثله.
يعتبر هذا الكتاب او قرأتي لنوعية جديدة من الكتب وهي كتب اصحاب قدرات خارقة او ال )superheros), في السنوات الاخيرة زادت هذه النوعية من الافلام او الكتب وانا قررت ان اعطي نفسي هذه الفرصة من باب التنويع في القراءة او معرفة الجديد عن هذا النوعية, الكتاب قرأته للجزء الاول والتعرف لهذا العالم والشخصية وفي الجانب الاخر القوة الخارقة لها كانت جديدة علي, وجدا استمتعت بقراءته, وحسب رأي الشخصي مناسبة لجميع الاعمار.
يمكن البعض لا تعجبهم هذه النوعية من الكتب خاصة تكون شبابية او للمراهقين أكثر شيء خاصة لمحبي القوة الخارقة, ولكن العامل الجذب لدي هو نوعية القصة وايضا تستطيع ان تستمتع بقرأته وفي الجانب الاخر الكتاب تعتبر ثلاثية وتكون قرأته ممتعة, ولكن غير مناسبة للذي لا يحبون القصص الخيالية او الغير واقعية.
-----------------------------------
In a city devastated by corruption and crimes, the orphan Kao, the thirteen-year-old, has no friends except for the group of ravens he has lived with since his parents abandoned him when he was only five years old. With his three crows, the escape of some prisoners forces him to communicate with other human beings, especially a girl named Lydia who is attacked by the escaping prisoners and is rescued by Cao. Cao realizes that these escaped prisoners are savages who have more in common with him than he wants to be, as well as supernatural like himself.
This book or my reading is considered to be a new type of books, which are books with superheros or superheros. In recent years, this type of films or books has increased and I decided to give myself this opportunity in terms of diversification in reading or knowing new about this quality, the book I read it for the first part and get to know this world and personality, and on the other side, the supernatural power of it was new to me, and I really enjoyed reading it, and according to my personal opinion, it is suitable for all ages.
Some people may not like this type of book, especially young people or teenagers, the most special thing for fans of supernatural power, but the attraction factor I have is the quality of the story and also you can enjoy reading it and on the other hand the book is considered a trilogy and reading it is fun, but not suitable for those who do not like fairy tales Or unrealistic.
يعتبر هذا الكتاب او قرأتي لنوعية جديدة من الكتب وهي كتب اصحاب قدرات خارقة او ال )superheros), في السنوات الاخيرة زادت هذه النوعية من الافلام او الكتب وانا قررت ان اعطي نفسي هذه الفرصة من باب التنويع في القراءة او معرفة الجديد عن هذا النوعية, الكتاب قرأته للجزء الاول والتعرف لهذا العالم والشخصية وفي الجانب الاخر القوة الخارقة لها كانت جديدة علي, وجدا استمتعت بقراءته, وحسب رأي الشخصي مناسبة لجميع الاعمار.
يمكن البعض لا تعجبهم هذه النوعية من الكتب خاصة تكون شبابية او للمراهقين أكثر شيء خاصة لمحبي القوة الخارقة, ولكن العامل الجذب لدي هو نوعية القصة وايضا تستطيع ان تستمتع بقرأته وفي الجانب الاخر الكتاب تعتبر ثلاثية وتكون قرأته ممتعة, ولكن غير مناسبة للذي لا يحبون القصص الخيالية او الغير واقعية.
-----------------------------------
In a city devastated by corruption and crimes, the orphan Kao, the thirteen-year-old, has no friends except for the group of ravens he has lived with since his parents abandoned him when he was only five years old. With his three crows, the escape of some prisoners forces him to communicate with other human beings, especially a girl named Lydia who is attacked by the escaping prisoners and is rescued by Cao. Cao realizes that these escaped prisoners are savages who have more in common with him than he wants to be, as well as supernatural like himself.
This book or my reading is considered to be a new type of books, which are books with superheros or superheros. In recent years, this type of films or books has increased and I decided to give myself this opportunity in terms of diversification in reading or knowing new about this quality, the book I read it for the first part and get to know this world and personality, and on the other side, the supernatural power of it was new to me, and I really enjoyed reading it, and according to my personal opinion, it is suitable for all ages.
Some people may not like this type of book, especially young people or teenagers, the most special thing for fans of supernatural power, but the attraction factor I have is the quality of the story and also you can enjoy reading it and on the other hand the book is considered a trilogy and reading it is fun, but not suitable for those who do not like fairy tales Or unrealistic.
July 17, 2015
Creo que esperaba un poco más de este libro y de ahí que lo califique con tres estrellas. Ferals cuenta la historia de Caw, un chico que fue abandonado por sus padres cuando tenía cinco años -ahora tiene trece- y que, desde entonces, ha vivido en una especie de nido en lo alto de un árbol en el parque. Caw vive en Blackstone, una ciudad que antaño fue resplandeciente, pero que después del Verano Oscuro cayó en una de sus peores épocas.
Pronto nos enteramos de que este chico tiene la habilidad de hablar con los cuervos, especialmente con tres que han sido sus amigos desde que puede recordarlo: Grum, Screech y Milky. Y las cosas empezarán a ponerse interesantes cuando Caw ve que sus sueños, que siempre han sido los mismos, empiezan a variar ligeramente y empiezan a mostrar a un hombre con un tatuaje de araña. Estos cambios serán los detonantes que conducirán a Caw a salir de su nido, a hablar con más gente, a descubrir que es un feral -es decir una persona que puede hablar con un tipo de animal- y a enterarse de que hay más personas con estas habilidades... y que todos están en peligro.
En fin, me pareció que la premisa del libro prometía bastante, pero creo que se quedó corto. No hay mucha acción aunque sí que hay misterios que se van resolviendo poco a poco. Y también hay giros de trama que no te esperas, identidades secretas, alianzas que se recuperan y enemigos que no pensabas que eran enemigos. Ferals tiene personajes muy interesantes como la feral zorro y el feral lobo, que espero se desarrollen más en los siguientes dos libros de la trilogía.
De Caw qué puedo decir... bueno, es un protagonista que está entendiendo apenas que, efectivamente, él es el protagonista. Está descubriendo sus habilidades y aceptando el hecho de que, así sea un chico de trece años, aparentemente será la pieza clave cuando de derrotar al enemigo se trate. Por otra parte está Lydia, una chica, digamos, normal que se hace amiga de Caw y lo va a empezar a acompañar en sus aventuras y misiones para recolectar información. Y claro, por esto mismo, se ve arrastrada en medio de la acción. Lydia es un muy buen personaje que creo será vital en el segundo libro de la trilogía, confíen en mí :)
Pronto nos enteramos de que este chico tiene la habilidad de hablar con los cuervos, especialmente con tres que han sido sus amigos desde que puede recordarlo: Grum, Screech y Milky. Y las cosas empezarán a ponerse interesantes cuando Caw ve que sus sueños, que siempre han sido los mismos, empiezan a variar ligeramente y empiezan a mostrar a un hombre con un tatuaje de araña. Estos cambios serán los detonantes que conducirán a Caw a salir de su nido, a hablar con más gente, a descubrir que es un feral -es decir una persona que puede hablar con un tipo de animal- y a enterarse de que hay más personas con estas habilidades... y que todos están en peligro.
En fin, me pareció que la premisa del libro prometía bastante, pero creo que se quedó corto. No hay mucha acción aunque sí que hay misterios que se van resolviendo poco a poco. Y también hay giros de trama que no te esperas, identidades secretas, alianzas que se recuperan y enemigos que no pensabas que eran enemigos. Ferals tiene personajes muy interesantes como la feral zorro y el feral lobo, que espero se desarrollen más en los siguientes dos libros de la trilogía.
De Caw qué puedo decir... bueno, es un protagonista que está entendiendo apenas que, efectivamente, él es el protagonista. Está descubriendo sus habilidades y aceptando el hecho de que, así sea un chico de trece años, aparentemente será la pieza clave cuando de derrotar al enemigo se trate. Por otra parte está Lydia, una chica, digamos, normal que se hace amiga de Caw y lo va a empezar a acompañar en sus aventuras y misiones para recolectar información. Y claro, por esto mismo, se ve arrastrada en medio de la acción. Lydia es un muy buen personaje que creo será vital en el segundo libro de la trilogía, confíen en mí :)
July 30, 2019
That was such a fun story!! started this with low expectation since im not a huge Middle Grade reader.. i found myself surprised how much i enjoyed the story
i love the idea about Feral! (people who can control and speak to certain animal) its so freaking cool and the main character is loveable 😍😍 i also love the banter between him and his crows (yeah the crows here are pretty sassy and i love it)
However its indeed a very light story 😁
Adventure, mystery and magical aspect wrap in one book, its such a fun read after i finished read so many epic fantasy
i love the idea about Feral! (people who can control and speak to certain animal) its so freaking cool and the main character is loveable 😍😍 i also love the banter between him and his crows (yeah the crows here are pretty sassy and i love it)
However its indeed a very light story 😁
Adventure, mystery and magical aspect wrap in one book, its such a fun read after i finished read so many epic fantasy
December 25, 2016
یه روایت روان ساده و در عین حال مهیج. یه داستان نوجوان که ازش لذت بردم و یه عنوان یه کتاب نوجوان خیلی از توقعاتم رو برآورده کرد. شخصیت پردازی های مناسب و به اندازه و فضاسازی های دارک و خوشایند و متناسب با دنیای داستان. کشش خوبی داشت و نویسنده حد داستان و شخصیت هاشو به خوبی می شناخت و رعایت کرده و داستان رو کش دار و کسل کننده نکرده.
شخصیت کاو خیلی خوب معرفی میشه و یه جورایی مثل داستان بلوغ می مونه. کشف کاو از دنیای بیرون و شروع تعاملش با انسان های دیگه که مثل ورود به یه دنیای دیگه و شناخت خودش و رازهایی که از هویت خود و خانواده اش بدست میاره. و این شناخت ها با تعاملش با یک روح مونث (لیدیا) رنگ تازه ای به خودش می گیره.
یه داستان خوش قلم برای نوجوان. مهیج و دلنشین در عین حال دارک
پ.ن: کاش گودریدز امتیاز دهیاش از یک تا ده بود. من به فرالها 7 از ده می دم. و به عنوان یه کار نوجوان نه از ده
شخصیت کاو خیلی خوب معرفی میشه و یه جورایی مثل داستان بلوغ می مونه. کشف کاو از دنیای بیرون و شروع تعاملش با انسان های دیگه که مثل ورود به یه دنیای دیگه و شناخت خودش و رازهایی که از هویت خود و خانواده اش بدست میاره. و این شناخت ها با تعاملش با یک روح مونث (لیدیا) رنگ تازه ای به خودش می گیره.
یه داستان خوش قلم برای نوجوان. مهیج و دلنشین در عین حال دارک
پ.ن: کاش گودریدز امتیاز دهیاش از یک تا ده بود. من به فرالها 7 از ده می دم. و به عنوان یه کار نوجوان نه از ده
January 7, 2016
This was an OK middle grade read, however, it is strange that its publisher made the connection between it and The Graveyard book or even Batman. Perhaps it has something to do with how Caw, the child protagonist, grew up without his parents and was raised by crows, just like Bruce Wayne lost his mother and father and Nobody Owens was raised by dead souls on the Graveyard. But it might have been better that the connection hadn’t been made because once the reader hears those word before having laid his/her eyes on the book, and that makes them have great expectations about the writing style. The premise of “Ferals” is truly unique, a boy being able to control crows and turn into one sure does sound cool; he as Harry Potter, has a nemesis, a Spinning Man, who can control spiders but has died and now resides in the World of the Dead. Nonetheless, its coming to fruition is somewhat clumsy and it never actually approaches the universality of message, depth of emotion and quirkiness of Gayman’s writing. Some of the plot solutions are overdone and stale, and the thought comes to your mind while reading: “I’ve seen this all before”. A breath of fresh air is direly needed in today’s literature but not only in ideas-it is also required in their coming to life. No matter. Superpowers and a lot of action will surely keep many kids glued onto the pages of this novel.
December 25, 2016
کتاب فرال ها به نظرم ایده خیلی جالبی داشت، از اون ایده هایی بود که حس میکردم از خوندنش خیلی لذت ببرم، چون حال و هوای داستان با روحیات من نزدیک بود و در کل، چیزی بود که دوست داشتم. داستان به نظرم ریتم کلی جالبی داشت، مثلا اغلب کارهای نوجوانی که خوندم، داستان یکسری جریانات خاص رو میگذروند و در آخرش، دقیقا به همون نقطه ای میرسید که باید برسه. به شخصه آخر کتاب نه غافلگیر شدم، نه هیجان زده. چون حس میکردم تقریبا از همون اواسط کار پایانش معلوم بود.
داستان در کل خیلی موارد مثبت داشت، که برای کار اول یک نویسنده خوب بود. مثلا من توصیف های کتاب رو دوست داشتم و کاراکترهایی هم که ساخته بود قابل قبول بودن.
انتقام زبان کلاغی، در کل کتاب نسبتا خوبی بود، اگه که سطح انتظارتون ازش زیاد بالا نباشه. و صد البته یکی از بهترین گزینه ها برای گذروندن یه عصر سردِ زمستونه که حوصله هیچ کاری رو ندارین.
داستان در کل خیلی موارد مثبت داشت، که برای کار اول یک نویسنده خوب بود. مثلا من توصیف های کتاب رو دوست داشتم و کاراکترهایی هم که ساخته بود قابل قبول بودن.
انتقام زبان کلاغی، در کل کتاب نسبتا خوبی بود، اگه که سطح انتظارتون ازش زیاد بالا نباشه. و صد البته یکی از بهترین گزینه ها برای گذروندن یه عصر سردِ زمستونه که حوصله هیچ کاری رو ندارین.
July 11, 2015
My nephews will really enjoy this book. This is a great thing as I picked this book up for them in mind. However, I did not really see too much similarity to the Batman reference. I thought that this book was in its own way different from Batman and this is a good thing. I like different.
Caw is someone that the readers can connect with. He is the underdog that turns into the hero. Plus, he has a cool ability to be able to communicate with crows like a horse whisperer.in addition, I liked the names of the characters in this book. Besides Caw there is Milky, Crumb, Quaker, and Spinning Man to name a few. The characters in this book are not boring.
Caw is someone that the readers can connect with. He is the underdog that turns into the hero. Plus, he has a cool ability to be able to communicate with crows like a horse whisperer.in addition, I liked the names of the characters in this book. Besides Caw there is Milky, Crumb, Quaker, and Spinning Man to name a few. The characters in this book are not boring.
September 10, 2019
Sesuai blurb di belakang buku, Ferals memang middle grade fantasy yang menceritakan tentang pengendali hewan.
Caw, tokoh utama buku ini, pengendali gagak. Semua berawal dari dia yang selalu terganggu oleh mimpi masa lalu, kemudian menemukan keanehan di kotanya yang dia yakini berhubungan dengan mimpi itu.
__________
Menurutku, buku ini cukup seru. Pas jadi middle grade. Aman dibaca anak-anak yang cari bacaan fantasi. Lumayaaan.
Untukku pribadi, Ferals belum mendapatkan kesan yang terlalu mendalam. Belum tahu akan lanjut ke buku keduanya atau ngga. Kita lihat nanti 😁😁
Caw, tokoh utama buku ini, pengendali gagak. Semua berawal dari dia yang selalu terganggu oleh mimpi masa lalu, kemudian menemukan keanehan di kotanya yang dia yakini berhubungan dengan mimpi itu.
__________
Menurutku, buku ini cukup seru. Pas jadi middle grade. Aman dibaca anak-anak yang cari bacaan fantasi. Lumayaaan.
Untukku pribadi, Ferals belum mendapatkan kesan yang terlalu mendalam. Belum tahu akan lanjut ke buku keduanya atau ngga. Kita lihat nanti 😁😁
May 7, 2015
Heroes for the younger generation which will grow up with them as the story progresses . Well written, fast paced and interesting and likeable characters. The orphaned Caw and the crows especially with his new friends the brave Lydia., Crumb and Pip and their animals. I can see why this has been snapped up by 31 countries and film makers already. it would make an awesome film if it is done right. Good versus evil, Caw has so much to learn. Interested to read more:)
March 12, 2017
Īsti rudenīga grāmata. Dažbrīd pat creepy momenti un nāves gadījumi. Noteikti attaisnoja manas cerības, kuras uzšāvās debesīs kopš pirmo reizi ieraudzīju "Ferals" tulkojuma izziņojumu. Šķiet, ka es katru reizi pārvēršos par 12 gadīgu puišeli un no tiesas izbaudu šīs bērnu piedzīvojumu un fantāzijas grāmatas.
https://vilkamidzenis.wordpress.com/2...
https://vilkamidzenis.wordpress.com/2...
February 17, 2017
اگه توی دوران راهنماییم می خوندمش شاید یکی از داستان های مورد علاقه م می شد. و همین الان هم اگه کسی بتونه توقعاتشو کنترل کنه و انتظار شخصیت پردازی یا مفهوم سنگینی نداشته باشه، ازش لذت می بره. ایده ی بامزه ای داشت، و نمی دونم از این ایده قبلا جایی استفاده شده یا نه، ولی فکر کنم در هر صورت چنین ایده ای میتونست طوری شاخ و برگ پیدا کنه که تبدیل به یه چیز بزرگ بشه. و فکر کنم الان توی موقعیتی نیستم که اجازه ی نقد جدی داشته باشم.
پی نوشت: نمیدونم توی ریویوو جای این صحبتا هست یا نه؛ ترجمه ی روون و دوست داشتنی ای داشت، ولی گهگاهی همراه بود با ایرادات تایپی یا ویراستاری یا هرچیز تخصصی ای که اسمشو بلد نیستم ولی خب به چشم میان. و امیدوارم توی چاپ های بعدی یا جلدهای بعدی نباشن.
پی نوشت: نمیدونم توی ریویوو جای این صحبتا هست یا نه؛ ترجمه ی روون و دوست داشتنی ای داشت، ولی گهگاهی همراه بود با ایرادات تایپی یا ویراستاری یا هرچیز تخصصی ای که اسمشو بلد نیستم ولی خب به چشم میان. و امیدوارم توی چاپ های بعدی یا جلدهای بعدی نباشن.
October 20, 2017
La început mă gândeam că voi parcurge repejor cartea și că mă voi relaxa citind. M-am relaxat, dar am rămas surprinsă de modul în care autorul a împletit această poveste. În primele pagini am crezut că voi merge pe urmele lui Caw, piesa centrală a acestui roman, dar, ca să rămân în nota cărții, dinaintea ochilor mi s-a desfășurat o pânză de păianjen. Am dat de urma altor fire care m-au dus într-o sferă fantastică și mi-a făcut cunoștință cu alți înzestrați.
https://ancasicartile.wordpress.com/2...
March 16, 2017
Can I just say, the names in this book, were so ironic, and so badly made that I basically cringed on every page as it mentioned people;s names. I mean, there's a kid named Caw, who can talk to crows. And what are his crow's names? Oh their names are Screech, and Milky. I did somewhat enjoy the story though, even if it had god-awful names.
January 9, 2018
Was it a good book? Yes.
Did I like it? Yes
Will I read the next one? Yes
I actually liked this book more than I thought I would, and I love the plot of the series.
For me the book is a little short, I would have liked to be longer and more detailed. But all in all it was a good book :)
Did I like it? Yes
Will I read the next one? Yes
I actually liked this book more than I thought I would, and I love the plot of the series.
For me the book is a little short, I would have liked to be longer and more detailed. But all in all it was a good book :)
zzz-books-not-for-me
January 27, 2016Read from September 26 to 27, 2015, DNF
Ahhh, pretty cover...helas, it was not meant to be.
Ahhh, pretty cover...helas, it was not meant to be.
September 1, 2019
*baca di Gramedia Digital
=)
cukup lumayan cerita'y..
cocok buat dibaca para remaja, nggak ribet, sederhana cerita'y..
di tunggu lanjutan'y..
:D
eeh tapi, kalau ini dijadiin film, mungkin q nggak bakalan nonton..
terlalu banyak binatang yg mati, nggak tega lihat'y..
yaach kecuali ular dan kecoak sich..
:p
=)
cukup lumayan cerita'y..
cocok buat dibaca para remaja, nggak ribet, sederhana cerita'y..
di tunggu lanjutan'y..
:D
eeh tapi, kalau ini dijadiin film, mungkin q nggak bakalan nonton..
terlalu banyak binatang yg mati, nggak tega lihat'y..
yaach kecuali ular dan kecoak sich..
:p
May 7, 2017
Lectura simple, idea interesante...
Añadiendo más narrativa y más guión hubiera hecho de este libro una historia perfecta.
Bueno pero no excelente.
Añadiendo más narrativa y más guión hubiera hecho de este libro una historia perfecta.
Bueno pero no excelente.
July 16, 2015
I received a free copy of this book by the book's publishers via NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.
Caw keeps having the same dream/nightmare every night. He's being thrown out of a window by his parents and then is saved by crows. The thing is, it doesn't feel like a dream, it's more of a memory to be precise. Living without his parents, Caw's sole companions are three crows. Living and finding food with his three crow companions is day to day life until everything changes. Why can Caw communicate with Crows? Why does he keep dreaming about spiders? Perhaps more importantly, are there truly any human he can trust?
This book blew me away. It has to be one of the best books I have read so far this year and after reading a book that I didn't particuarly enjoy, it couldn't have been more welcome. The whole concept of Ferals, escaped prisoners and extraordinary powers was brilliant and is executed just as well! This will appeal to boys and girls alike and has the potential to be one of those extraordinary books which get children (or even adults) passionate about reading! As a trainee teacher, this is certainly a book which I want to share with pupils to enthuse, engage and motivate them to delve into the magical worlds of books!
Caw is an extremely likeable protagonist and seeing the world of Ferals through his eyes really helps the reader to empathise with his plight. An orphan child, completely alone, apart from the company of three crows. Seeing families with wealth, food, security, love and happiness. A world that juxtaposes/contrasts the harsh reality of Caw's life. Can a little girl, a librarian and animals change his life? You're just going to have to read the book to find out!
Highly recommended for children and adults alike. 5/5 stars!
Caw keeps having the same dream/nightmare every night. He's being thrown out of a window by his parents and then is saved by crows. The thing is, it doesn't feel like a dream, it's more of a memory to be precise. Living without his parents, Caw's sole companions are three crows. Living and finding food with his three crow companions is day to day life until everything changes. Why can Caw communicate with Crows? Why does he keep dreaming about spiders? Perhaps more importantly, are there truly any human he can trust?
This book blew me away. It has to be one of the best books I have read so far this year and after reading a book that I didn't particuarly enjoy, it couldn't have been more welcome. The whole concept of Ferals, escaped prisoners and extraordinary powers was brilliant and is executed just as well! This will appeal to boys and girls alike and has the potential to be one of those extraordinary books which get children (or even adults) passionate about reading! As a trainee teacher, this is certainly a book which I want to share with pupils to enthuse, engage and motivate them to delve into the magical worlds of books!
Caw is an extremely likeable protagonist and seeing the world of Ferals through his eyes really helps the reader to empathise with his plight. An orphan child, completely alone, apart from the company of three crows. Seeing families with wealth, food, security, love and happiness. A world that juxtaposes/contrasts the harsh reality of Caw's life. Can a little girl, a librarian and animals change his life? You're just going to have to read the book to find out!
Highly recommended for children and adults alike. 5/5 stars!
July 1, 2016
فرال ها، انسان هایی هستند که توانایی صحبت کردن و ارتباط برقرار کردن با حیوانات رو دارند. حالا، بعضی از فرال ها قصد دارند از حیوانات سو استفاده کرده و به قدرت و تسلط بر شهر بلک استون (شهری که به طرز عجیبی تمام فرال ها در آن زندگی می کنند) دست پیدا کنند.
کاو، به عنوان فرالی که قدرت ارتباط با کلاغ ها را دارد، باید با بازگشت مخوف ترین فرال، یعنی فرال عنکبوتی، مقابله کند.
کودک-نوجوانِ خوبی بود. هیجان داشت، جذاب بود، کشش خوبی داشت، اما چیز به یاد موندنی ای نبود. حداقل برای من.
اگر سعی کنید فقط لذت ببرید، کتاب باهاتون خوب همراهی می کنه. اما اگر بخواید حتا یه خرده سختگیر باشید، منطق داستان خیلی جاها لنگ می زنه و تقریبن تمام اتفاقات قابل پیشبینیه.
پ.ن) در توضیحات اصلی کتاب نوشته شده این کتاب ملهم از کتاب گورستان و بتمنه. مطلقا ذره ای شباهت با این دو داستان ندیدم توش.
کاو، به عنوان فرالی که قدرت ارتباط با کلاغ ها را دارد، باید با بازگشت مخوف ترین فرال، یعنی فرال عنکبوتی، مقابله کند.
کودک-نوجوانِ خوبی بود. هیجان داشت، جذاب بود، کشش خوبی داشت، اما چیز به یاد موندنی ای نبود. حداقل برای من.
اگر سعی کنید فقط لذت ببرید، کتاب باهاتون خوب همراهی می کنه. اما اگر بخواید حتا یه خرده سختگیر باشید، منطق داستان خیلی جاها لنگ می زنه و تقریبن تمام اتفاقات قابل پیشبینیه.
پ.ن) در توضیحات اصلی کتاب نوشته شده این کتاب ملهم از کتاب گورستان و بتمنه. مطلقا ذره ای شباهت با این دو داستان ندیدم توش.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 387 reviews