Title: The Alphabet from A to Y with bonus letter Z!
Author: Steve Martin and Roz Chast
Genre: picture book
Theme(s): Alphabet book
Opening line/sentence: A Anuabke Amy, Alice, and Andie Ate all the anchovy sandwiches handy.
Professional Recommendation/Review #1:
Publishers Weekly
Actor, playwright and novelist Martin (Shopgirl) branches into picture books for this nutty abecedary. No humdrum "A is for apple" list, this volume faces outrageous, alliterative couplets with full-page cartoons approximating the situations they describe. Known for skewering middle-class anxieties, Chast (Meet My Staff) ably sketches scenes of kitchen mayhem ("Friday when Frank fixed frijoles and French fries/ His fiancée Franny was covered in fruit flies") and pictures the main office for Xerxes Xylophones, where a bizarre X-perience unfolds ("Ambidextrous Alex was actually axed/ For waxing, then faxing, his boss's new slacks"). She also supplements the nonsense rhymes with added images of items that start with the highlighted letter (when "Quincy the kumquat querie[s] the queen," readers see a bookshelf of tomes on quintuplets, quantum mechanics and quartz). Martin and Chast show their mettle as each other's wacky sidekicks, performing for an all-ages crowd. Adults see two well-known artists at work, creating mind-bending tableaux, while children get a taste of original tongue twisters. This peculiar and funny book resembles a round of the Surrealists' game of exquisite cadaver or Mad Libs, worked out in a dizzying combination of words and pictures. All ages. (Oct.)
Professional Recommendation/Review #2:
KIRKUS REVIEW
This high-profile crossover will slide effortlessly onto the bestseller lists, but it’s not likely to win its creators many new adult fans—or any child ones. Showing a fine disregard for foolish consistencies like end words that actually rhyme consistently, Martin fashions surreal situations in 26 couplets, each paired to a literal illustration from Chast strewn with both her customary cast of homely, anxious figures and other words or items that feature the selected letter. Though some spreads have a certain verbal and visual bounce—in the art for “Pedro the puppy piled poop on his paws / And Papa dog published his photo because,” for instance, the peeved paternal parent brandishes a copy of “Popular Pooch,” as mama dog praises a parsnip pizza—more often the captions read like random words strung together. Furthermore, some of the image choices, such as the 107 (or so) hunchbacks in Henrietta’s hairdo, or the drunk wandering past David the dog-faced boy, skate to the edge of poor taste. A gallery of accented letters on the endpapers provides some added value, but not enough. Like Shirley and Milton Glaser’s The Alphazeds (2003), any resemblance to a title for tots is coincidental. (Picture book. Adult)
Response to Two Professional Reviews: Among the two reviews, the first one is more positive, but the second one is more negative. Both of them show me that this is an alphabet book that will work for any age. But it seems like it won’t work with children very well. Or say it won’t be appealed to children very much. The illustrations
Evaluation of Literary Elements: The texts are a bit too complicated for kids who are still learning alphabet. May be it should be used as a read- aloud. And teach the children a basic idea of alphabet.
Consideration of Instructional Application: This is not an appropriate choice for children to read alone, they will get so confused. I will do read- aloud with this book, and use the texts as a tongue twister for kids to develop their oral language skill.