A very mixed bag, and was very tempted to give this book a lower rating, yet Richard Neer's "FM: The Rise and Fall of Rock Radio" is littered with buried treasures beneath its mesh of rock and roll radio history, and soap opera.
I loved hearing stories about some of my favorite New York DJs like Scott Muni, Dave Herman, Carol Miller, Dennis Elsas, Dan Neer and Richard Neer himself. I loved the Bruce Springsteen stories, and the candid anecdotes involving Chrissie Hynde, Elton John, John Lennon, George Harrison and Jimmy Page. I loved hearing about some of the drama involved with Neer's many years at New York's WNEW FM. Yet the problem is...these fun moments were buried between pages and pages of facts and figures and tales that were far less interesting.
At times a personal biographical account of Neer's many years in radio...functioning in many different capacities...at other times, "FM: The Rise and Fall of Rock Radio" goes off on tangents...in an attempt a complete story...well, like the title says "The Rise and Fall of Rock Radio" in the ENTIRE United States. There were just too many dull stories, with too many names that were difficult to keep track of as Neer goes on and on about radio stations in San Francisco, Boston, Philadelphia, Cleveland, Washington D.C., and more. His aim was just too high and too broad, and Neer is not exactly the most clever storyteller, and does himself no service by choosing a scattered structure as opposed to a linear one. By the end of the book, I no longer cared about the rise and fall of FM rock radio, as he never really gave me enough reason to care.
"FM: The Rise and Fall of Rock Radio" was worth the read for the buried nuggets, yet I felt disappointed in the end.