Having already read Dickens and Shakespeare, it was with great expectation that I started working my way through this, the collection of the great Oscar Wildes work.
Unfortunately, the first book, The Picture of Dorian Gray, which forms the centrepiece of this collection, does not get the collection off to a good start. The main character is completely unlikeable, which makes it hard to feel any sympathy, or indeed interest in his story. The plot itself lumbers along at a glacial pace, and the ending leaves the reader feeling cold. is rather disappointing. To Victorian Britain, 'The Picture of Dorian Gray' may have been shocking, but it is also incredibly shallow, and the first half of the novel appears to be more a comment on society than the fiction you were expecting.
Whilst the next entry, the title story in the 'Happy Prince' collection, is an excellent little tale of morality, it also demonstrates Wilde's major failing. Perhaps seeing success in the first story, he then proceeds to use the same tack again and again. Unfortunately, the stories are clumsy, and rather pointless, with the 'The Nightingale and the Rose' being perhaps the worst example.
There is also a particular conversation that is copied, almost exactly word for word, at least four times throughout this collection. It raises a small smile the first time, but is downright annoying the third.
However, just as you feel that there is little to commend, 'Lord Arthur Savile's Crime' begins. This is an excellent tale, similar in style to 'Tales of the unexpected', and for the first time, i started to see what the hype was about. 'The Canterville Ghost' is just as good, if not better, and it is in stories such as these that the writing feels best suited. It is just a shame that this peak is so quickly over.
The plays are of similarly varied quality. 'The Importance of Being Earnest' is excellent, and 'An Ideal Husband' and 'Lady Windermere's Fan' are very good, being witty, relatively concise (which i cannot say for most of his work)and are a joy to read through. Unfortunately, other plays, 'Salome' in particular, are awful, and carry on the hard to understand obsession with living by the commandments. Such sentiments feel forced, clumsy, and in fact unnecessary, as my favourite works feature none of this.
The poetry, which is also riddled with strict Victorian values, also features numerous, and repetitive references to ancient Greece. For those with limited knowledge of ancient Greece, the bulk of the poems will pass them by, and even for those who do understand the references, the poetry is heavy going. In fact, i can recommend hardly any of it, because reading it feels like you are wading through treacle. It is only right at the end, the very last poem, that you can take any joy from the writing. 'The Ballad of Reading Gaol' is witty, interesting, and more importantly, a good story.
Most of this collection is hard work and difficult to enjoy, and had this not been a 30p book from a charity shop, I would have felt robbed. However, the aforementioned 'Sir Arthur Savile's Crime', 'The Importance of Being Earnest' and the final poem are a real joy to read, and it for this reason that I give the collection as a whole 2 stars. Were I reviewing the best of his work separate, this rating would be much higher.