What do you think?
Rate this book
The Lucky Kind
High school junior Nick Brandt is intent on getting a girlfriend, and Eden Reiss is the one that he wants. He has exactly four semesters to get the girl, but when the phone rings on an otherwise ordinary Tuesday night, life for Nick and his parents will never be the same. What had been a seemingly idyllic home life has become something else entirely. But with this shake-up comes a newfound confidence for Nick; he's become a bolder version of himself, no longer afraid to question his parents, and no longer afraid to talk to Eden.
Alyssa B. Sheinmel has written a powerfully gripping story about family secrets, falling in love, and finding luck in unexpected—and sometimes unwelcome—circumstances.
Alyssa B. Sheinmel has written a powerfully gripping story about family secrets, falling in love, and finding luck in unexpected—and sometimes unwelcome—circumstances.
208 pages, Hardcover
First published May 10, 2011
11 people are currently reading
1554 people want to read
About the author
Alyssa Sheinmel
16 books987 followersAlyssa Sheinmel is the New York Times bestselling author of several novels for young adults, including A Danger to Herself and Others and Faceless, as well as the adult novel Such Sheltered Lives. Alyssa grew up in Northern California and New York, and currently lives and writes in New York. Follow her on Instagram @alyssasheinmel or visit her online at www.alyssasheinmel.com.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 56 reviews
July 9, 2011
This was my first time reading a book by Alyssa B. Sheinmel and it did not disappoint! I rarely get the chance to read a book from a boys point of view. This one pulled that off beautifully! It's from the point-of-view of Nick, a 16-year-old boy who seems to have a typical high school life. He has a best friend, a crush, and a loving family.
Nick slowly pursues Eden (the crush) and it's adorable to watch their relationship progress. They had that nice, romantic connection that helps the reader really get to know each character. I honestly loved Eden. She was a strong young girl, with a sweet personality and a fierce love for Nick. She honestly cared about him deeply and their relationship was more than puppy love.
Nick was a great character. Alyssa did a great job getting into the mind of a teenage boy. Nick was frustrating at times because he seemed to displace his anger, which is something most guys do. His anger stemmed from a secret he discovered his father was keeping. It wasn't something horrific, but it threw Nick's world upside down. Everything he thought he knew about his parents was then questioned.
I have to mention another character I absolutely loved, Stevie. Stevie is the best friend of Nick and he was perfect! Not perfect as in nothing was wrong with him, but he was the picture perfect representation of a great best friend. He was funny, interesting, caring, and a great addition to this story. He was able to give Nick some insight when he was unable to see past his anger.
This story was wonderful and although I felt the ending left some things hanging, it was a very well-rounded book. It really opened up the life of Nick and allowed us to see how one moment can change every other aspect of a life. The Lucky Kind is full of intense emotion, teenage drama, and a level of love from friends and family rarely seen in young adult novels.
Nick slowly pursues Eden (the crush) and it's adorable to watch their relationship progress. They had that nice, romantic connection that helps the reader really get to know each character. I honestly loved Eden. She was a strong young girl, with a sweet personality and a fierce love for Nick. She honestly cared about him deeply and their relationship was more than puppy love.
Nick was a great character. Alyssa did a great job getting into the mind of a teenage boy. Nick was frustrating at times because he seemed to displace his anger, which is something most guys do. His anger stemmed from a secret he discovered his father was keeping. It wasn't something horrific, but it threw Nick's world upside down. Everything he thought he knew about his parents was then questioned.
I have to mention another character I absolutely loved, Stevie. Stevie is the best friend of Nick and he was perfect! Not perfect as in nothing was wrong with him, but he was the picture perfect representation of a great best friend. He was funny, interesting, caring, and a great addition to this story. He was able to give Nick some insight when he was unable to see past his anger.
This story was wonderful and although I felt the ending left some things hanging, it was a very well-rounded book. It really opened up the life of Nick and allowed us to see how one moment can change every other aspect of a life. The Lucky Kind is full of intense emotion, teenage drama, and a level of love from friends and family rarely seen in young adult novels.
May 23, 2016
There is no one thing that's true. It's all true - Ernest Hemingway (For Whom The Bell Tolls)
This is the first time I decided to read a book after an ad appeared for it on some website. I know there is a kind of universal rule that one should not believe advertisements, especially the type that appear on weird websites alongside tons of virus-carrying ads. But, the book's description sounded good so I decided to give it a chance.
The lucky kind is a about a boy in his junior year of high school, trying to get it on with the girl he has been dreaming about for years. Eden appears to him as the most beautiful girl in the world. And, right there supporting him, is his best friend. Then comes a twist. Although Nick manages to get Eden, he realizes he can't hold on to her while dealing with the secret that has just been revealed.
This book has emotions a perfect mix of drama to keep the readers going.
I liked the way the author showed the way many teens deal with the issue discussed in this book. At one point
This novel is for the younger audience as well as the older people looking for a light read in between intense books.
This is the first time I decided to read a book after an ad appeared for it on some website. I know there is a kind of universal rule that one should not believe advertisements, especially the type that appear on weird websites alongside tons of virus-carrying ads. But, the book's description sounded good so I decided to give it a chance.
The lucky kind is a about a boy in his junior year of high school, trying to get it on with the girl he has been dreaming about for years. Eden appears to him as the most beautiful girl in the world. And, right there supporting him, is his best friend. Then comes a twist. Although Nick manages to get Eden, he realizes he can't hold on to her while dealing with the secret that has just been revealed.
This book has emotions a perfect mix of drama to keep the readers going.
I liked the way the author showed the way many teens deal with the issue discussed in this book. At one point
This novel is for the younger audience as well as the older people looking for a light read in between intense books.
May 9, 2011
My first thought when I started reading The Lucky Kind was that Nick, the main character, was someone that I would love to hang out with. He's sweet, slightly awkward, has a wit to be contended with, and really seems to think things through. Add in his sarcastic and amazing friend (essentially brother) Stevie, and the focus of his admiration, Eden, and you have a group of characters that will steal your heart. Despite anything else I have may thought while reading this book, these characters never stopped making me love them.
At the heart of this book is a story of an adolescent boy who is growing up. Nick knows he's smitten with Eden, but he doesn't know how to talk to her. Stevie is like the ying to Nick's yang. He is the one who is smooth with the girls, witty when it's called for, and never seems to be awkward in situations. Then Nick finds out some information that turns his life upside down, and suddenly he's the strong one. He finds the confidence to talk to Eden, he finds the ability to question his parents when he feels they aren't being truthful. Unfortunately with this new found freedom comes the need to question himself as well.
The chemistry in this book between all the characters is pure perfection. As a girl who grew up with a "Norman Rockwell" family, only later to discover that the older you get the less perfect they seem, I felt Nick's emotions perfectly. His disbelief over the news he is given, his inability to cope with it the way everyone thinks he should, right down to the way that he projects those feelings into other areas of his life. Nick is just a boy who is trying to grow up "right", and now has been given something huge to overcome in this already difficult time in his life. I felt for him, and I loved it.
His relationship with his parents is one that I think a lot of teenagers will appreciate. Too often out there the parents are hidden in the background, not caring what their children do or say. Or they are too weak to stand up for themselves if their children make bad decisions. Nick's parents aren't perfect, but really what is perfect? No, his parents are the type that are there for him, but let him have space. They banter with him, and talk to him like an adult when he needs it. Nick's parents reminded me a lot of my parents, which is probably another reason why I so connected with this book.
As you can tell from reading my ramblings above, I really connected with Nick and his struggles. The Lucky Kind is a book that tells a story that really could belong to anyone. However Alyssa Sheinmel has created, I think, the perfect character to live this story in Nick. Sweet, touching, and more than a little emotional, this is a book that I think readers will really enjoy. I highly recommend you get your hands on a copy as soon as you can.
At the heart of this book is a story of an adolescent boy who is growing up. Nick knows he's smitten with Eden, but he doesn't know how to talk to her. Stevie is like the ying to Nick's yang. He is the one who is smooth with the girls, witty when it's called for, and never seems to be awkward in situations. Then Nick finds out some information that turns his life upside down, and suddenly he's the strong one. He finds the confidence to talk to Eden, he finds the ability to question his parents when he feels they aren't being truthful. Unfortunately with this new found freedom comes the need to question himself as well.
The chemistry in this book between all the characters is pure perfection. As a girl who grew up with a "Norman Rockwell" family, only later to discover that the older you get the less perfect they seem, I felt Nick's emotions perfectly. His disbelief over the news he is given, his inability to cope with it the way everyone thinks he should, right down to the way that he projects those feelings into other areas of his life. Nick is just a boy who is trying to grow up "right", and now has been given something huge to overcome in this already difficult time in his life. I felt for him, and I loved it.
His relationship with his parents is one that I think a lot of teenagers will appreciate. Too often out there the parents are hidden in the background, not caring what their children do or say. Or they are too weak to stand up for themselves if their children make bad decisions. Nick's parents aren't perfect, but really what is perfect? No, his parents are the type that are there for him, but let him have space. They banter with him, and talk to him like an adult when he needs it. Nick's parents reminded me a lot of my parents, which is probably another reason why I so connected with this book.
As you can tell from reading my ramblings above, I really connected with Nick and his struggles. The Lucky Kind is a book that tells a story that really could belong to anyone. However Alyssa Sheinmel has created, I think, the perfect character to live this story in Nick. Sweet, touching, and more than a little emotional, this is a book that I think readers will really enjoy. I highly recommend you get your hands on a copy as soon as you can.
June 6, 2011
I wasn't sure what to think going into this book. I had heard mixed reviews on it, but I still didn't know much about it. It wasn't a greatly hyped up book, which I think is what caught my attention when I saw it. I thought that if there isn't much talk about the book, then maybe I could enjoy it without getting my hopes to high.
It focus' on adoption and the turmoil the secrets of adoption can cause in a family. It also touches on the subject of how a boy could finally get the nerve to talk to a girl he has been crushing on and how it might have been the family circumstance's that finally give him the push he needed to do it.
While the writing was just okay, and the characters weren't as great as I was hoping, it was a fairly quick read. I did enjoy how it is from a boys perspective instead of a female for a change. Nick was a character that I though was okay, but at times I thought he could have been much more. His mind kind of wandered too much for me. He would be focused on Eden and then he would switch gears and think about Sam. He seemed to be pushy for answers as well when speaking with his Father. I can understand the curiosity of adoption and the history behind what happened, but I felt that he should have just asked his Father to explain things all in one conversation. I didn't like how he would just change subjects at whim and throw a question out there at his Father. I also would have liked to have seen more of his Mother involved in the discussions and her feelings on the history.
The book had a believable plot, but the ending was lacking in closure as well. It is left open ended in a way for you to come to your own conclusions for the story. Personally, I like my books to have closure at the end. If I spend my time reading a book, I want to know that the author had an ending in mind that would finish it up. When the final chapter is left like that, I get the feeling that the author didn't feel like completing the story and just gave up.
Overall if you are a big fan of touchy subjects that involve the family, then give it a try. Personally, it is not one I would read again in the future.
It focus' on adoption and the turmoil the secrets of adoption can cause in a family. It also touches on the subject of how a boy could finally get the nerve to talk to a girl he has been crushing on and how it might have been the family circumstance's that finally give him the push he needed to do it.
While the writing was just okay, and the characters weren't as great as I was hoping, it was a fairly quick read. I did enjoy how it is from a boys perspective instead of a female for a change. Nick was a character that I though was okay, but at times I thought he could have been much more. His mind kind of wandered too much for me. He would be focused on Eden and then he would switch gears and think about Sam. He seemed to be pushy for answers as well when speaking with his Father. I can understand the curiosity of adoption and the history behind what happened, but I felt that he should have just asked his Father to explain things all in one conversation. I didn't like how he would just change subjects at whim and throw a question out there at his Father. I also would have liked to have seen more of his Mother involved in the discussions and her feelings on the history.
The book had a believable plot, but the ending was lacking in closure as well. It is left open ended in a way for you to come to your own conclusions for the story. Personally, I like my books to have closure at the end. If I spend my time reading a book, I want to know that the author had an ending in mind that would finish it up. When the final chapter is left like that, I get the feeling that the author didn't feel like completing the story and just gave up.
Overall if you are a big fan of touchy subjects that involve the family, then give it a try. Personally, it is not one I would read again in the future.
December 21, 2012
The Lucky Kind is a young adult novel written from the perspective of a high school junior named Nick. It was a nice change to read a young adult book from a boy’s point of view since most of the YA books I read have female main characters. This book was written by a woman, and while I thought she did a decent job getting inside a boy’s head I really am not an expert judge, being a girl myself. I would be curious to hear a guy’s perspective on this book as to how realistic her characterization was.
In The Lucky Kind Nick is faced with two problems: figuring out how to approach the girl that he has a crush on, and discovering what secret his parents are hiding from him. Once he finds out the secret it wreaks havoc on the rest of his life, and causes him to reexamine how he sees himself and his parents.
I have to admit that reading this book was a lot like watching an after-school special. You don’t know quite how the character is going to mess things up, but you’re pretty sure he’s going to learn some life lessons about relationships in the process. This is great for me because I’ve always enjoyed after-school specials. On the flip side, I have to wonder how much this story would really appeal to teenage boys.
Some young adult books have crossover appeal to the adult audience, but I think this is one that is going to appeal mostly to a younger crowd. I should also mention that the following issues play a role in the book: teenage sex, drinking, and smoking. More than anything else though, it is a story about the difficulties of keeping open and honest relationships between teenagers and parents.
In The Lucky Kind Nick is faced with two problems: figuring out how to approach the girl that he has a crush on, and discovering what secret his parents are hiding from him. Once he finds out the secret it wreaks havoc on the rest of his life, and causes him to reexamine how he sees himself and his parents.
I have to admit that reading this book was a lot like watching an after-school special. You don’t know quite how the character is going to mess things up, but you’re pretty sure he’s going to learn some life lessons about relationships in the process. This is great for me because I’ve always enjoyed after-school specials. On the flip side, I have to wonder how much this story would really appeal to teenage boys.
Some young adult books have crossover appeal to the adult audience, but I think this is one that is going to appeal mostly to a younger crowd. I should also mention that the following issues play a role in the book: teenage sex, drinking, and smoking. More than anything else though, it is a story about the difficulties of keeping open and honest relationships between teenagers and parents.
October 20, 2011
Nick spends most of this book being angry and sullen and not so nice to the people around him. Fortunately for him, all these people understand what he's going through and love him anyway. The End.
Okay, there is more to the book than that, but that's pretty much the premise. I wish there had been something more here than there was. I with Nick has talked about first love with his father and gotten some clarity on his father's long ago relationship. I think the story needed that, but it wasn't included for some reason. We get only glimpses of it and since that was actually central to the story, there should have been more about the choices made.
It's almost as if the whole book is told too brusquely without enough detail.
A good quick read. I'd try this author again, nice writing style.
Okay, there is more to the book than that, but that's pretty much the premise. I wish there had been something more here than there was. I with Nick has talked about first love with his father and gotten some clarity on his father's long ago relationship. I think the story needed that, but it wasn't included for some reason. We get only glimpses of it and since that was actually central to the story, there should have been more about the choices made.
It's almost as if the whole book is told too brusquely without enough detail.
A good quick read. I'd try this author again, nice writing style.
May 9, 2011
I didn't believe the male voice at all (and given it takes you more than one chapter to figure out what the gender is is a problem, too) and I thought the fact the entire plot hinged on a landline phone call/the inconsistencies therein were thin.
That said, I really like Sheinmel's voice in writing. It's clear and smooth, as well as quiet. It's a slower paced book but it's purposeful in being that way.
Full review here: http://stackedbooks.blogspot.com/2011...
That said, I really like Sheinmel's voice in writing. It's clear and smooth, as well as quiet. It's a slower paced book but it's purposeful in being that way.
Full review here: http://stackedbooks.blogspot.com/2011...
November 9, 2011
Tired of books in which teen boys treat teen girls like sh-- ----badly.
September 6, 2016
i love this quiet book
July 26, 2024
Book:
THE LUCKY KIND by Alyssa B. Sheinmel
Review:
3 ⭐
I don't know how to start this review. I mean, I liked the book, but I didn't love it. From the synopsis of THE LUCKY KIND, I was expecting a contemporary, slightly romantic move full of mystery. Yes, the book brushed each of those subject, but the mystery wasn't that great---it was kind of lackluster in that sense. You would think mysterious phone calls, multiple times a day, would lead to something else. But, it didn't.
THE LUCKY KIND by Alyssa B. Sheinmel
Review:
3 ⭐
I don't know how to start this review. I mean, I liked the book, but I didn't love it. From the synopsis of THE LUCKY KIND, I was expecting a contemporary, slightly romantic move full of mystery. Yes, the book brushed each of those subject, but the mystery wasn't that great---it was kind of lackluster in that sense. You would think mysterious phone calls, multiple times a day, would lead to something else. But, it didn't.
September 16, 2018
I really liked the point of view that it was written in. I didn't expect for it to be so well written and take a regular 16 year old boy's life and make it so interesting. It especially takes a basic plot line of his parents keepinga secret from him and puts a twist on it.
August 21, 2019
This was really interesting I highly recommend it
September 24, 2023
Review pending I promise
July 8, 2025
Yes Nick was annoying and he was snobby but the book was actually pretty good.
3.5/5
7/10
3.5/5
7/10
April 18, 2013
Have you ever dreamt about that dream boy or girl you wanted to be with? You just can’t think of anything else? An ever better question is, have you ever wondered if you have another sibling out in the world somewhere? Well for Nick Brandt in The Lucky Kind, both of these unrelated topics became a very key role in his life. Author Alyssa B. Sheinmel does a great job of detailing how this teenager’s seemingly perfect life gets even greater when he gets the girl of his dreams then it is drastically flipped around when he finds out a family secret. His father tells him something that changes his life and perspective on life just from one phone call one ordinary day.
To begin, everything can change in a blink of an eye. For Nick Brandt, he thought he’d always have his girlfriend and his perfect world would always be there. Nick never actually appreciated all the great things in his life and thought it would just be that way forever. He soon found out this is not the case. One phone call that changed this teenager’s life one day made him realize he really did have many things that he should be grateful for. All audiences will reflect back on their lives and find many parts of our lives that we all overlook every day, but could be gone in a split second.
Another key point that author Alyssa B. Sheinmel gets across within this book is you can’t assume that everyone has super high standards for you. This is well explained by Nick’s experiences when he has a girlfriend, but he is constantly thinking he isn’t good enough for her so he keeps trying to be something that he is not. In his mind, she has higher standards than what he can fulfill, when in reality all she wants is him. He doesn’t realize his girlfriend wouldn’t be his girlfriend if she was looking for someone better. His perspective of this topic eventually gets him into a problem. The point the author got across is that you just have to be yourself and know that that will be good enough.
Next, the best part of reading a book is when you want to keep reading and you can not put it down. After reading this novel I could really connect to the meaning and relate to the events that happen in this teenager’s life, so this has become one of my favorite books I’ve read this year. All the suspense within this novel kept building up with such great detail you feel like you are in a high action movie, which is why it has such a wide variety of audiences. Sheinmel did a great job of making sure she got this element in her book The writing style within this also has the element of informing by describing every detail, because she was able to execute this well, the audience got the full experience. An example of this is when Nick is asking his soon-to-be girlfriend out: “…it was that day in science class when we were dissecting frogs that I knew. Everything about that class was disgusting from the smell to the slimy guts all over our labs tables, except you. You were the most beautiful girl in the class with your red sneakers on; I knew I wanted you to be my girlfriend.” I felt like I was a bystander in the book watching all the elements of Nick’s life unfold. I really enjoyed this book, the style of writing, and all the element of suspense the author created. Although this was a great read there was just the style of adding many conflicts into the story but not tying up the loose ends in the book. She never tells you what happens to Nick and his girlfriend in the end and it leaves the audience hanging, for me I don’t like this element. All in all, I would recommend this great thriller to anyone young or old because anyone can learn and enjoy it.
To begin, everything can change in a blink of an eye. For Nick Brandt, he thought he’d always have his girlfriend and his perfect world would always be there. Nick never actually appreciated all the great things in his life and thought it would just be that way forever. He soon found out this is not the case. One phone call that changed this teenager’s life one day made him realize he really did have many things that he should be grateful for. All audiences will reflect back on their lives and find many parts of our lives that we all overlook every day, but could be gone in a split second.
Another key point that author Alyssa B. Sheinmel gets across within this book is you can’t assume that everyone has super high standards for you. This is well explained by Nick’s experiences when he has a girlfriend, but he is constantly thinking he isn’t good enough for her so he keeps trying to be something that he is not. In his mind, she has higher standards than what he can fulfill, when in reality all she wants is him. He doesn’t realize his girlfriend wouldn’t be his girlfriend if she was looking for someone better. His perspective of this topic eventually gets him into a problem. The point the author got across is that you just have to be yourself and know that that will be good enough.
Next, the best part of reading a book is when you want to keep reading and you can not put it down. After reading this novel I could really connect to the meaning and relate to the events that happen in this teenager’s life, so this has become one of my favorite books I’ve read this year. All the suspense within this novel kept building up with such great detail you feel like you are in a high action movie, which is why it has such a wide variety of audiences. Sheinmel did a great job of making sure she got this element in her book The writing style within this also has the element of informing by describing every detail, because she was able to execute this well, the audience got the full experience. An example of this is when Nick is asking his soon-to-be girlfriend out: “…it was that day in science class when we were dissecting frogs that I knew. Everything about that class was disgusting from the smell to the slimy guts all over our labs tables, except you. You were the most beautiful girl in the class with your red sneakers on; I knew I wanted you to be my girlfriend.” I felt like I was a bystander in the book watching all the elements of Nick’s life unfold. I really enjoyed this book, the style of writing, and all the element of suspense the author created. Although this was a great read there was just the style of adding many conflicts into the story but not tying up the loose ends in the book. She never tells you what happens to Nick and his girlfriend in the end and it leaves the audience hanging, for me I don’t like this element. All in all, I would recommend this great thriller to anyone young or old because anyone can learn and enjoy it.
December 31, 2015
This is one of those coming of age books that I don’t usually enjoy but I actually really liked this one. It was sweet, a tad silly, imperfect in the best ways, and overall, realistic.
Nick is just a boy who wants to reach out to the girl he likes and he has liked her for quite some time now. He doesn’t know how to talk to her and spends a lot of time concocting scenarios in his head that never goes anywhere. When he later finds out about something but he wasn’t entirely sure what it was so he came up with a few different wild scenarios in this head, he suddenly turned his life around and gets the girl – he became outgoing, sure, and more confident in himself. But once he finds out what his family was actually hiding and have hidden from him for a while now, he became lost and struggled to find himself again. I actually liked him a lot when he became more confident because he was nice, caring, and an overall wonderful boyfriend for Eden and it was obvious that they really loved each other. But then when he did the douche move after he found out about his family secret, I wanted to reach into the book and shake him silly.
I really liked Stevie, his best friend, because he was the one who basically completed Nick. When Nick was feeling shy, he was the one who was outgoing and vice versa. He was like his rock. When Nick became a douche to Eden, his girlfriend, Stevie was the one who tried to make him see reason. Their friendship was rock solid and I really liked that. A friendship like that is hard to find these days. And Eden, his girlfriend, is so understanding. Even though he treated her like shit after they basically told each other “I love you” and did the deed, she tried to win him back and convince him that their love was real and they’re one of the lucky ones without being creepy or stalker-like. She gave him his space when he needed it and reached out when necessary.
While I enjoyed Nick’s relationship with his parents – they let him have his space while also being there for him but the whole family secret thing threw some shade into that relationship. Yes, they treated him like an adult but at the same time, they thought he was too young to understand the family secret and decided for him to not include him until he overheard and found out. I related to the relationship because there were definitely times when my parents thought I was too young to understand something when really, I was not but at the same time, I could understand why his parents wouldn’t confide in him because it was a pretty big secret.
Anyways, pretty good book for this type of genre. I would definitely recommend it to those who are a fan of coming of age novels.
Nick is just a boy who wants to reach out to the girl he likes and he has liked her for quite some time now. He doesn’t know how to talk to her and spends a lot of time concocting scenarios in his head that never goes anywhere. When he later finds out about something but he wasn’t entirely sure what it was so he came up with a few different wild scenarios in this head, he suddenly turned his life around and gets the girl – he became outgoing, sure, and more confident in himself. But once he finds out what his family was actually hiding and have hidden from him for a while now, he became lost and struggled to find himself again. I actually liked him a lot when he became more confident because he was nice, caring, and an overall wonderful boyfriend for Eden and it was obvious that they really loved each other. But then when he did the douche move after he found out about his family secret, I wanted to reach into the book and shake him silly.
I really liked Stevie, his best friend, because he was the one who basically completed Nick. When Nick was feeling shy, he was the one who was outgoing and vice versa. He was like his rock. When Nick became a douche to Eden, his girlfriend, Stevie was the one who tried to make him see reason. Their friendship was rock solid and I really liked that. A friendship like that is hard to find these days. And Eden, his girlfriend, is so understanding. Even though he treated her like shit after they basically told each other “I love you” and did the deed, she tried to win him back and convince him that their love was real and they’re one of the lucky ones without being creepy or stalker-like. She gave him his space when he needed it and reached out when necessary.
While I enjoyed Nick’s relationship with his parents – they let him have his space while also being there for him but the whole family secret thing threw some shade into that relationship. Yes, they treated him like an adult but at the same time, they thought he was too young to understand the family secret and decided for him to not include him until he overheard and found out. I related to the relationship because there were definitely times when my parents thought I was too young to understand something when really, I was not but at the same time, I could understand why his parents wouldn’t confide in him because it was a pretty big secret.
Anyways, pretty good book for this type of genre. I would definitely recommend it to those who are a fan of coming of age novels.
March 11, 2011
After reading Alyssa's unique and beautifully written debut last year, I've been eager to find out more about her upcoming projects. I was beyond excited when a copy of her sophomore novel, The Lucky Kind, landed on my doorstep. It was just as intriguing and original as her debut and I definitely recommend it.
The Lucky Kind tells the story of sixteen year old Nick, an ordinary high school guy navigating life the best he can. Nick is in love with the beautiful and elusive Eden Reiss and I liked being able to watch their relationship develop and turn into something more. Nick has always been happy and has a good relationship with his parents, and he's even happier when he and Eden start dating. He also has his best friend Stevie and is doing well in school. But then his life is turned upside down when he learns his father had a son with his girlfriend 29 years ago that they put up for adoption and this almost thirty year old man is now contacting Nick's (and his real) father. Nick starts to wonder if his father really is the kind and honest guy he always knew and trusted and their relationship changes drastically in just a day. Suddenly Nick is a new person.
The concept of The Lucky Kind was one I've never encountered before and I felt for Nick when he learned his father had been keeping something so serious from him. The fact that Nick was indeed not his father's first born son. Alyssa B. Sheinmel made sure Nick's parents had a key role in the story and his relationship with them was a key part of the novel. Nick's character is very complex and he goes through a lot over the course of a few months and changes quite a bit.
Eden and Stevie are also very developed secondary characters and have a large role in the book. One of my favorite aspects of the book was reading about Nick's relationship with not only his parents but Stevie and Eden. He learned a lot about himself from those two even though they had their ups and downs.
The plot is well executed and Alyssa manages to capture all the turmoil and emotion brought forth by a family secret perfectly.
While some may think the ending was a bit abrupt I think it was the best way to end the story. Readers can make their own guesses as to what happens next. Overall, The Lucky Kind was an original and well written second novel and I finished it very quickly. Alyssa B. Sheinmel created a great character in Nick and I think many teenagers will feel for and relate to him. I'm sure Alyssa's third book will introduce a new, rarely touched topic that will intrigue readers as well!
Overall: 4 out of 5 stars
The Lucky Kind tells the story of sixteen year old Nick, an ordinary high school guy navigating life the best he can. Nick is in love with the beautiful and elusive Eden Reiss and I liked being able to watch their relationship develop and turn into something more. Nick has always been happy and has a good relationship with his parents, and he's even happier when he and Eden start dating. He also has his best friend Stevie and is doing well in school. But then his life is turned upside down when he learns his father had a son with his girlfriend 29 years ago that they put up for adoption and this almost thirty year old man is now contacting Nick's (and his real) father. Nick starts to wonder if his father really is the kind and honest guy he always knew and trusted and their relationship changes drastically in just a day. Suddenly Nick is a new person.
The concept of The Lucky Kind was one I've never encountered before and I felt for Nick when he learned his father had been keeping something so serious from him. The fact that Nick was indeed not his father's first born son. Alyssa B. Sheinmel made sure Nick's parents had a key role in the story and his relationship with them was a key part of the novel. Nick's character is very complex and he goes through a lot over the course of a few months and changes quite a bit.
Eden and Stevie are also very developed secondary characters and have a large role in the book. One of my favorite aspects of the book was reading about Nick's relationship with not only his parents but Stevie and Eden. He learned a lot about himself from those two even though they had their ups and downs.
The plot is well executed and Alyssa manages to capture all the turmoil and emotion brought forth by a family secret perfectly.
While some may think the ending was a bit abrupt I think it was the best way to end the story. Readers can make their own guesses as to what happens next. Overall, The Lucky Kind was an original and well written second novel and I finished it very quickly. Alyssa B. Sheinmel created a great character in Nick and I think many teenagers will feel for and relate to him. I'm sure Alyssa's third book will introduce a new, rarely touched topic that will intrigue readers as well!
Overall: 4 out of 5 stars
October 17, 2012
originally posted at http://actinupwithbooks.blogspot.com/...
When I first read this synopsis of The Lucky Kind, I was drawn to the romantic aspect of the storyline. It sounded like one of those underdog stories, where the awkward geeky-cute boy tries to get the girl of his dreams. There is a little bit of that going on, but this story is so much more than this relationship.
The focus on the family dynamic is what makes The Lucky Kind stand out from other stories. Nick's parents are central to the storyline and his father's betrayal, or what he perceives as a betrayal, is important to his growth as a character. This event allows Nick to realize that his parents had a life before they became his parents. They made their own mistakes, their own choices - that they are human too.
What I like most about The Lucky Kind is that is doesn't pull any punches, it's subtle in it's depth. I loved that Nick questioned his parents and their authority but not in a bratty, over the top defiant way(while he did have his moments). It wasn't drama-filled which made it feel all the more real. Some readers may need the drama and may think that a lot doesn't really happen in the story, but that's not what I took from it all.
One of my favorite scenes from the book is when Eden tells Nick that she notices that his parents still hold hands. She demonstrates by talking his hand and holding it and then not letting go. This is the first time they've ever touched and she's so casual about it.
Our hands are resting in the space between our legs, but loosely, like we've been holding each other's hands for years, like it's not a big deal. It doesn't even feel like she was really taking my hand, only that she was trying to show me something. (pg 45)
There are many tender moments like these that made me fall in love with Nick and Eden. And I appreciated that their relationship wasn't all swoon and lust. It felt real - full of confusion and doubt - the overwhelming feeling that can only come from a first love.
The Lucky Kind is, in the best way possible, an emotional read. The story is moving and believable, subtle, and honest. I'd recommend it to any fan of contemporary YA.
Disclaimer: This review is based on the Advanced Readers Copy which I won from Random Buzzers/Random House. Any quotes mentioned may differ from the final published copy. I was not compensated from providing a review. Thoughts and opinions are my own.
When I first read this synopsis of The Lucky Kind, I was drawn to the romantic aspect of the storyline. It sounded like one of those underdog stories, where the awkward geeky-cute boy tries to get the girl of his dreams. There is a little bit of that going on, but this story is so much more than this relationship.
The focus on the family dynamic is what makes The Lucky Kind stand out from other stories. Nick's parents are central to the storyline and his father's betrayal, or what he perceives as a betrayal, is important to his growth as a character. This event allows Nick to realize that his parents had a life before they became his parents. They made their own mistakes, their own choices - that they are human too.
What I like most about The Lucky Kind is that is doesn't pull any punches, it's subtle in it's depth. I loved that Nick questioned his parents and their authority but not in a bratty, over the top defiant way(while he did have his moments). It wasn't drama-filled which made it feel all the more real. Some readers may need the drama and may think that a lot doesn't really happen in the story, but that's not what I took from it all.
One of my favorite scenes from the book is when Eden tells Nick that she notices that his parents still hold hands. She demonstrates by talking his hand and holding it and then not letting go. This is the first time they've ever touched and she's so casual about it.
Our hands are resting in the space between our legs, but loosely, like we've been holding each other's hands for years, like it's not a big deal. It doesn't even feel like she was really taking my hand, only that she was trying to show me something. (pg 45)
There are many tender moments like these that made me fall in love with Nick and Eden. And I appreciated that their relationship wasn't all swoon and lust. It felt real - full of confusion and doubt - the overwhelming feeling that can only come from a first love.
The Lucky Kind is, in the best way possible, an emotional read. The story is moving and believable, subtle, and honest. I'd recommend it to any fan of contemporary YA.
Disclaimer: This review is based on the Advanced Readers Copy which I won from Random Buzzers/Random House. Any quotes mentioned may differ from the final published copy. I was not compensated from providing a review. Thoughts and opinions are my own.
July 19, 2011
This novel is about Nick Brandt, a high school junior, who is faced with a family secret that has been kept from him his whole life. He feels betrayed and angry that his parents kept this secret from him. Enter Eden Reiss. Eden is the girl he's always lusted after, and eventually works up the nerve to talk to. Basically, they fall in love and he tries to balance his relationship, his friendship with Stevie (his BFF who he's known forever), and his family problems. These different things all intersect and I found myself wrapped up in Nick's problems. I felt I could relate a LOT with Eden and Nick, because their relationship reminded me a little bit of me and my boyfriend. I liked this book, because it had quite a few very tender, touching moments.
As I was about halfway through this, I found myself almost angry with Nick, because he was just being a little too dramatic. He had always been pretty close with his parents, and after this one incident, he closes them out for months. Now come on, the secret really isn't even THAT bad. I think he just needed less time to just get over it because he was being a little close minded about his parents reasoning and such.
He is also a really big a-hole to Eden at one part in the story. She's pretty much perfect to him (as far as we know) and he just ruins everything with her. It just makes you angry with him for messing things up with "the girl of his dreams" when he was confusing the fact that he didn't love her anymore with confusion about his family problems. Eden doesn't deserve that, and Nick's quick thinking doesn't do them any good.
Sam (who I won't spoil and say who he is) is probably my favorite character besides Eden. Even though he only appears for a few chapters, I really liked him. He's smart, funny, a nice guy, and just someone I can relate to.
Something I did like about this novel was the title. It is called The Lucky Kind and though I can't find the quote right now, Eden says something about her and Nick being "the lucky kind" when it came to love. I loved how that was the title because I thought it fit the book perfectly. There's also another mentioning of "the lucky kind" at the end of the story (I think by Sam and Nick when they were talking). Also, the cover is just TOO cute!
I did like most of this book, but there were also some of Nick's choices that I disagreed with. But we must also realize that he was going through a difficult time in his life. It was really just an okay story, not something I would find myself reading again anytime soon.
As I was about halfway through this, I found myself almost angry with Nick, because he was just being a little too dramatic. He had always been pretty close with his parents, and after this one incident, he closes them out for months. Now come on, the secret really isn't even THAT bad. I think he just needed less time to just get over it because he was being a little close minded about his parents reasoning and such.
He is also a really big a-hole to Eden at one part in the story. She's pretty much perfect to him (as far as we know) and he just ruins everything with her. It just makes you angry with him for messing things up with "the girl of his dreams" when he was confusing the fact that he didn't love her anymore with confusion about his family problems. Eden doesn't deserve that, and Nick's quick thinking doesn't do them any good.
Sam (who I won't spoil and say who he is) is probably my favorite character besides Eden. Even though he only appears for a few chapters, I really liked him. He's smart, funny, a nice guy, and just someone I can relate to.
Something I did like about this novel was the title. It is called The Lucky Kind and though I can't find the quote right now, Eden says something about her and Nick being "the lucky kind" when it came to love. I loved how that was the title because I thought it fit the book perfectly. There's also another mentioning of "the lucky kind" at the end of the story (I think by Sam and Nick when they were talking). Also, the cover is just TOO cute!
I did like most of this book, but there were also some of Nick's choices that I disagreed with. But we must also realize that he was going through a difficult time in his life. It was really just an okay story, not something I would find myself reading again anytime soon.
April 21, 2011
Nick, a Junior in high school, is focused on getting the girl of his dreams: Eden Reiss. He's just an average guy with a nice family, whose biggest problem in life is how to get Eden's attention. However, all of that changes when the phone rings one night. It isn't soon until Nick finds out that the man on the other end of the line is the older brother he never knew he had. Nick's father gave up his first son for adoption almost thirty years ago. Now juggling between a new relationship with Eden, and a broken trust with his father, Nick's life has completely changed.
All of the many different relationships in this book were realistic and interesting in their own way. I could feel the tension between Nick and his father, and it was nice having his family play a big role in the book. Usually in the young adult genre, the parents are rarely mentioned. I think that Nick, even though not a really memorable or unique character, was extremely realistic. He made decisions that he couldn't justify, which I believe is the case for most teen guys. Sometimes he'd snap at someone for no reason, or get frustrated just because. I could totally relate to him and think that the author did a great job creating his character. Eden, on the other hand, I had more trouble getting to know. She was unpredictable, and I didn't quite think she was as believable. It seemed like she was instantly interested in Nick and even though I loved reading about the romance between them, it was really rushed.
The book dragged some and seemed to focus more on characters than plot. I actually enjoyed the book more after I was done reading it and thinking back on it, than I did while actually reading it. I think the novel had an interesting concept though, and Nick's anger at his parents for keeping the truth from him was acceptable. I really felt for him and would have probably acted the same way. I adored the ending: it wasn't cliche or cheesy, it didn't say what actually ended up happening, and it left room for the reader's imagination. It kind of lets you make up your own ending, which was interesting. Overall, I think this book was just alright. It had unique relationships, a good message, and a very believable story line, however the writing was a bit bland. I'll probably check out more writing done by this author though.
All of the many different relationships in this book were realistic and interesting in their own way. I could feel the tension between Nick and his father, and it was nice having his family play a big role in the book. Usually in the young adult genre, the parents are rarely mentioned. I think that Nick, even though not a really memorable or unique character, was extremely realistic. He made decisions that he couldn't justify, which I believe is the case for most teen guys. Sometimes he'd snap at someone for no reason, or get frustrated just because. I could totally relate to him and think that the author did a great job creating his character. Eden, on the other hand, I had more trouble getting to know. She was unpredictable, and I didn't quite think she was as believable. It seemed like she was instantly interested in Nick and even though I loved reading about the romance between them, it was really rushed.
The book dragged some and seemed to focus more on characters than plot. I actually enjoyed the book more after I was done reading it and thinking back on it, than I did while actually reading it. I think the novel had an interesting concept though, and Nick's anger at his parents for keeping the truth from him was acceptable. I really felt for him and would have probably acted the same way. I adored the ending: it wasn't cliche or cheesy, it didn't say what actually ended up happening, and it left room for the reader's imagination. It kind of lets you make up your own ending, which was interesting. Overall, I think this book was just alright. It had unique relationships, a good message, and a very believable story line, however the writing was a bit bland. I'll probably check out more writing done by this author though.
September 3, 2012
I recently finished this booka and unsurprisingly, I enjoyed. I really like reading from a guy's point of view because they tend to be funnier, in my opinion, concerning their inappropriate thoughts. But, I also love seeing how guys can be pretty emotional and sensitive and not what girls typically see in guys. So, I really liked all of the main characters Nick, Stevie, and Eden. They actually didnt annoy. Although,
Anyway, I think Nick and Eden are perfect for each other. If there is a girl that could put up with Nick's emotional/sensitive side, it's her. ;) She has problems of her own, so I love that she understood what Nick was feeling even before he did. And then there's Stevie, who was an amazing :D best friend to Nick and really supported him. They have to be one of my favorite friendships among boys by far. :)
So the ending...I thought the ending was not bad, but could have been much better. I wasn't satisfied enough.
Finally, I really liked that even when Nick was being a butt, he realized it. Sometimes not right away, but at least his mind wasn't completely insane like his actions seemed to be. So, all in all, I really enjoyed this book. I would add another star if not for Thanks for reading my looooonnngggg review unless you gave up on reading it by now, hehe. \(^_^)/
Anyway, I think Nick and Eden are perfect for each other. If there is a girl that could put up with Nick's emotional/sensitive side, it's her. ;) She has problems of her own, so I love that she understood what Nick was feeling even before he did. And then there's Stevie, who was an amazing :D best friend to Nick and really supported him. They have to be one of my favorite friendships among boys by far. :)
So the ending...I thought the ending was not bad, but could have been much better. I wasn't satisfied enough.
Finally, I really liked that even when Nick was being a butt, he realized it. Sometimes not right away, but at least his mind wasn't completely insane like his actions seemed to be. So, all in all, I really enjoyed this book. I would add another star if not for Thanks for reading my looooonnngggg review unless you gave up on reading it by now, hehe. \(^_^)/
June 16, 2011
High school junior Nick Brandt has every reason in the world to be happy. He has two parents who love him and each other. He goes to an exclusive Manhattan private school, and he’s finally gotten up the nerve to talk to Eden, the girl he’s had a crush on for the past two years. Then one day his father gets an unexpected phone call, and Nick, who always believed that he was an only child, finds out that he has an older brother. Nick’s father and his high school girlfriend had had a child when they were both in college and decided to give him up for adoption. At first, Nick does not have a strong reaction to the news, but this revelation about his father’s past plants a seed of doubt that grows over the next few months. He wonders how his father, who has always seemed so solid and dependable could have done something so irresponsible. He also begins to resent the fact that his father hid this secret from him for so long. Meanwhile, his relationship with Eden has grown more serious, and when they have sex for the first time using a condom of unknown expiration date, Nick begins to wonder if he is destined to repeat his father’s mistakes. This causes him to withdraw from Eden without fully understanding why. Nick’s growing resentment and anxiety come to a head when he finally comes face to face with the brother he never knew he had.
The beauty of The Lucky Kind lies in its simplicity. Many of the books, television shows, movies and video games directed towards a teen audience are so filled with “drama” that they become unrealistic. In this novel, Sheinmel depicts a relatively ordinary family dealing with an unusual (but not unrealistic) problem. The characters are well-developed, and the family dynamics and interactions are realistic. Though they are going through a tough time, it is clear that Nick has loving and attentive parents especially by comparison to Eden’s parents, who seem to be on the brink of divorce, and Stevie’s parents, who don’t seem to have time for their son. Teens will be able to relate to these three realistic family situations. The book’s resolution is well done, providing closure without tying everything up too neatly.
The beauty of The Lucky Kind lies in its simplicity. Many of the books, television shows, movies and video games directed towards a teen audience are so filled with “drama” that they become unrealistic. In this novel, Sheinmel depicts a relatively ordinary family dealing with an unusual (but not unrealistic) problem. The characters are well-developed, and the family dynamics and interactions are realistic. Though they are going through a tough time, it is clear that Nick has loving and attentive parents especially by comparison to Eden’s parents, who seem to be on the brink of divorce, and Stevie’s parents, who don’t seem to have time for their son. Teens will be able to relate to these three realistic family situations. The book’s resolution is well done, providing closure without tying everything up too neatly.
December 9, 2011
3.5 stars. I thought this book handled the serious issues well with light humor and great characterizations. Nick is a junior in High School when he finds out that his dad had a son almost 30 years prior. That son, Sam, was given up for adoption and has now taken the option of talking to and possibly meeting his biological father. Nick takes the first phone call from Sam and from there the secret gets out. Nick feels betrayed that his parents, especially his father, would keep something so important from him. At the same time Nick is finally pursuing the girl of his dreams, Eden. He's known her since grade school and finally feels ready to try and get to know her. Soon they are a true couple but Nick can't shake all that is going on with his family, who most people refer to as a "Norman Rockwell painting". Although some of the inner dialogue that goes on with Nick sounds more like what a girl would think and feel, I liked that his character was sort of stumbling through this part of his life. I really liked the secondary characters as well - they were believable and the kinds of people you wish you actually did know in real life. A pretty breezy read, but it was paced well and presents some great coming of age topics in a charming way.
July 24, 2013
I love a good guy-lit reality fiction book. They are rare! This book was honest and raw, real and relatable, and all of the characters - main and supporting, were likeable, laughable and inspiring. 16 year old Nick is starting his junior year, when he finds out that his "perfect" family has a secret. Now, it's not the kind of secret that rips a family apart or has dire consequences, but Nick struggles to deal with the implications all the same. He has always had a great relationship with his parents and now he begins to doubt the stability of his life. At the same time, he finally gains the courage to go after the girl of his dreams, but because of his family drama, he acts out against their relationship and potentially ruins the best thing he has. This book was deep and introspective. The emotions and process that Nick went through were understandable and caused me to do my own self-evaluation! I highly suggest this book.
March 18, 2014
Nick is a high school junior who has never had a problem with his parents, and never had a girlfriend. Then a phone call sets off a chain of events that changes both of those truths - he realizes his parents have been keeping a major secret from him for years, and the unsteadiness of his life inspires him to shake it up further by finally pursuing the girl he's crushed on for years. As he copes with falling in love and dealing with his new family situation, he has a lot to learn. This book is well-written, thought-provoking, and (though I hate how condescending this sounds, it must be said -) sweet.
January 7, 2012
Nick is a high school junior who has a pretty normal life, which includes a crush on Eden, a girl he’s known at school for a long time. They finally get together, fall in love, and things become shaky when Nick learns that his dad has another son, who he and his high school girlfriend gave up for adoption many years ago. Nick lets his bitterness and sense of betrayal push away everyone close to him, especially Eden and his father.
Realistic fiction has to really have strong characters in order to resonate with me, and these characters just didn’t sparkle enough. The adoption piece was interesting, but otherwise it fell a little flat and I was bored.
Realistic fiction has to really have strong characters in order to resonate with me, and these characters just didn’t sparkle enough. The adoption piece was interesting, but otherwise it fell a little flat and I was bored.
February 13, 2013
Nick is a pretty lucky kinda guy. He gets along with his mom and dad, gets good grades and has a great friend Stevie. When he finds out that his parents have been keeping a pretty big (but in the Big picture, understandable) secret from him, he goes sideways and feels betrayed. His friends and family (did I mention he is a pretty lucky kinda guy?) make all kinds of allowances for him and his sullen, nasty behavior.
As the story progresses he pushes away his girlfriend in a truly egregious way- In all this is realistic fiction of a boy coming to grips with what kind of person he wants to be - and because he is a lucky kinda guy he has some spectacular examples to work with.
As the story progresses he pushes away his girlfriend in a truly egregious way- In all this is realistic fiction of a boy coming to grips with what kind of person he wants to be - and because he is a lucky kinda guy he has some spectacular examples to work with.
July 21, 2011
Nick really likes Eden, but thinks that she is out of his league. So, even though she is always friendly towards him, he is reluctant to ask her out. Then, one night, the phone rings bringing news that will change his, and his family's, world completely. It shakes him up enough that he realizes he needs to just take a chance or two, so he asks Eden out. They realize that the kind of love they share is the lucky kind despite the tough times they both are facing. A sweet story with realistic characters. A good read-alike for Sarah Dessen fans.
January 15, 2012
This book is about a boy who learns the truth. Not just about his own father but about his life in general. He learns the truth of love and hate. But most importantly he learns the truth of himself. The Lucky Kind had every single kind of emotion wrapped into it. Anger, sadness, joy, and everything in between made its way into this book and into my heart.
For the rest of the review click here!!!
For the rest of the review click here!!!
May 30, 2011
The Lucky Kind is an engaging, quick read told from a guy's point of view. Any teen who has had a disillusioning experience with a parent will be able to relate to this story. Nick finds out about a baby given up for adoption in his parents' past, and that adult child has now contacted Nick's family. The story revolves around Nick's anger and jealousy, and his inability to separate the emotions...(see full review here: http://www.storysnoops.com/detail.php...)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 56 reviews