When I was younger, I read a lot of the Necromunda books, and it has always been a favorite setting of mine. Yet, for some reason, I had never picked up this book, so this time around I thought I would take a crack at it.
Three years. It took me three years to finally finish this book. Was it a bad book? No, in fact I would argue it is just an okay book. It just wasn't all that exciting in the grand scheme of things. Farrer gets props for writing from the stand point of someone who isn't a ganger, but rather just a simple lamplighter who has a knack for electricity and such, and thus is fairly important in the underhive of Necromunda. Fairly realistic in my mind, and something that would be fairly important in a place where there is no natural light outside of luminescence.
The overall story is about this lamplighter and them trying to deal with various things that are going on around them within their settlement as it all falls down around them and lamplighters get betrayed by the populous. There is a nice mystery here as to what is going on, which is an interesting idea within Necromunda and one I was glad to see. However, the protagonist felt far more reactive than proactive in this story, constantly reacting to everything around him rather than actively taking his future into his own hands. Yes, he does do this later on in the climax of the novel, but at this point it feels almost alien to his character. Yes, you can be pushed around and bullied into acting the way he does, but I don't feel he went through enough to cause this change in character.
And the overall twist at the end that the Guilder reveals? Sure, it was interesting, but in a place like Necromunda, almost expected and all in all not as shocking as I expected. In the grand scheme of this story, it feels almost like it was a let down and is there just to be the motivator to cause the mental switch from reactionary to proactive for our protagonist.
These two elements makes for a boring story for the most part. Sure, there is some nice action sprinkled throughout the novel, but even then, the lamplighter is reacting to most of the dangers rather than taking his personal safety into his own hands. Hard to cheer for someone like that.
In the end, this book was an average one in the Necromunda series for me. It offers some nice setting material for Necromunda and adds some nice world building. If you want to enhance the overall feel of Necromunda, this is a good book to pick up. Otherwise, pick up one of the other books in the series.