I love the Tradd Street series, so was really excited about this spinoff. While I really enjoyed reading it, now that I am finished I am more confused and frustrated than anything else. There are so many loose ends that were left unresolved, and it seems like the Jeanne/Charles storyline was concluded. Here are my issues:
1) Jeanne was supposedly Mimi's best friend. She was set to move in with her, and she stated that Jeanne introduced her to Charles. Yet, Jeanne keeps turning up the heat and coming onto her best friend's fiancé?
2) Speaking of Charles, how old is he anyway? We have some contradictory information. When Nola and Jolene are looking through Jeanne's client book and start speculating on the relationship between Jeanne and Charles, Nola mentions that he was "a young man" at that time. But he was a doctor by then, and Mimi states that although Jeanne was engaged to someone else, she didn't really love him that way because she "liked older men". So which is it?
3) A major omission was the explanation for why Charles was buying pajamas and/or gloves every week for months. At first, Nola and Jolene think it was an excuse to see Jeanne, but as we find out, that is not the case, as he is not interested in Jeanne that way. So what the heck is up with the repetitious weekly purchases?
4) How did Jeanne's client book end up in the closet with the other items? How would the family have had access to it in the first place? Supposedly, Mimi's son Buddy took the door and other items to hide in the house to get keep them away from Mimi, who wanted nothing to do with them, and that was in 1997. But Sunny wasn't even born yet then, so how did her hair ribbon and the photo negative end up with the book in the hat box?
Another thing, and I didn't recognize it while I was reading the book, but upon reflecting on it afterward, it's so obvious that this book follows basically the same formula as the Tradd Street series. Main female character with an attitude and chip on her shoulder, side-kick best friend, guy with whom she has an antagonistic relationship but secretly has the hots for, and a "distraction" guy. Nola=Melanie, Jolene= Sophie (and maybe a little bit of Rebecca), Beau=Jack, and Michael=Marc Longo. I get that some conflict is necessary, I just wish it was not so close to the series from which it spun off.
All of that said, I did enjoy reading the book. I just wish I had some answers to the above questions. Karen White remains one of my favorite authors and I am eager to read the next in the series. I just can't give it more than 3 stars due to the all the plot holes.