(Zero spoiler review of the omnibus collecting this arc) 4.5/5
I know that Bendis can be somewhat polarising, and he has absolutely gone off the deep end in recent years, although back in the day, the man could write some. This is the second thing I've read of his, his Alias omnibus being the first, and the man is kicking goals when it comes to impressing old Omni Ben. And don't get me started on the Alex Maleev, art... Ok, seeing as how it's a review, you can get me started on it. It's simply scrumptious. This is how you draw a dark and gritty noirish tale. I imagine he's done something on Batman here or there, although how he hasn't had a multiple year run (I'm assuming he hasn't) is beyond me. Oh no, wait. DC leadership... I understand completely.
The three issues here during the run proper not drawn by Maleev are awful. Not so much as the artist isn't talented, but going from a grainy, ink laden oppressive style to cartoonish and bright... seriously, what the hell? You didn't have an artist who could better imitate Maleev's style? Just delay the damn book if that's the case. I assure you, disappointment on the delay aside, no one wants such a jarring and drastic change of art. It would be like me walking into a fruit shop after years of buying a banana every day for lunch, and them saying, "sorry, we're all out of bananas, but we have an onion for you instead".
But back to Bendis, as a noirish crime thriller, this is solid. As a superhero comic, it's outstanding. Mostly because it's not very superhero-y, and is in fact, a solid noirish thriller. And not very superhero-y is a great way to get me invested in your superhero story. There's barely a super villain in sight here, and the odd one that does make an appearance (Kingpin is always the exception to this rule, because he is awesome) has received said dark and gritty, noirish update.
No, it's not perfect, and it makes more than a few missteps here and there, but the overall style and tone of the book, perfectly accentuated by Maleev's excellent art, makes this an absolutely must- read Daredevil run. 4.5/5
OmniBen.