TRANSITIONAL CHAPTER BOOK
Title: High Tide in Hawaii
Author: Mary Pope Osborne
Illustrator: Sal Murdocca
Genre: Transitional Chapter Book, Fantasy, Fiction
Theme(s): Magic, Time travel, Hawaii, Friendship
Opening line/sentence: “Jack and Annie were sitting on their porch reading books.”
Brief Book Summary:
In this book, Jack and Annie travel to a Hawaiian island in search of a ship, or so they think. They discover a village of people doing the hula and join in, making friends with a brother and sister named Kama and Boka. Jack and Annie spend the night with their new friends, share in a meal with them, learn about their way of life and go surfing. Jack, who doesn’t succeed at learning to surf, feels the earth shake as the others paddle out to catch a wave. He reads in his book that tsunamis are often the result of earthquakes on the island and rushes to save his sister and friends. They get to higher ground safely and return to Frog Creek as Magicians of Everyday Magic, learning that the ship they were searching for was actually friendship.
Professional Recommendation/Review #1:
Osborne, Mary Pope High Tide in Hawaii
76 pp. Random (Random House Children's Books) 2003. LE ISBN 0-375-90616-9 PE ISBN 0-375-80616-4
(4) 1-3 Illustrated by Sal Murdocca. Magic Tree House series. In their twenty-eighth adventure, Jack and Annie wish themselves from their magic tree house to Hawaii, where they make friends with siblings Boka and Kama, learn to surf, and narrowly escape a tsunami before returning to their family. Hawaiian details are accurate, if predictable; the plot is exciting, if quickly resolved; and the text, with black-and-white illustrations, is readable by novices.
Professional Recommendation/Review #2:
Danielle Williams (Children's Literature)
In this continuation of the children's series the "Magic Tree House," Jack and Annie are whisked away to old Hawaii. When they arrive they are just in time to attend a Luau and meet two young Hawaiians who open their home to them for the night. The next day the four children go surfing, an activity that Jack is uncertain about. After his first failed attempt, and teasing from the other children, he waits on the beach while the other children go surfing again. While he is waiting he feels an earthquake and consults one of his books on Hawaii for more information. He reads that earthquakes at Hawaii can result in a tsunami and quickly catches the other children's attention and warns them of the danger. The children make it to safety just in time and Jack and Annie soon return to their own time. Tidbits of information about Hawaiian culture and history intersperse the text, along with illustrations of scenes occurring in the chapters. Some background information is provided concerning how the children found the Magic Tree House, and how they know where they are going and the tasks they are supposed to perform. However, the book would be more interesting if read as part of the series instead of as a stand-alone piece of fiction. A very brief Hawaiian timeline and brief facts about Hawaii appear at the end of the text, along with a list of titles in the Magic Tree House Series. High Tide in Hawaii is number 28 in the "Magic Tree House"
Response to Two Professional Reviews:
As stated in these reviews, High Tide in Hawaii is a predictable, transitional chapter book with basic illustrations, predictable plot, and few dispersed informational facts about Hawaii and the people who live there. The book, when read as a continuation of the series, would be more enjoyable than if read alone. The information provided in the book gives a quick overview into old Hawaiian culture and a message about the importance of friendship.
Evaluation of Literary Elements:
This book is a good choice for a transitional chapter book. The plot is predictable while the written language is simple yet descriptive. Young readers will enjoy learning about old Hawaii through the tidbits of informational facts dispersed in the writing. The few black and white illustrations allow for readers to use their imaginations to fill in the blanks to create mental images of the scenes. Overall, this book provides informational facts, allows for imagination, has a simple plot and conflict resolution, and has a central message of friendship that is relatable to young readers.
Consideration of Instructional Application:
Instructional Applications for this book could focus on three different topics: tsunamis as natural disasters and the geography of Hawaii, historical Hawaii culture and lifestyle, or friendship. Lessons could be based on learning more about how tsunamis are created, why they are created, where they are most likely to occur, what their aftermath is and what the history of tsunamis in Hawaii is. Lessons could also be based on telling stories through hula dancing, what the daily lives of historical Hawaiian people were like, and diving deeper into cultural facts and experiences. Lastly, lessons could also be based on creating friendships and what makes a good friend and how Annie, Jack, Kama and Boka showed that.