Mr. Doyle,
Three of these Sherlock Holmes stories I had read before, one I had not (The Stock-Broker's Clerk). I decided to listen to this audiobook because I usually listen to Sherlock Holmes stories as I fall asleep, and I wanted to make sure I heard the entirety of the stories while awake to make sure I didn't miss any of their details.
The Speckled Band is one of my favourite of the Holmes stories. I remember the thrill of terror I got the first time that I listened, when Helen describes the circumstances of her sister's death - specifically the mysterious whistle in the night! The entire story is gripping and the murder scheme is inventive as in the best Holmes stories.
The Adventure of the Copper Beeches is another story with a great mystery and a satisfying conclusion. The strange details - the cut off braid, the electric blue dress, the man who watches the house - all create a fascinating, and at times terrifying, story.
The Red-Headed League is a perfect example of the type of Holmes story where a collection of totally weird details stump Watson and the reader, but Holmes understands the implications very quickly. It's always fun to share Watson's role of the clueless one being dragged around by Sherlock, knowing at the end he'll reveal what's going on.
This was my first time hearing the Stock-Broker's Clerk. It reminded me a lot of the Red-Headed League, with a strange new job turning out to be only an attempt to distract the victim of the plot so that crimes can be done behind their back. Red-Headed League was published 1891 and Stock-Broker's Clerk in 1893. I think it was done better the first time, with the stranger details of the case leading to more confusion on the part of Watson and the reader, but this wasn't a bad story at all.
Thank you for this book,
Jordan