Hold On to Your Kids: Why Parents Need to Matter More Than Peers

Hold On to Your Kids: Why Parents Need to Matter More Than Peers

4.24 of 5 stars 4.24  ·  rating details  ·  799 ratings  ·  174 reviews
A psychologist with a reputation for penetrating to the heart of complex parenting issues joins forces with a physician and bestselling author to tackle one of the most disturbing and misunderstood trends of our time -- peers replacing parents in the lives of our children.

Dr. Neufeld has dubbed this phenomenon peer orientation, which refers to the tendency of children and...more
Paperback, 320 pages
Published August 15th 2006 by Ballantine Books (first published 2004)
more details... edit details

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.
The Baby Book by William SearsWhat to Expect When You're Expecting by Heidi MurkoffHow to Talk So Kids Will Listen & Listen So Kids Will Talk by Adele FaberThe No-Cry Sleep Solution by Elizabeth PantleyNurtureShock by Po Bronson
Most Influential Parenting Books
32nd out of 196 books — 255 voters
Freakonomics by Steven D. LevittThe Tipping Point by Malcolm GladwellOutliers by Malcolm GladwellBlink by Malcolm GladwellNickel and Dimed by Barbara Ehrenreich
Sociology Books
102nd out of 229 books — 197 voters


More lists with this book...

Community Reviews

(showing 1-30 of 2,048)
filter  |  sort: default (?)  |  rating details
Genet
Apr 19, 2008 Genet rated it 5 of 5 stars  ·  review of another edition Recommends it for: all parents, and anyone thinking of becoming a parent!
Recommended to Genet by: Alison Bennett
My favorite parenting book of all time. While it is not extremely well-written (in a literary or organizational sense), I absolutely love and believe in the ideas presented in this book. Neufeld very clearly identifies the underlying problems in our culture that pull our children away from us. Children need to attach to parents, grandparents, and other adults who can help them develop a true sense of self. We are robbing our children (and ourselves) when we push them too quickly out into the wor...more
Tara Hendricks
Children need to know in very concrete ways that you and the other adults in their lives are available to them always and for all things. I really liked this book because it gave me good ideas for ensuring that my children turn to me (and other adults that I trust), lean on me and stay attached to me as they grow. This book shows how very important it is for children to be attached to the adults in their lives. Their parents, their teachers, their grandparents, or family friends. If they don't h...more
Wendee
Polarization occurs in relationships, which explains why youth shun their parents when they attach to their peers... they can't see how to have both connections. It is soooo important for parents to spend plenty of time with their kids in fun engaging activities.

For me, this is one of the main reasons I homeschool... I could never find enough time to spend with my children when they were gone from 8am to 4pm and then racing off to other activities when they weren't at school. Now, I can actually...more
Jessica
if i could file-copy Neufeld's brain and upload it into my own I would be there in a heartbeat! lol. his passion seems to be in regards to the attachment of children to their parents, and the need for children to be attached to a caring adult rather than to their peers. his DVD seminars are great as well!

Neufeld is also against 'time outs.' i'll butcher the reasons he gave and you really ought to read the book, but basically he calls for a 'time in.' the need to re-collect our kiddos, kind of li...more
Heidi Thorsen
I thought the first part of the book where the author gives examples of the horrors that can result when kids are "peer oriented" went on a bit too long, but did find the chapters where he eventually got around to explaining concrete steps to take to maintain parental attachment while avoiding or reversing peer attachment to be useful.



Before reading this book, I thought kids would "attach" to their parents based largely on the sheer quantity of time they spent together, but the authors have exp...more
Eva Musby
I'd recommend this to any parent, but I'm writing this review from the point of view of a parent whose child suffered from anorexia. What you’ll find in this book is very, very relevant to parenting a child with anorexia, especially if you’re hesitant about your strong role around meals, or if you feel tempted to give up when your child screams how much they hate you because you are asking them to eat. It will help you clarify your role as a supportive, caring parent who does what’s needed witho...more
Wendy
I thought this book was excellent. It really highlighted so many problems that we have in society and the writing style, as another reviewer pointed out is a bit alarmist and I think it is warranted. As a society we are losing our children! The rise in bullying and ADHD diagnosis/difficulty teaching are addressed and it all makes sense!

I picked up this book because I am a parent and am interested in child development. It later came into use and I subsequently bought THREE more copies of the boo...more
Jen
Here's what I put on my blog about it:

A few months ago a friend blogged about a book she had read. Seeing how it seemed to have an impact on her and respecting her as a seriously amazing mom, I decided to pick it up. She was right. It was one of those books that I would try to relay to Ryan after every chapter I read. (And he even listened, which is sort of, um, rare.) It's obviously a little older than the stage my kids are at, but I'm glad I read it before I get to that point where your kids a...more
Corinne
The premise of this astounding book is that in today's culture, more and more children are living their lives being more attached to their peers than their parents. Sound mind-blowing? Maybe not, but at the soul of this book is the idea that our attachment to our children is the one crucial thing that our children cannot truly grow-up without. The book goes in-depth into attachment theory, but not so deep that you can't find your way out again and understand how necessary it is. We learn about h...more
Cheryl
Sep 23, 2007 Cheryl rated it 4 of 5 stars Recommends it for: all parents, maybe educators
Neufeld suggests children lose attachment to their families as they slowly develop attachment to their peers. This makes perfect sense and the way he lays out the background of family/friend contact over history really seemed plausible. This whole topic fascinates me. I also agreed with his ideas about how to rebuild attachment. I did find myself disagreeing with a few things the author wrote -can't exactly remember them, sorry. But overrall, his ideas were inspirational to me.
Michael
I definitely underestimated this book. This is why it languished on the shelf for a few years before I picked it up. I expected yet another underwhelming parenting book. Instead I encountered a revolutionary interpretation of the role of attachment in the lives of our youngsters and an exploration of the implications of this on our culture and our role as parents. The basic neurodevelopmental role of attachment in the establishment of natural authority is explained and the toxic influences of mo...more
Ruth
This is probably the best parenting book I have ever read. It explains so much about peer-dominated culture, why it keeps getting worse, and why kids succumb to it at younger and younger ages.

As our kids grow up, they are put into far too many situations where they are expected to develop dependent relationships on their peers rather than on mature adults. Classroom sizes are too big, parents are too busy with work or life stresses or only one parent is present, families are often isolated from...more
Rudy Dyck
I give this book 4 stars as a resource book. Quite frankly some of the material in here is fantastic and deserves a higher rating. However the book would be 2 stars at best if I ranked it for enjoyable reading. It reads more like a textbook.

Gordon Neufeld shares his work on the problems of kids and their relationships with their parents which he attributes to not enough time spent together. Their is a price to pay for daycare but there are ways to overcome it.

There are a number of stories, stati...more
Jamie Maltman
Read this for your kids' sake. I very strongly recommend this book to all current and future parents.

If your kids are little or not born yet, you'll find some very good principles to work with to build the best relationship possible for your kids to prepare them for life.

If your kids are older, this book may help you understand the roots of current or future conflicts, and how working on the relationship and attachment will help you navigate through these.

This is expecially important for fami...more
Willa
Jun 17, 2011 Willa added it
Shelves: 52-books-in-2011
This is one of my favorite parenting books. I have reread it several times and always get something valuable to take away from it. It describes vividly the same peer-orientation behavior that you see in books like Reviving Ophelia and Odd Girl Out. I like the way the authors write, and find their insight almost always convincing.

What distinguishes their book from other parenting manuals is that as it says, it does not simply offer a list of strategies. The authors say that thinking of parenting...more
Zane
This book solidifies the importance of parents in the lives of children. I also like how the book looked at the idea of how children are raising children. As an educator myself I note how influential modeling can be and also the lack of modeling when parents delegate the responsibility of raising their children to others. The other interesting note is how globalization is changing the structure of families. The idea of community and having an aunt or uncle to be there to help mentor or guide a c...more
reed
I picked this up because I heard about the author's concept of counterwill - that innate human tendency to resist when someone tries to control you. But I was turned off by his "kids these days" rhetoric. Didn't make it past the first chapter.
Christina
I picked up the book "Hold On to Your Kids: Why Parents Need to Matter More Than Peers" by Gordon Neufeld, and I did not put it down until I finished all 279 pages of it, including the glossary. Gordon Neufeld, Ph.D. is an expert on child development and his co-author Gabor Mate, M.D. Together they provide a sobering look at what "peer orientation" is and why it stunts the emotional maturation of our children. The devastating effects of this all-too-common phenomenon are seen everyday, from chil...more
Jennifer
This is an important book about maintaining your connection to your children as they grow older. Neufeld argues that having teens pull away from their parents and orient to their peers is not a natural process (only developing in the last few generations) and is very unhealthy for kids and society as a whole. I thought he spent too much time on his explanation of the problem, though. I would have preferred more discussion of strategies of maintaining and strengthening attachment.

Edit:
I forgot to...more
Samira Kawash
My daughter is turning 10, and this book came at just the right time. The author shows the danger of allowing our children to become peer-oriented rather than parent-oriented, and the importance of maintaining strong, supportive relations between parents and children even as our children mature and become more independent. Friends are NOT the most important thing; they are other children, by nature irresponsible and unreliable. Neufeld argues that by keeping out kids firmly attached to us, their...more
Stephanie
Fantastic book, one of the best parenting books that I have read. The theory is amazing, potent, relevant, and laid out very clearly, with many examples. This may be an updated version compared to the one I read, but it would be mainly the same. This book is a heavy read b/c it is full of relevant content, but it is compelling at the same time. I originally borrowed this book from the library but ended up buying it b/c I knew that I needed to reread much of the book to really grasp all of the su...more
Rorie
This the attachment parenting book to read after you can't carry them in slings anymore, they've stopped breastfeeding, and they're out of the family bed....almost. This book explained A LOT of what ails us as a society and what ails (sad to say) a LOT of young people. The book goes on a bit too long about what is wrong ( all right I GET it already) but overall a very important read for anyone coming into contact with non-adults. I want to get one for every parent I know. I've tried some of the...more
Go2therock
This book warrants a thorough reading by any and all parents. I could invest in a discussion on a page by page basis. Although it is a secular book, there is a tremendous amount of parenting wisdom within. Being an adoptive mother, I was familiar with the issue of Attachment. But I had never made the connection of Attachment as a purely parental-child foundation. I really connected it in my mind as an issue of adoption. However, as I reflected upon all five of my children and the years we have s...more
Robina
I found myself really ambivalent about this book. While I found myself nodding in agreement about some of the ways in which American parenting has gone wrong and lost perspective, I also found the complete disavowal of peer relationships to be a bit absurd. I did like some of the suggestions for "positive discipline" at the end and the way in which such suggestions are rooted in the repair of connection first and foremost, but overall I found myself feeling a little antagonistic to the book. But...more
Tia
Absolutely one of my favorite advice/parenting books on the market today!
Darlene
I received this audiobook from the publisher in exchange for an honest review. I did not receive any compensation for my review, and the views expressed herein are my own.

This is an invaluable resource for any parent who is concerned about the effects of peers on their children.

The advice given by Drs. Neufeld and Maté really resonated with me, and it validated my instinctual parenting practices. I have always been a proponent of attachment parenting, and I consider my children's attachment bond...more
Laura
I had heard of this book a few times in the past and was never interested in reading it because the title sounded to me like, "how to be a nightmare helicopter parent that gives your child no freedom or space" That is NOT what this book is about. The message of this book is extremely important and has hugely influenced my parenting. I am so grateful to have discovered this book BEFORE my children hit the teen years so that I can lay the groundwork now for a good relationship later. A good relati...more
Sarah
Nov 13, 2009 Sarah rated it 4 of 5 stars Recommends it for: New Parents
I slso rate this book a 5 for content and a 2 for writing. It is terribly repetitive and poorly organized. However, Neufeld very clearly identifies peer orientation as the underlying problem in our culture that pulls our children away from us. Children need to attach to parents, grandparents, and other adults who can help them mature and develop a true sense of self. I love what one reviewer wrote, "We are robbing our children (and ourselves) when we push them too quickly out into the world with...more
Nora
I really appreciated this book very much. Dr. Gabor Mate signed this book for me when I bought it at a conference. He had done an outstanding presentation.In the book he explained how to reach the teens who were so much in search of finding their identities through their relationship with peers and in some cases were excluding their parents completely.He had some humorous bits about teens and their attachment to their technology devices and explained how both a relationship to family and peers i...more
Andrea Paterson
There are some good ideas in this book, but they don't happen until more than half way through. Far too much of this book is dedicated to repetitively outlining the horrors that will befall children if they become peer rather than adult oriented. Neufeld goes too far in driving home the point that parents will end up with completely screwed up children if they don't follow his advice and attach to their children properly. I was annoyed with the tone of the opening chapters and the insinuation th...more
« previous 1 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 68 69 next »
There are no discussion topics on this book yet. Be the first to start one »
Hold Onto Your Kids (Paperback)
Hold On to Your Kids: Why Parents Need to Matter More Than Peers (Paperback)
Hold On to Your Kids: Why Parents Matter (Hardcover)
Hold On to Your Kids: Why Parents Need to Matter More Than Peers (Hardcover)
Hold On to Your Kids: Why Parents Need to Matter More Than Peers (ebook)

61795
Dr. Gordon Neufeld is a Vancouver-based developmental psychologist who consults with parents and professionals regarding children and their problems. He brings to us his unique synthesis of the developmental literature and his exceptional ability to make children understandable. He has a widespread reputation for being able to make sense of difficult and complex problems and for opening doors for...more
More about Gordon Neufeld...
Heartbreak and Rage: Ten Years Under Sun Myung Moon Retrouver Son Rôle De Parent Teenagers: A Natural History: A Natural History

Share This Book

Your website
“The key to activating maturation is to take care of the attachment needs of the child. To foster independance we must first invite dependance; to promote individuation we must provide a sense of belonging and unity; to help the child separate we must assume the responsibility for keeping the child close. We help a child let go by providing more contact and connection than he himself is seeking. When he asks for a hug, we give him a warmer one than he is giving us. We liberate children not by making them work for our love but by letting them rest in it. We help a child face the separation involved in going to sleep or going to school by satisfying his need for closeness.” 4 people liked it
“Children learn best when they like their teacher and they think their teacher likes them.” 4 people liked it
More quotes…