[I have deleted my previous review because I recently found a better one! The following review is an email I sent to D. Harlan Wilson shortly after I finished reading the book.]
I finished reading your book last night. It’s bizarre. It defies explanation. It will scare people away [...] and nobody will know what to do with it. This is a good sign. Things that are easily categorized are easily forgotten, so people who read this will have no choice but to assimilate its memory into their subconscious and somehow live with the consequences. I’m glad I did. It’s a great trip. My heart was pounding after I read it.
“Dr. Identity” seized me by the neck, slapped me a dozen times [...] while it recited Vogon poetry with the voice and eloquence of the Cheshire Cat singing Jabberwocky. The experience was suffocating, painful, guiltily pleasurable and at the same time suicide-inducing and melodiously gorgeous (in that order).
There is no back story. Little world building. No gradual process to bring the reader into this world. No explanation of why the world is the way it is. No inclination even if this world is supposed to be seen as a real place, a real future, a distorted view of the present, or even anything at all. It forced me to look in the chaos and energy of the events for something to ground my sanity, instead of relying on character development and back story.
You have written a living, breathing, surreal monster of nonsense that the brain will struggle to organize. The brain hates chaos, and it will look for patterns in the chaos so it doesn’t get caught in an infinite loop. Because of this tendency of my brain, I got the feeling that I knew exactly what was going on. Somewhere in the chaos and raw energy there seemed to be purpose to the events. On the edge of comprehension, maybe inside a node of my reptilian-derived brain structure that even Freud did not imagine was there, the mechanics, dynamics and hyperphallics of this world *made sense.*
I enjoyed reading it. The energy it contains is incredible and the ending feels appropriate. The hopelessness, mindlessness and total chaos of life in Bliptown...it’s enough to make anyone insane. It’s funny in a very dark kind of way. I loved chapter one, the lecture scene (damn student-things!). The lobster was great, too. The childproofed dragon vehicle that shot Spaghetti-O’s made me laugh, and the newscast was perfect. The questions he asks Dr. Blah's wife-thing all in one breath are exactly the kinds of questions I've come to expect from reporters! And don’t forget the politician scenes haha. Then there’s the schizoverse sequence. It’s downright interesting to read about a place where people’s animal nature is blatantly out in the open and anything goes. Can’t quite put my finger on why it’s there, but it fits in...somehow.
I’m trying to take the book’s advice and judge it on the surface. But since my brain is too weak to handle chaos without order, it seems to have sorted it into something like: this is a vision of the future wherein the world has descended into mindless consumerism. This has robbed people of any sort of purpose for living, except to stay alive to keep working in their pointless jobs so they can keep their bank accounts full so they can buy more and stay alive so they can keep working... Life has no meaning anymore. Pleasures of the flesh and even pleasures of the mind have become irrelevant. Because of this, there’s no value on life in this world. No sense of right or wrong, and without it no line between logic and reality. All that’s left is media, advertising, consumption, violence, and sex--surrogates for real meaning in life. (And yet, society hasn’t stopped functioning even though it’s going nowhere and existing for no reason. It just muddles on and on, like it always has.) To combat this purposeless existence, people employ robots to face it for them, so the real people can hide in even more consumerism or lusts of the flesh. Our main character’s two halves (representing his Id and his Ego) react differently to this kind of world. The Ego, the part that represents higher-minded desires, seems crushed by it. He doesn’t know how to survive where there is no sense, leaving the Id--his deepest, inmost animal desires--to survive for him. But even Dr. Identity is defeated by this world of fickle, media-focused consumerism, advertising and disregard for life itself. This is a society that has crushed both sides of the human mind (higher reason and animal pleasures) leaving nothing to live for but the chaos of media and fads. And in the end, all they can do is be assimilated by it. So if life comes to a point where it means nothing, does reality mean nothing? But instead of asking this question (or making it the moral of the story), the book shoves this chaotic society up our asses and forces us to smile for the camera. Or perhaps this is a distorted vision of the present...?
There’s so much going on that maybe it doesn’t have one particular interpretation, if any at all. For all I know the book may be just a random, sanity-bending stream of consciousness onto which I’m projecting some kind of meaning. Although I’m confident about Dr. Blah as the Ego and Dr. Identity as the Id, and the effect this kind of society has on them. I dunno.
The great part about this book is that I don’t *have* to understand it. I kept reading because of that nagging feeling in the back of my head that somewhere deep down I sensed that I understood everything that was going on. But it’s like trying to see a tree in twilight. You can look at it from many different angles and it seems to change shape every time. It’s changed my reality. I like having my reality changed. It gives life meaning.
Although honestly I don’t know if I would have made it to the end unless I had read your short stories as a prerequisite. I remember that I tried to read a book called Flow My Tears The Policeman Said, by Philip K. Dick. I made it about halfway before I gave up because there was no world building, nothing made sense, and the characters were shallow and pointless. “Dr. Identity” feels deeper than that book ever did, but I’m glad I was prepared for it.
And it’s definitely not an Oprah book :-)
I hope this is somehow useful to you. [...]
Thank you, Herr Wilson-thing for one hell of a ride. Surreal chaos *can* make for a fascinating read.
James Steele